Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
DaveMinion · 20/07/2020 22:03

I was diagnosed with adhd last year at the age of 42. It definitely exists but in girls and women is very underdiagnosed. Luckily the tides are changing and it’s becoming recognised that it presents a lot differently in us. Those of us educated in the 80’s and 90’s were a missed generation I think.

I’m diagnosed as severe combined and although I would say my hyperactivity is mainly internalised as my mind never shuts off, I am pretty hyper most of the time when around people. Lockdown has brought out my inattentive side though. It’s been an interesting time.

Medication for me (I’ve tried long acting ritalin - concerta and lisdexamfetamine which I’m going back to this week) is not a cure but a tool and a very useful one. I would urge any parent to at least try it for their child as honestly if I had it at school my experience would have been so different. As it was I had no grade above a D and was excluded from 4 subjects including English.

BertieBotts · 20/07/2020 22:02

^ Sorry - so not really similar to microdosing from the five second read of a wikipedia article I just read. Although my own doctor's low dose antidepressant one is similar to microdosing, perhaps.

BertieBotts · 20/07/2020 22:01

@Ilovecranberries

I haven't reached the medication stage in my research about the conditio , to be honest. So effectively the medication for adhd is based on the same principle the same as the fashionable in some circles "microdosing"?
I'm not sure, because I don't really understand how microdosing works, but I think unlikely - Ritalin for ADHD has been around for a very long time and initially they had absolutely no idea why it worked, to be honest they still don't really know how it works, the idea that it gives the brain the stimulation it's short on is one theory, but basically we just still have it because it works but nobody knows exactly why.

Stimulant-based ADHD medications are heavily controlled in the US because there is quite the roaring trade among university students for Adderall for example as a "study drug" and Dexamphetamine because it's very similar to street amphetamines but purer. Some patients have to take regular drug tests to prove that they are actually taking the medication. You can get into quite serious trouble if you lose your prescription as it is possible that you are lying about having sold it. Of course, for a condition that makes it highly likely you will regularly lose things this is unfortunate.

2020wasShocking · 20/07/2020 22:01

She’s ignorant OP. Also you mention she teaches in a foreign country, so I’m wondering if it’s not a diagnosis there?

I’m sure about 20 years ago people thought the same about dyslexia and the like, but then more research was done and it became apparent that indeed there was such a difficulty

Witchcraftandhokum · 20/07/2020 22:00

Cacaoosfarriage You've misunderstood. The doctor wasn't saying that FAS was a cause of ADHD, she was saying that research showed around 1/3 of cases of ADHD were actually FAS instead.

TrainspottingWelsh · 20/07/2020 22:00

@tabulahrasa I was dx as a child, but never medicated. I discovered during teen experimentation that drugs didn't have the same effect on me as they did on my friends, particularly anything amphetamine based. My friends would take stuff to rave through the night, something that I never needed anything for. I'd take the same amount to complete particularly boring revision and coursework.

GreytExpectations · 20/07/2020 21:59

@HoldMyLobster

I've had experience with close friends and family members whose children have been diagnosed in America. If you don't agree with me then fine but I'm just giving you my experience.

It sounds like all that happened was you were prescribed Ritalin. Did an educational psychologist work with your parents and yourself on developing a support plan? Did the school work on developing a 504 plan? Were you given additional instructional support at school? Were you helped with executive functioning skills?

All of these are quite normal nowadays - I'd be quite sad if your friends and family are not getting that sort of help today. I wouldn't be so surprised if it didn't happen when you were a child though, sadly.

When I was a child in the UK, children with ADHD were told they were stupid, and generally failed all their exams and left school early.

This is exactly my point. In America it often is a case of prescribe medication and that's it. I wasn't offered any support.

The UK is much better in my opinion for offering support than America is.

museumum · 20/07/2020 21:58

I believe 100% in the adhd diagnosis and know adults with it.
But I’ve also met and unfortunately been left in charge of children with horrific dangerous behaviour who told me their parents and doctors would confirm they weren’t responsible for their actions as they had adhd.
These actions included in one case throwing huge rocks at another kids head and I had to exclude the kid with adhd much to their parents disgust. I don’t know if the problem was adhd or parenting but I couldn’t allow that in my setting.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 20/07/2020 21:56

Jesus fucking Christ! We're not talking about God or fairies or the Cookie monster here.

We're talking about a medical condition that is well documented, research, has a diagnosis pathway and various treatments (not cures).

It's not something you believe in or not. It's something that exists and is acknowledged regardless of your beliefs.

Maybe if you just say "I don't believe in ADHD" long enough your son will just get better OP.

So many misconceptions and myths on this thread.

ADHD is not Autism. They can be comorbid, but they're entirely separate conditions.

ADHD doesn't always mean badly behaved.

The diagnosis path is not an easy or straightforward one.

Meds can work, so can other things. Trying different things for different children is not a bad thing.

Just because a child has a shitty/neglectful upbringing doesn't mean they can't also have ADHD. Their upbringing might make the condition worse but that's it.

Just like autism, ADHD manifests in different ways in different children. Just because x does a and b and reacts positively to c and d it doesn't mean that y will display the same behaviours or respond to the same things.

And breathe...

BertieBotts · 20/07/2020 21:56

@weebarra

Yes, I think there are a lot of misconceptions about medication. Ritalin is a stimulant and helps some people because it pushes them over the stimulation curve. DS1 isn't able to take it because of other medical conditions so he takes another drug which helps the uptake of norepinephrine in the brain and helps concentration.
Me too. I don't take Strattera though because it's not licenced for adults where I live but I take a tricyclic antidepressant in very low dose which has the same effect.

It's still not great but I'm more functional on it than off it. Although the unskippable alarm I have to set on my phone to make sure I really do take is now a running joke among my friends :)

D4rwin · 20/07/2020 21:54

Amazing how many teachers think that they're experience of one child having a different presentation of a condition than another means that they're more knowledgeable than the experts who made a diagnosis. So many teachers fail to recognise their absolute massive bias when "deciding" whether a child is genuine or "just" has a behavioural issue. But this diagnosis results in what can be challenging behaviours. Still these teachers think they know better than the experts.

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 21:54

I haven't reached the medication stage in my research about the conditio , to be honest. So effectively the medication for adhd is based on the same principle the same as the fashionable in some circles "microdosing"?

OP posts:
Cacacoisfarraige · 20/07/2020 21:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

HoldMyLobster · 20/07/2020 21:51

I've had experience with close friends and family members whose children have been diagnosed in America. If you don't agree with me then fine but I'm just giving you my experience.

It sounds like all that happened was you were prescribed Ritalin. Did an educational psychologist work with your parents and yourself on developing a support plan? Did the school work on developing a 504 plan? Were you given additional instructional support at school? Were you helped with executive functioning skills?

All of these are quite normal nowadays - I'd be quite sad if your friends and family are not getting that sort of help today. I wouldn't be so surprised if it didn't happen when you were a child though, sadly.

When I was a child in the UK, children with ADHD were told they were stupid, and generally failed all their exams and left school early.

BertieBotts · 20/07/2020 21:50

Something I've come to realise is that I cannot expect anybody else to have an in depth understanding of ADHD. I don't, and I appreciate that, for example, I myself don't have a very in depth understanding of dyslexia, or T1 diabetes, or hypermobility, or food allergies, or chronic fatigue, to take a random selection of issues that people I know and love live with. I have an in depth understanding of ADHD because it's my issue and my son's issue and so it's important to me to understand it. I can't possibly understand every single issue somebody might have to the same extent. And so I respect that other people won't know everything about my issue either.

So I no longer feel annoyed about people not understanding subtypes, and nor would I expect other people to automatically understand if I say "Oh I have ADHD, please support me". Instead I ask for specific things "Please can you send me this information in an e-mail?" "Excuse me while I write this in my calendar before I forget" "Could I give you money towards the picnic rather than bringing something? Let me give it to you now".

But I have never said things like "Allergies aren't that serious, I'm sure he'll be fine if he has a little bit of milk powder". I listen to the mum of the allergy kid because I know she has much more of an understanding than me!

I do not say "Well I tried so hard to help that dyslexic person but he just isn't trying hard enough." or "Why don't you just use spell check?" I don't know why spellcheck doesn't work for dyslexic people but I know that would be incredibly annoying.

I don't decide randomly that it's best if the person with diabetes eats this food rather than that, because I have no idea what is the best way to control blood sugar levels with diabetes, even if I did read an article about it in a health food magazine.

So if you do not have an in depth understanding of ADHD, that's absolutely fine, but please don't go around pretending that you do know about it (by saying that it's overdiagnosed, or overmedicated, or that XYZ therapy is better than medication, or that medicating children is "sad"). It's okay not to know about something. If you like, you could ask "How can I support you with that?" But mainly, just understand that it's OK not to know a lot about a subject and just be alright with that.

JollyRogerandDiane · 20/07/2020 21:50

My teen dd has been diagnosed with ADHD, quite recently. I’m a primary school teacher. I had no idea. ADHD in girls presents SO differently in boys. I’ve taught many boys with ADHD - I thought I knew what it entailed. www.google.co.uk/amp/s/childmind.org/article/how-girls-with-adhd-are-different/amp/ It’s a completely different kettle of fish and girls are often overlooked. I’d urge everyone to have a read (not particularly this article but any on girls and ADHD) - I can see why ‘people’ don’t believe in ADHD when the presentations are so different. It’s ignorance rather than stupidity (certainly was on my part!) - I always understood (and believed) it was a condition but I certainly didn’t understand the breadth of it.

Busymum45 · 20/07/2020 21:50

I thought it wasn't real too and just naughty kids but i.dont think that's the case

weebarra · 20/07/2020 21:48

Yes, I think there are a lot of misconceptions about medication. Ritalin is a stimulant and helps some people because it pushes them over the stimulation curve.
DS1 isn't able to take it because of other medical conditions so he takes another drug which helps the uptake of norepinephrine in the brain and helps concentration.

Cacacoisfarraige · 20/07/2020 21:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tabulahrasa · 20/07/2020 21:46

“I don't know how old I was but I remember reading a throwaway comment somewhere on a message board where someone pointed out that actually, ritalin (and many other ADHD treatments) are NOT tranquilisers, they are stimulants.”

Yep, the most common U.K. drugs work in a very similar way to amphetamine, in other countries the medication is actually amphetamine.

If anyone has experience of people taking amphetamine recreationally, they’ll appreciate that it does not have the effect it has on people with ADHD usually, lol

Pugdoglife · 20/07/2020 21:45

ADHD is definitely real, I've seen many students struggling with its effects over the years, some diagnosed, some not diagnosed, some on medication some not.
There is a clear difference between those children and children "being naughty".

TrainspottingWelsh · 20/07/2020 21:42

I don't know about the teaching profession, but Ime generally it's only a minority that don't believe it exists, the problem, as evidenced by this thread, is so many people are completely ignorant about what adhd is, and therefore don't believe it when the person/ child fails to fit their narrow view of what adhd should look like. And of course when we fail to conform with the nt tactics that could reform us into nt behaviour it just consolidates the bullshit view we are all just badly behaved and should try harder.

The only over diagnosis is of the armchair variety, not actual dx. I don't include those struggling for help prior to a dx in that. Ime it's usually those parents or adults that aren't interested in pursuing support/dx, and are basing their self dx on one or two symptoms that in their ignorance they have decided sum up adhd. Eg naughty children and losing keys, they're always a favourite stereotype.

Children with adhd aren't naughty anymore often than nt children are. Sure, there are times when children with adhd don't behave the same way as nt dc, but we don't go round suggesting nt dc are naughty because they struggle to do things that come easily to those with adhd. And even when a child with adhd has the added problem of inadequate parenting, it isn't representative.

We don't read the bollocks spouted by the likes of @mistyrivers87 and assume nt people are all ignorant and too dull witted to think in anything but one very slooow narrow line, with frequent halts because their 1D brains can't handle more than one thought at a time. But apparently it's ok to do the same when it's adhd.

@Ilovecranberries
May I suggest cutting all sugar/ gluten/ dairy/ going vegan, a wanky reward chart, having firm boundaries and sitting him down to explain why he shouldn't be impulsive or lacking focus, always on the go etc. Of course those suggestions are all patronising and a complete waste of time, but apparently it's helpful to regularly trot out this shit to anyone involved with adhd Grin

GreytExpectations · 20/07/2020 21:35

@HoldMyLobster

And have you recently had a child diagnosed with ADHD in America GreytExpectations?
I've had experience with close friends and family members whose children have been diagnosed in America. If you don't agree with me then fine but I'm just giving you my experience.
Witchcraftandhokum · 20/07/2020 21:35

I absolutely think it's real. However I also think it's also massively mis-diagnosed. I once heard a paediatrician speak at a conference who reckoned that about 1/3 of ADHD diagnoses were actually feotal alcohol syndrome.

BertieBotts · 20/07/2020 21:34

I seem to remember there being a lot of bad publicity about ADHD in the late 90s/early 00s - perhaps it genuinely was overdiagnosed in the US at that time? I only knew one person with an ADHD diagnosis in real life and he was very severely hyperactive when not on his medication and would do things like fly into a rage and hit or threaten other pupils and teachers. (He has ASD as well).

I assumed (in most cases) it was a bit overdiagnosed/a lazy shortcut as well and that medication was absolutely a bad thing and ought to be a last resort - the thing is, I assumed that ritalin/other ADHD medications were tranquilisers. That's how they were presented in the media at that time, and I think a lot of people had (maybe still have?) this misconception.

I don't know how old I was but I remember reading a throwaway comment somewhere on a message board where someone pointed out that actually, ritalin (and many other ADHD treatments) are NOT tranquilisers, they are stimulants. You give a neurotypical child ritalin and they would be running up the walls bouncing off the ceiling, hyped up, crazy. You give an ADHD child ritalin and they calm down. Because their brains are actually getting the stimulation that they need and they aren't going utterly crazy with boredom any more.

I hadn't known that before - and it suddenly changed my perception.

Then as an adult getting diagnosed myself (another mind blown moment) and learning more and more about how medication helps and works I now get so angry at the misinformation out there. It's one of the most useful and least harmful medications out there and yet to many people it's deathly dangerous and/or terrible parenting if you don't waste years of your child's life trying every other thing first?

Yes of course if there is a cause like sleep apnoea let's do an extremely simple check to rule that out. But otherwise?? I don't understand where the hostility comes from and it makes me really upset.