Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nannies are overpaid?

358 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 19:59

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 01/10/2022 10:25

So @VIPNanny are you single or have no kids or partner /husband

is the massive salary , also heavily taxed worth not having a life so to speak

VIPNanny · 01/10/2022 10:15

Well, as someone who do earn £120k as a Nanny,
am I overpaid? I would say anyone on £100k+ is usually overpaid in comparison to most other jobs (irrelevant of the jobs one does unless potentially jobs in which people either save lives or risk their life). That being said, I am paid £120k+/year in exchange of accepting to have no life of my own. Most people wouldn’t do that even if offered that price.

Many women at that salary range in this profession who have been doing it for a long time, end up at 50yo+ not having had their own kids or ever having gotten married because they dedicated their life to somebody else’s children and family and never had enough time off to build a life of their own.

I earn £120k+ because I work unsociable hours, have to deal with very high expectations and constant last minute changes and requests, and usually have very little time off, etc…

If you divide my salary in the amount of hours I work it wouldn’t feel like I am actually earning that well.

I do agree that most childcare professions are incredibly underpaid and that’s unfair. Having a nanny is a luxury though so I don’t necessarily think having exclusive care of your children, at your home, tailored to your schedule and needs should be cheap. I personally that if I asked for a raise I would get it because the family I currently work for sees the value in my work and doesn’t undervalue what I do and they 100% grasp that I am a big portion of what allow them to earn as much as they do and to work as well as they do (they don’t have to worry about childcare, they don’t go to work sleep deprived, they know if there is an emergency I am abilited to cope with it and sort it without normally needing them to drop everything last minute.) It’s a luxury to have that peace of mind and they know it and so they happily pay the price tag that come with it.

The Nanny market is a free market though, Nannies can ask for what they want and you can offer what you wish. Nobody is forcing you to pay 50k for a nanny, I have worked to the same standard (my standards of work are unaffected by my paycheck) for way under 50k, and I would do it again if a family valued the work of a nanny was in need but couldn’t afford it, but I would never work for a family who thinks Nannies have an easy job and that they shouldn’t be paid much more than peanuts for it as a result.

Treat your nanny like you want her to treat your kids is usually my advice. If you expect the best care for them, give her the best package you can afford to give her, if your only criteria is that they stay alive and everything else is free game then by all mean go ahead and pay the minimum.

LittleBearPad · 01/10/2022 10:09

aliatalia · 01/10/2022 09:17

I've had two nannies who looked after the baby from 8 to 6pm and did cooking and cleaning at £10ph. Only the qualified ones charge more.

Ah yes because cheap unqualified childcare is the best option!

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/10/2022 10:01

aliatalia · 01/10/2022 09:11

I don't know what you're talking about as I live in London and pay my nanny £10ph. Sure many will ask for £50k but will then come down when they see you aren't an idiot.

You pay her 10 cash or employ her and would be around £14/14gross

aliatalia · 01/10/2022 09:17

I've had two nannies who looked after the baby from 8 to 6pm and did cooking and cleaning at £10ph. Only the qualified ones charge more.

aliatalia · 01/10/2022 09:11

I don't know what you're talking about as I live in London and pay my nanny £10ph. Sure many will ask for £50k but will then come down when they see you aren't an idiot.

GreenCoxing · 28/08/2020 03:34

We’ve had Nannies for the last 5 years. Like any childcare, the painful part is having to pay out of taxed income!

I think Nanny salaries are also high to reflect the fact that most posts are relatively short term (often till youngest reaches school). Hours are usually very long.They usually don’t have the benefits other jobs have (sick pay (most will be on SSP)).

coronafiona · 28/08/2020 03:00

I had one. Nearly bankrupted me. YANBU

Mincingfuckdragon · 28/08/2020 02:51

OP, you seem reasonably commercially savvy.

So you know about supply and demand.

Supply and demand is why nannies are paid what they're paid. And why you're paid what you're paid. There's no point whining about whether or not it's fair or reasonable in this context - it is what it is (and is not to be conflated with situations where normal supply and demand is warped by government involvement eg teaching and NHS staff).

A separate issue is whether or not your nanny is giving you a standard of service which is generally to be expected from nannies who are paid the amount which you are paying to your nanny. If not, then change this - you have most of the power within your relationship with your nanny so you can't whine about that either.

You seem a bit frustrated and stressed. FWIW, I hope you're OK. From someone who worked extremely long hours in stressful jobs for many years - it's easy to see others as having it better than you if you are actually not happy in your work and in yourself. Consider if the status and money are worth it. They were worth it for me for years - until they weren't. I work for myself now and make about half as much and am far far happier.

Pixxie7 · 28/08/2020 02:39

There are a lot of people in my opinion that are overpaid footballers as example however it is supply and demand.

MrsKypp · 28/08/2020 02:08

Norland nanny salaries & fees

www.norland.ac.uk/salaries-fees/

MrsKypp · 28/08/2020 02:05

I think they should be qualified. It's a profession and really, really important.

www.norland.ac.uk/

KentMum81 · 28/08/2020 01:54

Mixed view here.
I think if you are employing a nanny with extensive qualifications and experience and who organises their own tax and personal liability insurance, then you should pay for their skill set and the fact they are looking after your child/children exclusively.
That being said, there’s absolutely no way you should be paying £50-£60k pa for an unqualified nanny, that’s madness!
As a highly qualified childcare professional, with 15 years experience, who works 50h pw and earns £22k pa before tax, that boils my piss.

SmileTolerantly · 02/08/2020 15:24

One way to look at it is that median full time salary is circa 30 thousand. Full time for 9-5 with an hour’s lunch break is 35 hours. A nanny will typically work 50 hours, potentially with no lunch break, which is 42% more. That would gross up to about 42,500 which is very close to the OP’s nanny’s salary.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 02/08/2020 11:28

55k sounds a lot but that isn't what she's taking home after tax. And for 11 hour days and the level of responsibility, I think it's a reasonable, fair wage - neither under or over paid.
It must be lovely to go to work and not have to worry about your children at all, to know they are getting a really high standard of care and when you come home you don't have to do all the hard slog involved in parenting but can just be with your kids, doing nice things and enjoying family time. Someone else has cooked their dinner, cleaned their rooms, ensured they have school uniform ironed and ready.
You can just leave your house in the morning and only be responsible for yourself.
For people who are on really high wages, the cost of a nanny is worth every penny for what it gives to your life in terms of ease.

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/08/2020 12:48

@stealthbanana so nice you appreciate your nanny

South east is about £14g for a good exp quals nanny so £36.5k for a 50hr 8.6 week plus employers ni and and pension which bumps it up

mathanxiety · 01/08/2020 09:19

'Live-in' is a benefit in kind on top of a salary of £750 per week (though the governess was also 'live-in' iirc).

I don't think the nanny salary is enough for what the average family requires, the flexibility, etc. When families employ a nanny they are doing so in the expectation that they are going to get an experience for their babies and children superior in ways they consider important to that of the local CM or nursery.

C8H10N4O2 · 01/08/2020 08:26

That job description matched the nanny job I had, and all the nanny jobs of women I know who did nannying

Its a few years since I did a governess job but the families employed nannies seperately and our roles were very different.

However my point was not the relative worth of nanny v governess but the fact that governess job titles attract higher salaries.

Hence the claim that lots of nanny jobs pay 1k per week is not well supported by the two supplied adverts, one citing a salary well below 1k and the other for a governess.

BuggertheTabloids · 01/08/2020 07:20

Nanny salaries must have gone up massively then. I had nannies up until 5/6 years ago and it was no where near that salary.
But I am out of London, employed live in (which is cheaper, but what we needed), and I nearly always had newly qualified nannies (great - enthusiastic and keen to use all their recently acquired knowledge!)

Hannahmates · 01/08/2020 07:08

YABU. Nannies are in demand. That's why they get paid so much. If you don't want to pay so much look after your own children.

stealthbanana · 01/08/2020 05:44

(Sorry by every day I meant M-F!)

stealthbanana · 01/08/2020 05:44

They really aren’t a status symbol. They are mostly a necessity for households with 2 working parents with long or unpredictable hours. I know that MN for some reason is deeply uncomfortable with the concept of a nanny’s existence but they are a reality for people who don’t have family close by and/or where both individuals want to maintain their work (and let’s face it it is usually the woman who gets hit with that - the old “why did you have kids if someone else is looking after them” thing).

We pay our nanny £55k (NI pension etc on top of that). She works 730-630 every day, hasn’t had a sick day in 3 years, will stay overnight on the (very) odd occasion we haven’t been able to manage our diaries to avoid both being away for work (pre corona times) obv. She cooks them healthy nutritious meals, reads to them and does lots of developmental educational stuff, knows what to do if they’re sick and showers them with affection. She is hugely trusted and respected, and really part of our family. I don’t think that’s an unreasonable price to pay (and even if I did, well that’s supply and demand isn’t it?!).

I agree that it’s superficially a very good wage but it’s a skilled job with a huge amount of (unsupervised) responsibility.

Hopoindown31 · 01/08/2020 04:45

They get paid a lot because they are as much a status symbol as anything else. At least they have managed to leverage this into better pay. I say good luck to them.

SallyB392 · 01/08/2020 04:27

A Nanny shouldn't be expected to provide cleaning / catering services except for, for the children in their care. They are not cleaners or housekeepers.

Qualifications or not, they have huge degrees of responsibilities, for THE most important people in our lives, and in my opinion, that makes their services priceless!

EinsteinaGogo · 31/07/2020 15:06

@SuperDuperJezebel

I saw this on Facebook yesterday and it feels apt to share.
That's a brilliantly worded message - I really agree with it 👏👏👏👏