Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end with the death of Queen Elizabeth 2

492 replies

Gingertea2020 · 27/07/2020 17:43

As an Aussie am curious to know if British monarchy can really prevail beyond life of Queen.

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

Added to this there is the Prince Andrew saga.

With all that is happening in world, will it really continue ?

I can’t imagine a Prince Charles.

I genuinely wonder why the British bother with it all.

OP posts:
StoneofDestiny · 30/07/2020 10:53

Well, being close to people who have had to arrange royal visits to towns/events etc, I can assure you a vast amount of money is put in to refit and paint up areas they ‘might’ visit, cater for the entourage, police and clean up and that is even before the visit - then security and policing for the event and clean up after. It’s a money guzzler.
Like Andrew insisted on his first daughters ‘princess’s’ wedding - cost of policing was vast for their ride about (not to mention sweeping the homeless aside). Yet attendance was scant - disinterest from the public at large but cost to them was huge. The homeless were still homeless after the farce was over. No shame.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/07/2020 10:38

Nah, KC will twin the fat. PA will continue to be kept out the way, the Princesses married well so don't need royal money, Anne's kids work, Edwards kids will work eventually and will just be rich people with titles.
Megan and Harry will stay abroad and as they aren't financed anymore it won't matter, or they'll divorce and he'll come back and plead forgiveness and repent and be forgiven.

By the time it's KW&QK the kids will be post education so I'm the military or working as royals - in 20/30 years most of those doing the hard work now will be ancient or dead so there will be enough to keep the kids busy and I think within his reign it'll go the way of European royalty so not abolished just less significant. George will be in training but Charlotte and Def Louis/baby 4 will have jobs

BadgersPaws2 · 30/07/2020 10:31

@StoneofDestiny

also human Assume 'diatribe' is attributed only when you disagree with someone.

I'm not happy with the status quo and am able to voice my opinion - thankfully this is a democracy.
The very idea of curtsying or bowing to an entitled family is extraordinary in the 21 century as is handing over hardworking taxpayers money (from many already struggling to pay their way) to multi millionaires.

The money that the Royal Family get to spend doesn't come from taxpayers. For example the Queen's money comes from a portion of the income that the Crown Estate generates from things like rent. The Crown Estate makes about £330 million a year, 25% of that passes to the Queen and the rest is passed to the Government. Travel, property maintenance and the "civil list' (passed on to some other Royals) comes out of that 25%.

So, the money the Queen gets to spend and fix her palaces with doesn't come directly from tax payers. However I'd argue that "we" should own the Crown Estate, so therefore the Queen is funded by money that "we" should be getting rather than being funded by money that "we" are currently paying. If that makes sense.

There's then an additional raft of expenses that are very hard to total up (I'd suggest this obscurity is deliberate). There are security costs that the Government pays and also things like local authorities having to pay for certain things when there is a Royal visit.

Furthermore there are then things like the Duchy of Cornwall which are set up to fund the heir to the thrown and have special rules about taxation. So again it's not money from the taxpayer as such but rather money that, I'd argue, that the Government should be getting more of anyway.

So it's complicated, it's certainly not as simple as saying that tax payers fund the Royals.

derxa · 30/07/2020 10:29

While key workers turned up and did extra hours of gruelling service every day Did you?

GetOffYourHighHorse · 30/07/2020 10:16

'The very idea of curtsying or bowing to an entitled family is extraordinary in the 21 century as is handing over hardworking taxpayers money (from many already struggling to pay their way) to multi millionaires.'

It does seem odd that all the curtsying and silly traditions continue. As morale boosters and reasons for celebrations like jubilees etc or networking with other heads of state and raising profiles of charities fine, but I can't stand all the forelock tugging outdated procedures and protocols. I'm no fan of Harry but the fact it would be deemed a 'break with protocol' to make an unannounced visit to his granny seems absurd.

C130 · 30/07/2020 09:48

I would not be troubled if the monarchy were to end with the death of the Queen. I have no interest in this over privileged, pampered family. The only member who I paid any attention to has now gone, which is a shame, I think.

StoneofDestiny · 30/07/2020 09:45

also human
Assume 'diatribe' is attributed only when you disagree with someone.

I'm not happy with the status quo and am able to voice my opinion - thankfully this is a democracy.
The very idea of curtsying or bowing to an entitled family is extraordinary in the 21 century as is handing over hardworking taxpayers money (from many already struggling to pay their way) to multi millionaires.

Alsohuman · 30/07/2020 09:32

Did you even bother to read the very pertinent point @StillCoughingandLaughing made before posting that diatribe? The majority of British people are happy with the status quo.

StoneofDestiny · 30/07/2020 09:25

alsohuman
It's not about that. It's the idea of elevating and praising one families efforts that are far from extraordinary, when they are rewarded substantially by hard working taxpayers and allowed a life of extreme privilege by accident of birth.

Nothing is extraordinary about their efforts and nothing will stop functioning if they don't exist.

Since Andrew and Fergie were shunted off - nothing has changed (except the hostility to monarchic privilege they brought on themselves). Since Philip moved aside - nothing has changed (except more hostility to his arrogant attitude). Nothing changed when Margaret of her mother died - except more revelations about their extravagance and racist views. Nothing has changed since Harry and Meghan flew off - except tonnes of newspaper inches and revelations about the family. Nothing changed since William and Kate battened down their hatches in isolation (While key workers turned up and did extra hours of gruelling service every day)

Too much credence is given to how important they all are - the gap is so easily filled and the extravagance, arrogance and indulgence is patently obvious to all and money keeping this pantomime going could better be directed to the NHS, Police, Prison and other essential services.

RandomUser3049 · 30/07/2020 09:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

StillCoughingandLaughing · 30/07/2020 09:07

Yes - but that description fits the majority of people who do difficult or dangerous jobs with low reward and no privilege to soften their exhaustion.

But the point is surely that Anne used her privileged position - which she was born into and had no choice about - to do something of value. She could have been like Auntie Margo, swanning about at premieres, shagging toyboys and puffing on a B&H on Mustique.

Japa · 30/07/2020 08:56

I think that it will continue with King Charles but will come under increased scrutiny. I wonder if down the track THEY may decide that they don't want to continue? For example, Prince George may say when he's older that he would rather live a 'normal' life.

PhilSwagielka · 30/07/2020 08:53

Honestly, by the time Liz dies Charles probably won't have long left either. It'll probably go straight to Wills.

Alsohuman · 30/07/2020 08:43

@StoneofDestiny

SusieOwl14 Yes - but that description fits the majority of people who do difficult or dangerous jobs with low reward and no privilege to soften their exhaustion.
They really can’t win, can they?
StoneofDestiny · 30/07/2020 07:09

SusieOwl14
Yes - but that description fits the majority of people who do difficult or dangerous jobs with low reward and no privilege to soften their exhaustion.

SusieOwl4 · 29/07/2020 23:30

Well I have just watched the programme on princess Anne . What an inspiring woman . Hard working , dedicated and not wanting the lime light or attention at all . What a life she has led . Hats off to her .

madamim · 29/07/2020 22:16

I hope so bloody grifters

StartupRepair · 29/07/2020 22:15

The referendum question in the Australian republic vote was very skewed and made people nervous about what they were voting for. That was a generation ago. Since then I personally have given birth to 2 people who will vote for a republic.

nancy75 · 29/07/2020 21:52

@janaus50s it will be interesting in Aus when the Queen dies. My husband is Australian, I know his parents & their generation are very pro the monarchy but the younger generation seem disinterested in them at best, those that I have spoken to about it all say they would vote to get rid (obviously this is a very tiny % of the voting pool!)

janaus50s · 29/07/2020 21:47

Stone of Destiny, the last referendum about the monarchy here in Australia, was in 1997. The result was 54% to keep Monarchy.
I think they then decided to try again when the Queen passes.
I’m an Aussie and I love the Royal family, Well, most of them.

Mittens030869 · 29/07/2020 21:09

I think Charles will want it. He actually does care passionately about global warming so he'll want to make the most of his status as King of the United Kingdom and in the Commonwealth to push that issue. He's also very politically aware and will probably have too much to say on some issues.

StoneofDestiny · 29/07/2020 19:25

OP - didn't the Aussies vote to keep the monarchy (always thought that was bizarre).

In answer to the question - I hope it does end with Betty - or sooner!

Alsohuman · 29/07/2020 19:12

@The80sweregreat

Charles seems very fit and didn't have to go into hospital with covid , unlike Boris Johnson who is about 14 years younger ( I think ) and did end up on an ICU ward! I think he'll live a long time myself : he could be King for many years.. I wonder if he really wants it though? His been waiting a long time! It'll be strange having a King and not a Queen.
I reckon he’s gagging for it. He’s been groomed for it all his life.
The80sweregreat · 29/07/2020 18:28

Charles seems very fit and didn't have to go into hospital with covid , unlike Boris Johnson who is about 14 years younger ( I think ) and did end up on an ICU ward!
I think he'll live a long time myself : he could be King for many years..
I wonder if he really wants it though? His been waiting a long time!
It'll be strange having a King and not a Queen.

Mittens030869 · 29/07/2020 18:18

*When Charles becomes king, it wont be for a long, as he is already over 70
*
I wouldn't bet on that, going on the age (so far) of his parents. He could have 20 years.

And he's obviously very healthy, demonstrated by how mild his COVID symptoms were.