Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
FlemCandango · 21/07/2020 19:47

My 14 yo daughter has a diagnosis of ADHD (inattentive type), she takes ritalin she is also diagnosed with ASD. She is absolutely not a badly behaved student, she has never been in trouble at school she is a good student. She definitely struggles and she gets upset and tearful at school because she wants to do well but finds it very difficult to stay focused. No one has ever suggested that we need to parent better, the issues DD has are recognised and she gets support (most of the time), she has an amazing imagination she is well liked by her teachers. She struggles with friendships and finds online socialising much easier but that is more about being autistic.

We didn't seek out ADHD as a diagnosis, but when the paediatrician said she had it we read up and saw the parallels. We were against medication but when we saw DD managing school so much better with it we changed our view.

drspouse · 21/07/2020 19:42

"Spectrum" is just a word for something that varies. You could have a spectrum of different leaves or anything really.

IHateCoronavirus · 21/07/2020 19:40

It is a very real condition. Unfortunately there are a small number of children’s parents seeking a diagnosis that isn’t there.

We had a mother getting very aggressive with us the HV and the paediatrician for implying her child’s issues were down to parenting. She couldn’t understand why her child was equally agressive.

doingmeheadin · 21/07/2020 19:37

I used to think it was a made up thing and excuse for poor parenting. Brought back down to earth with a bump when my son got his diagnosis age 7 (although issues seen well before then) and now other people get to judge me instead. It's horrendous tbh and I find managing him so hard, even with medication. It's relentless.

impeccabledave · 21/07/2020 19:37

@drspouse thanks for clearing that up - relatively new diagnosis so still learning!

I think it confuses things when professionals often refer to the “spectrum” when discussing ADHD as symptoms often “overlap” with ASD - I think perhaps they may be doing this for ease of conversation and understanding

drspouse · 21/07/2020 19:24

(My DS who has ADHD also looks at me for a reaction. Sometimes he's aggressive because he's impulsive when he doesn't get what he wants. Sometimes he hides or runs away or is aggressive because the world is too noisy. And sometimes he just wants to work out the screen time password so he can play on the iPad for longer, or to wind his sister up because it's fun).

drspouse · 21/07/2020 19:22

@impeccabledave I think you've misunderstood.
They are referred to as under an umbrella of conditions but ASD is one condition and ADHD is another. You can have either or both. ASD has specific diagnostic criteria which are different to those of ADHD.
The "spectrum" means that in ASD, all those who have it have e.g. social communication problems. For some, that means they are nonverbal. For others, they struggle with metaphor, or body language etc.
Not everyone who has ADHD has such difficulties (though it's common). And there are other criteria needed for an ASD diagnosis.

Realityofsen · 21/07/2020 19:06

ADHD is not on the autistic spectrum.

Realityofsen · 21/07/2020 19:05

I have a NT child and a non-NT child. I can see clearly the differences in their behaviour. My non-NT child doesn't push the boundsries, she religiously sticks to he boundsries she can't cope with not sticking to the boundaries. All her behaviours are entirely impulse led when heightened and she is completely controlled by her emotions.

My NT son looks to me for a reaction. He laughs in my face going haha when doing something he knows he shouldn't. When you see them side by side the difference is as clear as day.

impeccabledave · 21/07/2020 19:04

DS has a diagnosis of ADHD with Autistic Traits and every professional I have spoken with regarding DS has referred to ADHD as being on the Autistic Spectrum... paediatricians, occupational therapists, senco, etc

Maldives2006 · 21/07/2020 18:46

@MrsZola

Adhd is not definitely not part of the Autistic Spectrum it maybe a co morbidity but it is definitely separate!!!

TrainspottingWelsh · 21/07/2020 18:30

I don't disagree @BertieBotts, but I do think it depends on how you're defining 'naughty'. Pushing boundaries, being silly at inappropriate times, actively deciding to do something they know isn't allowed etc come under my personal definition of naughty, and virtually all dc do them at some point, nt or otherwise. And yet I'd also argue they are a completely normal, necessary part of development for the vast majority. Imo it's a very natural and healthy part of growing up.

I think the problem is when people refuse to see the difference between eg the child that is actively testing the boundaries, the child that genuinely hasn't been raised to understand boundaries, and the child with adhd that might understand boundaries but at that particular moment can't control their actions anymore than they can control their reaction to gravity. And even in the case of normal, general naughtiness, doing further harm by making the child feel they are bad, rather than a good child that's simply done something naughty as all dc do at some point. Even more harmful when the child wasn't choosing to behave that way in the first place.

Genua · 21/07/2020 18:01

Well put BertieBotts. I never find “naughty” a useful description. It’s not specific enough apart from anything else

PasstheBucket89 · 21/07/2020 17:02

Couldn't have said that better myself Bertie Botts, Ross Greenes wisdom is always a breath of fresh air.

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 16:44

The thing is though is any child actually "just naughty" - what does that even mean? It seems to rest on a set of assumptions which are outdated, IMO.

Okay - there are some children who have no idea how to behave because they have not been given consistent boundaries. They are "naughty" if you like, as in there is no diagnosis, but only because they don't know better. Usually when children in this situation are put in a situation where there are clear rules, explanations and boundaries in place they do much better.

Are there children who know how to behave and choose not to? Or are we a bit more open, these days, to the idea that "kids do well if they can" and that every child wants to do well so if they aren't, it's because they can't, not usually because they won't.

Is it constructive to keep punishing behaviour we don't like, or look for the reasons behind it, so that the child can be supported to behave in a way which is more co-operative or less disruptive for everyone? If you punish a child who is already doing their best, they will become demotivated and/or resentful. Whereas if you support a child who is perfectly able to do what you ask, the worst that happens is... they get a bit of extra attention.

artisanparsnips · 21/07/2020 16:41

@PutYourBackIntoit I will get that book, the title is the exact description of DD, who got an inattentive ADD diagnosis earlier this year.

And just to reiterate, she wasn't naughty at all, in fact she was very well behaved. But, gradually, her teachers kept saying that she wasn't producing the work they knew she could.

It runs down the female line here: I suspect my mother had it, and I was so classically ADHD that I nearly drove her to a breakdown.

TrainspottingWelsh · 21/07/2020 16:40

@WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo

I'll apologise in advance if I'm teaching you to suck eggs, especially as your dd has different challenges to me. But I can very much empathise with the impulsive behaviour with cows. I grew up a pony mad child, rurally with horses at home, I'm sure you don't need any explanations about the main outlet for my impulsive behaviour!

Explanations about danger and practicality never meant anything to me in the moment, still don't if I'm completely honest. Eg I could agree logically that I wasn't experienced enough to jump large hedges and might hurt myself, but as soon as I was on the pony and impulse took over reason went through the door. However understanding beforehand that my inexperience could also harm the pony changed my perspective. Instead of hedges being something I considered fun but impractical, a view quickly lost in the moment, large hedges became something that could hurt the pony, and therefore not something I wanted to do. (Naturally my own impulsive solution was to jump them on a large experienced horse where my inexperience didn't risk their injury Grin)

I'm wondering if you can maybe explain it from the cows perspective, you can't prevent the impulse from a general logic pov, but if you can change the underlying desire for a pet cow because the cow wouldn't like it, it's possible the impulse won't occur.

Again, I apologise if that's either something you've tried or wouldn't be appropriate for her, I just thought it was worth mentioning because it's the main reason I reached double figures without breaking my neck.

@juneisbustingout wow, I'm impressed. You've met everyone with adhd and are therefore able to offer your amazing insights. Then again, it's fairly clear you're one of the many that ignore the fact we're all individuals that happen to share a dx, rather than a joint personality.

I've not fully caught up yet, but it's a shame we can't find some labels for certain nt people to differentiate between them all. If some had an official dx of dickhead I'd find it a lot easier to make reasonable adjustments for their lack of critical thinking.

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 16:36

Caca LOVE your bookshelf!

Smart But Scattered has been an amazing read. I now need to un-overwhelm myself on it and work out where to start Hmm

My only disappointment is that it claims to include advice about what to do when you have the same difficulties as your child and then it actually doesn't at all - there is a fairly pointless chapter with a couple of anecdotes and no actual advice except to "do the exercises with your child".

EricLove123 · 21/07/2020 16:16

@drspouse

Oh, and no Drs are 'handling' controlled drugs. Pharmacists do that. But Drs dealing with ADHD prescribe controlled drugs, daily far more than GPs and other Psychiatrists and indeed, in the list of criminal offences this particular Psychiatrist went to prison for, one was prescribing himself controlled drugs under a fake name that are stimulants prescribed for ADHD.

Which would have potentially come to the attention of the authorities earlier if he wasn't routinely prescribing controlled drugs. As every other Dr working with ADHD does...

EricLove123 · 21/07/2020 16:06

What are you reading that I didn't say Drspouse?

I didn't say he was the ONLY one I reported. I said that often it came down to a 'difference of opinion' and a private Dr not being given all the information. That's what came out of reporting concerns.

And that I did report one who had been suspended anyway so that wasn't investigated. It was pretty low down on the list of concerns considering he was sentenced to over 3 years in prison.

Sorry if it wasn't clear.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 21/07/2020 16:06

Of course kids are still "naughty " . They kick off sometimes,they're cheeky, they have a tantrum, they're rude etc.

Children with SEN can be naughty too, the issue is you need to separate the SEN issues and needs from typical behaviour.

So Jimmy quietly crawling under the table when anxious or overwhelmed isn't naughty.

Alexa fiddling with her pens or rocking her chair isn't naughty.

James refusing to look at you no matter how many times you ask isn't rude.

Sarah repeating your words back at you or taking a long time to answer isn't cheeky or ignoring you.

Matthew wandering around the class while still putting his hand up or going into a long diatribe when it's his go isn't naughty.

Lisa rocking ,covering her ears or removing herself from the room isn't her having a tantrum.

Sam needing input and direction after every sentence isn't needy or stupid.

drspouse · 21/07/2020 15:57

@EricLove123 well diagnosing "for pay" would certainly be a matter for the GMC but the example you gave was of someone who was in breach of their regulations and also a criminal; that was the only one you reported.

KittyFantastico · 21/07/2020 15:56

Schools or parents may use the term "behavioural problems" rather than naughty but that in itself isn't a diagnosis or a condition and shouldn't be confused for one

My point here ^ I don't mean ADHD presents as 'naughtiness' for all children, I meant it as 'naughty' children aren't automatically given a diagnosis of a condition simply so we don't have to label them as naughty.

KittyFantastico · 21/07/2020 15:54

I can't help noticing that there are no naughty children any more as they are all suffering from some condition or other.

This is incorrect. Schools or parents may use the term "behavioural problems" rather than naughty but that in itself isn't a diagnosis or a condition and shouldn't be confused for one.

Is it possible that in some cases we're avoiding dealing with behavioural issues that could be handled by parents/teachers (with a bit of support) by just giving it a fancy title and packing them off for someone else to sort out?

No.

ADHD, ASD, PDA, ODD, etc aren't fancy titles. They're neurodevelopmental conditions with marked differences in brain development when compared to neurotypical brains. Partly why the assessment process takes so long, aside from waiting lists and cuts to services, is because the professionals doing the assessment need to see a consistent level of difficulty or difference across more than one setting.

FanFckingTastic · 21/07/2020 15:50

ADHD may be real with real sufferers - I'm not qualified to have an opinion, but I can't help noticing that there are no naughty children any more as they are all suffering from some condition or other.

Some kids with ADHD are naughty, some are not, the two are not mutually exclusive. Naughtiness is not actually a criteria for an ADHD diagnosis so this is a bit of a red herring. Many kids with ADHD find it hard to concentrate and can also present with hyperactivity and find it hard to sit still. In a classroom environment, these two things feature heavily so it can sometimes appear that a kid with ADHD is not behaving correctly. In actual fact they are acutely aware of what they should be doing but can't manage to do it, however hard they try. You have to remember that asking someone with ADHD to 'stop wriggling' or to 'just concentrate' is like telling a person with a visual impairment to just see, or a person with depression to just pull themselves together.

Swipe left for the next trending thread