Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end with the death of Queen Elizabeth 2

492 replies

Gingertea2020 · 27/07/2020 17:43

As an Aussie am curious to know if British monarchy can really prevail beyond life of Queen.

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

Added to this there is the Prince Andrew saga.

With all that is happening in world, will it really continue ?

I can’t imagine a Prince Charles.

I genuinely wonder why the British bother with it all.

OP posts:
PicsInRed · 28/07/2020 22:20

The reason people went mad at the death of Diana is that Diana represented hope that at least someone in the establishment (or who was seen to be the establishment) CARED about them. Saw them as people rather than workhorses and peasants.

True or not, that's what people thought. She was the establishment. But she cared.

When she died, that idea died with her. Without realising, those people were grieving their own damnation inside the class system. That's where the madness came from. Not love, but oppression and the death of hope.

Alsohuman · 28/07/2020 21:59

He’s living exactly where he always has. He went riding with his mum and went to church with her. None of that says blatant contempt to me.

CathyorClaire · 28/07/2020 21:46

@Alsohuman

the contempt is blatant

Can’t be that blatant. I haven’t noticed it.

What do you make of giving him the full run of a selection of opulent palaces to hunker down in?

Horse riding in full view of the paps a few days after 'that' interview?

Having him riding shotgun on a church visit?

Alsohuman · 28/07/2020 21:36

the contempt is blatant

Can’t be that blatant. I haven’t noticed it.

CathyorClaire · 28/07/2020 21:27

You don’t like Queen Bet? Why?

Lilibet has played a blinder in putting up and shutting up but the mask's slipping lately. She can't contain her disdain for the opinion of the proles when it comes to silently championing His Royal Dryness Andrew.

We saw signs when awkward for the firm Diana died but now her favourite son's involved the contempt is blatant.

Wolfgirrl · 28/07/2020 21:23

Agree with @Pelleas

We forget she is also the head of a church

That sit on untold wealth and chooses not to share it

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/07/2020 21:14

Totally agree with you about the scenes over Diana's death, annabel85
A certain sadness over the loss of a young woman's life is natural, but wailing in the streets over someone you don't even know? Hurling abuse at others deemed insufficiently upset? The widespread promotion of emotion over reason?

I don't think so

derxa · 28/07/2020 21:00

People being upset when they heard the news is natural. It went on for weeks. But I still cry when I see the footage of Diana's coffin being driven home and people throwing flowers at the hearse. I can't help it. No one makes me and DH says 'FFS not again!' Grin

ListeningQuietly · 28/07/2020 20:48

When Diana died the hypocritical hand wringing got right up my nose
even satirical radio 4 shows went all mushy

I did not sign a condolence book for her because she was a manipulative clothes horse when alive
and stayed the same once she was dead

annabel85 · 28/07/2020 20:41

When Diana died news readers were crying. Nobody made them.

People being upset when they heard the news is natural. It went on for weeks.

derxa · 28/07/2020 20:29

Diana's death was the first time I felt a stranger in my own country. Yes, it was sad, yes it was tragic, but it was as if the country had a mental breakdown and never really recovered from it. It's the kind of scenes you'd expect if the leader of North Korea died.
Grin I think if you failed to show grief at the death of the leader of North Korea you might expect a wee knock on the door.
When Diana died news readers were crying. Nobody made them.

annabel85 · 28/07/2020 20:22

@bridgetreilly

Most of us have never known anything but The Queen.

Yes. I will genuinely be devastated. I couldn't understand the public displays of grief for Diana at all, and I thought it was overplayed for the Queen Mother too. But I can't bear the thought of the Queen just not being there any more.

Diana's death was the first time I felt a stranger in my own country. Yes, it was sad, yes it was tragic, but it was as if the country had a mental breakdown and never really recovered from it. It's the kind of scenes you'd expect if the leader of North Korea died.

Queen Elizabeth is the personification of the British spirit, duty and do your grieving in private and was hammered at the time for not joining in the public wailing and mass outpouring of grief over her death. If ever the saying of 'one death is a tragedy, a million deaths are a statistic' was true it was over that.

annabel85 · 28/07/2020 20:15

When the Queen dies it's not just the end of an era but the end of an age.

The monarchy would almost seem pointless after that.

Pelleas · 28/07/2020 20:12

@Codexdivinchi

I agree, Johnson is dreadful but he can at least be voted out, unlike a King or Queen we were landed with but didn't like

You don’t like Queen Bet? Why?

Because she is a hypocrite. She's head of the CofE - a Christian church - yet she is sitting on piles of wealth, owning multiple properties, while many of her subjects are homeless or in extreme poverty. How dare she pop up at Christmas talking about following the example of Christ when she so spectacularly fails to do so herself? I say this as an agnostic, so I am not 'offended' by the religious aspect of what she's doing, just the sheer, blatant, unadulterated hypocrisy of the way she lives her life. I would actually mind it less if she was honest enough to say 'stuff the proles, I'm going to enjoy my dozens of houses while they wonder where their next meal is coming from'.
Pelleas · 28/07/2020 20:06

@Snaleandthewhail One problem we have at the moment is very low turnout in elections. It's impossible to judge whether a higher turnout in elections would change the overall trend of results, but I have often wondered whether, if the stakes were higher (even if only nominally) and we were electing a 'president' we would achieve a higher turnout.

Codexdivinchi · 28/07/2020 20:05

[quote Snaleandthewhail]@Pelleas I know, I know, I know... I have argued against constitutional monarchy since my early twenties. But your phrase

It would be for the public to decide whether we wanted the PM to assume the role of Head of State.

Terrifies me at the moment...[/quote]
This. The thought of a party like labour in charge terrifies me. They have eaten themselves. Shit JC as HoS Shock

I’ll stick with what we have at the moment 👍

Codexdivinchi · 28/07/2020 20:02

I agree, Johnson is dreadful but he can at least be voted out, unlike a King or Queen we were landed with but didn't like

You don’t like Queen Bet? Why?

Snaleandthewhail · 28/07/2020 20:00

@Pelleas I know, I know, I know... I have argued against constitutional monarchy since my early twenties. But your phrase

It would be for the public to decide whether we wanted the PM to assume the role of Head of State.

Terrifies me at the moment...

Codexdivinchi · 28/07/2020 19:56

@Pelleas

And then who do you go after because of their privilege? Because there will always be someone.

Once we have got rid of the monarchy and aristocracy, the next step is to introduce a law limiting salary (and overall remuneration) multiples within organisations. So, just as an example, we might say that the highest earning employee cannot be paid more than 10x the lowest earning employee - including ancillary benefits. This puts an end to the fat cat culture - or at least, if the executives want to be fat cats they can only do so by raising their entry-level employees to at least the level of well-fed cats.

Ah communism... well we know how well that turns out..

I prefer the the way it is, the head of state is there till they die or abdicate which is usually a long time. This offers stability, in republics new heads get elected every few years costing thousands. It would be like the GE over and over again and then the real GE in between. No thanks

They are not politicians so less chance of corruption. They are raised from birth to be the head of state and will act accordingly to fulfil the job rather than some like Donald trump causing shit on Twitter.

Our system isn’t perfect but it does work.

Alsohuman · 28/07/2020 19:55

@Pelleas

And then who do you go after because of their privilege? Because there will always be someone.

Once we have got rid of the monarchy and aristocracy, the next step is to introduce a law limiting salary (and overall remuneration) multiples within organisations. So, just as an example, we might say that the highest earning employee cannot be paid more than 10x the lowest earning employee - including ancillary benefits. This puts an end to the fat cat culture - or at least, if the executives want to be fat cats they can only do so by raising their entry-level employees to at least the level of well-fed cats.

No, I’m pretty left leaning but that’s too far for me.
Pelleas · 28/07/2020 19:52

@Snaleandthewhail

I am a lifelong republican.

But Trump, Johnson, Brexit have all shown the failings of democracy. Particularly when that democracy is ruthlessly manipulated by outside sources and increasingly shows the selfish, insulated, “I’m all right jack”’voters I see littered around social media.

I would rather take my chances with a head of state literally bred for public service than the electorates or the people who want to be in charge at the moment:

I don’t think it’s right, but I don’t think any of it’s right at the moment.

The monarchy have no meaningful political influence - or at least, no more than any celebrity might have and probably less because there are constraints on what they are allowed to say. So I don't see that their removal would make the situation you describe better or worse.

It would be for the public to decide whether we wanted the PM to assume the role of Head of State. I agree, Johnson is dreadful but he can at least be voted out, unlike a King or Queen we were landed with but didn't like. We'd have the option of an elected head of state who wasn't necessarily of the majority government (like the US presidential elections are their own thing) or even an apolitical figurehead, again elected, but chosen purely for their qualities as the country's representative - diplomacy, charm, apolitical achievements, general ambassadorial ability and so on.

Snaleandthewhail · 28/07/2020 19:40

I am a lifelong republican.

But Trump, Johnson, Brexit have all shown the failings of democracy. Particularly when that democracy is ruthlessly manipulated by outside sources and increasingly shows the selfish, insulated, “I’m all right jack”’voters I see littered around social media.

I would rather take my chances with a head of state literally bred for public service than the electorates or the people who want to be in charge at the moment:

I don’t think it’s right, but I don’t think any of it’s right at the moment.

Pelleas · 28/07/2020 19:29

And then who do you go after because of their privilege? Because there will always be someone.

Once we have got rid of the monarchy and aristocracy, the next step is to introduce a law limiting salary (and overall remuneration) multiples within organisations. So, just as an example, we might say that the highest earning employee cannot be paid more than 10x the lowest earning employee - including ancillary benefits. This puts an end to the fat cat culture - or at least, if the executives want to be fat cats they can only do so by raising their entry-level employees to at least the level of well-fed cats.

PatriciaPerch · 28/07/2020 19:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

derxa · 28/07/2020 19:21

do aristocracy get funded by the tax payer? confused I thought they were self funded... They are but were given land and titles by the king so therefore part of the Evil Empire.

Swipe left for the next trending thread