Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nannies are overpaid?

358 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 19:59

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

OP posts:
Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 21:30

@Hardbackwriter No, she was furloughed for over two months. I didn’t mention it because maternity leave sprang to mind as a much harder time to look after my children (although lockdown not much fun either, trying to look after children and work at the same time)!

OP posts:
Miljea · 29/07/2020 21:29

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@Palavah Yes I stand by what I said. My work is more difficult, more stressful and requires a higher skill level “than keeping someone else's children alive” as you put it.

Most adults manage to “keep a child alive” - it’s not that hard.

That doesn’t mean I don’t think my nanny is great and I don’t appreciate her because I do - but my job justifies a higher wage because it’s something you need to be highly qualified to do and which requires me to work very long and unsociable hours. The stress level is much higher - I don’t get to switch off when I’m not physically at work, I’m constantly checking my emails, taking calls at all hours, waking up in the middle of the night worrying I made a mistake, etc![/quote]
Froth. I mean this kindly.

But no one ever lay on their death bed and wished they'd put in more hours at the office.

The reality is, your nanny is quite possibly earning more per hour than you.

But making the comparison with others, like teachers and so forth, is pointless. She provides a service that you need. She appears to be doing a good job. She facilitates your chosen way of life.

It's possible that you need to go on paying that because if you don't, others, possibly in your social circle, will pounce on her, upon witnessing that you're happy with her work but moaning about her pay.

The Rich, like you, will always attract those who would seek to relieve you of your money. But paying a good nanny the market rate for her services, nannying for The Rich, isn't her exploiting you.

morriseysquif · 29/07/2020 21:29

As a childcare professional it is really sad that this woman has been in your children's lives at the key time for them in forming emotional attachments and feeling safe and secure in the world and the only thing you can reflect upon is how much she was paid. Yet you set the terms and paid her. Confused

Seem to me you know the price of everything and the value of nothing.

Pamalarrrr · 29/07/2020 21:29

Where are these jobs where nannies earn £120k!!! Wow! They must be Norland Nannies surely and be qualified

Binswangers · 29/07/2020 21:27

@itsaratrap
Interesting. In my experience, those acquired through reputable agencies do.

It is interesting. I've had a very variable experience with agencies. Many of the ones who I haven't kept for long have been through an agency. The best were by recommendation. I think it's very hard to find a nanny you like.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 29/07/2020 21:27

@talkingkrustydoll

I'm in the wrong job. I work in a special needs school and earn just over 11k a year.
You absolutely do! I worked as a TA in an SEN school then left to become a nanny!

OP, nannies are a luxury, hence the price. Nurseries don't do laundry and tidying and taking care of the kids bedrooms and cooking, or have your child when they're sick. And it's your choice to employ someone with no qualifications. I have a degree and years of experience in education, and provide a nurturing and stimulating environment for the children that I care for.

I don't just 'chuck clothes in' I do the whole family's laundry (even though it isn't officially a nanny's job to do so), tidy up messes left over from the weekend or the night before, all because I know my bosses come home tired and don't want to deal with that stuff. And I do it when the kids are at nursery, so again, more fool you for having your nanny do 'nothing' (although I'm sure she does, but you seem to be trivialising most tasks).

She's there while they are at school to be on call should they need to be collected, or can't go in because they are sick or some other issue arrives.

I only do 4 days a week and am absolutely shattered every day when I get home, I barely get a chance to sit down. And don't forget, we don't get lunch breaks like you do in most jobs, where you can leave if you want and have completely uninterrupted time.

Ironing isn't a nanny's job if the clothes are the children's; a nanny isn't a housekeeper (although many parents seem to think this).

A nanny's job is quite specific to each family. And like anything that is customisable, it also comes with a higher price tag.

Hardbackwriter · 29/07/2020 21:26

Given that you didn't name lockdown as a time that you looked after your children, can I take it that your nanny worked throughout? If so then you have been in an amazing position compared to anyone using other forms of childcare and I feel like that alone surely justified the decision to use a nanny, and the cost of it, many, many times over? Speaking as someone who's been working full-time while caring for a toddler!

Saz12 · 29/07/2020 21:24

8.30am-6.30pm, 5 days is 50hrs per week. £44k per year, with only 20 days holiday (I assume including public hols), no real flexibility, fairly short term role, and no other remuneration (bonus/enhanced pension/extra maternity/private health/car allowance/training courses/etc). The only perk is not having to pay for the lunch that she eats with your children (that’s got to be about £2 a day). It’s not a brilliant salary package for London, is it?
Her hourly rate is around £18 or so. So good, but not fantastic.

And the lack of qualifications (really? Not even first aid??!!) doesn’t equate to a lack of skill- surely your employer pays you more now than you’d have earned as a newly-qualified?

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 21:24

@Miljea Chippy much 🙄? Of course there is a price to be put on childcare, ridiculous comment.

OP posts:
Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 21:22

@Hercwasonaroll Ouch! I looked after my children during long maternity leaves, my youngest was an incredibly difficult baby and a terrible sleeper, and I looked after her together with a two year old with autism (which was thought at the time to be severe - thank goodness that now he’s older that’s not the case but at the time it was no picnic, let me tell you), so I have looked after my children (at a much more difficult stage) for a lot longer than 4 weeks, thanks.

OP posts:
Miljea · 29/07/2020 21:22

@bjonesreborn

I’ve been a nanny for 20 years and I can assure you we DO work hard. I work 48 hours in 4 days. The parents trust me with the most precious things in their world. The responsibility is huge. I do the children’s washing and ironing, cook for them, arrange their social life (!), educate them and entertain them, Food shop, errands for the parents. I can’t even list everything I do as I’d be here forever! Nannies don’t get lunch breaks/coffee breaks. I can honestly say I earn every penny of my £12 net/hour. The parents come home every night to a tidy house and 2 very happy and healthy children. I don’t think you can put a price on that.
Best reply.

She facilitates their lifestyle.

However, can they be assured nanny is fostering the right social networks via the DC's social lives? Hmm? 😂

windmill26 · 29/07/2020 21:21

@Thehop

Blimey. I’m 40, with 20 years experience in early years (childminding and private nurseries) and an early childhood studies degree. I have paediatric first aid, food hygeine and am up to speed in Montessori, loose parts, cloth nappies and specialist baby training. Ask well as being a mother of 4. I charge £10 per hour for babysitting and always clean up and do a basket of ironing/laundry one children are in bed!!!! I also am happy to arrive early and do children’s dinner whilst parents get ready.

Maybe I’m in the wrong job!!!

If you are in London you are definitely underpaid as a Nanny with your experience! Cleaners earn more than £10 per hour in London.
Mothermorph · 29/07/2020 21:20

When you earn 25k and trying to budget and pay for school holiday care, the state school holidays dont seem that short!!

MissConductUS · 29/07/2020 21:19

There's no intrinsic value based on qualifications. It's supply and demand. This is why surgeons make more than people with a doctorate in medieval literature.

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 21:16

@HighlandPeach Yes you’re probably right. My nanny is the kindest person ever and really warm and she absolutely loves my children to bits. She’s not very professional to be honest (and yours sounds amazing in that regard!) but I think it’s pretty hard to find someone who is the whole package. Fact is that you don’t need to have the whole package to be demanding very good salaries as a nanny.

OP posts:
bornninthe80s · 29/07/2020 21:16

My child is the my entire world. I sought the best care for her when I had to return to work, I think nannies and childminders have a massive job to do and I'm glad to hear they can earn big!

ParisianLady · 29/07/2020 21:14

Our London nanny wasn't officially qualified and we paid her £10/hr net. I wouldn't have expected her to do nothing for 3hrs a day home alone. Her main attributes: caring, calm, affectionate

Our out of London nanny earns £13/hr gross. When the children are out of the house she does housekeeping: laundry, cooking, light housework. She's a trained nanny but her main attributes: calm, loving, gives great hugs.

She's incredible, the children love her, I love her being here. Worth every penny.

JoJoSM2 · 29/07/2020 21:14

Yes, they do get paid shedloads compared to other roles that require similar level of qualifications, intelligence etc.

However, the hours are generally very long and full-time nannying is pretty much impossible to juggle with being a parent and not easy for having a work-life balance. That’s probably the main reason why the supply isn’t greater and rates of pay high.

Hardbackwriter · 29/07/2020 21:14

To those that have asked, I wanted a nanny rather than a childminder or nursery as one of my children has special needs (nothing major but I thought a nanny would be better). I wouldn’t have wanted them at a nursery all day when they were very little anyway - and I work very late every night so we needed flexible childcare.

You've answered your own question here. You need the flexibility of a nanny, and value what they can offer over a group childcare setting. That's true of nearly everyone who has a nanny, and it's why they pay the premium for it. There's no point looking for an objective rationale for the price, the market sets it by demand. It's like asking why a house in Kensington costs so much more than one in Hull if they're made of the same bricks - because the person who buys the house in Kensington is willing to pay the premium for it because they want what it comes with and they can afford to.

Tunnocks34 · 29/07/2020 21:14

I’m a qualified teacher - I would not work as a nanny, they deserve every bit of what they are paid tbh.

Thehop · 29/07/2020 21:13

@ssd we should team up!

I’m in Yorkshire and happy to travel a reasonable distance of anyone needs me 😄

Hercwasonaroll · 29/07/2020 21:12

"it's not that hard"

Says the woman who hasn't looked after her own kids full time for more than 4 weeks a year.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 29/07/2020 21:11

If you think she asking for too much, find someone cheaper!

It always amazes me that people who think nothing of paying £50 for a bottle of wine baulk at paying a decent wage to the person they are entrusting their most precious part of their lives to!

There are qualified nannies out there - why not employ one of them and get your money's worth? What made you choose this particular one. and why did you offer her such a generous wage if you don't think she's worth it?

HighlandPeach · 29/07/2020 21:10

I don’t think the issue is the money you’re paying. That’s fairly standard for a live-out nanny (up to £48k gross). I think you hired the wrong person! Our nanny graduated from Norland College, so has an academic background in childcare, as well as many years of experience. She’s worth her weight in gold, as she’s happy, kind, caring, thoughtful, calm and DC adore her. The playroom, DC bedrooms and kitchen are immaculate at the end of the day, too. I think you could have found someone more qualified for the money you were paying

strawberrymilkshakemonkey · 29/07/2020 21:10

if she's there for that amount of time she's basically playing the role of parent. she wil be shaping your child, teaching them, helping them develop and watchin them grow. of course they are well-paid. but if you dont want to pay her that much you could always look after your own child yourself :)