Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end with the death of Queen Elizabeth 2

492 replies

Gingertea2020 · 27/07/2020 17:43

As an Aussie am curious to know if British monarchy can really prevail beyond life of Queen.

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

Added to this there is the Prince Andrew saga.

With all that is happening in world, will it really continue ?

I can’t imagine a Prince Charles.

I genuinely wonder why the British bother with it all.

OP posts:
CathyorClaire · 27/07/2020 21:05

@PotholeParadise

To be honest, I can well believe Harry has been a seething ball of anger and resentment in private.
That particular loose cannon has been cleverly and expensively spun for years.
CathyorClaire · 27/07/2020 20:59

@albatrossdreams

I don't feel massively sorry for them because they have a life of priviledge

I don't feel they have a life of privilege. Lack of privacy and normal life and agency over one's own life. Must be crap.
The only argument for ending the monarchy I agree with is that it is just not fair on the poor sods born into it.

They are and always have been free to renounce it all.

Fairly telling that only one in modern times ever has.

Alsohuman · 27/07/2020 20:51

@SantaClaritaDiet

Alsohuman

Anyone who asks questions like this is revealing breathtaking ignorance of our political system and what constitutes a republic.

some of us have experienced a bit more than our tiny country and probably know a bit more about a republic than you do. Wink

It's not all about a president wearing the Queen Crown Jewels instead of her GrinGrinGrin

No of course it isn’t, in answer to your last comment, although that’s what you initially implied.

You have no idea where I’ve lived or what I know. You know what they say about assumption.

PotholeParadise · 27/07/2020 20:51

To be honest, I can well believe Harry has been a seething ball of anger and resentment in private.

purplecorkheart · 27/07/2020 20:48

I don't think it will be it will be the end but it will be a huge start. Prince Charles is already stream lining the Royal Family as far as I can see. I think it will be the beginning of the end.

Brahumbug · 27/07/2020 20:35

The monarchy does have real powers, the frightening thing is that they are exercised by the prime minister. Anything which is 'royal prerogative' can not be questioned by parliament. We should have a ceremonial president. There should be a ban on any politician from having the role.

SantaClaritaDiet · 27/07/2020 20:30

Alsohuman

Anyone who asks questions like this is revealing breathtaking ignorance of our political system and what constitutes a republic.

some of us have experienced a bit more than our tiny country and probably know a bit more about a republic than you do. Wink

It's not all about a president wearing the Queen Crown Jewels instead of her GrinGrinGrin

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/07/2020 20:28

perhaps Harry was a seething mass of resentment and anger

If so, he made a hell of a good job hiding it for all those years - and TBH I'm not convinced he has the intelligence to have kept that up

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/07/2020 20:26

There is no power as such these days, it’s all just tradition

I find it genuinely frightening that some really believe this, and can only think it's because the Queen's never abused her powers

Unfortunately that's no guarantee that a less rational monarch wouldn't

MaddieElla · 27/07/2020 20:13

Nah, people want King William and Queen Katherine

FrippEnos · 27/07/2020 19:55

AgeLikeWine
All the monarchy’s palaces, castles, estates, artworks etc etc would be sold off and the proceeds used to create a sovereign wealth fund for the benefit of the whole country.

For about five minutes before the self serving government (which ever side of the political twattery they are) would take it all and fuck it up the walls for their own and their mates gain.

GetOffYourHighHorse · 27/07/2020 19:52

'Funny that he’s been happy for the last 30-something years and just suddenly decided to quit now'

Maybe he wasn't, perhaps Harry was a seething mass of resentment and anger. He always believed it was 100% the media's fault for his mother's death. Its such a shame they didn't just get married quietly then naff off to live privately, he seems to want to drag everyone down with him.

safariboot · 27/07/2020 19:52

YABU.

At least in Britain, I think the death of the Queen really won't feel like the appropriate time to end the monarchy. For those who support the monarchy it will be a time of mourning and reflection. For those opposed, frankly it will be a distasteful time to be vocal in that opposition. The next monarch could be the last, but I expect there will be a next monarch. Though it's plausible it will be William, either by Charles immediately or promptly abdicating or by him passing away before the Queen does.

Of course the other Commonwealth realms are free to go their own ways.

Personally, notwithstanding some of the recent issues with some of the royals, I look at the elected Presidents in some other countries and I think I don't want that here.

AgeLikeWine · 27/07/2020 19:49

I certainly hope so, but I’m not optimistic. I have a great deal of personal respect for the Queen but the monarchy is an anachronism in the 21st century. In democratic societies, people should choose their own leaders.

I would support replacing the monarchy with an elected figurehead presidency with a mainly ceremonial role along the lines of the German or Irish models. The salary could be the same as the Prime Minister’s and Clarence House might be a suitable residence. Any member of the Windsor family who wished to stand for election to such a role would be welcome to do so.

All the monarchy’s palaces, castles, estates, artworks etc etc would be sold off and the proceeds used to create a sovereign wealth fund for the benefit of the whole country.

FrippEnos · 27/07/2020 19:47

"they" got lucky with Meghan too, shame some haters took her as an easy target and pushed her young family away.

She has as many sycophants as haters.

And given the book that she wanted to be written was started before she was married and now she seems to want to distance herself from it, just like she has done to so many of her friends.

StillCoughingandLaughing · 27/07/2020 19:45

Was she supposed to toe the line and behave or was she meant to be this empowered feminist not scared to share her opinions on things?

The problem was she wanted the platform for those opinions - the kind of platform she would never have had as an actress - but none of the difficulties; specifically the lack of privacy. You can’t say ‘I just want to be left alone by the press’ but then court them when you want coverage for your latest speech about the environment, women’s rights or race relations.

dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 27/07/2020 19:45

@TracyBeakerSoYeah

I'd rather have a King or Queen as head of state rather than an elected muppet like Donald Trump.
This although I didn't think this when I was younger!
viques · 27/07/2020 19:41

I think William will make a pretty terrible King.

I think he is well meaning, but not terribly bright, doesn't seem to have much sticking power when it comes to work. I think it is clear where the impetus lies in his relationship.

He actually reminds me a lot of my brother who had a similar personality, could talk to anyone, every one loved him but he was actually a bit of a lazy sod, didn't like upsetting people, and would take the easier route in life always with an eye to his own comfort .Early on he found a woman, or rather she found him, for whom life was mapped out from an early age. She had a ferocious work ethic and stood behind him with a well hidden sharp stick .

I think people feel sorry for William , and Harry, because they had such a sad childhood but neither of them strike me as particularly dynamic or charismatic personalities, or outstanding brains. I hope their children make a better fist of their advantages.

I think the best thing all round would be for the whole shebang to be reduced down to a shell, a bit like the Netherlands or Spain(but without the sex scandals and financial shenanigans) with a vaguely ceremonial role but little pomp and circumstance. Children expected to work for a living at proper jobs and to generally disappear into the general population without titles or the expectation of public money sustaining them.

Puffalicious · 27/07/2020 19:41

I bloody hope so!

jessstan2 · 27/07/2020 19:41

No! We have the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge who are immensely popular, modern, engaged with the world and caring. Charles may turn out alright too but will obviously rely on his eldest son, daughter in law and their family because he's over 70.

Regarding Prince Andrew, we honestly don't really know yet what he has done and it may come to nothing. However the family have survived really big scandals in the past.

Harry and Meghan's book is not out yet, I bet you anything they say very little to rock the royal boat and what they have said has been taken out of context but we'll have to wait and see what it says - if we can be at all bothered.

PicsInRed · 27/07/2020 19:37

@Butteredtoast55

This thread has really made me woder how Diana would have fared in the age of Mumsnet....
A lot more pity and less mockery and told in the strongest terms to take the kids and LTB. "Your mental health will be so much better with distance from him".

Diana was reportedly terrified to leave as she feared that she would lose the kids, just like her mother did. All of the press stuff was media management to get the public on side and ensure that the Queen would allow her to keep the kids - rather than demand they remain with Charles as legally she could have.

That is still the law. Women of that rank who want to leave still risk the loss of their children.

lyralalala · 27/07/2020 19:37

@iwantmyownicecreamvan

Some of the corgis will be re-homed

Noooooo!! Shock

What about the dorgis?

The Queen doesn't have any Corgis left. She has 2 dorgis, but hasn't bred any for a number of years
Youbigdosser · 27/07/2020 19:37

YABU. I think they do so much good and bring in so much tourism. Historical. I think it would be such a shame if it ended I love the Royals.

sonicbook · 27/07/2020 19:36

I'm no royalist but I'm sure they have been through much more than this throughout the long life of the many monarchs we have had.

Almost certainly not. Media and social media intrusion has never been so fierce. No doubt there have been royals in Prince Andrew's situation before but never with the scrutiny. Queen Elizabeth's death will be the end of the monarchy as we know it. Charles will be crowned but there will be a fundamental shift in the importance along the position and by the time William takes over they will receive no public funding.

BilboBercow · 27/07/2020 19:32

We've had unpopular monarchs before, we've had long ruling monarchs die and be replaced with less wonderful ones. There really isn't much of an appetite for a republic in this country. Not enough for people to actually take to the streets and demand one. And it appears Charles wants the job so I can't see him deciding to abdicate.
So yes, the monarchy will go on