Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end with the death of Queen Elizabeth 2

492 replies

Gingertea2020 · 27/07/2020 17:43

As an Aussie am curious to know if British monarchy can really prevail beyond life of Queen.

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

Added to this there is the Prince Andrew saga.

With all that is happening in world, will it really continue ?

I can’t imagine a Prince Charles.

I genuinely wonder why the British bother with it all.

OP posts:
lyralalala · 28/07/2020 08:13

@user1477391263

Dunno but apparently there is an unwritten rule that the names that were used a lot by Scottish kings like Alexander and James are not used. To avoid numbering issues.
Alexander is one of George's names so he could potentially use it if he wanted

They just use the higher number anyway. There was never a Queen Elizabeth in Scotland before QEII

If George opted to be King Alexander he'd be Alexander IV, even though there hasn't been a King Alex in England before.

lyralalala · 28/07/2020 08:08

@BroomHandledMouser

I was thinking about this last night....

When you’re royalty and you have kids that are next in line to the throne - do you have a certain lost of names to choose from such as Charles/George/William etc?

I’d like to see a King Kev personally.

Kept me up that did last night

They don't have a list, but they tend to give a few names so there is a choice

The recent royals seem to avoid John as it's seen as unlucky.

user1477391263 · 28/07/2020 08:00

Dunno but apparently there is an unwritten rule that the names that were used a lot by Scottish kings like Alexander and James are not used. To avoid numbering issues.

BroomHandledMouser · 28/07/2020 07:55

I was thinking about this last night....

When you’re royalty and you have kids that are next in line to the throne - do you have a certain lost of names to choose from such as Charles/George/William etc?

I’d like to see a King Kev personally.

Kept me up that did last night

Codexdivinchi · 28/07/2020 07:50

@GoingtotheWinchester

A big boom in tourism in London will have nothing to do with the royals! People visiting London don’t do so because they think they’ll catch a glimpse of Harry in the local Starbucks Hmm.

The idea that tourism would suffer if we got rid of our RF is patently nonsense but one that is continually pushed by RF supporters because there is precious little else they can say that’s positive about them Hmm.

Well considering 552,000 Visitors PAID to get in to Buckingham Palace last year I’d say people were still interested. 1.65 million paid to see the entire royal family estate bringing in 48 million pounds in addition to that over 21 million in retail sales.

Like it or not- they do bring in tourism.

8T8w · 28/07/2020 06:31

Recently there has been the biography of Megxit and details, intricate, of the fall out between the two Princes and their wives.

No way!! I can't believe that. How does one live in England yet not know about this??

GoingtotheWinchester · 28/07/2020 06:25

A big boom in tourism in London will have nothing to do with the royals! People visiting London don’t do so because they think they’ll catch a glimpse of Harry in the local Starbucks Hmm.

The idea that tourism would suffer if we got rid of our RF is patently nonsense but one that is continually pushed by RF supporters because there is precious little else they can say that’s positive about them Hmm.

StartupRepair · 28/07/2020 06:19

theconversation.com/palace-letters-reveal-the-palaces-fingerprints-on-the-dismissal-of-the-whitlam-government-142476

Whitlam didn't have control of the Senate and they blocked supply. He felt that the GG was working against him and he was trying to get the Queen to sack the GG. It was a race between them to each get the Queen to sack the other.
Whitlam made a lot of mistakes but he was a visionary and a reformer and many of the things we take for granted in Australia were his idea. On election he pulled Australia straight out of the Vietnam War. My brother in law had been conscripted to go so we always feel Whitlam saved his life.

Goosefoot · 28/07/2020 06:15

@Gingertea2020

Interestingly there was a situation with Australia’s former prime Minister Gough Whitlam. There was a dishonest situation that raised eyebrows and he was removed as Prime Minister by the Governor General (Queen Elizabeth’s Oz rep). It has now emerged Queen Elizabeth wasn’t informed of the Australian Governor General’s removal of then PM, Gough Whitlam. This has recently been revealed by historic letters that were released to the public.

The Queen refused to later intervene because she said the powers to remove a Prime Minister lay with the Governor General.

All very complicated and concerning because we rarely know who the Governor General is.

The parties here can choose a new prime minister, it’s the party we elect, not the person like in the US. We’ve had so many changes of Prime Minister within the same party.

I think a separation of powers is a good thing for a democracy. I can see why you all find comfort in history, tradition. It’s not just the role or the royal family but that you know their values. I mean sure there’s cheating and scandals but they’re never going to allow a rogue dictator too much freedom.

You can read about it on Wikipedia.

It wasn't a matter of having done something "bad" it was a matter of the government being unable to function because of a conflict between the two houses.

It's not totally dissimilar to the kind of problem where there is a non-confidence vote - the governing party may be democratically elected, but they have to be able to actually govern - to have the confidence of the MPs to pass legislation and do the work of Parliament. In this case the work of Parliament could not go on because of the conflict between the two houses.

This is exactly the sort of thing the GG exists for. In case of a non-confidence vote within the Commons the decision to trigger an election is pretty clear cut because there is a fair bit of precedent, and the way is clear for the GG to dissolve Parliament. In this instance, there was not the same precedent, so it was necessary for the advisors of the GG - generally constitutional lawyers - to do research and make recommendations, though the buck stops, in the end, with the GG.

This is why the position of GG is explicitly non-political - a decision like this is not meant to be a political one, but one based on the foundations of the system and governance. And there must be no appearance that it might be about politics, either.

Gingertea2020 · 28/07/2020 05:21

@StartupRepair have never been able to find a good summary of what he did to deserve being removed. It’s all very vague online. I’ve never fully understood.

OP posts:
Pebblexox · 28/07/2020 04:21

We can't afford to not have a monarchy.
The money they bring into our country, far outweighs that of much else. They're a selling point nowadays.
Especially with all the drama surrounding them, people are more interested than they have been, so when life is back up and running I believe believe london will see a big boom in tourism.

PhilCornwall1 · 28/07/2020 04:09

@KeepingPlain

The alternative would be a currency with Boris on it.

Oh dear god no.

President Boris Johnson.

Oh shit!! Confused

StartupRepair · 28/07/2020 04:04

@Gingertea2020 Whitlam was not dishonest. Can't let that stand.

Gingertea2020 · 28/07/2020 03:41

@Ispywithmycynicaleye I’m not one for conspiracy theories but agree with you. I don’t buy the kindergarten narrative or the superficial coronial enquire that Diana was killed by the press.

No other celebrity In history has even been in a car accident that was caused by the press. It’s extremely unlucky and questionable timing.

I think her recent success with the landmines caused controversy with politicians and I imagine arms dealers. She was so powerful. This is before social media. She could make any issue front page news and she did with land mines and made major progress.

I think there were powerful people who wanted her killed. I don’t think the royal family would have cared she was dating a Muslim. She was no longer a member do their family. I think it was more that she was no longer protected by people on the inside of power that had ties to royal family.

We think power lies with heads of state and politicians but it doesn’t. There’s a whole other layer of people with serious money and power behind the scenes.

OP posts:
Gingertea2020 · 28/07/2020 03:30

Interestingly there was a situation with Australia’s former prime Minister Gough Whitlam. There was a dishonest situation that raised eyebrows and he was removed as Prime Minister by the Governor General (Queen Elizabeth’s Oz rep). It has now emerged Queen Elizabeth wasn’t informed of the Australian Governor General’s removal of then PM, Gough Whitlam. This has recently been revealed by historic letters that were released to the public.

The Queen refused to later intervene because she said the powers to remove a Prime Minister lay with the Governor General.

All very complicated and concerning because we rarely know who the Governor General is.

The parties here can choose a new prime minister, it’s the party we elect, not the person like in the US. We’ve had so many changes of Prime Minister within the same party.

I think a separation of powers is a good thing for a democracy. I can see why you all find comfort in history, tradition. It’s not just the role or the royal family but that you know their values. I mean sure there’s cheating and scandals but they’re never going to allow a rogue dictator too much freedom.

OP posts:
Ispywithmycynicaleye · 28/07/2020 03:18

Think of all the queens jewellery she has on loan from the British public. She was asked by government to return the jewellery but refused. Millions of ££££££'s apparently. Imagine how much that would help poverty that the rich royals pretend to ralley around.
Absolutely dianna was bumped off. Marrying a Muslim wouldn't have been great for the royals. What was the recent headlines..... queen acted on necessity for the brand than family.... Harry's freedom clause probably had a silence order attached. Clearly he wasnt allowed to name his real dad WinkGrin

PotholeParadise · 28/07/2020 01:54

Let us suppose for a moment that Andrew was a born diplomat who would make the perfect head of state instead of merely being the first royal unable to sweat. Would it be to the Royal Family's advantage to let the public know what they were missing out on? They do their best to sway public opinion in the direction they want.

As already observed, the effort goes into the eldest heir, and there is nothing motivating is growing up knowing that whatever you do or achieve, your older brother/sister will be monarch, not you. That's one way to warp a character.

But if a younger child rose above that and outshone the eldest, it would be unhelpful to the institution to have it be well-known. Publicly popular younger siblings are what leads to wars of succession!

BigChocFrenzy · 28/07/2020 01:51

"I think we are very very lucky William was born before Harry. Katherine very much lives up to the role of future Queen consort."

If Harry had been born first, then Kate would have stalked and nailed him instead Grin

caringcarer · 28/07/2020 01:42

I think.monarchy will continue. I think Charles will be ok King. He won't have too many years and then William will be ok. Just grateful we won't get emotional wreck Harry and must be centre of attention Meghan.

The way she treated her father was appailing. I could not really care if Meghan wanted to jet about whilst lecturing the rest of us, or how much she spent of tax payers money on Frog House, what made me see her for what she is, a nasty attention grabber who can't bare anyone else being in the limelight was announcing her pregnancy at a family wedding is just so incredibly spiteful. Did anyone see her elbow Harry out of frame recently in video clip so she ended up centre of camera focus with Harry almost pushed out of shot? She just can't cope with not being centre of attention.

TibetanTerrier · 28/07/2020 01:32

@pigsDOfly
But judging by the thousands of people that flock to catch a glimpse of them every time there's a royal wedding or some other royal event it would seem that a great many of 'the British' are very happy with them.

There are 65 million people in the UK, so the few thousand who turn up to look at them are a tiny proportion of the population.

StillCoughingandLaughing · 28/07/2020 01:32

Charles can't slim down the monarchy for long seeing as William is having children as if he needs spare kids to create alliances with neighbouring countries.

Maybe we should go back to that method of choosing royal brides. Surely Scandinavia could have spared a couple of princesses for William and Harry?

I think we are very very lucky William was born before Harry.

Is it luck, or was it training? The establishment puts its energy into the heir, not the spare. Look at Andrew. Look at Margaret. Is it really sheer dumb luck that they weren’t the first-born, or were they simply not prioritised and left to their own devices?

StartupRepair · 28/07/2020 01:27

Definitely time for Australia to become a republic. Many people here are reeling from by the publication of letters between the Queen and our governor general at the time when the GG sacked a democratically elected Prime Minister in the name of the Queen. 1975. Major constitutional crisis. The letters show that the Queen was able to deny foreknowledge but her team was coaching the GG.

TibetanTerrier · 28/07/2020 01:23

@GreyGardens88
I think it should just be massively scaled down, they don't need Balmoral, Sandringham, Windsor, Buckingham Palace. They should have one residence and turn the rest into tourist attractions year round.

Balmoral and Sandringham are Lizzie's personal property, they don't belong to the nation and if the monarchy was abolished they would remain the personal property of the Windsors. Buck House and Windsor do belong to the nation, and they're held in trust for future generations by the Crown Estates.

caringcarer · 28/07/2020 01:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

janaus50s · 28/07/2020 01:09

Aussie here too. I think there will be a big push here to become a republic.