Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nannies are overpaid?

358 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 19:59

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

OP posts:
RaininSummer · 30/07/2020 19:18

Why does your daughter only get that paltry amount a month for a 40 week? Did you mean that is her weekly wage?

Mittens030869 · 30/07/2020 19:17

I think the OP has left the thread like she said she was going to do. She obviously didn't like the fact that posters weren't telling her what she wanted to hear. Not surprising.

Oblomov20 · 30/07/2020 19:16

£50k seems a huge amount to me. Surely only lawyers and husbands at Barings banks etc, stockbrokers on £200k+ can afford this?

Londonmummy66 · 30/07/2020 19:14

Personally I think that it depends on the nanny. I had a professional job with long and unpredictable hours so I had a nanny - they earn well but in practice they really do earn it. Mine did all the cleaning of the DCs rooms and all their laundry, fed them (and usually made enough that DH and I could finish it off for supper). SHe had the usual nanny contract rule of half her holiday at my choice and half her holiday at her choice and she was often able to find me holiday cover amongst her friendship group.As she lived in was expected to babysit for free 1 night a week but got paid at the weekend.

Like most she had a post 16 qualification in childcare but wasn't an all singing all dancing Norland/Princess Christian nanny.

I've always found this to be a sensible resource for checking what a nanny should be earning.

imperialnannies.com/candidate/

Mittens030869 · 30/07/2020 19:13

I think it’s more than other kinds of childcare workers (nursery workers in particular) are very underpaid.

^This. I'm really grateful to my DD1's childminder. I'm a SAHM, but DD1 (now 11 and about to start secondary school) has SEN and adoption related attachment issues and was being violent to me and DD2. She's done an amazing job, picking her up 2 afternoons a week to give me respite when we really needed it.

I'm really grateful and think she's underpaid rather than nannies being overpaid.

I also would never dream of slagging her off on MN like this OP. Very unkind.

FourPlasticRings · 30/07/2020 19:13

No, you've misread it @MintyMabel. He was talking about the long term effects being relatively small.

He continues: "There is now overwhelming evidence that daycare causes children to have abnormal cortisol levels, probably increasing the risk of behavioural problems like aggression, fearfulness and hyperactivity."

"If daycare is as distressing to under-threes as many researchers believe, it would not be surprising if it affected their cortisol levels: when distressed we usually secrete the hormone."

Compared to:

For children under two, the effects are small: the child might be slightly more bossy, more argumentative – something we might not consider to be negative. In some cultures it might be seen as a good thing," she says.

It's sort of like the controlled crying thing. We know it stresses babies out, but we don't know whether that causes any long term impact. For me, the stress aspect was enough of a black mark against it for me to choose other childcare, even if not accompanied by longer term impacts. There is a tendency for people to get defensive about this- honestly, I'm not judging those who choose to use daycare. But someone asked for reasons for nannies, and that was a factor in my decision. If I couldn't have afforded a nanny, I'd have gone for a childminder.

Whatnowhey · 30/07/2020 19:07

Oh should have said 1 child 6 months to just turned 4

MintyMabel · 30/07/2020 19:03

It's fairly well documented that babies have raised cortisol levels in day nursery, indicative of a stress response. I found this a fairly decent summary

One guardian article, where the author of the original study, himself says

“Whether we are talking about the good news or the bad news, these are small effects," he says.”

I was right about the quality of that research then.

Whatnowhey · 30/07/2020 19:02

Crikey - my daughter is a live in nanny works 4 days a week 7am to 5pm (was doing a full time Forensic Psychology degree for 3 years - just finished Upper 2.1 (Hons)) does the washing, cleaning and gets the dinner ready and is being paid £320.00 per month, yes that's right, not a typing mistake, I've not forgotten to add another digit. £320.00 per month. Oh and no student allowances. When I was working I held a very senior role in a school in London and didn't earn 50K!!

nannykatherine · 30/07/2020 19:02

@Ilovecranberries

If there is an accident they are trained in paediatric first aid. Let's be objective - a typical, market-standard pediatric first aid training for nannies is three hours of lectures with a mannequin, costing £80 to £100. It looks good on paper, but in practice has close to zero use.
And this is outrageously untrue .. most nannies do extra CPD paid for by themselves and this is at a high level .. I suggest you do some research
nannykatherine · 30/07/2020 18:59

And yes I am qualified with lots of experience and live in london

nannykatherine · 30/07/2020 18:58

Just to point out as a Nanny myself
I get £15 an hour
Gross
For more than one child ..
I work 12 hours a day with no breaks
I might get to visit the toilet alone for a few seconds
It generally understood that nannies don’t go off sick in a whim
Parents depend on us
We look after children
Develop them
Teach train
Mop up tears
Help sleep help weaning
Help language develop
Give them the grounding they need to start learning at school
Read to them sing to them dance with them
Paint with them
Push them around in prams
Lift them
Constantly
(Have you thought if the wear and tear in our bodies )
We look for signs of developmental Delay and help when it problems arise
We notice if they need eye tests
Or other medical intervention ..
We look after them if they are sick so parents can work
We cook
We clean up our mess and their
mess
We get home way after you
We are too tired to cook for ourselves
Or see friends or do a fitness class in the evening
In the morning we have to leave our home before you to-get to your home so you can get to work intime .
If you don’t notice all the million things your nanny does for you and your children then you dont deserve one

SuperDuperJezebel · 30/07/2020 18:56

I saw this on Facebook yesterday and it feels apt to share.

To think nannies are overpaid?
FourPlasticRings · 30/07/2020 18:56

@MintyMabel

I can just guess what the quality of that “research” was.

It's fairly well documented that babies have raised cortisol levels in day nursery, indicative of a stress response. I found this a fairly decent summary:

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/oct/02/nurseries-childcare-pre-school-cortisol

SuperDuperJezebel · 30/07/2020 18:54

IMHO it is a mistake to compare other caring roles such as care work and nursery work, and say nannies are overpaid, more that these other professions are undervalued and underpaid.

I've been a nanny for 20y and I work hard and earn every penny of my salary. I'm degree educated and put an effort into CPD to ensure I'm as up to date as I possibly can. I spent most of my working hours during lockdown (working longer days than I had initially been employed for) home educating two children with a toddler around, to enable my employers to continue working uninterrupted. I spend a lot of time and effort planning fun and educational activities for them, ferry them around constantly, spend a lot of time menu planning and preparing interesting food in an attempt to encourage a more diverse palate for a veg refusenik. I do all the family's washing and regularly prepare extra to save the parents cooking. I stay late at short notice and I'm super flexible despite having my own child. I work bloody hard and I'm knackered at the end of the week, I love my job and I genuinely love the children. It's a shame other professions are under paid but don't use that to negate our skills and effort.

frillydress · 30/07/2020 18:51

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@2bazookas Odd comment. Not “more important” but certainly more difficult, longer hours, more stressful and requiring of a much higher skill level.[/quote]
You certainly like to belittle your nanny as someone who does basically nothing, with no skills or qualifications whereas your job is highly stressful, requiring much higher skill level Confused look after and raise your own children if you think they're that overpaid for. How can you put a price on someone raising your kids for you.

willitbetonight · 30/07/2020 18:47

Yanbu at all.

Whycantibeapuppy · 30/07/2020 18:44

Just to add to my post, yes compared to childminders, teachers, SEN etc we are paid well but the problem is that they are massively underpaid for their role. Shockingly underpaid!

With nannying there is absolutely no job security, once finances go wrong with parents the nanny is the first to go sometimes with a weeks notice depending on contract. Nannies don’t plan jobs to be long term because children go to school. Any development is their own to find and finance. Absolute flexibility is required...if your train is cancelled and you’ll be an hour late, your nanny will still be there. We cannot make solid plans unless we book holiday off. Appraisals are rare, bonuses dependent on the parents and some nannies may be paid well but they are treated appallingly. I’ve had more awful jobs that good jobs because at the end of the day we are your employee and not all employers are good ones.

SUPERMANNY · 30/07/2020 18:41

As a qualified manny I wish I was getting 50k a year. I do everything for the children and for the house cooking for whole family, washing, ironing, cleaning, shopping, arranging repairs (or doing it myself). Maybe I need to start charging more.

Whycantibeapuppy · 30/07/2020 18:40

@Ilovecranberries actually the most commonly recognised qualification, required for Ofsted registration is a 12 hour course, sometimes a mix of practical and theory where you are tested on every single part and if you fail you fail, they are actually quite strict about it. I can count the times I’ve had to use my training one hand but god I am glad I had the training in each of those instances.

MintyMabel · 30/07/2020 18:38

Most of the research I had done suggested that day nurseries are stressful for babies

🙄

I can just guess what the quality of that “research” was.

MintyMabel · 30/07/2020 18:35

Depends how much value you put on looking after your children.

It bothers me people see that as a minimum wage job.

payens · 30/07/2020 18:33

Look after your own kids then

Atadaddicted · 30/07/2020 18:21

I was paid more than that 10 years ago for doing very little in finance in the city.... 9-5 (with a load of perks, private health, pension, amazing maternity pay....)!

Ilovecranberries · 30/07/2020 18:20

If there is an accident they are trained in paediatric first aid.
Let's be objective - a typical, market-standard pediatric first aid training for nannies is three hours of lectures with a mannequin, costing £80 to £100. It looks good on paper, but in practice has close to zero use.

Swipe left for the next trending thread