Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To feel like I'm losing my sister to conspiracy theories?

309 replies

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 13:24

My sister is a very intelligent, funny, interesting woman but recently , probably since lockdown she has been spending more and more time online and reading into conspiracy theories about the Hollywood elite and politicians and child sacrifices and all kinds of ludicrous claims.

This has utterly consumed her, you cannot have a conversation with the her that she does not turn to her trying to show some you tube video as "evidence". I'm so worried but do not know what to do as everything I say is met with "well that's what they want you to think".

OP posts:
Watdafark · 04/08/2020 15:14

Who here admits to bring a reptile?

malificent7 · 04/08/2020 15:12

You have lost your sister to weed...awful, paranoia inducing drug!

speakout · 04/08/2020 15:10

You have my symathies OP.

I have lost my sister and mother to religion, both "born again".
I have cut off all contact with my sister, she is so overtaken by her views that it is impossible to have a normal conversation with her.

walksonthebeach · 04/08/2020 15:10

@Devlesko

She could be right OP, have you thought of that? Not saying she is but who are you or anyone else to say she's wrong. You can only conspire against something you know to be correct, so unless you know, how do you know she is wrong or that her opinions are conspiracy. She maybe thinks you are a conspiricist because she believes what she does to be fact. so if you think she is wrong, you must believe everything you are being told then.
This!
sparepantsandtoothbrush · 04/08/2020 15:10

I had to stop looking at the Tom Hanks/Ellen/Red shoe society stuff as I could feel myself being pulled down in to the rabbit hole so to speak. I'm still not convinced there isn't something going on but it was starting to consume me a bit so I stopped looking in to it.

L8Bloomer · 04/08/2020 15:09

let her figure it out on her own eventually.

A friend was telling me a couple of weeks ago about some hormone ''chromium'' that was released when children were in terror and that various celebrities used it as a fountain of youth potion. I remember thinking what.the.fuck......... I got home and googled chromium and it's a skit from a film.

MaxNormal · 04/08/2020 15:04

OP if my friend had a sister, I'd think you were talking about her. She's been sucked into a huge conspiracy theory about scamdemics, the evils of vaccines, Bill Gates etc. Keeps posting youtube links and telling people to wake up.
She's not a weed smoker but she had tendencies before, she's quite an angry vegan.

Sonders · 04/08/2020 15:03

If you haven't already seen it, John Oliver/Last Week Tonight recently did a show on conspiracy theories thriving during COVID. It's really frustrating, but like others have said - targeting the belief can be futile.

The conspiracy can be as real to the believer as the sky being blue, or ice being cold. If someone starts telling you that the sky is magenta and ice is hot - you'd probably get defensive of the argument, and dismissive of the person making it. Not that it is right, but it is biological/psychological.

Humans struggle to understand that massive events often have small and/or random causes. Conspiracy theorists think they've 'solved' these mysteries - whereas many others don't think there's a mystery at all.

noblegiraffe · 04/08/2020 14:54

It’s really strange that he hadn’t made an public statement about it tbh.

Why would he give it the oxygen of publicity?

I had no idea that Tom Hanks was being battered on twitter but if he spoke out and said ‘I’m not a paedo’ you can guarantee that millions more people would suddenly believe he was a paedo.

Somevampsarehot · 04/08/2020 14:53

My dsis is the same. She's just told me she's anti-vax and believes the government deliberately released Covid so they could force us to take a vaccine. I tried to tall her back round but gave up pretty quickly. She's absolutely adamant she's right, and has been sending me random youtube videos of 'experts' (none with a science degree of any kind though Hmm) and screenshots of comments on facebook. She does have mental health problems, and has fallen victim to mlm's before. I iist shut it down whenever she starts to rant about it, but I'm not sure what else to do.

Namechange2020onceagain · 04/08/2020 14:52

The trouble is that she believes it 100% and wants to spread the "word".
It's like a new convert to a religion. They becomes zealots.

There is a lot of truth in most of these theory's. Just look at the Epstein scandal and the high profile people involved. Why would
Prince Andrew continue to associate himself with a convicted paedophile and meet him the week he was released from prison?

I think the best thing to do is try to convince her to quit the drugs and agree to disagree. She is free to think a certain way as are you. Tell her she cannot force you into her beliefs as you can't force her to your beliefs.

noblegiraffe · 04/08/2020 14:51

I think some times people pick up a thread of something and it hooks them in.

There were those MN threads obsessed with the idea that Louis Tomlinson’s baby was fake and that Louis Tomlinson was actually in a gay relationship with Harry Styles but they were hiding the truth and there would be a big reveal shortly.

I wonder what happens to these people when it becomes blatantly clear that the baby is real and that everything they read into videos, interviews, coded messages etc was all wrong.

Buccanarab · 04/08/2020 14:48

She's not entirely wrong is she?
Do you believe what the media tell you to believe or do you have a mind of your own.

I don't get this view. The very people/groups conspircay theorists (CTs) claim are controlling the media own most of the sites that these CTs get their "evidence" from. So surely if their "evidence" is on the surface web it's what "they" want you to see? You'd think some all powerful media controlling cartel would at the very least make sure any evidence against them was kept on the dark web. Interestingly I've yet to meet a new CT who even knows how to access the dark web, let alone navigate it.

She could be right OP, have you thought of that?
Not saying she is but who are you or anyone else to say she's wrong.

And this sort of view really gets my back up as it's irresponsible and dangerous. Imo there are two camps of conspiracy theorists, the old and the new.
The old tend to put together quite detailed theories on things like the NWO or ancient astronauts. While still out there (and often easy to disprovel) they can make for interesting and entertaining reading and I can see why they're appealing to people. The Denver Airport one is a particular favourtite of mine, especially since the airport itself started playing along, but believing that sort of conspiracy theory doesn't put the believer or the general population at risk.

One the other hand the new conspiracy theorists seem to just read a few memes or watch a couple of videos and swallow it all as unquestionable truth. That in itself wouldn't be too bad if it wasn't for the fact that there seems to have been a huge surge in people believing things that are not only demonstrably false but actually dangerous i.e. the covid hoax/anti-vaccinations. These people seem to take whatever random article or post they've read as gospel and make real life decisions that could have far reaching consequences for them and others and nothing changes thier mind. You can literally show them physical evidence of why it's false and they just dismiss it as "that's what they want you to think, wake up sheeple". It's fucking terrifying and frankly these people need professional help asap.

Thelnebriati · 04/08/2020 14:47

A frequent claim in conspiracy circles is that the Clintons are associated with various suspicious deaths that have been recorded as suicide.

Ohfredcomeon · 04/08/2020 14:46

Someone else on the thread mentioned a good reason why people get involved in this stuff. They’re scared the world doesn’t make sense for them and they’re looking for order. Things are changing and certain types of people are losing their place in the (Western) world so that is really bedrock shaking for a lot of them

I don’t think it’s that for everybody. I think some times people pick up a thread of something and it hooks them in. People think that folk who listen to theory’s like this are drug taking people who’s life is spiralling out of control - it’s not always.

Tom Hanks has been battered on Twitter. You type Tom Hanks in to twitter and there is thousands of tweets about him being a pedophile, a young lady is accusing him or abusing her when she was 13. He has just moved to Greece and become a citizen. Greece has no extradition agreement with USA so there is lots of videos and tweets about it.

It’s really strange that he hadn’t made an public statement about it tbh. His twitter account is ruined.

Ohfredcomeon · 04/08/2020 14:40

The thing with pizza gate is that Hilliary Clinton did delete thousands of emails. And out of the 12 cops that found the lap top with the emails on 9 have committed suicide and their still hadn’t been an investigation by anybody.

My family member showed me this rabbit hole but I checked on it later. There is elements of truth embedded in their some where and that’s why these stories end up getting out of hand.

It’s odd. All of it is.

I just thought bill gates made computers. You don’t want to go down that rabbit hole..

JingsMahBucket · 04/08/2020 14:34

Someone else on the thread mentioned a good reason why people get involved in this stuff. They’re scared the world doesn’t make sense for them and they’re looking for order. Things are changing and certain types of people are losing their place in the (Western) world so that is really bedrock shaking for a lot of them.

Can you talk to your sister and ask her what her fears are/were pre-pandemic? Get to the root of it. Maybe also ask her about her social media YouTube usage and ask how it has affected her life. Relay to her that you’ve been feeling “too digital” lately and maybe would she want to do a digital detox with you so you can mutually support each other. Giving each other time limits, formulating new activities to do together or separately that aren’t online. Essentially removing the habit and instinct to constantly check things online.

noblegiraffe · 04/08/2020 14:30

The problem is there is grains of truth embedded in this.

There always is. That’s how you get sucked into conspiracy theories. That and they get you to ‘construct’ the ‘truth’ yourself so that you are more wedded to it than if you had simply been told the ‘facts’.

I’ve been on a few conspiracy theory websites and they ask what seems like a simple question, and when you fail to answer it, they push their interpretation so that you had a hole in your understanding and you grasp gratefully at their ability to fill it rather than be left with a gap.

I’ve been on 9/11 sites where they’ll post a picture of the Pentagon after the plane crashing into it and say ‘where did the wings hit the building’ and you think ‘gosh that is strange, where did the wings go?’ And then they’ll say ‘doesn’t it look more like the result of an explosion?’ And you go ‘I think you’re right’.
Similar tactics for the twin tower collapse - you need to have in-depth knowledge of construction and demolition to dismantle their argument for the towers having been blown up rather than collapsing, and because you don’t have that knowledge, you’ll go with their ‘simple’ explanation. Bearing in mind that they’ve presented you with a skewed version of events that would naturally lead to their explanation, you really do have to give your head a wobble and remind yourself of what they are trying to do before falling for it.

Same tactics on holocaust denial sites, anti-vax sites, and sites that believe that the world was created 6000 years ago.

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 14:24

@JingsMahBucket
Yep, pizzagate is at the top of my sisters topic of conversations. And you're right about twatalert. I just find this so frustrating when I can see my beautiful sis literally changing personality in front of my eyes

OP posts:
JingsMahBucket · 04/08/2020 14:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BiBabbles · 04/08/2020 14:18

Groups that perpetuate conspiracy theories and cults have a lot in common and do have tendencies to focus on people at their worst (which is a lot of people right now). It's far more about people wanting answers and part of a community that has answers rather than mental illness. YANBU OP to be concerned about the drug use and be drained by the constant talk about it, but that also means as someone she still views as part of her community, you can try to find alternative ways for her meet those needs.

It’s like 90% of people keep drinking that bloody kool aid!!!
Off topic, but I learned recently that many of the people who died in Jonestown didn't drink the FlavorAid, but had it shot into their mouths with a needles syringe or were injected with cyanide by others (some in the back...).

Sparklesocks · 04/08/2020 14:18

I wonder if sometimes people use conspiracy theories as anchors in difficult times to try and put reason to uncertainty. We are in the midst of a pandemic, on the verge of a recession, there’s a lot of political unease and fears about wider issues like climate change etc - I can see how it might be reassuring to ascribe everything to all knowing, all controlling boogeymen who are orchestrate all of this confusion and hardship.

It might be a more comforting alternative to the idea that everything is random and we are all at the mercy of sheer chaos at any time, with nobody really knowing what’s in store.

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 14:17

@Twatalert can you not see that having different views is not an issue even though I believe some if hers are wildly ridiculous and she believes I am blind to what is really going on. It is the fact that all conversations with her are brought back to these topics and it is taking over every aspect of her life. Surely you can agree that is not healthy?

OP posts:
SomewhereEast · 04/08/2020 14:11

Also conspiracy theories have always been around, especially in times of stress (historian checking in) but they've been absolutely turbocharged by social media. It crosses the ideological spectrum too - I'm a liberal Labour voting Remainer type & I've had to step away from some acquaintances who genuinely believe that the Tories are using Covid to cull the elderly (their core voters...makes total sense to me????) or that Boris's baby is a fake brought in to distract the public. These people weren't always like that. They just got very sucked into the wilder end of the FBPE community online where everyone reinforces everyone else's views. Its really sad

Twatalert · 04/08/2020 14:11

Thestreets: you are drip feeding. Now, apparently she is unable to look after her child. As I said, address the weed problem. That's more likely the source of her messed up routine than discovering things on youtube.