Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To feel like I'm losing my sister to conspiracy theories?

309 replies

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 13:24

My sister is a very intelligent, funny, interesting woman but recently , probably since lockdown she has been spending more and more time online and reading into conspiracy theories about the Hollywood elite and politicians and child sacrifices and all kinds of ludicrous claims.

This has utterly consumed her, you cannot have a conversation with the her that she does not turn to her trying to show some you tube video as "evidence". I'm so worried but do not know what to do as everything I say is met with "well that's what they want you to think".

OP posts:
Shinyletsbebadguys · 07/08/2020 03:53

@Userzzz

According to you and 95% of mumsnet if you question anything you're told by the media you must be a conspiracy theorist or have a mental illness. Hilarious. Have you ever questioned anything or used your reason to independently form an opinion outside of what you are told?
Have you actually read this thread ? At all? With the best will in the world you have posted an uninformed clunky attempt at shaming with no evidence and a blatant disregard for any comments made on here. You simply used this as a forum to put others down in an intangible referenced dig presumably in order to cackle sheeple internally?

You have genuinely just defined which type of conspiracy theorist makes the whole group appear laughable.

Several comments (including mine) have clarified that people don't believe everything they read and critically analyse it. That's not as falling for whatever pseudo science rubbish is reduced into bite sized soundbites for conspiracy theorists. A post up thread claiming to have evidence turned out to be several badly referenced online articles with only one (tenuous) reference to actual empirical evidence.

Userzzz · 07/08/2020 01:40

According to you and 95% of mumsnet if you question anything you're told by the media you must be a conspiracy theorist or have a mental illness. Hilarious.
Have you ever questioned anything or used your reason to independently form an opinion outside of what you are told?

TomPinch · 07/08/2020 01:30

There's an article on the Guardian website on this subject - the comments are worth reading too. It concerns Americans, but the phenomenon is wider: Meet the white, middle-class Pinterest moms who believe Plandemic

@MaybeDoctor

Since the late 1960s there has been an increasing movement in Christianity that rejects the traditionally-organised church (ie, with a bishop or moderator responsible for lots of parishes and clergy) in favour of independent 'house' churches. It's a reaction to the decline of Christianity by jettisoning the baggage that those big churches have (I mean CofE, CofS Catholic etc). They're now at the point where they are becoming more influential in Christian circles than those older churches.

The danger in them is that they don't have proper oversight, and the people who run them don't have nearly as much training as the traditional CofE vicar has. Until really very recently it normal for anyone who ran a church to have at least some understanding, for example, of New Testament Greek and the philosophical ideas that were going around at the time (there's a lot of Plato in St Paul for example - trad Christianity borrows hugely from Greek culture). In house churches this is not generally the case, leastways around me, and the result is that the contents of the Bible get taught in a very simplistic sort of way. The classic mistake these churches make is forgetting that the Bible was written in different languages in different times, and it isn't simply a matter of translating it like an Asterix comic. The other classic mistake they make is denying that what is in the Bible was a matter of debate for hundreds of years, and what went in and what stayed out was based on what the Church had decided to believe - and not the other way round. They are actually commiting a simple historical illiteracy.

Concerning the Bible Society, I remember that in my youth they were an entirely mainstream organisation and for them to make a presentation in a school would have been entirely uncontroversial. My mother gave me a Bible published by the Bible Society, as I recall. She is an old-fashioned, sensible, mild-mannered academic type of the sort that one still finds around churches - but now they are all very elderly.

I do not know what they are like now. But I have to say that it is quite normal for ethical views of all sorts to be advocated in schools. I think that's quite proper, within appropriate limits, and as long as it is appropriately taught by knowledgeable people. I don't see that ethical views that involve belief in a divine being should be excluded from this - particularly the case of Christianity, which was the dominant belief system in the UK for one and a half thousand years until only just a few years ago.

In my kids' schools, Christianity isn't given an airing at all, but plenty of other views and beliefs are: they boil down to a querulous, zealous and disjointed pushing of the rights of various identified minority groups and it all looks very shallow to me.

Regarding conspiracy theories generally: I believe that across the West knowlege and ability in the humanities has been in decline for at least two decades. When I read something written 20 or 30 years ago I'm struck by more seriously it is written and argued, and how less likely it is to try and be entertaining. I think a lot of people no longer know how to be serious and who to treat something in a serious way - and that is why they do not recognise when an argument or belief oer a person is not serious and needs to be treated as a joke. I don't think, for example, that someone like Boris Johnson would have become prime minister 20 or 30 years ago. This has happened at the same time as decline in traditional church attendance and I do wonder if that means a moderating influence on people has been lost. However, I think it has a lot more to do with the rise of the Internet and the idea that one can just Google everything. Even my kids' schools teach in this way - they go light on the content because the Internet has the answer, and I understand that is a worldwide teaching trend.

It's very, very depressing. I think that Trump will lose in November but this nonsense won't go away any time soon.

Sunrise234 · 06/08/2020 20:31

It’s all gotten a bit dangerous for those of us who’ll be being put at risk by those particular theories.

I agree.
Having a childlike naivety and believing things like the government are hiding mermaids and unicorns from us I can deal with.
But when it comes to not believing in COVID or vaccinations it becomes very worrying.

TheHoneyBadger · 06/08/2020 20:24

Off to put Tom Hanks into a YouTube search Grin

TheHoneyBadger · 06/08/2020 20:19

I enjoy a the odd conspiracy wormholes but make myself look at the ones from a different political or religious etc leaning too. I remember forcing myself to watch right wing ones to counterbalance Grin

As others say they’ll contain kernels of truth and they are also good for understanding people’s mindsets and values and how those are manipulated.

Trump has totally encouraged conspiracy theories with deliberate repeated references to fake news and is totally exploiting the fears and concerns revealed in conspiracy theory channels and sites.

I’m a teacher and find it pretty terrifying on mumsnet to realise there are parents who don’t believe covid is real, refuse to wear masks and aren’t taking any precautions. Their kids will be in our classrooms and be being sent in with symptoms because their parents don’t believe it’s real or it’s no big deal.

It’s all gotten a bit dangerous for those of us who’ll be being put at risk by those particular theories.

Chickenkatsu · 06/08/2020 17:39

I heard that most people in the past didn't believe in gorillas and giant pandas, they thought they were mythical, I'm not sure if that's true or not. I think that the first time scientists saw a duck billed platypus they thought it was made up.

The idea that radioactive elements like uranium produced some magical radiation that could pass through solid objects and was slowly killing people wasn't widely believed at first.

Buccanarab · 06/08/2020 17:16

*Please can someone share a conspiracy theory that has been proven right.

I can’t think of one in the thousands of years that they’ve been around, but surely when something is true it would be easy to prove so therefore there should be loads of conspiracy theories which have turned out to be true*

There's been a few but most aren't big one's. Things like tobacco companies supressing research between smoking and cancer in the 50s and 60s have been proven true over the years but the evidence was always there if you wanted look.
The two biggest I can think of are the MKUltra programme and the Tuskegee syphilis experiments. Both involved the US carrying out illegal experiments on humans without their consent but they were on a relatively small scale and I'm not sure whether there was wide scale public interest/theories about them at the time. It's probably stuff like that that leads to people believing in the more out there conspiracy theories.

BlingLoving · 06/08/2020 16:43

Personally, and obviously this is from a relatively small sample size, my experience is that people who get sucked into this kind of thing are people who dont read much normally, particularly fiction. They have no experience in reading and absorbing different viewpoints, no understanding of how stories can be manipulated to show different agendas etc. Fiction often provides useful insights into other peoples lives and experiences and while these are all biased in some way, the more you read the more your understanding expands.

I cant buy into theories of large groups controlling other groups because I have read and seen enough of human nature to know that kind of complicity just isn't practical. Except in the most extreme of cults there are still differences of opinion and approach. Hell, most of us have experienced this in our own (small) lives - the PTA all agree raising money to help the school is important but the fighting and disagreement about how to do this is usually 50% of the process. Ans yet we are supposed to believe that a group of potential totally 100s of people are all entirely on the same page? Hahahahahahahaha.

Chickenkatsu · 06/08/2020 16:08

@MaybeDoctor Yes, I was livid, they used a lot of fake blood too. They would have a baddie who didn't believe in God and the children would all boo him, really biased.

MaybeDoctor · 06/08/2020 15:37

That is shocking! Shock

The National Secular Society has written something about this issue here:
www.secularism.org.uk/evangelism-in-schools/

Chickenkatsu · 06/08/2020 15:34

@MaybeDoctor

It was the head master who brought them in, so it was very difficult to lodge a complaint. They've stopped doing it now though. I think that nailing someone to a board and having them die slowly in front of the reception class was a deal breaker for a lot of the parents.

MaybeDoctor · 06/08/2020 15:21

@Chickenkatsu
Thanks, not the same group of churches but of a very similar flavour.

That website is interesting to say the least:

'If you’re excited about sharing Bible stories with school children and want to have fun with a team dressing up in costume to act the part, perhaps you’d like to be a Storyteller and get a team started from your church?'

The volunteers are DBS checked and have online training, but fundamentally it is anyone who wants to do it.

'The programme consists of three years of Bible Storytelling with an additional, but optional, year of material called 'Christian values: A biblical approach.'

I am an ex-teacher and believe that RE is a very important part of the curriculum. I also think it is fine to use Bible stories in collective worship and visits from ordained ministers of religion, but it should be teachers leading the assemblies not volunteers from random churches. The recommended programme of twice a month for three years (as per the template letter to headteachers) is giving a lot of exposure to people who are fundamentally not accountable to the school or its governing body.

Chickenkatsu · 06/08/2020 13:36

@MaybeDoctor

www.spicerstreet.org.uk/about-us/what-we-believe/

It was that church.

It's part of this group, who focus on young children:

www.biblesociety.org.uk/get-involved/open-the-book/

SeaEagleFeather · 06/08/2020 13:35

I think the world runs 95% by cockup but Ive no doubt that -something- very very nasty in the conspiracy way lurks at the top of British society (and probably other countries too) en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westminster_paedophile_dossier

AuntMasha · 06/08/2020 13:16

@Sunrise234

I'm surprised that this post hasn't been challenged. It was the Nazis who relied on conspiracy theories, about the Jews. Those views were not the mainstream in Germany, until they had achieved power, when they suppressed dissent to those views.

You are absolutely right.
Honestly I saw this and just could not find the words to even say.
Everyone knows the nazis relied on conspiracy theories and look what happened!

I can’t believe anyone is that naive so I don’t know if they’re a troll and just joking or they have no intelligence/common sense at all. So I wasn’t sure how to respond. I am genuinely worried about this persons mental health.

This document specifically was used by the Nazis to justify their anti -Semitism.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protocols_of_the_Elders_of_Zion

But though it has been proved to be fake, time and time again it is still used and quoted by conspiracists such as Q as legit.

jackdawdawn · 06/08/2020 12:42

Northern Irish society has not been improved by this sort of thing.

Communities demonised each other for decades, each claiming that Rome/the Republican movement, or the Orange Order/the 'British war machine' are trying to crush the other. The tensions were whipped up by demagogues like Paisley, who used to refer to the Pope as the Antichrist. Conspiracy theories can actually become institutionalised and part of the fabric of a society. They sow division and mistrust and are not 'harmless.'

MaybeDoctor · 06/08/2020 12:22

Oh yes, they do assemblies too! My view is that headteachers need to be far more careful about the organisations they allow into schools, as per the Prevent strategy.

I would be interested to know if this was the same church - could you message me if you know?

Chickenkatsu · 06/08/2020 11:19

This is exactly the same as the group of religious fanatics who came into our school and taught my DC that dinosaurs have never existed.

MaybeDoctor · 06/08/2020 10:20

@TomPinch

You are right - the religious organisation I am describing is not a conspiracy theory - unfortunately it is far more rooted in society as a physical, public-facing organisation that receives millions of pounds every year in donations. It is involved in toddler groups, youth work and food banks - all good stuff on the surface, but the theology behind it is far more extreme.

I have no objection to individual members of religious groups living by any moral code they wish to hold themselves to. What I do have a problem with is evangelism, especially towards young people.

My own family member has given tens of thousands of pounds to this organisation in one way or another, beginning when they were just twenty years old.

Sunrise234 · 06/08/2020 09:58

I'm surprised that this post hasn't been challenged. It was the Nazis who relied on conspiracy theories, about the Jews. Those views were not the mainstream in Germany, until they had achieved power, when they suppressed dissent to those views.

You are absolutely right.
Honestly I saw this and just could not find the words to even say.
Everyone knows the nazis relied on conspiracy theories and look what happened!

I can’t believe anyone is that naive so I don’t know if they’re a troll and just joking or they have no intelligence/common sense at all. So I wasn’t sure how to respond. I am genuinely worried about this persons mental health.

Sunrise234 · 06/08/2020 09:52

If I'm wrong then please share an example of where someone sharing a conspiracy theory has quoted their legitimate sources, because I've never seen one yet.

Please can someone share a conspiracy theory that has been proven right.

I can’t think of one in the thousands of years that they’ve been around, but surely when something is true it would be easy to prove so therefore there should be loads of conspiracy theories which have turned out to be true.

Mimishimi · 06/08/2020 06:19

To be honest it's something I struggle with a lot and I have not smoked pot. That's because dreadful things do happen (holocausts etc) and usually there is some malign motivation/interests behind them (slave labour, theft anyone?). Then there are conspiracies designed for pay back and it's all just one big mess. We don't tend to fare very well in either situation and it does my head in a bit because it sucks being poor and powerless.

anxietyaunt · 06/08/2020 06:17

@Somevampsarehot

My dsis is the same. She's just told me she's anti-vax and believes the government deliberately released Covid so they could force us to take a vaccine. I tried to tall her back round but gave up pretty quickly. She's absolutely adamant she's right, and has been sending me random youtube videos of 'experts' (none with a science degree of any kind though Hmm) and screenshots of comments on facebook. She does have mental health problems, and has fallen victim to mlm's before. I iist shut it down whenever she starts to rant about it, but I'm not sure what else to do.
I have a friend who did the same thing. Screenshots from someone’s bloody Facebook page! She’s a smart woman. She researches for a living and would have done so at uni. Yet is happy to rely on Facebook “evidence” to decide on whether to get her kids immunised etc. Mind boggling.
TomPinch · 06/08/2020 04:46

There has been some mention of religion on this thread.

We need to be a little careful. Mainstream religion, ie, Anglicanism, Catholicism isn't a conspiracy theory because it doesn't rely on the belief that some secret knowledge is being withheld from the public by TPTB.

Even at the conservative end, this is still true. For example, believing that homosexuality is sinful or that men should run everything is a view based on an interpretation of the Bible, one which in my view is wrong, but the point is that it's not based on the belief in some secret information that is out there somewhere.

However, there are groups that say that the world was created in 6 days and that this can be proved (this is the important bit) as a scientific fact. That's a conspiracy theory- because the science is against them they say it's bring suppressed. Because of the decline in mainstream churches, these voices have become more influential, and it's very troubling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread