Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nannies are overpaid?

358 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 19:59

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

OP posts:
lmfaoo · 29/07/2020 22:02

I don't think nannies are over paid but I think you were possibly overpaying your nanny.

As an employer / boss, that's on you, not the nanny.

Genevieva · 29/07/2020 22:02

How much nannies are paid is no one's business but the parents and the nanny - supply and demand. What I do object to is that parents are expected to shoulder all the costs that a business would shoulder, without being able to offset those costs against tax in the way that a business would. The parents have to pay employer NI contributions, pension, etc. Either nannies should be self-employed or parents should be able to treat having a nanny as a business expense and offset the cost of a nanny against tax.

Nanny0gg · 29/07/2020 22:02

@Fr0thandBubble

Inspired by another thread about how much people earn. Plenty of nannies earning £50-£60k per year apparently and one on £120k!

Our nanny has just left us (youngest about to start reception, thank goodness) and we were paying her nearly £50k for 8:30am-6:30pm Mon-Fri. She would also pick up quite a bit of extra money babysitting evenings and weekends L. She didn’t even have to do anything from 9-12 each morning while my youngest was at nursery - and then only had my youngest to look after until school pick-up time when she had my eldest too. And nannies these days are very reluctant to help out with any cleaning or ironing so she really was doing nothing much at all in those hours.

She was lovely but has no qualifications and is in her early thirties.

It seems wrong to me that nannies are getting paid more than most teachers when they don’t need any qualifications. What do you think?!

If she was unqualified and did bugger-all in the mornings, why the hell did you pay that much?

And she may have been 'reluctant' but that was down to you putting up with it!

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 22:02

@Saz12 Yes I can see the sense in that.

OP posts:
Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 22:00

@nannynick I think it’s just London. We’re not even in one of the most expensive areas. I imagine nannies in areas like Chelsea or Kensington or Notting Hill get even more than we paid ours.

OP posts:
Saz12 · 29/07/2020 21:59

A lot of qualifications don’t make any difference to salary. It’s a myth that they do: look at how many folk with phd’s earn very little.

Finding your job stressful doesn’t mean you should get paid more.

What influences salary is how useful a service the employer provides to the employer... ie how much money they help their employer make.
Your nanny means you can do your well-paid job.
Your work means clients/customers buy stuff so you get paid a lot because you bring in a lot of ££ to the company you work for. Not because of your qualifications (they just get your foot in the door).

Ironically, both you and your nanny have a willingness to work long hours and sacrifice personal/family time, and that’s a big reason why you both earn excessive amounts - it limits how many others would do your jobs.

Phineyj · 29/07/2020 21:58

I earn about the same as your nanny as a teacher in central London (full time equivalent - I choose to work part time). I wouldn't swap jobs for all the tea in China!

As I teach Economics, I will suggest that you look up 'non pecuniary benefits', 'marginal revenue product of labour' (yours is probably high; she's enabling it to be) and 'efficiency wage'.

There's no qualification for being nice, warm, kind and reliable.

eurochick · 29/07/2020 21:57

That sounds toppy, even for London. We are on the outskirts on London and have paid mid-30k for nannies, to work the same hours as yours. Less experienced candidates we interviewed were cheaper.

SunshineCake · 29/07/2020 21:53

I think you sound resentful with no understanding of what a nanny does.

I used to be a nanny. I did everything in my contract and a lot more besides. It is hard work emotionally and mentally. We get attached to children and can be given notice whenever. We are responsible for someone else's child which is scarier than when it is your own. I used to do anything to do with the child/ren so their washing, cleaning of their rooms, ironing, cooking, taking on outings, etc etc etc.

I was paid well with rises and bonuses but I earned every penny as I cared for the children a lot and they were my complete focus for the ten hours or more I had them each day.

nannynick · 29/07/2020 21:51

As a nanny with over 20 years experience, why don't I get paid that much. Most I've ever made in a year is £28k. Guess it's those people working in London.

lyralalala · 29/07/2020 21:51

You might not pay for qualifications with a nanny, but normally you pay for experience. A brand new nanny costs less than one with a good amount of experience.

Also you're partly paying for what she may have to do - last minute days off school/nursery, dealing with emergencies and the likes. Much the same as firefighters sometimes don't get called out while on a shift, but still get paid as they are there in case they are needed.

I find it fascinating how so many people grudge paying for the care of their children. nursery workers are appallingly low paid in general. Obviously you are going to pay a high premium for one-to-one care or one-to-two care. If a nanny works full time on a pittance how is she supposed to live?

CharityRoyall · 29/07/2020 21:49

I nannied for 5 years and it was the hardest job I’ve had. Didn’t earn anywhere near that much though - I was on £32k which is still the most I’ve ever earned. I worked 5 days a week, 6am-8pm, 6am-midnight on Thursdays (I stayed over). I loved the children but I was constantly on the move, doing stuff all the time. Many difficulties with the parents over that time, though we’re good friends now. Looking back I was exhausted, anxious and depressed - it definitely wasn’t the right job for me. Wouldn’t do it again even for 60k!
My point is nannies work bloody hard and as a PP said they’re a luxury, they’re supposed to cost a fair amount Smile

nannymags · 29/07/2020 21:45

They are likely Norland and / or rota nannies working for high profile types. They most likely will be working 24/5 or possibly 2 weeks on 2 weeks off for the jet set world. Comes with its own set of perks but also drama and demands in my experience

LakieLady · 29/07/2020 21:43

Sorry, that should £15+ an hour, not £25 - fat fingers!

LakieLady · 29/07/2020 21:42

I’d say that £40kish gross in London for 50 hours/week isn’t really that well paid at all

It works out at £25 + something ph, so not a lot for London imo.

DP used to work for a company that provide payroll services to people who employ domestic staff. He was gobsmacked by how much some people paid them. One very rich person paid their housekeeper and her handyman husband £100k a year, and they got a cottage that they lived in for free. The employer had a 2nd housekeeper at their London house, too, plus a gardener, a chauffeur and a cleaner, and he reckoned their wage bill was bigger than a lot of companies he's done payroll for!

The convention for domestic staff is that their contracts are based on net pay. If someone has 3rd party deductions, eg student loans, child maintenance, the employer effectively carries the cost, and the net pay remains unchanged. If tax rates were to go up, the gross pay would have to go up, too.

Hardbackwriter · 29/07/2020 21:41

Out of interest, what's the plan now they're both in school - you clearly need wraparound care and holiday care and that's not much of either that will offer those sort of hours? I thought most families in that position keep the nanny.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 29/07/2020 21:41

@Cadent

Seems to be some sexism at play here, where jobs that are primarily done by women are not deemed deserving of a commensurate salary.
Bingo.

Also the fact that it's a 'domestic' role.

Damnloginpopup · 29/07/2020 21:40

Well deserved imo. Anything to get rid of the little wankers for a while 😁

MolyHolyGuacamole · 29/07/2020 21:39

@Pamalarrrr

Where are these jobs where nannies earn £120k!!! Wow! They must be Norland Nannies surely and be qualified
I guarantee the ones earning that salary are on a 24/7 rota and working for high net worth, demanding families. That's always the case. When you divide the salary by 24 hours a day where they need to be on call, it's actually a pretty average hourly rate
upsidedownwavylegs · 29/07/2020 21:38

Just because I have a nanny it doesn’t make me one of “The Rich”

Eh? Of course it does. Why do you think most of us don’t have them?

mathanxiety · 29/07/2020 21:38

My point is that nannies get paid really well without needing any qualifications or having to work that hard.

@Fr0thandBubble
My counter point would be that you wouldn't be able to do your job unless you had the complete peace of mind about childcare coverage that the nanny offers.

That is what you are paying for.

How much is that worth to you?

Have you ever tried to function in your job without that peace of mind?

Fr0thandBubble · 29/07/2020 21:35

@Miljea No, she isn’t earning more per hour than me. What a strange comment.

And I don’t appreciate your classist assertions. Just because I have a nanny it doesn’t make me one of “The Rich” or that I want my child to “socialise with the right people” or whatever it was you said. You couldn’t be further from the truth on that by the way - I absolutely hate classism with every ounce of my being and you are way off mark.

OP posts:
Cadent · 29/07/2020 21:33

Seems to be some sexism at play here, where jobs that are primarily done by women are not deemed deserving of a commensurate salary.

kaikaidodo · 29/07/2020 21:31

I'm a nanny in Oxfordshire 40 hours per week over 4 days and I'm on 25k (12.50 ph) I drive my own car have 4 years experience Ofsted registered etc etc.

I think it's a good wage and I love my job, it barley feels like work but realistically you could be let go at any time depending on the parents circumstances and there's no opportunity for promotion. If I were to stay in nannying for the next 10 years my wage probably won't increase that much. Also it is such a lottery whether you get great employers or terrible employers and some children can be much harder work than others.

All things considered I don't think I'm overpaid?

FinallyHere · 29/07/2020 21:30

Surely people pay nannies what they need to pay in order to secure their services.

Seems fair enough.

There is no reason to pay people more than is necessary to secure their services. If your job is so much more stressful, what's stopping you giving up your job and being a nanny ?

Thought not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread