Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
puzzledpiece · 21/07/2020 10:54

Well the teacher friend is in complete opposition to the psychologists who write about it and diagnose it. I think some parents do use it as an excuse for poor parenting, but I know from personal experience how difficult it is to have a genuine adhd kid

Estan · 21/07/2020 10:51

I am really surprised at the content of this thread. I have two ADHD children. One also has High Functioning Autism (formerly known as Aspergers). I talk quite openly about both of them and to both of them about their challenges, how I can help them, and how they can help themselves, etc. This includes medication. Incidentally, not all ADHD medications are stimulants. But the stimulants (methylphenidate, lisdexamphetamine) are known to be more powerful. We tried one of the others and it made my son feel nauseous every day and didn't really work. So we went back to the stimulant.

I am shocked by the number of teachers who have come on here with their views of particular cases. In my experience, teachers and Sencos are not experts in ASD, ADHD, or a variety of other conditions/disorders. I feel that these diagnoses need to be made by a medical doctor (e.g. psychiatrist not psychologist).

I've never had anyone tell me they thought ADHD didn't exist. I have had people tell me that they think my child doesn't have it. And I have had people express their disapproval of my putting my six year on Ritalin/Concerta. These comments are always made by people who don't know anything about ADHD or the medication. Pure judgemental nastiness born of audacious ignorance.

GarlicMonkey · 21/07/2020 10:45

Someone on this very forum, told the mother of an ASD child, that they were sure that mum could control his behaviour if they tried. So yes, I believe a lot of people think it's made up. I have an HFA (high functioning autism, I don't like using Aspergers) teenage son & people have no idea of the amount of work involved or how different our 'normal' is. It's like a suped of version of the refusal to acknowledge how hard parenting is in general. Giving that acknowledgement would mean having to value the work that we do.... & 'hard work' it certainly is.

AhBallix · 21/07/2020 10:35

@Vodkacranberryplease

Very well said. Where there's a child with ADHD, there's more often than not a parent (or even two) with undiagnosed ADHD who doesn't have the tools to cope. They are overwhelmed because that is their own default position too.

All the discipline in the world will not 'cure' ADHD. Nor will love and care. Structure can help to manage it. But try getting a parent with their own ADHD to embrace the concept of structure!

aquashiv · 21/07/2020 10:34

Very interesting responses and yes I agree many do not understand this is as a real difference in the chemical makeup of the brain which can create in the wrong environment the wrong behaviour.
Although there are subtypes some children are inattentive often labelled lazy. Some are hyperactive often labelled naughty as they struggle to focus and sit still. Some are all of the above. Often Adhd is co morbid with ASC but not always fits the diagnostic criteria until medicated then AS can become more pronounced.
It is a life long difference but many many adults are highly successful if they find their passion and can channel their energy.
The treatment plan and medication is variable and it is impossible to say if stimulants work for everyone.
Finally diagnosis is far from easy and lack of boundaries or poor parenting might be a symptom but not the cause.

AhBallix · 21/07/2020 10:19

It's crap forgetting stuff all the time and letting people down or just looking stupid, slow or lazy.

Oh my goodness, this resonates with me to the point I want to cry! I always just feel as though I'm not 'doing life' as well as I should.

Reading all these posts makes me feel I should pursue a diagnosis for myself. But I think I'll wait until the process is over for DS.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 10:15

@janeisbustingout I think you need to start applying some basic logic to this. If a child has ADHD and is rushing around, hard work etc then the parents are stressed and less able to provide the loving good parenting they should.

Also one of those parents will also have ADHD and be highly triggered by what they are seeing in their child. They will have had their own troubled childhood of rejection from everyone and judgement and conflict with parents and won't want that repeating.

So the attachment will be less strong and that is caused by untreated ADHD. Not vice versa. The child has a lifetime of being told they are wrong and judged and almost everyone who has ADHD has rejection sensitivity dysphoria which greatly affects emotional regulation.

The parents you are seeing also have untreated adhd which is presenting to you as an inability to control their emotions and not following your rules, setting up structure etc. So you blame the lack of rules and structure. And you judge them and set impossible tasks for them.

The non ADHD parent doesn't really care about rules and structure - if they did they would be less likely to choose an ADHD partner.

People thinking like you do is part of the problem. You have taken the 'information' you have and reached the wrong conclusions. This is what I meant before when I said people having just enough information to be dangerous.

You aren't familiar enough with this to even know about RSD. Or the genetics. To know if there's an ADHD kid there's an ADHD parent. So you think you know.. but you don't.

AhBallix · 21/07/2020 10:04

@Galvantula

I totally relate to the underachieving aspect. I was often faced by frustrated teachers telling me they knew I had more to give, but I was too lazy. 'That should've been an A' will be inscribed on my gravestone! I thought I was lazy too, but in all honesty I was often bored and when I was bored, I tuned out. I can see DS doing this all the time.

Girls are often overlooked when it comes to ADHD, even though it's an equal opportunities condition and I think this adds to the erroneous image of the boisterous boy whose parents aren't good enough at controlling him. DP's much younger brother was diagnosed back in the early 1990s when ADHD became much more publicised as a condition and was suddenly being picked up more. I have to admit to rolling my eyes because he was a right pain in the arse, always getting into trouble, defiant, risk taking, bunking off school. And his parents were pretty awful, as DP will confirm. So I was sceptical about the diagnosis and thought he just needed a firmer hand, but that was ignorance and I have since learned a lot about ADHD. I'm pretty sure their dad has it - DP and at least one of his sisters show multiple signs too. Younger children in the family have been formally diagnosed. It's a big family!

Gordonbennit · 21/07/2020 10:02

I have found this thread fascinating & depressing.

As a parent of a child with ADHD just about to start with meds could anyone Recommend any good online forums for me to go on? I often find with MN lots of ADHD threads are ruined by the non-believers putting in their 2pennys worth of “just change your parenting style/give them a good smack and they will be cured” etc it’s hard to find people with actual experience & knowledge of either parenting or living with it.

Thanks for sharing your experiences Flowers

juneisbustingout · 21/07/2020 10:01

Pass
Of course
However many children were actually RAD and wrongly diagnosed with ADHD. I've never met a biological parent who would accept a RAD diagnosis instead pushing for ADHD

Galvantula · 21/07/2020 09:59

@juneisbustingout eh?

I was born in a perfectly normal, not neglectful home. As was my DS.

It can be co-morbid with ASD as posters above have mentioned but not always.

Neglect or chaotic upbringing can cause similar symptoms/behaviour I believe. ADHD however is a neurological condition, an actual difference in the brain.

It can't be diagnosed by a brain scan, but differences in activity in certain areas of the brains of people with ADHD has been clearly shown.

Believe me I don't really want to have to take medication to function better as a parent, spouse, friend and employee, but I will if I have to.

It's crap forgetting stuff all the time and letting people down or just looking stupid, slow or lazy.

PasstheBucket89 · 21/07/2020 09:57

ASD and ADHD is not caused by childhood trauma or ipads 🙄, it is a neurological difference! not MH condition.

juneisbustingout · 21/07/2020 09:51

I feel very mixed about this
My experiences are over 40 years working within Education and Social care
IMO it's a real condition but actually quite rare.
I've only see it on its own without associated ASD a handful of times in 40 years.
Around 20 years ago numerous children were being diagnosed incorrectly when they were actually attachment disordered ( RAD) which most definitely exists but is always as a result of early parenting or childhood traumas, hence parents never wanting that diagnosis and fighting to get the ADHD diagnosis instead.
Now 20 years on its much more uncommon for CAMHS to make an ADHD diagnosis and much more common to have an ASD diagnosis.
There will always be inadequate parents but there will also always be these conditions. I think it solely depends on what era a child is born into as to what his diagnosis will be

PasstheBucket89 · 21/07/2020 09:46

I think its worth understanding in the UK ADHD is under diagnosed and in America its over diagnosed, so a lot of the dismissive responses are just not accurate at all.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 09:43

I meant play to your weakness!

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 09:42

@ChockyBicky you are right. Here's what does work to some extent.
1 tell no one. And I mean no one. They use it against you
2 get meds. Go private if you have to (easy to switch to the nhs once diagnosed and settled) to get meds. They make you about 60% more NT than you were.
3 try and set up some backups. I've got my front door keys covered after a million years finally by buying a locked key box and putting my keys back before I finish getting inside the house.
4 find a well paid job you are great at and pay people to be organised for you. Adhd has some benefits and there are things you can do others can't. Jobs where being organised etc are not the focus. Keep away from 'lady jobs' which are all about being a good mummy and therefore okay to your weaknesses.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 09:35

@WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo I am very well familiar with the challenges of ADHD. This isn't one. Unfortunately it doesn't always come on it's own - but she's probably an animal lover and that might be a way for her to get help. Equine therapy as suggested? There's something very safe and solid about cows - they are actually a great animal.

There's a woman in America (the cow whisperer) who 'knows' what they are thinking. They use her to make the cows lives less stressful (I won't say where.)

There are two types of stimulant - I would try the other, or try the other meds. Though amoxetine can make people stressed/aggressive. Or it could be dosage (slightly too much). Or try taking with prozac. And take her off hormonal contraception and onto the (non hormonal) coil. That made a huge difference for me.

I can tell you that the private docs often will try and do things the nhs (all about saving money) won't

ChockyBicky · 21/07/2020 09:21

I think the hardest part is that the mocking and ridicule can inevitably cause social anxiety but then what do you do about that?
No amount of learning to accept who you are will change the fact other people will not accept how you are and you are forced to be someone you can't be and live in a way which is not natural but it is to everyone else so that's the only acceptable way to be and it makes life impossible for those that don't function like them, it's exhausting.

Mrsfrumble · 21/07/2020 09:11

Good point @SinkGirl. I think it's down to a misconception that ADHD medication is actually a sedative? Whereas, like you say, giving a neurotypical, naughty child stimulants would end in carnage!

KittyFantastico · 21/07/2020 08:58

I can't believe some of the ignorance on this thread. How can Mumsnet be so supportive and understanding of ASD but yet many posters think ADHD is either not really or a product a nurture?

They're not really that supportive of ASD either and think it is also not real, a result of nurture, overdiagnosed, used as an excuse for poor parenting, etc - essentially all of the views seen on this thread. You only have to look one of the periodical "unpopular opinions" threads that pop up from time to time, by the end of page two there will have been at least one post stating that ASD is the result of shit parenting.

What is with all the deleted posts on this thread? I've never seen that happen before

That's where some of the more hateful posts have been deleted

SinkGirl · 21/07/2020 08:58

I love how people keep referring to medication as an “easy fix”.

If the problem were poor parenting and bad behaviour, how would prescribing a stimulant fix anything?

Mrsfrumble · 21/07/2020 08:57

Interestingly on the ASD / ADHD overlap, the clinical psychologist who ran the cygnet course we attended felt that ADHD was probably part of the autism spectrum and that the diagnoses would be merged at some point.

ChockyBicky · 21/07/2020 08:53

It's the same adults that don't believe it's real who get frustrated at work when their coworker zones out in meetings and then doesn't know what was discussed, is always late and disorganised or didn't deal with that email you told her to while she was doing something else and forgot to chase up that phone call or didn't get the number of that woman you need to call back so you can't be arsed to work with her because you 'can't tolerate stupid' so instead you degrade them and make out their an idiot and you're just flabbergasted because what is wrong with them?

Well they are trying to tell you but nobody wants to listen because it's easier to write them off as thick or not suitable for the job.

Mrsfrumble · 21/07/2020 08:52

I confess I haven’t read the whole thread as it’s just too depressing. Just the first few and last few pages.

We didn’t pursue DS’s diagnoses; he was being assessed for ASD (which he also has) and the additional diagnosis of ADHD took us by surprise, although in retrospect it makes lots of sense. Like AhBalix’s son he’s not disruptive and is actually a golden child at his school (his teacher rated him “outstanding” for behaviour and attitude in his latest school report, and called him a “wonderful role model”) but he does fidget, rock, hum and sing constantly and takes “movement breaks” at school so he can let some of the energy out without annoying his classmates. We / school / CAMHs caseworker all feel medication is unnecessary at this point as it isn’t affecting his academic performance (other than atrocious handwriting and a slapdash approach to SPaG) or behaviour.

Adults generally comment on how articulate and polite he is, and I’m fairly open about his diagnosis because he confounds the lazy and ignorant stereotypes too many people hold about the condition.

wagtailred · 21/07/2020 08:44

Yes the accommodation probably wouldnt be impressed! Grin My son does equine therapy and we have a bit of pressure for a sheep to come home with us. At least they are smaller.