Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 23:59

[quote Elladisenchanted]@minimum97 I cried reading your post. I have adhd and was diagnosed as an adult. I could have written your description word for word. Thank you - you've made feel a little less alone. The word finding thing - yes! My dh has learned to understand what I mean when I say the wrong or muddled word but I have always felt so stupid about this. Matching names and faces is also really really hard.
I have no concept of what day it is or time at all and have constant running alarms to remind me of what time I have to pick up from school and appointments.
The beginning of lockdown was a relief for me because I didn't have to do the school run and remember which child finished when (I have a child in a special needs school and others in a regular school and there were multiple finishing times on different days). I regularly got it wrong.
So much energy all the time on trying to find ways that work for me to do things that other people seem to do so effortlessly. And then when I inevitably mess up I feel like a failure.
I'm not on meds right now because I am breastfeeding and it's a constant struggle.
Being on them calms my brain down enough for me to take in what's going in around me and slow down and concentrate a little bit better.[/quote]
Thank you for your post, that's lovely. You are not alone!!

I'm sorry to hear you are finding things so hard.

I am not on meds yet either. I also have physical health issues and my thyroid is currently overactive so no meds for me!

Yes my husband took a long time to get used to it!! He used to get quite cross when I peppered a whole sentence with "thingys". He now just seeks clarification or helps me find the word. (Interestingly my ASC/ADHD son usually just knows what I mean even when there have actually been few normal words in the sentence!). About 60 times I say I think I say "what word am I thinking of" and he has to read my mind. I didn't realise I actually got words wrong until a few months ago. I saw a post on another ADHD forum asking whether people got words wrong and I said that I didn't! A few days later I called a fence a door (if I recall rightly) and noticed o did in. Asked my husband if I Ed done that before and he said yes all the time, you are always getting words wrong!

My worst symptoms are poor concentration, distraction and procrastination. If meds help with those my life will be transformed! Fingers crossed I can start trying them soon.

TrainspottingWelsh · 20/07/2020 23:43

@2155User I've been exposed to very few paraplegics, hence why I wouldn't jump in and share my uninformed experience on the subject. I wouldn't be coming out with shite such as 'I'm sure some are genuine but most are just lazy' 'it's just bad parenting' 'it didn't exist in my day' 'it's over diagnosed' 'I once saw a programme on tv with a fake disability claim so paraplegics are mainly making excuses' And if I did come out with any of that shite I certainly wouldn't expect anyone to excuse it as understandable because I've not been exposed enough. But when it's adhd it's perfectly acceptable to share your fuckwittery.

Elladisenchanted · 20/07/2020 23:43

@minimum97 I cried reading your post. I have adhd and was diagnosed as an adult. I could have written your description word for word. Thank you - you've made feel a little less alone. The word finding thing - yes! My dh has learned to understand what I mean when I say the wrong or muddled word but I have always felt so stupid about this. Matching names and faces is also really really hard.
I have no concept of what day it is or time at all and have constant running alarms to remind me of what time I have to pick up from school and appointments.
The beginning of lockdown was a relief for me because I didn't have to do the school run and remember which child finished when (I have a child in a special needs school and others in a regular school and there were multiple finishing times on different days). I regularly got it wrong.
So much energy all the time on trying to find ways that work for me to do things that other people seem to do so effortlessly. And then when I inevitably mess up I feel like a failure.
I'm not on meds right now because I am breastfeeding and it's a constant struggle.
Being on them calms my brain down enough for me to take in what's going in around me and slow down and concentrate a little bit better.

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:40

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble

Should I have just answered "Yes" to the OP then because the views do occur?

Probably better if I explained my answer, which I did

MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 23:39

@Vodkacranberryplease

Unless you have it, or your child has it or you treat it you do NOT have an informed opinion. So please spare us your 'wisdom'. It's not showing your cognitive abilities in a good light. Do your research and be informed instead of foisting your prejudices on people who have had more than enough of that kind of thing.

If you arent bright enough to grasp the complexities that's fine - just don't think that you are right.

My thoughts exactly. Please stop with the prejudice and ignorance. Our lives are hard enough as it is!
ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 20/07/2020 23:38

OP never asks why such views occur, just whether they do and how prevalent they are.

So you're reinforcing a fairly damaging narrative/view to answer a question that doesn't exist.

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:37

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble

I totally agree.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 20/07/2020 23:34

As a result, some people don't believe something like HG is real because they've been exposed to the 'wrong side'

And those people are stupid and/or ignorant and there's no excuse for it given the access to information,studies and even free online courses (particularly at the moment).

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:33

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble

No, you don't go around saying that, but if someone asks for reasons why others may not think ADHD is real, then surely you provide a reason, even if that reason only accounts for 0.1% of all thinking? It's still a reason, albeit a small one

WombOfOnesOwn · 20/07/2020 23:31

I work in an industry and area where ADHD diagnoses are highly-sought by adults looking for stimulant prescriptions to be able to more effectively (at least, they think so) do their high-pressure, long-hours jobs.

I think a higher-than-normal number of people in this area also disbelieve any ADHD diagnosis, because they've seen so many people use extremely vague symptoms and engage in what could only be described as drug-seeking behavior for maximum medication doses.

In a lot of workplaces, these drugs are the new cocaine, at least in the US.

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:30

@Vodkacranberryplease

As an example...

I had severe HG when I was pregnant, nearly died. I also spoke to women who said they had HG with no medical diagnosis/no medical opinion etc and they quite clearly didn't have HG. As a result, some people don't believe something like HG is real because they've been exposed to the 'wrong side'

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 20/07/2020 23:30

*trend not thread

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 20/07/2020 23:30

There are people that lie about cancer. If you check out the MIL /toxic parent thread you might think that's quite a prevalent thread.

Do you go around telling people with cancer/suspected cancer that "well I know cancer is real, but some people don't believe in it because a minority of people lie?"

If it's such a small number, why does it even matter? Why mention it all? Even more importantly, why use it as an excuse for ignorance and prejudice?

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:28

@Vodkacranberryplease

You've just copied and pasted the same thing twice, not sure if you've bothered to read my response.

Either way, it is relevant.

OP asked why some people might think it isn't real, and one reason may be because they've experienced a parent before who has labelled their child with no support, medical, or evidence, possibly wrongly.

You're clearly very emotionally invested in the subject, which as great as it means you can really educate others and inform them, but it also means you're struggling to see another perfectly acceptable view

MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 23:27

@BertieBotts

Something I've come to realise is that I cannot expect anybody else to have an in depth understanding of ADHD. I don't, and I appreciate that, for example, I myself don't have a very in depth understanding of dyslexia, or T1 diabetes, or hypermobility, or food allergies, or chronic fatigue, to take a random selection of issues that people I know and love live with. I have an in depth understanding of ADHD because it's my issue and my son's issue and so it's important to me to understand it. I can't possibly understand every single issue somebody might have to the same extent. And so I respect that other people won't know everything about my issue either.

So I no longer feel annoyed about people not understanding subtypes, and nor would I expect other people to automatically understand if I say "Oh I have ADHD, please support me". Instead I ask for specific things "Please can you send me this information in an e-mail?" "Excuse me while I write this in my calendar before I forget" "Could I give you money towards the picnic rather than bringing something? Let me give it to you now".

But I have never said things like "Allergies aren't that serious, I'm sure he'll be fine if he has a little bit of milk powder". I listen to the mum of the allergy kid because I know she has much more of an understanding than me!

I do not say "Well I tried so hard to help that dyslexic person but he just isn't trying hard enough." or "Why don't you just use spell check?" I don't know why spellcheck doesn't work for dyslexic people but I know that would be incredibly annoying.

I don't decide randomly that it's best if the person with diabetes eats this food rather than that, because I have no idea what is the best way to control blood sugar levels with diabetes, even if I did read an article about it in a health food magazine.

So if you do not have an in depth understanding of ADHD, that's absolutely fine, but please don't go around pretending that you do know about it (by saying that it's overdiagnosed, or overmedicated, or that XYZ therapy is better than medication, or that medicating children is "sad"). It's okay not to know about something. If you like, you could ask "How can I support you with that?" But mainly, just understand that it's OK not to know a lot about a subject and just be alright with that.

This.
Vodkacranberryplease · 20/07/2020 23:25

@2155User I never said it didn't exist, but you have to realise there are people who throw the label about with no medical support or evidence and this isn't good.

This is all you can think about. Why are you so fixated on this? It's just not relevant. People pretend and lie all the time. In fact people with adhd tend to do a lot less pretending and lying than others...

MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 23:24

@TrainspottingWelsh

I don't know about the teaching profession, but Ime generally it's only a minority that don't believe it exists, the problem, as evidenced by this thread, is so many people are completely ignorant about what adhd is, and therefore don't believe it when the person/ child fails to fit their narrow view of what adhd should look like. And of course when we fail to conform with the nt tactics that could reform us into nt behaviour it just consolidates the bullshit view we are all just badly behaved and should try harder.

The only over diagnosis is of the armchair variety, not actual dx. I don't include those struggling for help prior to a dx in that. Ime it's usually those parents or adults that aren't interested in pursuing support/dx, and are basing their self dx on one or two symptoms that in their ignorance they have decided sum up adhd. Eg naughty children and losing keys, they're always a favourite stereotype.

Children with adhd aren't naughty anymore often than nt children are. Sure, there are times when children with adhd don't behave the same way as nt dc, but we don't go round suggesting nt dc are naughty because they struggle to do things that come easily to those with adhd. And even when a child with adhd has the added problem of inadequate parenting, it isn't representative.

We don't read the bollocks spouted by the likes of @mistyrivers87 and assume nt people are all ignorant and too dull witted to think in anything but one very slooow narrow line, with frequent halts because their 1D brains can't handle more than one thought at a time. But apparently it's ok to do the same when it's adhd.

@Ilovecranberries
May I suggest cutting all sugar/ gluten/ dairy/ going vegan, a wanky reward chart, having firm boundaries and sitting him down to explain why he shouldn't be impulsive or lacking focus, always on the go etc. Of course those suggestions are all patronising and a complete waste of time, but apparently it's helpful to regularly trot out this shit to anyone involved with adhd Grin

Your last paragraph!....😂😂😂😂😂
MiniMum97 · 20/07/2020 23:21

@MrsZola

"So my Ds's psychiatrist at CAMHS was wrong then?"

Yes, or you have misunderstood. ADHD and autism are separate conditions, diagnosed separately. There is however overlap in some symptoms.

Vodkacranberryplease · 20/07/2020 23:18

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble I definitely wasn't referring to you - you are not part of the amorphous 'fuckwit blob' on here.

I'm just shocked how many people actually think they have an informed opinion despite knowing nothing and use the constant invalidations of 'shit parents have kids with adhd and so it's a parenting issue'.

It would be kind of funny if so many of them weren't working with children too

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:17

@bridgetreilly

Yes, unfortunately I think you're right

SinkGirl · 20/07/2020 23:17

It often runs in families, especially when the cause is childhood trauma/ parenting as all siblings within the family will probably be subjected to this too.

Christ. Is this really what people think? So my twins are both autistic, so you think that means that it’s been caused by our parenting rather than because it’s genetic?

Unbelievable.

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:17

@KittyFantastico

I'm talking about those who throw the diagnosis around with absolutely no prior information/knowledge etc.

Of course you can mention ADHD before getting a formal diagnosis, but there are some, again a massively small minority, who will use the label before even thinking of other options

bridgetreilly · 20/07/2020 23:16

I think it went through a period of being over-diagnosed and also used as a label without diagnosis which was not helpful to anyone (see also: OCD). But it's clearly a real thing for those who actually have it.

2155User · 20/07/2020 23:15

@Vodkacranberryplease

I never said it wasn't real.

OP asked whether some people think ADHD isn't real, and my response is that yes, some people do not think it's real as a result of a small minority self labelling their own child before any diagnoses or without any help.

I don't know why you're getting so angry at me when I've said that ADHD is absolutely fundamentally real but I also understand why some people might not think it is when they haven't been exposed to it or been informed enough

KittyFantastico · 20/07/2020 23:15

To add to the whole "people throw the label around without a diagnosis" conversation...

It can take years to get a diagnosis of a neurodevelopmental condition, years which are crucial for your child, and what are you supposed to do while you're waiting for the diagnosis? Carry on as normal? Ignore their difficulties? Or parent in line with the presumed diagnosis and employ strategies known to benefit children with that particular condition?

When you hear a parent say their child has "suspected " 99% of the time they are not just chancers using that condition as an excuse for some seriously slack boundaries, what they mean by "suspected" is that they are somewhere on the referral/assessment pathway. "Suspected" doesn't mean "made up", it means "awaiting confirmation".

Swipe left for the next trending thread