Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 22:51

Oh yes! First time I've seen a deleted message quoted! Very exciting :)

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 22:50

Something which was absolutely fascinating to me - I went to a conference a couple of years ago about how to support kids with LDs. There was a talk about Neurofeedback (which ended up being a sales pitch, but anyway) and I had a go on their Neurofeedback machine thingy where you have to try and relax and when you make the right kind of brain waves which show you are relaxing, a little monk would start levitating and hovering high in the air.

I didn't say that I had ADHD, but as they were demonstrating it on me I could hear the guy discussing what was coming up on the laptop screen just behind me. He commented that I was showing low levels of Beta brainwaves which is usually associated with attention and learning disorders (but then he quickly added, could also just mean that a person is tired or relaxed!) It was pretty amazing to me that it was the first thing that came up when I hadn't actually mentioned it or said that was my reason for curiosity around it.

I found that when I listened to people's conversations and focused on the room and thought about what was happening around me or on the computer screen and wondered how it worked, the monk would plop decidedly down to the ground. When I let my mind wander the way it generally always does, it would fly right up - other people had a go after me and found it quite tricky to make the monk fly, and asked me how I managed to do it so easily. I chatted with them afterwards and they said that for ADHD they generally do the opposite - use software which encourages/trains the use of more Beta brainwaves, whereas the monk was supposed to help train people who are anxious or type A personalities to relax.

I also did concentration and memory testing as part of my medication trial (I'm in Germany and it's different here) and it was interesting to see how medication had an incredibly clear effect on that.

And the parent quiz in Smart But Scattered where you score your own executive functions (in order to see your strengths and weaknesses), up to a maximum score of 7x3 for each skill. I kept getting 8, 7, 6 with the odd 10 or 4. I thought oh, I haven't done too badly, until I read that most adults get scores of around 13-14 in most areas Blush and that a score lower than 13 constituted a weakness. I got one single score of 13, and that's the one area I would say I've heavily worked on coping skills. The rest were lower and most of them were single figures, a couple were even the minimum possible score of 3. To be honest it kind of made me feel better - to see I really do have that severe level of impairment yet here I am living some kind of a life and not completely wallowing in a pit of despair. I have wallowed in a pit of despair at times. But I am doing OK.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 22:45

@Scatterbrainbox OT I'm impressed with how you Remembered/have the content of a message that was deleted hours ago! I didn't even see it, it's that old!

And I'm sure you are right but I have to say all of the brain information kind of makes it sound like we are talking about massively defective brains that don't have half of the bits they need to function. So in a way I'd say to be careful of that because then it's a bit like the old 'women's brains are smaller so they must be thicker' argument trotted out many years ago.

There are measurable physical differences as you know, bits that don't light up when they should, prefrontal cortex loves not quite talking to each other. However. No one wants to feel examined. Especially someone with ADHD! Though with your username you may already know that first hand...

peonypower · 21/07/2020 22:45

I am baffled that people are discussing, in a subjective manner, whether or not a clinically diagnosable condition exists or not.

Depression used to be thought of like that. "Stop moping about, feeling sorry for yourself" etc. So I am not that surprised people doubt it.

I'm a big believer in ADHD being real, and actually being a psychiatric condition where medication can often really help. Children going from having NO friends and nobody inviting them on play dates to being able to participate in normal social life. It can be quite dramatic. Who would deny them that diagnosis and help? It would break my heart if it were my child ...and then was told it must be my bad parenting that caused it!

Scatterbrainbox · 21/07/2020 22:35

I am baffled that people are discussing, in a subjective manner, whether or not a clinically diagnosable condition exists or not.

SinkGirl · 21/07/2020 22:32

I have an issue with self labelling and online diagnosing of SEND needs and mental health conditions.

Well perhaps take that up with a system that puts so many barriers in the way of proper assessment.

We were “lucky” that our twins ASD is so blindingly obvious and has caused such extensive delays that they were diagnosed at 2. I know plenty of other parents who’ve been told they won’t diagnose it before 5, or after 5. I know parents who are forced through absolutely ridiculous measures before their child is assessed. I know parents whose child can’t be diagnosed because they can’t rule out other issues and they are stuck in a diagnostic purgatory for years.

What are those children and their parents supposed to do in the intervening years?

Scatterbrainbox · 21/07/2020 22:32

As in, you either get a diagnosis at the end of the pathway which will lead to an EHCP and/or being placed on the school's SEND register, or not. The is no third outcome for self diagnosis.

Scatterbrainbox · 21/07/2020 22:30

@LolaSmiles

I think it does exist.

I also think that along with a selection of 'socially acceptable**' conditions, it's often misused and self diagnosed by people for whatever reasons.

** By that I mean you see people think nothing of making a big fuss about how DC has ADHD, they have anxiety, they're a little bit OCD for example, when really they've read online and self diagnosed in a way that you tend not to get people self diagnosing other SEN needs or mental health needs, for example you tend not to hear about someone saying they are a bit bipolar, or self diagnosing as having schizophrenia, or MLD etc.

I have an issue with self labelling and online diagnosing of SEND needs and mental health conditions.

You can't 'self-diagnose' for the purpose of school and SEN support though, there is a lengthy pathway ... Are you talking about SEN diagnosis in school (which the OP refers to) and support given around behaviour difficulties or is this 'self-diagnosing' something you have encountered in another context? It would not be possible to obtain any support, meds or otherwise, with a 'self-diagnosis'.
LolaSmiles · 21/07/2020 22:21

I think it does exist.

I also think that along with a selection of 'socially acceptable**' conditions, it's often misused and self diagnosed by people for whatever reasons.

** By that I mean you see people think nothing of making a big fuss about how DC has ADHD, they have anxiety, they're a little bit OCD for example, when really they've read online and self diagnosed in a way that you tend not to get people self diagnosing other SEN needs or mental health needs, for example you tend not to hear about someone saying they are a bit bipolar, or self diagnosing as having schizophrenia, or MLD etc.

I have an issue with self labelling and online diagnosing of SEND needs and mental health conditions.

Scatterbrainbox · 21/07/2020 22:11

@mistyrivers87

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.
I'm a SENCO with an MSc in Psychology and a particular interest in the interplay between neurodiversity (ADHD, ASC etc) and mental health.

Clinical evidence exists for the association between attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), or hyperkinetic disorder (HKD), and possible structural, functional and neurotransmitte alterations in various regions of the brain in children, adolescents and adults with ADHD.

Imaging studies suggest that ADHD is typically associated with some structural abnormalities in the brain.

The following structural abnormalities have been observed in children/adolescents and adults with ADHD versus healthy controls:

Lower grey matter density
White matter abnormalities
Reduced total brain volume and volume of some brain structures
Cortical differences
Delayed cortical maturation in children/adolescents
Reduced cortical thickness in adults.
In a prospective magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study, children and adolescents with ADHD (n=223) exhibited delays in cortical maturation versus typically developing controls (n=223).10 Delays were most prominent in prefrontal regions, which are important for control of cognitive processes, including attention and motor planning.

This is my evidence, from a range of peer reviews clinical sources that proves you are an ignorant twat. Please feel free to offer evidence to refute this and support your claim.

It also explains why meds can be a key tool in treatment, it is not a 'lazy' solution.

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 21:11

Yes. I wasn't "naughty" as a child either. I was extremely eager to please and it would massively upset me if I ever got into trouble for anything. I had one teacher who took a strong dislike to me because I was daydreamy, but mostly I was popular with teachers because I was bright.

Trainspotting I should have just quoted it to begin with :)

nestisflown · 21/07/2020 21:01

I wish I didn’t have it. It’s basically the knowledge that I always will have it and even though I know I can do the things I want to achieve, I simultaneously know I won’t get them done. Adhd feels like really cruel form of self sabotage to me.

I’ve never been remotely “naughty” though - that’s a massive misconception and ADHD presents differently in girls/women.

tabulahrasa · 21/07/2020 20:59

“It takes some quite seriously, shockingly bad parenting to make a neurotypical child behave persistently badly as a response”

If it wasn’t so hurtful to people it’d almost be funny that people think it’s about parenting...

Most of the parents I meet of children with ADHD and ASDs for that matter have much stricter boundaries, thought out rules and consequences and are parenting a damn sight harder than other parents.

You can’t just say you’re not allowed to do that and that’s that, lol.

And... NT children who have no rules or boundaries at all at home don’t often have issues at school, because they very quickly adapt to what’s expected of them there, their parents are fine with them doing what they want at home and no-one’s even looking to get a diagnosis.

If a child is being sent for assessment it’s because there’s an issue, someone is trying their best and failing so is looking for help - that isn’t terrible parents...

TrainspottingWelsh · 21/07/2020 20:53

@BertieBotts in that context I completely agree. But tbh as soon as I start reading the posts that think adhd is naughty boy syndrome from those keen to share their ignorance I tend to switch off, so I read your reply fully but not the drivel that you were responding to!

The self esteem issue isn't something I see changing. We're measured against nt standards, so the things we're better at aren't considered worthy for the most part, or at least they are just accepted as something we find easy and therefore not worthy of praise. Or worst still, with things like hyper focus, or the ability to calmly juggle a million and one things in a crisis, it's used as evidence that we can conform when we want and therefore just need to make an effort the rest of the time.

I'm lucky, with hindsight I was unwittingly receiving equine therapy from the day I was born, and knew the advantages adhd gave me before I even knew I had disadvantages or even adhd. My life is entirely suited to my strengths and weaknesses, and having been dx as a child I've always had the coping strategies, rather than having to learn them after a lifetime of feeling a failure. I like my adhd and wouldn't want to get rid of it. But one of the reasons I don't tell many people is because they then use it as justification to shit on others that are struggling with adhd.

Estan · 21/07/2020 20:50

In my experience "bad behaviour" is what presents when a child's mental health has been neglected at school (not at home). There are several comments on this thread accusing parents of not proving the right atmosphere at home. But if you read up in the SEND communities (e.g. special needs jungle) it is the schools and the LAs who are failing these kids.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 21/07/2020 20:34

It takes some quite seriously, shockingly bad parenting to make a neurotypical child behave persistently badly as a response

I've only seen this happen once and it was very extreme, as well as absolutely heartbreaking. Pretty average child when in nursery, some slight issues as he moved through the years, some cheekyness, some swearing but a really lovely and sweet child. Then one year it started escalating,massively and quickly. Big issues at some, SS involvement, police and child old enough to understand where it was all going and why. The child was eventually removed, but at the height of it all they couldn't even be in the classroom anymore. Too angry, too heartbroken, too aggressive, running off etc.

It was fucking brutal and heartbreaking for us to witness,can't even imagine how it was for that 10 yo to live through it.

SisyphusAndTheRockOfUntidiness · 21/07/2020 20:34

My mother doesn't believe in it. DD is being assessed for autism. I am also very likely to be autistic. My mother believes such things are caused by demonic possession. And can be cured by prayer. Seriously. She feels similarly about disability & homosexuality.

I'm evidently a big disappointment to her, being as I'm disabled & refuse to go her her church of bigots.

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 20:28

I should add it's tied in with a constant sense of shame. No kid wants this dx. Reading some of the comments here I could fucking slap some of these people for the ignorant crap they are spouting without a thought for how it affects people.

And when you confront them with logic they refuse to acknowledge it, get involved in petty squabbles and vanish when they realise what a fuckwit they have made of themselves.

This is not a condition you want to have, that you want your kid to have or that's easy to get help for.

To the utter moron that implied people are trotting off to private psychs to get a diagnosis because they want one - no that's not it. They are going private because they are treated like utter shit in the nhs and just can not stand the humiliation and longer.

Why put yourself through that just to get shit treatment if you have money? Then you can see a consultant from the Maudsley without having to battle your way through the 'educators' and get drugs that work instead of whatever the nhs thinks it wants to pay for.

doingmeheadin · 21/07/2020 20:25

Will have a look, thanks x

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 20:20

In relation to this I mean! Bloody Apple auto correct!

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 20:20

@doingmeheadin check out rejection sensitivity dysphoria. Essentially people with ADHD find the constant struggle with criticism and judgement unbearable. Everything they do wrong they are acutely aware of and are waiting for the inevitable comment about it. For kids trying so desperately hard to be normal it can be catastrophic.

So it's not so much struggling with emotions, but having a lot more of them. Because RSD hits like a freight train out of nowhere. And then dies down leaving a kid who over reacted.

Therapy is zero use because it's essentially a hijacking of the nervous system. Not something you hear much about here because the uk is behind the times. I think it was Dr Russel Barkley that first talked about it in rejection to this.

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 20:18

Of course, all children do things which are naughty at times.

But I was responding to LastTrainEast's post a couple of pages back where she said:

"I can't help noticing that there are no naughty children any more as they are all suffering from some condition or other."

And so I am not talking about occasional naughty/bad behaviour but about the idea that there are children who are "just naughty", I believe this is outdated, it's also a really damaging view of those kids, who were generally in the past written off for life - and it's good that we now understand that children who persistently misbehave are likely struggling - whether that's because of some kind of special needs, whether it's because they aren't getting clear guidance or whether they are experiencing something traumatic such as bullying or abuse at home.

And yes it can sometimes be fixed with clearer guidance or more stable parenting, but basically everyone on this thread with experience of CAMHS has actually said this is generally the first thing they want you to try - but IME if you have got to the point of contacting CAMHS you have probably read a parenting book or two, and tried out various techniques with not much of a result.

But also - neurotypical kids can cope with a massive amount of flexibility in parenting and will generally come out alright. It takes some quite seriously, shockingly bad parenting to make a neurotypical child behave persistently badly as a response (and in that case they are often so affected by that parenting that they actually DO have some kind of condition directly caused by it - attachment disorder for example, or complex PSTD) - most children do absolutely fine, even with inconsistent parents, not very nice parents, slightly absent/neglectful parents, and so on. They would probably do even better with good parenting. But children who struggle in the first place need a very specific and intense kind of parenting and it's likely most mainstream/ordinary kinds of approaches aren't going to do them very much good at all.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 21/07/2020 20:16

The lack of self esteem is a big issue as well . It's heartbreaking to hear a child saying they can't do x, they are stupid, why are they so bad etc. Add in a streak of perfectionism (even if not in all areas) and it makes for very unhappy, miserable children. It's not all sunshine and rainbows .

Or the need for reassurance/reminders/input ,especially when they have enough awareness to realise they're supposed to be independent or that other children don't need as much. Even worse when they get shut down.

the lack of emotional regulation so even small things are a catastrophe, This can often be exacerbated by classmates who deliberately push their buttons for a reaction, the distraction it causes or purely for shits and giggles. Then the parents moan their little angel got a consequence and a serious telling off because x did a,b,c that was so much worse or that x is so disruptive for the rest of the class.

doingmeheadin · 21/07/2020 20:03

Also, I should've said - most people think its the hyperactive kid running around, unable to sit still is what adhd is all about. It really isn't, its so much complex than this, the lack of emotional regulation so even small things are a catastrophe, the lack of executive function which means a few simple of instructions to try and get out of the house turn into a huge performance /battle. These things amongst others make their lives so hard, often finding it hard to make/keep friends which result in them being socially isolated and lower their self esteem even more. And to top it all off some truly awful provision throughout the NHS which doesn't act quickly or vigoursly enough to give any real level of support. So yes it is a real thing, please be kind to those who you know have it, whether diagnosed or not. Smile

HoldMyLobster · 21/07/2020 19:54

I find these threads about ADHD so educational and useful, especially ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble's and BertieBotts's posts up there about what is naughty? I'm learning all the time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread