Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To feel like I'm losing my sister to conspiracy theories?

309 replies

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 13:24

My sister is a very intelligent, funny, interesting woman but recently , probably since lockdown she has been spending more and more time online and reading into conspiracy theories about the Hollywood elite and politicians and child sacrifices and all kinds of ludicrous claims.

This has utterly consumed her, you cannot have a conversation with the her that she does not turn to her trying to show some you tube video as "evidence". I'm so worried but do not know what to do as everything I say is met with "well that's what they want you to think".

OP posts:
Thestreets · 04/08/2020 15:56

@redbushtea please read my earlier posts. It is not her option that worrys me but the fact that it has completely consumed her whole life and is affecting her work and her relationships by being so obsessed.

OP posts:
ColourMeExhausted · 04/08/2020 15:56

Oh and friend is a big weed smoker...interesting as I hadn't made that connection.

TheSandman · 04/08/2020 15:55

How can they not see that the "proof" they keep bringing up is so obviously fake it's funny?

Because it's not 'proof' as generally accepted. ie a test of veracity... Generally it goes like this: I have this theory, I test it by doing X, Y, and Z. The results of the tests are as the theory predicted. The results are my proof.

To the conspiracy theorist proof is non-experimental confirmation. 'Evidence' rather than proof. They can't see the difference and can't examine the evidence other than to look for ways in which it confirms their beliefs. Just as Fundamentalist Religious types will use the Bible or the Koran* as 'proof' of their claims.

It's circular. The theory and the evidence confirm each other therefore both are unquestionable.

This is not just a conspiracy theory thing. The history of science is littered with similar circular thinking which becomes orthodoxy until the evidence against it mounts up and someone comes up with a better way of explaining a phenomenon.

The difference here is Science has the concept of Falsifiability. All theory can be proven wrong. Science acknowledges that there is doubt. Conspiracy theory doesn't. Conspiracy theory KNOWS. It's religion disguising itself as science.

*Other religious texts are available.

ColourMeExhausted · 04/08/2020 15:55

Yes, i have a friend who has well and truly fallen down this rabbit hole! She's posting loads of stuff on Facebook and it's becoming more far fetched as time goes on. At first it was annoying and now it's worrying (and this, my friends, is how Trump will win another election).

PrinnyPree · 04/08/2020 15:55

Can you one up her? Say you think these conspiracy theories are a conspiracy theory! Like powerful people want to distract people from the real "boring" conspiracies like tax avoidance and corporate lobbying by releasing sexy conspiracies that sound like the plot of a convoluted movie. Like why would they need to use a vaccine to microchip people when everyone voluntarily walks around with a gps enabled "microchip" with camera and microphone in their pocket on a day to day basis.

Everytime she mentions a batshit conspiracy just say ah thats what they want you to think to distract you from the less exciting truth. Wink

FrontToBackTree · 04/08/2020 15:53

Personally I think the reason conspiracy theorists have latched onto covid is for them thinking that the government is controlling it all is less scary than the actual scientific truth, which is that life is we know it could effectively be over for good.

Shinygreenelephant · 04/08/2020 15:53

My ex has gone the same way, spouting absolute nonsense and posting all over social media about it. I'm only letting him see DD under close supervision by his mum at the moment, he's been to the doctor at my insistence but all they've done is signed him off work - not helpful at all. He smokes weed too and although he swears hes stopped now I think the damage is done. Its really sad and I don't have any advice really because I'm struggling with it myself

AnneOfQueenSables · 04/08/2020 15:53

It sounds like you're losing her to weed smoking tbh. Today it's conspiracy theories but people who smoke a lot of weed often have compulsions and paranoia. I don't think there is any point in you trying to change her opinions or getting her to do a digital detox if she is still smoking. That would need to change first.
I'd drop all the conspiracy theory arguments and focus on the health risks associated with her smoking, how bad it is for her DC etc.

redbushtea · 04/08/2020 15:51

Everybody is entitled to their opinion and that includes your sister. You really can't blame her. We have to admit there have been very illogical things going on in the past months, and things are going from bad to worst. I certainly don't trust the governments of this world to have our best interests at heart.

WinterAndRoughWeather · 04/08/2020 15:44

My sister has been like this for years. It started when she got pregnant and she became anti-vax and she’s got worse and more extreme as time has gone on.

I think weed smoking is a red herring. She doesn’t touch the stuff, or even alcohol. I think there’s a paranoid mindset that can be exacerbated by weed, but I don’t know that it’s causative.

Shinyletsbebadguys · 04/08/2020 15:44

The irritation for me is that conspiracy theorists are rarely interested in making the world a better place but far more in having such low self esteem that they need to put others down.

A ridiculous colleague was bleating about "sheeple" and turned to me and said you need to wake up and not believe the news and what you see online. I rather shrugged and said "I don't". He got very excited and started twittering on and I had to point out that anyone who is silly enough to believe without question everything you read in the media then you deserve to be horrified when it turns out it's been spun or changed. Anyone who believes that people with lots of power and money hide things then you don't understand the concept of power on identity. However he was doing the same thing and not using his brain when he read every conspiracy going so he was just as naive. Automatic embracing of every pseudo science claim was exactly the same as believing a single person like Donald Trump was a bloody saviour or that everything on BBC news was true.

I have a healthy scepticism of most things really, I don't automatically believe what the BBC says anymore than I believe what the online journals say unless they can publish empirical proof and even then only when its verified, peer reviewed etc.

My DP mother was and still is going down this rabbit hole (previous MH issues , socially disenfranchised and has had a horrendous time,also the most lovely woman I have ever met ) , she was concerned about Agenda 21 (or whatever number it was) I did some looking and when I mentioned the only groups it involved in the UK were power defunct NGOs she just found something else to worry about.

If you use the word sheeple your beliefs have nothing to do with the content and everything to do with feeling so desperately empty you need to push others down to feel you are remotely relevant.

I'm really sorry OP it does sound like the weed is affecting her , as to what you can do I would be non committal so you can stay nearby to keep an eye on her DC. Not easy but right now I suspect the only option.

SockYarn · 04/08/2020 15:42

Arguing with a conspiracy theorist is impossible. Any counter-argument is taken by them as proof of brainwashing, that you can't see the truth, that you're a sheeple.

I feel sorry for you, OP. It must be very draining.

jessstan2 · 04/08/2020 15:40

There's a lot of this about. It's a phase, your sister will get over it when things go back to normal. In the meantime just tell her she is becoming a bit of a bore.

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 15:34

@JingsMahBucket
They are really good suggestions. I will start with some of those thank you

OP posts:
PatriciaPerch · 04/08/2020 15:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FrontToBackTree · 04/08/2020 15:31

I saw someone I thought was a sensible and intelligent human being post a picture of a small glass bottle containing clear liquid on instagram. This was apparently a substance that "hollywood elites" had extracted from the adrenal glands of tortured children. Said hollywood elites use this substance to keep them looking young and beautiful. Apparently this child torture ring has been going on for years and all the left wing hollywood celebs and other powerful people are involved.

I mean, how do you even begin to argue with that level of stupidity? Hmm

TheSandman · 04/08/2020 15:29

Buy her a subscription to the Fortean Times.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fortean_Times

It does a pretty good job of holding this kind of stuff up to the light without appearing to be overtly dismissive and 'debunking'. And it's pretty funny in places too.

Oswin · 04/08/2020 15:28

Tom Hanks hasn't moved to Greece. He has been given honory citizenship because he helped out in an emergency.

What I don't understand is why do people not see the bullshit. Look at the people targeted by Qanon. Left wingers. Critics of trump. How can these people not see this is political manipulation?
How can they not see that the "proof" they keep bringing up is so obviously fake it's funny?

SusieOwl4 · 04/08/2020 15:28

There are many conspiracy theories that actually can be proven wrong with literally 5 minutes research so for those saying she is right then you should know what these people are posting is not opinion they are posting things as fact, and can be corrected .

And then there is the crazy, just as annoying group of people who believe everything they read in the press as fact - before it is announced by the Government . That is just as annoying and devisive and dangerous. Get everyones backup just so they can make a political point before something has happened - or it may not even ever happen at all , but that does not matter because people just want to have a rant about it .

People have too much time on their hands.

infuriating .

LittleRed53 · 04/08/2020 15:27

Freedom of thought, freedom of speech. She's not hurting you, and engaging with her is obviously stressing you out and wearing on you, so just leave her be. Maybe you don't like how her behavior has changed, but she has the right to think what she wants.

SusieOwl4 · 04/08/2020 15:21

there is a friend of mine on facebook who is doing the same thing .

As if the government is purposely controlling us and wanting to ruin the economy on purpose? and covid does not exist . Its very insulting to all those who work in the NHS and those that have lost family . She is normally a nice person . I started by posting kindly the facts that she had wrong and could be proven wrong . In the end I gave up and I just snooze her for 30 days when she posts something ridiculous , thank goodness I don't see her in real life .

FrontToBackTree · 04/08/2020 15:18

She maybe thinks you are a conspiricist because she believes what she does to be fact. so if you think she is wrong, you must believe everything you are being told then.

Anyone with half a brain would take 10 minutes to look into the "details" of such conspiracies and know that they are total fabrication.

jackdawdawn · 04/08/2020 15:18

I had a convo like this with a neighbour recently, posted about it on MN.

The only thing I can compare it to is religious mania. Human beings seem to have a compulsion to believe in organised evil, and I guess, salvation. It's not so different to people centuries ago believing that pandemics and crop failures were caused by witchcraft. It's just alarming that our educational system churns out people incapable of critical thinking.

I think the right word is 'radicalisation', and if this WERE happening around religious or political belief, there might be more concern expressed at a higher level. You may say 'what's the harm?' but people who believe this stuff are fodder for extremist political ideologies.

kerfuffling · 04/08/2020 15:17

She could be right

She isn't.

HolyForkinShirt · 04/08/2020 15:15

I think conspiracy theory is a huge rabbit hole. People idiots read one and get sucked into lots of different bonkers ideas.

I quite enjoy watching a few. Not because I believe them but they have been a great source of entertainment. (Like flat earth on Netflix)

Anyway, my friend is similar to your sister. He fed off the debate and loved trying to prove us non believers wrong. Now I just don't react to it, I just say 'sounds interesting' to his theories and it seems to have died down a bit. He has moved onto trying to convert other people, not me !