Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nannies are overpaid?

358 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 19:59

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

OP posts:
MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 30/07/2020 09:59

What you were paying for is convenience - of being able to just leave for work in the morning, knowing that you don't have to trek halfway across London to the childminder or nursery. Of coming home to children who have been fed and bathed, whose homework has been done and so all you have to do is enjoy being with them. You didn't have to do a full day at work, then fetch your kids and do all the hard work of caring for them before you could have dinner/work/relax. You had a safe, reliable babysitter on tap. Those things are expensive.

Othering · 30/07/2020 09:32

What you have going on here is internalised sexism op. Answer a question (based on what a pp said further upthread). Would you/do you complain about retained fire fighters being paid to sit in their station, taking the opportunity to rest, whilst waiting for their next call out? I bet it wouldn't even cross your mind and its because its traditionally been seen as men's work. Nannies are traditionally seen as female and its therefore not as acceptable for them to earn a decent wage.

Snog · 30/07/2020 09:31

I would also want to pay my nanny well and treat her well such that she didn't want to leave! Because I feel that continuity of care would be important for my dc. So I wouldn't be looking to pay as low a rate as I could get away with, more likely as much as I could afford to.

elenacampana · 30/07/2020 09:07

Exactly @Snog

This OP comes across very badly. From the protestations about not being classist, whilst appearing to be very classist to giving herself a pat on the back for looking after her own children during maternity leave and then dumping them on a nanny so she’s been able to spend her whole life at work ever since. Then she begrudges this nanny decent pay and claims to be a lovely person! I just don’t think so!

Snog · 30/07/2020 08:50

It's not wrong to value the work of someone entrusted with your children.
I think our society is at fault to value the work of nursery workers and carers so little.

I would want my nanny (if I had one) to feel highly valued. I would be very choosy about who I appointed but wouldn't necessarily make the choice based on her education as other factors would be more important to me.

Realitybites21 · 30/07/2020 07:02

Surely the real issue here is the add-ins after the take-home pay?

As a general rule of thumb, the take-home salary is just 50% of the true cost to the employer by the time you’ve taken j to consideration the NIC’s, pension, annual leave, motoring expenses, etc.

lookatallthosechickens · 30/07/2020 00:19

I actually have a nanny in London, unlike OP. She’s part time and very well paid and has qualifications- it comes out to about 30k pro rata for a very light workload, no nappies, no cleaning, a little cooking, plus extra for nights she babysits when we want to go out.

ClareBlue · 30/07/2020 00:18

Have I got this right. You have a job where you work all hours you are awake, when you are not awake you wake up worrying about your job, you are stressed and think the person that is nuturing and loving your child is overpaid to do the role that you cannot do due to your job. And the importance of your job is what? Real, real importance. Pl

SmileTolerantly · 29/07/2020 23:58

I do wish people wouldn’t compare nanny salaries with teachers without pro rataing the teachers’ salaries up to a 48 week equivalent.

And I wish even more that people wouldn’t compare hourly salaries for full time employed worker staff like nannies, with hourly rates for self employed workers like cleaners who sell their time on an hourly basis in dribs and drabs, often having to travel between jobs at their own expense and usually get no holiday pay, no sick pay, no NI contributions, no pension contributions, and no redundancy pay.

CayrolBaaaskin · 29/07/2020 23:54

You can get a nanny for less than that, even in London

imabusybee · 29/07/2020 23:51

@Fr0thandBubble you're coming across as weirdly nasty, and spiteful. You're harping on about you and your nanny being 'friends' but you clearly don't value her worth as an employee or extended member of your family.

Oh and clearly furloughed her in a global pandemic (did you top up her salary or just pay the basic 80%?) And then have made her redundant since. Im not sure she would consider you a 'friend' Confused

Worriedmum999 · 29/07/2020 23:51

Seems to me you also took advantage of the furlough scheme which was designed to help employers keep their staff on over difficult times. Seeing as you say you had to look after your children and work then I’m guessing you were paid your normal wage. Why on Earth not just pay your nanny as normal and let her keep working so you wouldn’t have to juggle childcare and work, no doubt doing a crappier job of the childcare than she would have done? I’m betting you didn’t top up her 80% eitherConfused Makes you wonder why some people have kids.

Polkasquare · 29/07/2020 23:50

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@upsidedownwavylegs Not really, I work ridiculous hours in a professional job which requires a degree and three years training on top of that. It’s very stressful and not much fun! Not many people could do (or would want to do!) my job, which is why I get paid well for it.

My point is that nannies get paid really well without needing any qualifications or having to work that hard.[/quote]
But they're not really nannies without a qualification.

Lilybet1980 · 29/07/2020 23:49

OP I’m assuming your nanny is actually just a bit shit at her job so you don’t really see her value. You’ve mentioned her being unprofessional a few times, and implied she’s a bit lazy by not doing anything when your youngest is at nursery. As you said, you’re too soft and perhaps your nanny takes the piss.

I pay our nanny more than you and don’t begrudge her a penny of it. She makes my life so much easier, allowing me to do my (highly paid, long hours, demanding, stressful and unpredictable) job without having to worry about my children, whether they are ok and whether I can get back from work in time. I pay her well because I need someone who won’t moan when I give zero notice that I’m going to be two hours late, or ask her to do an overnight the next day because I need to travel and OH is already away.

I don’t just pay her for what she does during the 12 hours a day that she’s contracted to work for us, I pay for the peace of mind of knowing I can fully focus on my job when I need to, and knowing that I have someone who adores my DC and is absolutely devoted to their well being.

The other aspect I hadn’t really considered before employing a nanny is that she makes my weekends easier too. I start the weekend with a tidy house and I don’t spend half of it doing DC laundry.

I suggest you look for a better nanny if you are paying that much!

C8H10N4O2 · 29/07/2020 23:40

Here are some examples of Nanny jobs going for that right now

The job mapping onto that salary is for a governess, not a nanny.

MorganKitten · 29/07/2020 23:38

And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

Nannies aren’t there to clean, you’d need a housekeeper or cleaner for that.
You hired the nanny for childcare, ironing isn’t childcare.

Yetiyoga · 29/07/2020 23:37

@ChrisPrattsFace to be fair, the op chose to pay that much and enployed a nanny without qualifications. Like I've said (outside London) going rate is anywhere between £9-15ish an hour.
Nannies earning £18-25 ph have normally gone to Norland College and tend to work for HNW families (celebs, Royal family etc...) where the job is extremely stressful and you basically have no social life.

ChrisPrattsFace · 29/07/2020 23:29

I’m loving all the people saying that £18-25 per hour isn’t much.
I do a skilled scientific job which requires accuracy and qualifications and I am just on NMW with 8 years experience.

Think I’m gonna be a nanny. Apparently don’t need any qualifications for that!

OpenWheelRace · 29/07/2020 23:27

Also - being a Nanny has a time limit on it. Usually around late thirties-early forties.

It also is not family friendly at all - most of us do it in our twenties, get a lum of money and then move on.

OpenWheelRace · 29/07/2020 23:25

@Dandarabilla

No nanny earns such an amount of money (especially unqualified) as you claim in your post. Maybe after tax, but no nanny earns £50K a year, that’s a blatant lie! £50K a year would translate to approx. £950/week. Show me a nanny who earns that much. Your post is a joke!
Here are some examples of Nanny jobs going for that right now. Also note that the salaries are quoted as NET = so add income tax on top.
To think nannies are overpaid?
To think nannies are overpaid?
Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 23:19

@Yetiyoga Ugh, that comment was specifically to address a PP who said two parents (with full-time jobs) looking after their children during lockdown was not even comparable to a nanny having to look after children on their own. My point was that that was bollocks, which it is.

As for you, you earn little over half what my nanny was getting, so clearly my comment was not aimed at you.

I’m signing off now as this thread has got weirdly nasty.

OP posts:
trixiebelden77 · 29/07/2020 23:15

Well, the nanny earning 120k is earning more than I am as a doctor. Am I about to quit and become a nanny? No.

Are you about to quit your job for the life of ease and luxury of your nanny? No.

Weird, isn’t it, how they’re so overpaid and their job is so easy.....but we don’t want to do it.

For a long long time I had a cleaner who earned more per hour than me. Why shouldn’t she? She was doing a difficult job, doing it well, and that’s what the market said she could get for her skill. This silly hierarchy of who should earn more based on perceived status is old and tired.

Blackcurrant66 · 29/07/2020 23:15

To get the £120k type salary you basically have to have no life of your own and to never have had any life of your own because you’ll have spent years working for high net worth families, getting excellent references, following them around the world, working more or less continuously, any time off will be adhoc to suit them outside of a few weeks a year, but you don’t really need time off because what the hell are you going to do stranded ‘on vacation’ in a luxury mansion in a remote part of Crete anyway? You might as well work.

And it’s totally incompatible with ever having children of your own.

OpenWheelRace · 29/07/2020 23:15

I'm the (ex) Nanny from the thread that you're referring to on the £120k.

Part of me thinks I was massively overpaid - but then I worked 24/6 for this money and did everything. It was horrifically stressful and I was completely at the mercy of the whims of the family.
I don't have qualifications, but I didn't exactly step into that job either - I started out on much lower pay.

The high paid jobs come with a lot more shit than your standard Mon-Fri Nanny job.

HOWEVER

My point is that nannies get paid really well without needing any qualifications or having to work that hard.

You lost me at this sentence. A Nanny who is not working hard, is not doing their job properly. Childcare is HARD, even more so when it is not your own child.

Walkaround · 29/07/2020 23:15

@Fr0thandBubble - tbh, if you think being a Nanny is so easy and enjoyable, whereas your work is comparatively stressful, difficult and boring, and no more important to society than being a Nanny is, then I’m wondering why you aren’t a Nanny yourself! Doesn’t it pay enough for you? Grin