Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end with the death of Queen Elizabeth 2

492 replies

Gingertea2020 · 27/07/2020 17:43

As an Aussie am curious to know if British monarchy can really prevail beyond life of Queen.

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

Added to this there is the Prince Andrew saga.

With all that is happening in world, will it really continue ?

I can’t imagine a Prince Charles.

I genuinely wonder why the British bother with it all.

OP posts:
SantaClaritaDiet · 27/07/2020 18:30

We don't need Charles to abdicate, we need to vote and the majority to decide we need a change. it's not that difficult. Probably not the most urgent thing to deal with in the middle of a pandemic and Brexit, but we could still get on it.

SantaClaritaDiet · 27/07/2020 18:29

All the business of government is conducted, as it should be, by elected officials, but all the pomp and glory goes to someone with no choice in the matter.

the French, the German.. they all manage very well and the role is hardly about the "pomp and the glory".

Presidents or real head of state don't need a gold-plated horse drawn carriage in 2020.

SusieOwl4 · 27/07/2020 18:28

I have to say that the Princes Trust does a huge amount of good work . They actually were responsible for turning my nieces life around. Just because you don’t hear about things every day does not mean they don’t exist .

bridgetreilly · 27/07/2020 18:27

Also, I think there is literally zero chance of Charles abdicating. Two people ever in UK history have abdicated: James II, de facto, following the Glorious Revolution, and Edward VIII. It's not a thing I think anyone in the royal family would ever consider for a second. It's certainly not a thing you do just because you're old.

Dahlietta · 27/07/2020 18:26

Picking and choosing would defeat the whole (stupid) basis of the monarchy. It has to be done on succession, not merit or popularity, or it isn’t monarchy any more.

Absolutely! If we were actually allowed to pick and choose, surely we wouldn't choose any of these plonkers?

derxa · 27/07/2020 18:25

Keir Starmer Keir Keir Keir.

bridgetreilly · 27/07/2020 18:25

Most of us have never known anything but The Queen.

Yes. I will genuinely be devastated. I couldn't understand the public displays of grief for Diana at all, and I thought it was overplayed for the Queen Mother too. But I can't bear the thought of the Queen just not being there any more.

SusieOwl4 · 27/07/2020 18:24

No I think it will continue . With William .

IMO .

bridgetreilly · 27/07/2020 18:24

I'd rather have a King or Queen as head of state rather than an elected muppet like Donald Trump.

This. A Presidential form of government is truly terrifying to me. A constitutional monarchy seems to me to work very well indeed. All the business of government is conducted, as it should be, by elected officials, but all the pomp and glory goes to someone with no choice in the matter. If you let people stand for election to be President, inevitably you sometimes get the kind of people who should never be allowed near any kind of power. Now, of course you get that with the monarchy too, but the difference is that they don't have any actual power, so it doesn't matter.

DomDoesWotHeWants · 27/07/2020 18:24

A few years ago I would have said yes.

But now people feel sorry for Charles because of the Harry and Meghan situation and have fallen in love with William's children.

I think it will survive.

SantaClaritaDiet · 27/07/2020 18:23

If Brexit and the pandemic have shown and proven one thing, is that the Monarchy is out-dated, completely redundant and pointless.

It's embarrassing to even accept the concept in these days and age. Countries like Cambodia at least have some kind of selection process, better than a country behaving like a group of sheeps.

Nothing against the individuals as such, it's the concept that needs to stay where it belongs, in the past.

TonyChestnut · 27/07/2020 18:23

Some of my best friends are Germans, but I cannot understand why the majority of people in the UK still think it is appropriate to allow a family such as these, or indeed any other, to continue to rule over us. But, seemingly, they do. So in answer to your question, no I don't think it's at all likely to end with the death of Elizabeth.

PicsInRed · 27/07/2020 18:22

@bridgetreilly

It won't end with the Queen, because the Queen is never going to die.

This is fact and no one will convince me otherwise.

Good point.

I've just realised that the requirements of the Brexit cupboard or the COVID cupboard will be nothing to the London-Bridge cupboard. At least initially, the country will grind to a halt and I think people will be quite stunned. Most of us have never known anything but The Queen.

Autviaminveniamautfaciam · 27/07/2020 18:22

If I asked a person to guess where this place was and then described a country where you bow or courtesy to a Queen or King, call others Ma'am, Sir, Lord, Lady, Prince/ss or you had to pay respect to "old money" and aristocracy, and you were defined by your "class", that person would probably say you were referring to somewhere back in the 18th Century or some unplaceable small country in SE Asia that no one can pin on a map.

Well, this is were we live and this is the sh!t we have to put up with.

I hope I live to see the day that the monarchy and aristocracy are disbanded.

GreyGardens88 · 27/07/2020 18:22

I think it should just be massively scaled down, they don't need Balmoral, Sandringham, Windsor, Buckingham Palace. They should have one residence and turn the rest into tourist attractions year round.

Completely get rid of all the lesser Royals, so no Princess Beatrice or Eugenie living it up in Palaces. Just have Kate, William and the three children, then when George is King just have him or if he is gay for example and has no children it can then focus on Charlotte more

bridgetreilly · 27/07/2020 18:19

It won't end with the Queen, because the Queen is never going to die.

This is fact and no one will convince me otherwise.

PicsInRed · 27/07/2020 18:18

@heartsonacake

Rose Hanbury.

PicsInRed What about her? There’s no proof anything happened, it’s nothing more than media speculation to create a buzz.

I can only state my observation that the media has reported it and that reportedly legal removals have occurred. It was only hinted at (though pointedly) in the UK, but more widely reported in foreign media.

Pretty much the same as David/Wallace (etc) and Charles/Camilla. The foreign press are more open and less deferential.

I think that if the only thing keeping people on side with The Monarchy is the idea that Charles is disgraceful but let's just skip to Will and all will be lovely...they're in for crushing disappointment.

PotholeParadise · 27/07/2020 18:17

I struggle to visual him.as King. I think it's a twisted form of nominative determinism
King Charles I caused the overthrow of the monarchy and was beheaded.
King Charles II restored the monarchy.
King Charles III will cause the overthrow of the monarchy again.

ListeningQuietly · 27/07/2020 18:17

Boris Johnson as Head of State

Thanks but I'll settle for Charles and Camilla
then William and Katherine
as the latter have clear plans to go Netherlands style

isntthatnice · 27/07/2020 18:16

I'm hoping we become a republic when Elizabeth passes. My gran would roll over in her grave if she knew my thoughts but it's 2020. It's not right that the reason why someone becomes the head of state is coming out of the correct vagina. It's wrong.

LioneIRichTea · 27/07/2020 18:16

I chose YABU because (although I agree) I don’t think it will end. It’s run like a business now, I can’t imagine it would end, even when it gets to William.

BubblyBarbara · 27/07/2020 18:15

And can you imagine Boris being our singular head of state? God help us. A relatively powerless random person is much better to have the “bling” of statehood and then let the elected officials do the real work

BubblyBarbara · 27/07/2020 18:14

The Monarchy is like the King in chess. It’s not about what they can do but what they can prevent the other pieces from doing. No monarchy equals a new leader living in palaces and being heard of state. An elected head of state means a sense of “losing your country” whenever the guy you didn’t vote for wins. See the US or France for both of these problems.

MsTSwift · 27/07/2020 18:13

We can but hope OP.

Think of the brilliant people we could have in that role instead of dull old Charles

Raimona · 27/07/2020 18:13

Rose Hanbury
Even if it’s true, Kate is smart enough to realise that her children’s future rests on maintaining the public facade of being a happy family that everyone loves.