Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo · 21/07/2020 08:39

@wagtailred she lives in supported accommodation with carers. I don't think they'd be too happy to have a cow poking it's head out the garage 😂😂😂🐄

She's used to cows and thinks because the ones she knows are friendly they all are and they're all friendly at all times for that matter. But obviously that isn't the case.

wagtailred · 21/07/2020 08:34

Im now fixated on the cow too! Would you be able to bring one home until the novelty wore off? Like ask a farmer to bring it round for a play date. Or would you get stuck with a cow. My sister brought a horse home once but i guess they move around normally.

WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo · 21/07/2020 08:25

@Vodkacranberryplease I think the fact she's 21 and only just progressed to going to the shop down the road should be enough to suggest she has a lot of needs. 🙄

It is her ADHD which causes the impulsivity. She cannot see past that fixation. Take away the ADHD and that lack of impulsive control and everything else is there to enable her to go to the shop unsupported.

As it is ADHD medication also made my dd very aggressive, it helped with the impulsivity but replaced it with a lot of negative behaviours. As it stands she is unmedicated.

Behaviour wise she's fine, in fact she's an ardent rule follower. She just cannot get past this one fixation.

Midsommar · 21/07/2020 08:18

What is with all the deleted posts on this thread? I've never seen that happen before Confused

I feel like I have learnt a lot about ADHD from reading through this and my heart goes out to all your children and you parents who suffer from it. In my opinion even though I don't know anybody personally who has it, of course it is real. The people claiming it isn't are the ones who roll their eyes at invisible illnesses, or mental health issues.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 08:13

@WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo I'm not sure that's the adhd to be fair. I think most people know the difference between seeing a cow (cute) and deciding to take one (not a good idea) even with adhd.

WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo · 21/07/2020 07:59

My dd has ADHD and Autism....... She's 21 now and recently progressed to going to a shop alone.

This was a big step for her and involved a lot of planning.

All went well until she decided she wanted a pet cow from the farmers fix, she can't see past having one and hops over the fence at every opportunity she gets.

She can't control the impulsivity, it's almost a fixation. Obviously this is a huge, safety risk so we're back at square one now. Sanctions, rewards etc do not work. She has to walk past this lane to get to the shop md each time all she sees is the cows. And how she wants a pet cow. She doesn't see danger. Or even how she's going to get the damn cow from the field to her house.

She's hilarious. And we love her dearly but there's no denying the fact her ADHD has had an awful, impact on her life.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 07:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

VioletsArePurple · 21/07/2020 07:47

More information on Autism and ADHD here.

www.autism.org.uk/about/what-is/related-conditions/adhd.aspx

wagtailred · 21/07/2020 07:47

Whilst i appreciate those of you who know about adhd probably want to scream reaading this thread - i feel much better informed so thanks to those who explained what its like. My DS has autism, the other condition often blamed on parenting - but it is more widely recognised.

VioletsArePurple · 21/07/2020 07:46

There is a lot of information on ADHD on the web. Search for ADDIS. or look up Professor Peter Hill on You Tube. There is some good research information from the US also. Just google it.

ADHD is not part of the autistic spectrum. It has some cross over in symptoms (e.g. difficulties with the executive functions). However it is very common for people with Autism to also have ADHD, but they are separate neurodeveopmental disorders - both of which require an assessment and diagnosis by a proper doctor -- not a teacher/SENCO (unless he or she also happens to be a doctor with an expertise in neurodevelopment disorders).

Whiskyinajar · 21/07/2020 07:43

@GreytExpectations

I can't believe some of the ignorance on this thread. How can Mumsnet be so supportive and understanding of ASD but yet many posters think ADHD is either not really or a product a nurture?
Sadly because there’s still a great deal of ignorance out there.
CalledYouLastNightFromWaitrose · 21/07/2020 07:27

I've been on Mumsnet nearly 12 years. There's always been a lot of eye-rolling about ASD too. You'll get periodic posts about how everyone on MN seems to have a kid with ASD. That's on the general boards, without the SN Boards I doubt eldest would have got the support in school he needed.
I do agree with ADHD it's straight to the jugular. (My 7 year old has ASD & ADHD). My 7 year old has disruptive and challenging behaviour. He's also the only one of my 4 who has such difficulties in school. My eldest is autistic but he is passive in presentation.

There's some incredibly knowledgeable, kind and helpful posters on MN wrt SEND.

GreytExpectations · 21/07/2020 07:17

I can't believe some of the ignorance on this thread. How can Mumsnet be so supportive and understanding of ASD but yet many posters think ADHD is either not really or a product a nurture?

Galvantula · 21/07/2020 04:57

@AhBallix " An almost constant churning in my stomach that I have forgotten something vitally important. "

This is the worst :( like constant low level stress.

I knew nothing about ADHD until less than a year ago. My oldest child's teacher asked if it was ok to get them assessed for some help, they can't focus or organise themselves like their peers. They can't complete work that they should be capable of (verbally show good knowledge, good at spelling etc).

ADHD wasn't mentioned, but when I searched for help with these problems, it came up. The list of problems matched almost exactly the things I've struggled with all my life.

As PP have said it is very hard to get a diagnosis in the UK. I spent 6 months waiting after I was referred before I (impulsively) went to a private psychiatrist instead.

I think by the time the process is complete, I'll have spent close to £1000 (luckily I have some savings) on the assessment, starting medication etc. I've been told I have primarily inattentive ADHD.

I haven't told many people yet, just a few close friends that I trust. The urge to overshare is real though!

Neither me nor my child were badly behaved at school. I talked too much and didn't complete my work in the expected time, was labelled a daydreamer from the very start of school. He isn't always so talkative, but has done a few crazy things so is maybe a bit more impulsive than me.
We both blurt out and interrupt a lot though, which drives DH nuts.

One thing common in people with ADHD is being told they're underachievers. Capable of much more if they just try harder. Even when you feel like you are trying really hard. :(

If you're lucky, when you tell someone they're interested to find out more. I'm reluctant to talk about it too much though, because of the stereotype of naughty kids being put on terrible drugs Hmm

AhBallix · 21/07/2020 04:27

My12yo son had just begun the ADHD assessment process before lockdown and this has now been delayed. He is a very compliant and biddable child, so fell through the cracks for many years as he did not display the more headline grabbing symptom of being very obviously disruptive. This idea of the 'bad' child is so unhelpful and has caused so many misconceptions about ADHD.

DS constantly fidgets in class, tips his chair back, sings and hums without realising and is genuinely apologetic when it's pointed out to him - then he continues where he left off, without registering that he's doing it again. He HAS to doodle or fidget in order to focus. He says himself that his brain shuts down if he has to concentrate on not moving. He tips all his pencils and pens on the desk to look for the one he needs, then sets his sheet of paper on top of them and tries to write like that. It genuinely doesn't occur to him that all those pencils and pens would be better off staying in his pencil case. Anyway, the list goes on. A general lack of focus peppered with amazing bouts of laser sharp attention to detail. Untidiness. Forgetfulness. I honestly worry that he will wander into busy traffic getting to and from high school.

And all of this we thought he had inherited from DP (who is undiagnosed himself, but has diagnosed family members) - they are like clones. But the interesting thing is that I did a FutureLearn course about ADHD and a woman who was diagnosed as an adult mentioned in her video that anxiety was one of her symptoms. I suffer very badly from anxiety and started doing some reading very specifically about women and girls with ADHD, never really thinking it would throw up anything relevant to me. And yet there I was. In almost every descriptor. Hundreds of things began to make sense. My supposed laziness. The way I often have to read the same page 2 or 3 times because my internal monologue is chattering away. The hundreds, nay thousands, of attempts to organise my life, just to try and do the stuff other people seem to do as second nature. Being 'away with the fairies' at school. Leaving everything to the last minute/procrastinating. An almost constant churning in my stomach that I have forgotten something vitally important.

Of course, diagnosing myself off the internet and from books is not the same as going through the proper process. And I could be wrong. But it would explain a lot, including why I'm about as much use as a chocolate fire guard when it comes to helping DS manage his condition. In saying that, he isn't yet diagnosed, but I believe firmly that he will be when appointments are up and running again.

Antipodeancousin · 21/07/2020 03:57

Is it true that ADHD diagnoses are over represented amongst boys from low socioeconomic backgrounds? I remember hearing or reading that years ago but not sure whether it is accepted.

Disillusioned11 · 21/07/2020 03:36

But it is regularly misdiagnosed? And clearly over diagnosed in a distinct groups. There are multiple studies that prove this beyond a doubt?
Im very surprised at all the knowledgeable people in here who don’t know about it - the finding are pretty well known I thought?
For those who don’t a quick google will give you a list of the studies but in summary, a study was done on children diagnosed (not parents who think their children have adhd) but on children who had actual diagnosis and it found the following ......in some states in America, there is anything between a 30% to 50% higher incidence of diagnosis of adhd of children who had August birthdays in states that had 1st September as the first day of the school year. And in states that don’t have this date, this August ‘spike’ disappears but reappears in which ever month was before the school year start date. This study has been repeated all over the world and, in predominantly white ethnicity, high socioeconomic countries, the exact same pattern is found. Anything between a 30 -50% higher incidence in the children diagnosed with adhd born in the month before the country’s school year starts. So something is clearly going wrong with diagnosis and that’s a lot of children on medication that they shouldn’t be on which is a concern, is it not?

Neverendin6 · 21/07/2020 02:55

Yes but for people saying it can be misdiagnosed... is this in reference to parents doing the diagnosis or an actual proper full diagnosis?

I have a child an autistic child with adhd and I’ve had a few people mention their child is Adhd or autistic too and when I ask it turns out there’s not diagnosis the parent has just decided themselves they must have it as they have lots of meltdowns.

Could this be why we hear it more and more?

anameIcallmyself · 21/07/2020 02:41

@MiniMum97

There is also massive issue with under diagnosis. Especially with inattentive ADHD. I have recently been diagnosed with this in my 40s. I was just thought of as lazy and disorganised at school.

I also haven't really told anyone yet about my diagnosis. I think ADHD is massively misunderstood and also carries quite a stigma.

I think many of my friends would say "oh but I do that..." and I haven't told work yet but am going to have to as my symptoms are worsening and I have been making mistakes.

I usually tell people who say that to me. Diagnosed with ADHD at 48."Do these same things that you do affect your quality of life? Do you require daily medication? Therapies? Support? Is your house covered with charts, calendars etc?" Are you able to regulate your emotion? Are you disorganised? I could go on but you get the point.
Durgasarrow · 21/07/2020 01:57

@thenshewasgone No, you are quite mistaken.

77wasmyyear · 21/07/2020 01:41

MrsZola

Where is adhd discussed as being part of autism? Genuine question I'd like to do th research

DaveMinion · 21/07/2020 01:36

@MiniMum97omg I’m always getting words wrong too! I’ve found my people lol.

Oh and it’s 1:30am and a perfect example of an ADHD sleep issue here. Can’t switch off lol.

As an aside it’s also named wrong. It’s not a deficit of attention, it’s too much due to hyper focusing. Or it should be executive function disorder. But not attention deficit.

DaveMinion · 21/07/2020 01:23

@Vodkacranberryplease

And for an adult it's easier to buy a house than get a diagnosis you go private. Around £500. Then £100 for meds per month. About £150-300 per month for the psych. Who then eventually might only need to see you every 6 months once he (it's always a he) has worked out you are not going to shove what is literally the worst drug ever your precious meds up your nose.

Jesus. If I wanted to buy drugs a) I wouldn't be buying fucking speed and b) I wouldn't be spending that kind of money on it.

No one does this for fun. No one wants to have this and what makes it so, so much worse is the utter fuckwittery of 99.9% of people when attempting any kind of discussion about it.

This 100%. I went private too as I am at uni and needed the help. It’s bloody expensive.
Elladisenchanted · 21/07/2020 01:03

Op in response to your question - I'm pretty open about having adhd. There have been a few people who were
disbelieving and one elderly relative who said 'but how come it wasn't around in my day'. I think mainly though that was due to their perception of adhd as the stereotypically wild boy who can't sit still. They have been open to discussion though.
I think understanding of ADHD is hampered by the stereotyping of the condition in a similar way to how Rain Man affected how people saw and understood asd. If you don't fit the Rain Man image then you couldn't possibly have asd etc and so people will say you don't fit the stereotype I have in my head so it can't be adhd and must be x y or z It's a lack of knowledge and a proliferation of misinformation about adhd that leads to these sorts of views.

Elladisenchanted · 21/07/2020 00:40

@minimum97 we laugh about the word thing because I can make some very odd sentences by accident!The conversation topic jumping when we were first married used to surprise him a lot Grin
I rearrange the furniture randomly and get mad ideas and just go for it, sometimes things work brilliantly and sometimes they don't. So many great ideas that never get fulfilled and plans that I just don't follow through. Like I think this week I'm going to do a meal plan, or manage to remember to do a laundry load a day or whatever is the latest idea I have to try to manage life.
Sometimes having adhd feels like an asset, but mostly it's just so debilitating.

How have you found lockdown? I've found some parts so much easier (no appointments no schedule no deadlines) that at the beginning my anxiety levels dropped massively for the first time in years. And then the repetitiveness of every day with no change became incredibly hard.

Pre-baby I found concerta seemed to help with the hyperactivity but not focus and lisdexamphetamine improved my focus but not hyperactivity. Or maybe it was the other way round. I ended up taking the one that helped more with my focus. My hyperactivity I can handle but the lack of focus and concentration makes me so anxious. It's that constant feeling of I'm missing something or I've forgotten something... and usually I have!

Hopefully you can try meds soon Smile

Can I ask what adhd forum you are on?

Swipe left for the next trending thread