Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
Inthebackoftheimpala · 20/07/2020 19:36

Nope they're not. Until my son was on medication I worked with the school to find solutions.

KittyFantastico · 20/07/2020 19:28

The overlap is why DS couldn't be diagnosed with ADHD even with indications that it is/was present. It was impossible to say where ASD ended and ADHD began (and visa versa) or how many of the behaviours indicating ADHD were down to needs relating to ASD. They were confident in the ASD diagnosis so that was made but the ADHD diagnosis was deferred due to insufficient/inconclusive evidence. They have tried to do the assessments since but couldn't proceed as he couldn't engage with them.

Realityofsen · 20/07/2020 19:26

My DD is very likely to end up with an ASD, ADHD, pda, spd diagnosis. I'm sure I'm not alone in spending far too much of my life overanalysing my parenting. Reading every book. Trying every approach. Doing all the courses.

I'm also not convinced that the system is such a nightmare to navigate that you have to have a certain level of intelligence to be able to navigate it to get the diagnosis.

ChangeOfNameNeeded07 · 20/07/2020 19:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bumblingbovine49 · 20/07/2020 19:23

not autism, it is attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder.

There is growing evidence that the two are related and often overlap.

ChangeOfNameNeeded07 · 20/07/2020 19:16

I do think that. It is a combination of bad parenting and, mostly, those children are chronically tired and emotionally overcharged.

AbsentmindedWoman · 20/07/2020 19:01

*children who HAVE Type 1 Diabetes.

Not have had. Freudian wishful thinking on my behalf Grin

AbsentmindedWoman · 20/07/2020 18:59

I'm a psychologist. My son has ADHD. Part of the debate about whether ADHD exists in professional circles is because of differing ontological views. Its a philosophical divide. It's clearly not an thing' in the same way as a lamp, a dog or a pebble are a thing. There are no physical tests ( brain scans, blood tests) that can predict whether a child shows the cluster of symptoms associated with ADHD and no clear causal pathway.

However, MRI scans clearly show different neural activity in ADHD brains during experiments where they get participants to perform particular tasks. Researchers can most definitely identify non-neurotypical patterns of brain activity.

Interestingly, recent research shows similar neural activity of children who have had Type 1 Diabetes. Shifts in brain function likely due to how the developing brain was affected by glucose that is higher than normal.

It fascinates me that some people still dismiss ADHD as something that doesn't exist. I wonder if a proportion of them would also be determined to believe they could cure their kid of Type 1 Diabetes, should they develop it, with a bit of 'diet and exercise' or the right snake oil?

ADHD exists, just like T1D.

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 18:48

@Genevieva
Thanks for the info, it is not something I came across in my research of the area. I will definitely look further in the direction you have indicated.

OP posts:
Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 18:46

actually in my experience and I can only speak for my experience is that ADHD is more likely to be diagnosed in “normal“ families.
I think it is really dependent on the whole social structure. The teacher from my OP teaches in a "rough" school in a third world country (the one I am from, so I can totally vouch for the school being challenging - and I admire her as it is fully by choice), but tutors many children from local well-off families too. Her view was diametrically opposite to the "chaotic poor families" expressed earlier on the thread, i.e. that all children with ADHD tend to mainly have wealthy helicopter parents and private diagnoses. But we did not discuss it in more detail.

OP posts:
Genevieva · 20/07/2020 18:43

Cecily, that is dreadful. You clearly have a set up that works for you and they should not judge that when you go to see them about other medical problems.

The issue that concerns me is all those children prescribe Ritalin who actually have a breathing problem during sleep that doesn't require Ritalin at all. This doesn't apply to all children, but to enough children for it to be a scandal.

Jimdandy · 20/07/2020 18:43

I think ADHD is real, but I think it is over diagnosed when parenting is misguided.

CecilyBlue · 20/07/2020 18:35

I have ADHD and without my Methylphenidate (Ritalin) I honestly could not function in my job, as a mother and with life in general.
Every time I go for a hospital appointment for anything not related to my ADHD I usually have to fill out a form listing any medications I currently take.
I always get asked by the Doctors or Nurses what the Methylphenidate is for and nearly every single time I say it's for ADHD, the response is absolutely shocking. I've had Doctors laugh, shake their heads, tell me it doesn't exist, etc. I honestly dread filling those forms in as it's so very rare to be met with a positive (or even neutral) response.

Genevieva · 20/07/2020 18:33

The over medication problem will depend on whether the symptoms can be treated any other way. If a child is only ever prescribed these medicines and those doses are increased when they fail to work, without ever having a sleep study, then there is a problem. Sleep studies should be a mandatory part of the ADHD diagnosis process.

Viviennemary · 20/07/2020 18:33

I agree with people who say that yes of course it does exist but not every naughty child will have ADHD. And surely it goes that not every child with ADHD will be naughty. It's a minefield.

ChittyChittyBoomBoom · 20/07/2020 18:31

@GreytExpectations

The issue is in America specifically it is over diagnosed meaning a lot of cases are mis diagnosed. They also treat the symptoms by giving very young children strong medication. This isn't always the best suggestion and doctors in America are very quick to proscribe. I'm talking about 6 years being given ritalin as an "easy fix"

Now, ADHD absolutely is a real condition and should be treated as such but I think the points I made above is sadly why some people often eye roll at it.

GreytExpectations

You’re talking about my son then. He was diagnosed and given Ritalin at 6.

Why do you see medication as an “easy fix”. Would chemotherapy be an “easy fix” for cancer? Or insulin for a diabetic? Or paracetamol for a headache?

Obviously, misdiagnoses happen and are far from ideal but I’m guessing the vast majority of diagnoses are accurate.

Cacacoisfarraige · 20/07/2020 18:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

pepsicola5 · 20/07/2020 18:28

@Vodkacranberryplease I know one of those too... avoid like the plague!

MintyMabel · 20/07/2020 18:28

I can rant about Big Pharma with the best of them: it does not change the fact that medication prescribed for ADHD has a significant positive effect on my child, when he is willing to take it. The issues many of us have with Big Pharma do not mean no illnesses exist and no medications are effective.

I’m no big pharma conspiracy theorist, but I did watch a great documentary on the BBC by Dr Chris where he talked about over medication for ADHD. There was a program from the Netherlands that encouraged meditation amongst other things teaching kids how to manage their symptoms. It seemed really positive and most of the kids were able to reduce their medication. I’m not sure if it’s still on IPlayer.

Cacacoisfarraige · 20/07/2020 18:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Magicismagic · 20/07/2020 18:27

@mistyrivers87 sorry your name was incorrect in my message above

Sinuhe · 20/07/2020 18:26

I think ADHD is real but not as common as it's believed to be. I have no doubt that a lot of children are miss diagnosed. Due to incompetence from parents, teachers and doctors alike.

My DS always had problems at nusery and through primary school in regards to his behaviour. (Just a little boy who couldn't sit still, but got better as he got older...)
We had several teachers telling us XYZ are classic for ADHD and we should seek an diagnosis. Thing is, we never had these behaviour problems at home. But he struggled with the confinement of the classroom.
I really believe it was an easy way to deal with him... stick a label on, give some medication, problem solved! (yep someone suggested medication for a then 6 year old!)

Magicismagic · 20/07/2020 18:23

@ mistyrivers87 actually in my experience and I can only speak for my experience is that ADHD is more likely to be diagnosed in “normal“ families. As many other PP’s have said it is very hard to get an ADHD diagnosis, referrals can go through the school but are more often done through a GP The below information is what happened in my DS’s case and I believe that a chaotic family would find it extremely hard to persevere through all this especially if they have other children at home.
Getting referred by the GP - this may necessitate a few visits, then a referral to a paediatric specialist again more than one visit, assessments are carried out the school will also be asked for an assessment, the school will be comparing the individual child’s behaviour to a large number of other children rather than the parents who may only have limited knowledge of usual child behaviour. The medication if prescribed is a restricted drug the same pharmacy must be used each time and ID must be shown. The child must attend for regular check ups usually every 6 months in my experience for height and weight checking as the medication can affect the Child’s growth so this must be monitored. There is more than one type of medication and not everyone will have a good reaction to each medication for example one medication my DS took caused hyper emotions, stopped him eating at all and made getting off to sleep near impossible . So back to the specialist different medication but he still had to have Melatonin to help him get off to sleep. As he grew his medication dosage needed tweaking the GP is not allowed to do this So back to the specialist again.
Usually parenting classes are offered in our area 8 sessions one hour a week for 8 consecutive weeks and you cannot take your child with ADHD or any other child with you ( no crèche either).

Chaotic families will be helped through this process if they come to the attention of SW but otherwise no they usually just muddle along and very rarely get their child officially diagnosed. Sometime organisations like Home Start can also help.

MintyMabel · 20/07/2020 18:23

The problem is some people via the route of “Dr Google” like to claim their child has is, minus any professional diagnosis

The problem is, parents have been fighting to get a referral to CAMHS for years but keep being told they are just shit parents because their teacher refuses to believe them on the basis a child can keep a lid on it for a few hours a day to try to fit in with peers and avoid being punished for being who they are.

Vodkacranberryplease · 20/07/2020 18:22

Pepsicola there are people who believe the earth is flat. These are the people you avoid