Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To feel like I'm losing my sister to conspiracy theories?

309 replies

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 13:24

My sister is a very intelligent, funny, interesting woman but recently , probably since lockdown she has been spending more and more time online and reading into conspiracy theories about the Hollywood elite and politicians and child sacrifices and all kinds of ludicrous claims.

This has utterly consumed her, you cannot have a conversation with the her that she does not turn to her trying to show some you tube video as "evidence". I'm so worried but do not know what to do as everything I say is met with "well that's what they want you to think".

OP posts:
TomPinch · 06/08/2020 04:33

[quote redbushtea]@Buccanarab
Being entitled to an opinion isn't the same as your opinion being right, or even acceptable. Opinions that are demonstrably false or wrong need to be challenged whenever they're raised

That works both ways. There is plenty which is demonstrably false about the mainstream media coverage of the current corona virus drama. In Nazi Germany, if more people had challenged mainstream opinion instead of slavishly going along with it, many lives would have been saved.[/quote]
I'm surprised that this post hasn't been challenged. It was the Nazis who relied on conspiracy theories, about the Jews. Those views were not the mainstream in Germany, until they had achieved power, when they suppressed dissent to those views.

In fact, many lives would have been saved if all Germans has recognized what dangerous lunatics the Nazis were, rather than simply most of them

If you watch the first few episodes of The World at War you will find a very good explanation of this.

skeptile · 06/08/2020 03:33

Well, Noam Chomsky has shown countless blatant mainstream fabrications across the span of his long and illustrious career. (His stuff on the Vietnam war and the New York Times literally reversing the actors in some circumstances is mind blowing.) His sources are impeccable - usually whistle blowers and documents secured under FOI. I see everything through his prism, for better or worse. Pretty sure politics and power haven't 'improved' since the 60s and 70s...

noodlezoodle · 06/08/2020 02:12

@Thegereldine3000

Have you actually ever researched any of these so called conspiracy theorise, because the people that make them do. All their sources are always listed in the discription and they come from legitimate sources. You're the one whos so inconsiderate and ludicrous that you choose to blindly follow along with obvious lies.
It's not research to watch a lot of YouTube videos and post links from personal websites. Those are not 'legitimate sources'. They are fellow conspiracy theorists.

If I'm wrong then please share an example of where someone sharing a conspiracy theory has quoted their legitimate sources, because I've never seen one yet.

Buccanarab · 06/08/2020 01:57

@redbushtea

That works both ways. There is plenty which is demonstrably false about the mainstream media coverage of the current corona virus drama. In Nazi Germany, if more people had challenged mainstream opinion instead of slavishly going along with it, many lives would have been saved

A delayed response as been away a couple days and there's so much wrong with that post I'm not sure how to address it but....

You need to be able to separate the politics around covid (and other diseases) from the science. Do mainstream platforms bend things to their agenda? Of course they do, and I'm not saying you should believe everything you see on the BBC or whatever.

What I am saying is you can't go around disregarding actual medical fact because someone on youtube claiming to be a doctor says vaccinations or what ever don't work. If you, or any of the people you prefer to listen to, have evidence that contradicts the current thinking then please, for everyone's sake, submit it to the appropriate medical society/journal for review and publication. If you, or your prefered sources, feel these societies/journals are corrupt or "part of big pharma" then you can publish the comments they make on your evidence for everyone to see and prove it.
If not then you need to accept you, and your preferred sources, don't have the knowledge or understanding to go against the science and shouldn't be disregarding it.

Edit - I actually typed up the above before seeing your later post but it appears you do just take whatever random person claiming to be a doctor on youtube says as truth. It took less than a minute to find that the Dr Blaylock you quote has many, many questions surrounding his motives, integrity and work and I can only assume you're quoting him because he confirms your bias.

Casschops · 06/08/2020 01:27

I posted about the same thing too. My cousin now in America believes the same thing. She also started supporting Trump
Scary

Oswin · 06/08/2020 01:04

@Thegereldine3000

Have you actually ever researched any of these so called conspiracy theorise, because the people that make them do. All their sources are always listed in the discription and they come from legitimate sources. You're the one whos so inconsiderate and ludicrous that you choose to blindly follow along with obvious lies.
What do you mean like the faked Epstein flight logged that was meant to show Chrissy Teighan as a murdering rapist. Yet she would have been a child at the time.

Watching YouTube is not research and faked images are not proof.

Thegereldine3000 · 05/08/2020 23:54

Have you actually ever researched any of these so called conspiracy theorise, because the people that make them do. All their sources are always listed in the discription and they come from legitimate sources. You're the one whos so inconsiderate and ludicrous that you choose to blindly follow along with obvious lies.

noodlezoodle · 05/08/2020 23:46

I'm sorry OP, I don't think there is anything you can do. I think until critical thinking and information literacy are taught much better in schools, this is only going to get worse.

This article by a game designer is fascinating (although pretty long) and explains the ways in which conspiracy theories are similarly addictive to games: mssv.net/2020/08/02/what-args-can-teach-us-about-qanon/

Sunrise234 · 05/08/2020 23:39

the only saying goes you can't argue with stupid

It’s so frustrating! It’s worrying that there are so many people getting brainwashed out there!

What’s ironic is that the ones saying face masks don’t work to protect you from COVID are probably the same ones who deny COVID exists.

Sunrise234 · 05/08/2020 23:33

You need to listen to the majority of experts. Just because someone is a doctor doesn’t mean they are automatically right.

There was a doctor who said that the measles vaccine gave you autism and another said the polio vaccine gave you HIV, both were completely false but people believed them.
And people on the internet lie so most aren’t doctors anyway or they’ve been struck off.

If 100 hair dressers tell you not to use a certain shampoo because it will make your hair fall out and then one says no they’re wrong it doesn’t make your hair fall out.
Who are you going to trust?
It doesn’t make you a sheep/nazi believing in the majority it just means you have common sense.

Thestreets · 05/08/2020 23:18

@WarmHeyerette I'm sorry you're going through this as well. Sounds like there is a long road ahead Sad

OP posts:
Thestreets · 05/08/2020 23:08

There really is no point in trying to use logical reasoning with somebody like @redbushtea as the only saying goes you can't argue with stupid

OP posts:
Gingernaut · 05/08/2020 22:47

Two of the links refer to Russell Blaylock who retired from brain surgery nearly twenty years ago.

He is not a virologist, epidemiologist, microbiologist, respiratory specialist or biochemist.

He has not retrained from brain surgery and has produced scientifically unsound books which can easily be debunked with a quick Google search.

The study showed that cloth masks offered no protection to the wearer compared to PPE.

Well, no shit, Sherlock.

THE CLOTH MASKS WE ARE BEING ENCOURAGED TO WEAR ARE NOT MEANT TO PROTECT US

THEY ARE MEANT TO PROTECT THOSE NEAR US

Healthcare workers use more than one type of face mask/shield, both to prevent infecting their patients and to reduce the risk of becoming infected themselves.

Komacho · 05/08/2020 20:58

This reply has been deleted

Message removed as it quotes a deleted post.

WarmHeyerette · 05/08/2020 20:51

Lots of sympathy OP, my sister is the same. She doesn't use any drugs though but it's been getting worse for the last 5 years. I try very hard to find things to connect with her about but covid has made it nigh on impossible. She believes all the QAnon stuff and loads of other stuff about aliens and spirits. She just can't talk about anything else. My adult nieces feel like they're being tortured by living with her.
I totally agree with pps about the need to feel clever and in control during uncertain times, especially if you've always felt inferior.
I don't know how it's going to end. She is unbearable and I'm having to have a rest from her even though I feel guilty about it because she is low and frightened. She just won't ask for help from us any more because she's had to convince herself that she's right and we're not.
It breaks my heart because I want my sister back. I miss her.

Sunrise234 · 05/08/2020 20:07

@redbushtea are you against wearing face masks?

I clicked on a couple of links you’ve just posted and they basically say you should wear them. One has done studies on the type of masks and which is more effective and another one I clicked on said the results found that wearing masks alone is not enough to stop the virus.

redbushtea · 05/08/2020 19:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Komacho · 05/08/2020 17:15

asking a conspiracy theorist for citations is an exercise in futility.

Gingernaut · 05/08/2020 16:40

@redbushtea, citations please.

Post proper links to these 'studies' or shut up.

We aren't being told to wear PPE, where the mask protects the wearer.

We are being asked to wear masks which prevent the spread of saliva and mucus as we breathe and speak.

The former neurosurgeon, Dr Russell Blaylock has been retired for nearly 20 years and is not an expert in virology, epidemiology, biochemistry respiratory medicine or dietetics

www.burtonsys.com/blaylock_bio.html

Stop peddling this shit.

Zilla1 · 05/08/2020 10:41

Redbushtea,

are you the OP's DSIS?

PMSL at 'an N95 mask can reduce blood oxygenation by as much as 20%'.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20420727/

MaybeDoctor · 05/08/2020 10:20

@speakout

You have my symathies OP.

I have lost my sister and mother to religion, both "born again".
I have cut off all contact with my sister, she is so overtaken by her views that it is impossible to have a normal conversation with her.

I have a family member involved in an evangelical church and think that far too little attention is paid to some of the practices going on there. These churches look lovely, with the shiny happy people and the soft-rock music, but there is another side to their operation.

Just as one example, the annual report of the national organisation freely describes 'youth work' that involves young people converting or receiving the spirit for the first time at large public events. So perhaps subject to peer pressure or the overexcitement of a mass gathering? It actually reports the numbers of conversions at these youth events as a success measure Hmm. Or church 'mentors' being involved in secondary schools. Or holding churches in secondary school halls and encouraging young people to come along on Sunday. All this is proudly described in the annual report!

Bearing in mind that this is a right-wing version of Christianity that encourages tithing a proportion of income, no sex before marriage, no homosexuality and not forming partnerships outside the church.

Everyday Life is Mundane and people should be free to choose a religion to inspire them, but I think that active evangelism towards children and young people is ethically dubious.

@speakout
Send me a message if you would like to talk about this.

Davespecifico · 05/08/2020 06:03

Even people you wouldn’t expect to are getting sucked in to conspiracy theory world. On minute they’re reading the DM, next they’re saying they don’t trust MSM and then they’re away with the fairies.

Gingertea2020 · 05/08/2020 06:02

Feel for you op, this happened with my ex husband and it was exhausting.

I believe with the other poster who said it’s underlying mental illness/issues.

Think with my ex husband it was a fear/anxiety and depression and feeling overwhelmed by life and that he couldn’t cope with it.

In some ways he had the last laugh because this was before covid and he stockpiled food + made financial investments in save havens. He’s now having the last laugh Since covid. Actually a very intelligent but went down quite a few rabbit holes.

I think covid is making people fearful and they use these theories to cope.

Imagine that being a single Mum, like me, she probably feels really fearful and vulnerable during Covid. There are so many ‘what if’s’ when you’re alone with a child.

May help to suggest GP and don’t give up on her. Retreat and don’t do in person catch-up is she looping out a bit but check up on her every morning at the same time. Stuff that makes her feel safe and secure.

MrsGoggings85 · 05/08/2020 05:50

Sorry but the weed smoking is a red flag for me - can cause ongoing paranoia and psychotic episodes, had so many similar problems with both conspiracy theories and paranoid episodes due to weed smoking with my DB - and this goes back years.

Arealnumber · 05/08/2020 01:08

Wouldn't it be great if the large number of conspiracy theorists actually put their time, passion and energy into productive action - volunteering or environmental activism for instance. I do however sympathise with their concerns around 5G. I really, really would prefer not to but I just can't help being hugely fearful around this and the effects it could have on young, developing brains. Two of my children have recently started having daily, debilitating headaches. Any causes have so far been medically ruled out so this is further exacerbating my concerns. I'm not in UK but Australia where it has recently started to be up and running. I believe this process has been slowed down in Britain by the Huawei roll out being halted. Am I a conspiracy theorist or a sane, concerned Mum?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread