Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
GreytExpectations · 20/07/2020 21:34

So my Ds's psychiatrist at CAMHS was wrong then?

Yes, they were wrong. Have you even read the other responses on this thread since you last posted? Plenty of people have shared links and resources as to why you and your CAHMS psychiatrist was wrong.

HTH.

MrsZola · 20/07/2020 21:24

@GreytExpectations

ADHD is part of the autistic spectrum in the same way that Asperger's Syndrome is.

No, it is not. Please do some research before giving false information.

So my Ds's psychiatrist at CAMHS was wrong then?
HoldMyLobster · 20/07/2020 21:21

What do you mean thicko? Is that someone with a lower cognitive ability???

No, I mean people with closed minds.

HoldMyLobster · 20/07/2020 21:20

And have you recently had a child diagnosed with ADHD in America GreytExpectations?

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 20/07/2020 21:20

Yes it's real.

I like others think its probably over diagnosed, although more likely so in the USA than here.

GreytExpectations · 20/07/2020 21:18

*You’re talking about my son then. He was diagnosed and given Ritalin at 6.

Why do you see medication as an “easy fix”. Would chemotherapy be an “easy fix” for cancer? Or insulin for a diabetic? Or paracetamol for a headache?

Obviously, misdiagnoses happen and are far from ideal but I’m guessing the vast majority of diagnoses are accurate.*

I am not saying that at all, you have misinterpreted my point. I am giving an example of the situation in America which is very different to here. They give Ritalin to every child with a diagnosis as a first port of call, over here more thorough assessments are done to look at other non medical routes to support those children with ADHD. I couldn't get a ritalin prescription here as an adult, even though I was diagnosed with ADHD because they didnt want to jump straight to medicine. America's pharmaceutical industry is disgustingly profit oriented which is a major problem over there.

Just for reference, I was diagnosed as a child with ADHD in America so I'm far from ignorant on it.

MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 21:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 21:16

@mistyrivers87 you have no understanding of what ADHD is. It does NOT necessarily equate to poor behaviour although that may be seen especially in those that have the hyperactive/impulsive sub-type.

ADHD is an executive function disorder. That means it makes it very difficult for you to concentrate on things you are not very interested in, difficult to switch tasks and difficult to start new tasks leading to to procrastination. Working memory is poor so you can't hold tasks or information in your head. You mislay or lose things. Your brain jumps about so you can switch from one topic to another struggling to take people with you.

ADHD means you have a motivation and interest deficit. It takes a lot to get our brain firing and working properly. For example I've always done my best work at the last minute. On the few occasions I have managed to complete things ahead of time, the work has generally poor quality.

We therefore get bored very easily and so struggle to maintain habits and hobbies. We struggle to maintain regular tasks at home due to this.

We struggle with emotional dysregulation so emotions can go up and down very quickly. For me my mood changes can be hourly.

You have no internal clock so time management is very difficult so your perception of time passing is often completely wrong.

Social interaction can be difficult. For me, I struggle with concentrating on what people are saying, without interrupting. I struggle to remember what I want to say - if I don't/can't say it immediately it's gone. I can't stand small talk. I tend to blurt our random things and over share which leaves me feeling vulnerable. It all means I have to constantly monitor what I am doing in social settings so they can stressful rather than fun.

ADHD can therefore make it very difficult to run your life. I get very overwhelmed for example if I have to plan to have a night out. I struggle to remember tasks and appointments so I have multiple systems in place to help me manage these things but that's can be time consuming to maintain. We struggle to look after ourselves - drink enough water, eat the right foods, exercise consistently. We often have sleep issues. So we have a higher rate of disease and a shorter life expectancy

A common thing in some ADHDers, that I definitely struggle with, is word and fact recall. I learn loads of things but can't recall them when I need to which is embarrassing and makes me sound stupid when I am not. I often say the wring word to (or make up words when I can't think of one that describes what I want to say!!).

It's a disorder of inconsistency. Some days better the others, some things you can concentrate and some you can't, constantly starting new things you can't maintain or finish.

Conversely, people with ADHD are often great ideas people who can hyper focus on things they are interested in. They tend to be great at research and love learning new things. Some can have lots of energy. They can have great senses of humour. They usually like change. We are usually great in a crisis or when there's a tight deadline.

So please educate yourself. ADHD is not just naughty hyperactive boys and an excuse for misbehaving. It is a condition that affects many facets of your life and can make like very hard for many people.

ADHD is real. It's been well studied over many years. There's been studies that have shown differences in the brain structure in people with ADHD. It's also known to be inherited.

Roomba · 20/07/2020 21:13

I can echo the comments about the way school is set up not always working well for those with ADHD. During lockdown, my son has gone from getting grade 6s in most subjects, with 'could try harder' comments, to getting 9s for everything, winning a speech day prize and entering a national competition for a subject - something he'd never have considered doing before. Because he's been able to work at home in a way that works well for him. I'm now worried about his mood and grades deteriorating when he returns to school, but less worried about how he'd cope at uni in future.

Notenoughchocolateomg · 20/07/2020 21:10

I used to think it was nonsense made up excuse for naughty children. I was a fool. My son isn't diagnosed, but he clearly has it. I'm a strict parent and both children have great manners. My eldest is a dream child. Does exactly as he is told. Very moral. Youngest has many sen, asd, sensory issues, tics, dyslexia and adhd too I think. He is hard work. I am strict and he knows right from wrong but lord he is always on the go, attention span is almost zero unless hes on his tablet. I feel ashamed about being so naive.

duletty · 20/07/2020 21:07

@HoldMyLobster

I would be better off teaching my dog to drive than trying to counter these idiotic opinions. People are, generally speaking, not too bright. Explaining something complex through the prism of their background of daily mail articles and 6th hand knowledge is just an utter waste of time.

I think most people get it. There are just some trolls and some total thickos on this thread who don't.

What do you mean thicko? Is that someone with a lower cognitive ability???
Roomba · 20/07/2020 21:01

I was a teacher and I definitely believe in ADHD! And I did so long before my own son was diagnosed with it. I'm also 95% sure that I have it myself, though what is dyspraxia related (diagnosed as a child) and what is ADHD related is hard to define!

I have met teachers who make nasty comments about ADHD just being an excuse for bad parenting. They didn't tend to be the most inspiring, well informed teachers though...

HoldMyLobster · 20/07/2020 21:01

I would be better off teaching my dog to drive than trying to counter these idiotic opinions. People are, generally speaking, not too bright. Explaining something complex through the prism of their background of daily mail articles and 6th hand knowledge is just an utter waste of time.

I think most people get it. There are just some trolls and some total thickos on this thread who don't.

HoldMyLobster · 20/07/2020 21:00

I feel it's much more likely to be under than over diagnosed, given all the adults who have likely not been diagnosed.

Oh yes, my MIL has probably the most severe ADD I've ever seen. Totally undiagnosed.

You know those threads where people say 'But isn't it funny how people who 'can't help being late' never actually miss flights?'

She misses flights regularly Grin

Phineyj · 20/07/2020 20:58

I don't see how it can be over diagnosed. We are in the process of getting a diagnosis. I have had concerns for about two years. There appears to be nothing available through the NHS at all. We have had to make a private referral. The process is going to cost us several grand. As this thread clearly demonstrates, there is stigma and judgement attached to a diagnosis. There was nothing in my teacher training about ADHD but I am fortunate to work with an excellent SENCO and she makes sure we've got all the info we need to work with our students. She's been way more help than anyone else. I feel it's much more likely to be under than over diagnosed, given all the adults who have likely not been diagnosed.

Vodkacranberryplease · 20/07/2020 20:51

Typo - I mean mums that always think they are right.

Vodkacranberryplease · 20/07/2020 20:50

This thread is a perfect example of why You never talk to anyone about this. Apart from the people that absolutely need to know.

I would be better off teaching my dog to drive than trying to counter these idiotic opinions. People are, generally speaking, not too bright. Explaining something complex through the prism of their background of daily mail articles and 6th hand knowledge is just an utter waste of time.

'The ones with adhd have mind that always think their kids are right' Grin. Dear oh dear.

mineofuselessinformation · 20/07/2020 20:44

Changeofnameneeded, I suggest you change your name to moreknowledgeandunderstandingneeded.
Are you a child psychologist or an educational psychologist? Oh, wait, let me answer that for you. NO.
Your judgemental attitude and the way you group people together for your own ease is disgusting.

Cacacoisfarraige · 20/07/2020 20:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Bupkis · 20/07/2020 20:28

@FabbyChix
It’s a behaviour issue - it’s not something your born with

This is not correct.

Many genetic conditions have ADHD as an associated part of the condition. These are conditions children are born with, their neurological differences are written into their DNA!

Freddofrogshop · 20/07/2020 20:18

ChangeOfNameNeeded07 stop talking crap. You dont know "all adhd mums" and how they behave, or whether the children are tired.
Those people who think it is just bad parenting are just being smug. I have 2 children, one with no sen, one with asd and adhd.
I have parented them the same.
One has never been in trouble at school, ever, and is now in year 12.
The other had absolutely no ability to concentrate, and ended up getting fidgety and unsettled in class, and getting into lots of trouble.
After his diagnosis and medication, he can concentrate and learn, but towards the end of the day, as the medication wears off, the movement, lack of focus, etc return. You can almost see his brain getting "fizzy" as he calls it.

So it's not parenting , or lack of sleep. He does need to take medication to help him sleep, but that didn't cure the problems.
Just watching him right now, he is pulling all sorts of faces, jiggling around, moving upside down on the sofa and making all manner of odd noises.
Certainly not being "naughty" just cant stay still.
This is a real condition, not something I have made up to excuse myself from parenting him.

bookmum08 · 20/07/2020 20:03

A lot of the ADHD = naughty can often be just because we (society) are deciding what is naughty or not. School is such a lot of 'sit down, listen to the teacher and get on silently with some written work'. Children with ADHD often just don't learn and behave that way. They need to be 'doing'. Uniform rules and making sure you have your equipment and bringing in homework etc are also often hard for those with ADHD to deal with. As a result they are labelled 'naughty'.
ADHD is very real but I believe a lot of the struggles that so many children and their families go through is that the school/exam system is set up just for one way of learning (academic focus) and for many children who have ADHD it just doesn't work for them.
Changes to the school system wouldn't mean ADHD would go away it would mean that so many children wouldn't be labelled 'naughty' it would just be that ADHD is the way they are.

Cacacoisfarraige · 20/07/2020 19:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Sockmonster23 · 20/07/2020 19:47

I think it exists but it’s over diagnosed now.. I do agree that poor parenting and chaotic households does sometimes lead to this diagnoses but then take them away from that environment and they do change. One of my sons is ASD and that definitely exists as well..

HoldMyLobster · 20/07/2020 19:41

I do laugh a little ruefully when people say ADHD is over-diagnosed and medicated here in the US. For my son to get an ADHD diagnosis...

We saw his GP with him
We filled in questionnaires
His teachers filled in questionnaires
We met with the counselor at school
We met with the psychologist at school
I met with another educational psychologist who interviewed me for 2 hours
He spent 2 days doing tests with the educational psychologist, who then produced a 28 page report with detailed findings, recommendations, and information.
We had a 2-hour debrief with the ed psych

At that point he was diagnosed with ADHD and was prescribed meds, at which point our health insurance company also wrote to us to ensure that he sees a doctor regularly while they are being prescribed.

We went back to the school who put together a 504 Plan for him to ensure they make accommodations for his learning disabilities. We meet with all his teachers at least once a year to review his plan.

He also sees a tutor who specialises in working with students with ADHD, and we regularly attend group sessions and parenting classes.

It was all worth it - he's so much happier now he's getting the support and understanding he needs.

He's never been particularly naughty btw. He's an incredibly well-behaved kid.