Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nannies are overpaid?

358 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 19:59

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

OP posts:
nannykatherine · 30/07/2020 22:03

@bloodywhitecat

I am an NNEB qualified nursery nurse, until 15 months ago I worked as a Specialist Nursery Nurse for the NHS looking after children with complex health needs. Many of the children were on home ventilation and had oxygen therapy as well as having complex epilepsy, complex drugs regimes and many were fed via tubes. As a team we provided care so that the rest of the family could do the things that most of us take for granted as the children on our books were too poorly to even leave the family home, we also worked nights so mum and dad/carer could sleep. For that I earned the princely sum of circa £23k pa. It seems mad that I could earn double that as a nanny.
How many hours a week did you work .. ?? Nannies work on average 50/60 hours a week ...compare you hours and salary to that and find out it wouldn’t be much different ..
Monkeynuts18 · 30/07/2020 21:54

@underneaththeash

Eh? What au pair regulation is there going to be after Brexit? And why would that lead to nannies being paid less?

Othering · 30/07/2020 21:51

@nicegirl73

YABU having relied on nannies as a single parent to three children I believe they are worth their weight in gold and I would pay that if I could. They are basically a spare mum.
They're absolutely not. Unless you think childcare and domestic work is the sole responsibility of women. A nanny is a spare parent, not mum.
underneaththeash · 30/07/2020 21:30

Nannies are massively overpaid, hopefully with au pair regulation after Brexit things will be better. There is a deficit of after school care, which qualified nanies don’t need to do.
But employers need be better at advertising only gross annual salaries and make it clear that they employees.

bemusedmoose · 30/07/2020 21:28

I think the question is - why did you pay £50k for someone unqualified to be in charge of your children!? If she was fully trained fair enough but nothing?

Nannies are there for child raising - when did they do house work to? Unless you have an agreement for such i would have assumed it was child care only. You are also preventing any other paid work during the day as she will have to do pick ups and step in for illness, cook tea, so you have to hire her for the full day. If you wanted extra chores you should have stated in the contract or got someone qualified.

Beebs101 · 30/07/2020 21:25

Hiya full time nanny here!!! Working in the industry for over 19years I have worked with many different types of families and dynamics. Most of these years were working in london. My rates have changed with my experience and qualifications to reflect what I bring to the table.

-I have 19+ years experience
-Combined BA in Education & Early Childhood studies
-A qualified maternity nurse and experienced twins, singles and triplet maternity nurse.
-deputy manager responsible for three crèches
-travel nanny and
-sleep trainer!!!

Having a nanny is a luxury that not all families can afford. If you are employing a nanny, they should do all child related tasks, which does not mean cleaning your bedroom or folding your smallest... however if you employ a nanny housekeeper that could be an agreement you make.

My starting salary used to be £10per hour making £500 a week. For the past 6years I have worked with High Profile families and High Net worth families. With a weekly salary 4x times the U.K. standard with the perks of 1st class Travel, own suites and drives/chefs. Double salary twice a year and my own apartment just to boast!! And name a few of the perks of my job. But these obviously come with long work hours and private life sacrifice so it’s no one sided at all.

I love my job and have enjoyed it over the years, and if there is one thing I’ll say about childcare, finding the right fit and compensating them fairly for it.

* You get what you pay for. *

Jonas14 · 30/07/2020 21:18

Stay at home with your children full time, take a year off and then you might realize how hard it actually is. I’ve gone from being a high flying professional to a mum, I have a nanny one day a week and work around mine, it’s hard work. I think your nanny deserves every penny she got. Kids laundry is not just a matter of throwing in a machine, mine takes forever to sort out and as for a quick sandwich lunch, just trying to get them to eat is a mission. Sorry but get a grip and be extremely grateful to have some for so long who took care of them in an environment you felt comfortable with. Not everyone can afford to go to university and get the qualifications you have got. You have a different kind of stress and 50k in London is peanuts. Plus working long hours with small children is difficult. teachers or nursery staff know what time they can clock off.

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/07/2020 21:15

I was a nanny for 20yrs now a Maternity nurse

Why did you chose an unqualified Nannies. Plenty of nneb and nancw btec etc for that salary

Nanny does sound a tad lazy. She can do children’s laundry and tidy rooms and batch cook

But also deserves some spare time as nannies don’t get a lunch break

Yes compared to someone in a Manual job earning nmw Nannies can earn a lot £12/15g per hour. Sometimes more

R.E.M. that nanny makes your life easier. Means you can go to work
And do your job knowing kids are safe and looked after

Monkeynuts18 · 30/07/2020 21:12

@FourPlasticRings

I have a child in nursery but did seriously consider a nanny (and still may do if we have another child, because the cost of having two in nursery isn’t far from the cost of a nanny). But the thing that really put me off was the risk. Surely all the benefits of a nanny that you mention only apply if you find a good one who stays with you? And surely if you have a bad one, or a string of ones who don’t work out, that will cause your child more stress than nursery would have done?

Lot of my colleagues have nannies and the stories I’ve heard are horrendous. The one who turned up to work drunk from the night before and was supposed to drive the children to school. The one who they found rifling through their jewellery box and looking at their passports. The colleague whose son kept wetting himself at night and showing signs of massive anxiety, then it turned out the nanny had been driving him around in her boyfriend’s car without a car seat. The one who kept dropping a little girl off at school late and in her pyjamas. The one who didn’t come into work because she was feeling ‘fatigued’ and the one who kept having breakdowns at work (in front of the children) over relationship dramas.

Admittedly lots of my colleagues now have nannies they’re incredibly happy with. And in fact I was looked after by a nanny when I was young and I adored her, we’re still in touch. But it seems to me like a huge amount of trust to put in one person. And you have limited insight into their work. They’re completely unaccountable. No Ofsted inspections, no oversight from anyone but your child. And they can resign at any time. Just the thought makes me nervous!

Baker0104 · 30/07/2020 21:04

I'm a nanny with 9 years experience and I earn £34500 working 7.15-18.15 either 4 days a week or 5 days a week (it alternates) its the best wage I've ever had nannying. I'm based in quite a nice area of Kent. If I worked in Central London I would expect to earn around £40000/42000.

I'm NVQ Level 3 qualified, first aid, dbs etc. I wouldn't expect to earn £44000 if I wasn't qualified and I would be doing nursery duties - children's washing and ironing, cooking, keeping kids areas clean and tidy etc.

My job is bloody hard. I love the kids but it's tough, I don't get any breaks, can't even go to the toilet myself without both of them coming in lol. That was fun today when I came on my period whilst we were at the beach 😂
Also as people have pointed out, we have very little job security. Most jobs are over after 2/3 years as kids go to school etc. It's rare to find a nanny that's been in their job for years.

So I don't think nannies are underpaid.... However I do think you have overpaid your nanny

thenovice · 30/07/2020 20:48

I am confused. If you pay her that much, you must earn more or it would be worth your while staying at home to look after the children yourself instead. If not, why are you doing it? And if you do earn more, do you think her job is less important than yours?

Whatnowhey · 30/07/2020 20:21

@RaininSummer nope per month - it's her best friends child and she wanted to help them out. I think that she should have had more (and to be honest we have supported her a lot financially) but it was her choice and we offered the help. The husband thought that was a lot!!!!! until friends started saying how much they were paying for nursery places for their young children. He soon realised what a winner he was on.

MacBlank · 30/07/2020 20:20

Don't come on here BOASTING about paying a teenager 50k to look after your sprog, and then say, don't you think they're over paid ... You chose to pay her.

Obvs you are loaded, and obvs care more about earning more money than raising your own children ... That's free, and a wonderful experience for both.

I find posts like these fucking nasty.

I can't afford to buy a piece of medical equipment I really need, because the govt decide that an amount is the MINIMUM REQUIRED BY LAW TO LIVE ON, except you can't live on it, especially when you're disabled.

Probably loose cash to you, but £750 to buy a decent walking frame, is a month's money on disablity benefit for 2 (my fiancee has cancer)... Not everyone gets 1,300 a month plus rent paid, and free meds. Yeah, I don't have to pay for meds or rent, but I do have to find £15-20 to go see my Dr, because it's the only one in my area, but I can't walk there from where the last bus stop is.

So yeah, I hate posts of people complaining on spending a decent amount of money, that would last us a few years.

So yes, you are being TOTALLY UNREASONABLE

SantaClaritaDiet · 30/07/2020 20:11

YABU for choosing to employ a nannie who wasn't "qualified" Hmm and then moan about it.

fascinated · 30/07/2020 20:08

@EmpressoftheMundane

Nannies aren’t over paid. Mothers are under valued.
THIS WINS THE INTERNET!
Mittens030869 · 30/07/2020 20:03

Tbh, I just think it's bad taste for the OP to come on here and complain about how much she was paying her nanny, who wasn't qualified. I would never dream of complaining about someone I was paying to look after my DDs, because I'm always very grateful to them.

Bringonspring · 30/07/2020 19:51

It’s not a massive wage when it’s 25% higher than normal working hours

bloodywhitecat · 30/07/2020 19:40

I am an NNEB qualified nursery nurse, until 15 months ago I worked as a Specialist Nursery Nurse for the NHS looking after children with complex health needs. Many of the children were on home ventilation and had oxygen therapy as well as having complex epilepsy, complex drugs regimes and many were fed via tubes. As a team we provided care so that the rest of the family could do the things that most of us take for granted as the children on our books were too poorly to even leave the family home, we also worked nights so mum and dad/carer could sleep. For that I earned the princely sum of circa £23k pa. It seems mad that I could earn double that as a nanny.

TheMarzipanDildo · 30/07/2020 19:39

Ops grasp on market economics wasn’t great.

nannygoat50 · 30/07/2020 19:36

As a nanny who is qualified and has over 40 years experience , I know no one on that money . Also you should have employed someone from pick up time if you begrudge here doing nothing.!!! If that was the case . I myself never stop in the couple of hrs the little one is at nursery. I tidy up parents mess, wash, iron , empty dishwasher ,empty bins, change beds prepare meals etc . Then when the children are there I can spend quality time doing things with them . Plus I’m there in case either child is sent hone from school for any reason . I don’t have a lunch hr nor t breaks , I don’t sit in front of the tv , I never stop.And I know I’m not the only one I know lots of other nannies are the same

Ilovecranberries · 30/07/2020 19:31

@nannykatherine
I've been employing nannies for a couple of years (interviewed dozens during that time), I can see for myself what the average candidate has to offer. I even paid for a couple of them to take the course to get them ofsted registered (in the good auld days of childcare vouchers, when it made financial sense).

nannykatherine · 30/07/2020 19:23

That must be the nett pay not the gross pay

SurroundedByIdiotsEverywhere · 30/07/2020 19:23

Nannies are 'only' looking after the most important thing in your life, your DC!

If you entrust your children to her on that wage then a) she is worth it and b) you must be on sensational combined? wages to pay her that amount, especially missing out on many important stages when growing so quickly early on... Like a lot of working partners do!

IncrediblySadToo · 30/07/2020 19:23

I’m signing off now as this thread has got weirdly nasty

No, it started off nasty!

Talk about goady AND smug.

jannier · 30/07/2020 19:21

@Ilovecranberries.
Most do 12 hours pediatric every 3 years many parents do zero.