Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end with the death of Queen Elizabeth 2

492 replies

Gingertea2020 · 27/07/2020 17:43

As an Aussie am curious to know if British monarchy can really prevail beyond life of Queen.

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

Added to this there is the Prince Andrew saga.

With all that is happening in world, will it really continue ?

I can’t imagine a Prince Charles.

I genuinely wonder why the British bother with it all.

OP posts:
Alsohuman · 28/07/2020 19:19

And then who do you go after because of their privilege? Because there will always be someone.

derxa · 28/07/2020 19:18

Of course the MNetters with their 'six figure salaries' probably in public service jobs will then be at the top of the pile. But they'll still be bleating that society is not fair and not letting workmen use their fucking loos Grin

PatriciaPerch · 28/07/2020 19:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AgeLikeWine · 28/07/2020 19:13

Then you've got the aristocracy. Will you get rid of them?

Yes, of course. And the House of Lords, which should be replaced by an elected Senate. This is about three centuries overdue!

Pelleas · 28/07/2020 19:09

Then you've got the aristocracy. Will you get rid of them?

They're next on my list after the Royals.

derxa · 28/07/2020 19:08

whereby the privileged remain at the top of the pile and there is less social mobility in 2020 than there was twenty or thirty years ago. No doubt there are many worthy studies which prove you correct but I find that hard to believe. The rich and the sharp elbowed will always push their way to the top. Then you've got the aristocracy. Will you get rid of them? Public schools? You will never stop the rich and privileged making connections and controlling power and money. Name these countries which are your ideals. I'll bet some of them have a monarchy.

Pelleas · 28/07/2020 18:48

Why does it irritate you that folk still like the monarchy in the U.K.

It doesn't irritate me that people like the monarchy - it irritates me that the monarchy exists. People liking something doesn't mean it has merit - a lot of people like heroin but that doesn't alter its detrimental impact on society.

squanderedcore · 28/07/2020 18:37

@derxa

That's my point really. What's yours? I'm not really sure. I'm a farmer and we had to keep the sheep going through lambing. That doesn't make me a hero since life didn't really change and there is no social distancing on a farm. People working on Covid wards are a different matter altogether. I just get the sense that on MN there are very few people that rub shoulders with ordinary working people. Like the people who lift dead stock, fence my fields, cut crops for me etc etc. I appreciate their work but I don't lionise them nor do I patronise them. We all have our niche in the world. I bet William occasionally would prefer to spend his days fencing. However he's been trained for this jaob all his life. A bit like farming really. Very hard to leave.
The view that "we all have our niche in the world" may not be shared quite so fatalistically by those earning a mininium wage. My point was not intended to lionise or patronise but to highlight the genuine social justice issues that Covid-19 has exposed. One example being that suddenly it was possible to house the homeless during the pandemic when for years prior to that, it was deemed too expensive or impractical. I was suggesting that our values in a society where let's say the more frivolous members are lionised (celebrities, royalty etc) are perhaps a bit skewed?

And although I value tradition in the sense of historical continuity (I also love mounted military parades and bands!) I'm no longer convinced that a monarchy serves our country well as it encourages a system whereby the privileged remain at the top of the pile and there is less social mobility in 2020 than there was twenty or thirty years ago. It's a bit depressing frankly and I don't think an objective assessment of why this remains the case (including a blunt look at the role of the monarchy) would be entirely out of order. I'm not saying that the monarchy is entirely responsible for such social disparity, but that it may be one contributing factor among many.

see article here

Codexdivinchi · 28/07/2020 18:33

@Pelleas

Admissions to the Royal Estate in the United Kingdom (UK) in 2018/19, by establishment (in 1,000s)*

Visitors in thousands
Windsor Castle and Frogmore House1,652
Buckingham Palace552
Palace of Holyroodhouse439
The Royal Mews196
The Queen's Gallery, London175
The Queen's Gallery, Edinburgh69
Clarence House11

All in which brought a heavy 48.4 MILLON in admission fees and added to that 21 MILLON in sales

People still want to visit them and they do bring in a substantial amount of money

There's an enormous flaw in that argument. Ask yourself what people are visiting. Is it the Royal Family? That's a no, because even if they were in residence at those properties, visitors would be kept away from them. They are visiting the properties, not the Royal Family.

And if you are trying to say that no one would visit if the Royals were retired ... look at the Louvre, which had a whopping 10.2 million visitors in 2018. That's over 6 million more than the combined British properties, based on your figures above - and France got rid of their Royals in 1792.

The Met police estimated that 1 million people took to the streets in London to try and catch a glimpse of Kate and wills wedding.

The Louvre is the worlds biggest museum of course it’s going to attract shit loads of tourist.

Why does it irritate you that folk still like the monarchy in the U.K. Grin

Pelleas · 28/07/2020 18:32

@PicsInRed

Those houses would have MORE visitors if the monarchy was abolished as they could be open all year round, rather than only during summer.
Excellent point.
GilderoyLockdown · 28/07/2020 18:31

Versailles is what I was thinking of, and mentioned upthread.

PicsInRed · 28/07/2020 18:27

Those houses would have MORE visitors if the monarchy was abolished as they could be open all year round, rather than only during summer.

SecretWitch · 28/07/2020 18:24

Christ I hope so. Especially after the racism that drove Harry and Meghan away.

LaurieMarlow · 28/07/2020 18:19

What we don't know is whether this would still happen if the RF no longer existed but the palaces etc still did.

Versailles gives us a very strong steer. Yes. Much more so.

Monarchy may be good for tourism, but getting rid of monarchy (and opening up palaces further) is even better.

derxa · 28/07/2020 17:41

That's my point really. What's yours? I'm not really sure. I'm a farmer and we had to keep the sheep going through lambing. That doesn't make me a hero since life didn't really change and there is no social distancing on a farm. People working on Covid wards are a different matter altogether. I just get the sense that on MN there are very few people that rub shoulders with ordinary working people. Like the people who lift dead stock, fence my fields, cut crops for me etc etc. I appreciate their work but I don't lionise them nor do I patronise them. We all have our niche in the world. I bet William occasionally would prefer to spend his days fencing. However he's been trained for this jaob all his life. A bit like farming really. Very hard to leave.

Pelleas · 28/07/2020 17:23

Admissions to the Royal Estate in the United Kingdom (UK) in 2018/19, by establishment (in 1,000s)*

Visitors in thousands
Windsor Castle and Frogmore House1,652
Buckingham Palace552
Palace of Holyroodhouse439
The Royal Mews196
The Queen's Gallery, London175
The Queen's Gallery, Edinburgh69
Clarence House11

All in which brought a heavy 48.4 MILLON in admission fees and added to that 21 MILLON in sales

People still want to visit them and they do bring in a substantial amount of money

There's an enormous flaw in that argument. Ask yourself what people are visiting. Is it the Royal Family? That's a no, because even if they were in residence at those properties, visitors would be kept away from them. They are visiting the properties, not the Royal Family.

And if you are trying to say that no one would visit if the Royals were retired ... look at the Louvre, which had a whopping 10.2 million visitors in 2018. That's over 6 million more than the combined British properties, based on your figures above - and France got rid of their Royals in 1792.

GilderoyLockdown · 28/07/2020 17:13

People absolutely visit sites associated with the RF and they bring in lots of tourism money that way. There's really no doubt about that. What we don't know is whether this would still happen if the RF no longer existed but the palaces etc still did.

squanderedcore · 28/07/2020 17:06

Derxa

I bet you're not amongst this group of people

No I'm not and I don't claim to be. I like many other middle class people have the privilege of sitting at home and working on-line, a choice that many essential workers don't have. That's my point really. What's yours?

Andahelterskelterroundmylittle · 28/07/2020 17:01

Christ , a Republic would be great! God knows what it'll take

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/07/2020 17:00

I just meant that I've had ' things I thought were true' about the royals crushed by mumsnetters who really do seem to know things! Well, they sound genuine enough anyway!

I know, The80s, and happily there are some very well informed posters on these threads who really know their stuff - I'd suggest a few names but that's perhaps not entirely fair
Trouble is, unless you spend a lot of time on the royal threads, it's not always easy to separate those stating real facts from others posting what they imagine are facts and are actually anything but

Best on the whole to use most posts (including mine) as a sort of trigger for your own research, if an issue matters enough to you

SheWranglesRugRats · 28/07/2020 16:47

King Andrew or President Arden?

Alsohuman · 28/07/2020 16:41

Excellent point Goosefoot. Not that it will cut any ice with the vast majority of MN. These threads always go the same way. The only way it would change would be if the Queen paid us and then someone would still find something wrong with it.

Codexdivinchi · 28/07/2020 16:40

@av3nturin3

I think the RF generate more income for media outlets than “tourism”. I’ve been visiting the UK over the past 30 years for various reasons, and I’ve never actively planned to visit a site associated with the RF (apart from V&A Museum, Science Museum, Natural History Museum). Haven’t been to Tower of London. Only took my kids to Princess Diana’s playground in Hyde Park after reading glowing reviews here on MN (yes, it was indeed amazing). Sure, I walked around Queens Park and St James’s Park but not to actively gawk at, or take photos of, Buckingham Palace. I’ve stayed in Windsor twice (in the town), but haven’t toured Windsor Castle. The castles I visited in Wales and Scotland were part of the National Trust/ Scottish National Trust (and were chosen primarily for having great kids play areas!).
This may surprise you then

Admissions to the Royal Estate in the United Kingdom (UK) in 2018/19, by establishment* (in 1,000s)

Visitors in thousands
Windsor Castle and Frogmore House 1,652
Buckingham Palace 552
Palace of Holyroodhouse 439
The Royal Mews 196
The Queen's Gallery, London 175
The Queen's Gallery, Edinburgh 69
Clarence House 11

All in which brought a heavy 48.4 MILLON in admission fees and added to that 21 MILLON in sales

People still want to visit them and they do bring in a substantial amount of money

The80sweregreat · 28/07/2020 16:38

Puzzle, I just meant that I've had ' things I thought were true' about the royals crushed by mumsnetters who really do seem to know things ! Well, they sound genuine enough anyway ! Such as the home that William lives in was gifted and owned by the Queen ; I didn't know this because I hadn't really given it any thought before or bothered to look it up ! Just things like that really.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/07/2020 16:31

someone in the know will say ' ahh, they don't cost us that much and make more than for us in tourism and Charles has income from the Duchy and he bought Highgrove house himself '

I wouldn't call that "in the know" since the only provably true remark is that Charles has income from the Duchy

It's not always easy to pick a way through fact, opinion and wishful thinking, but the effort can be rewarding

Swipe left for the next trending thread