Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do many people think that ADHD is not real?

739 replies

Ilovecranberries · 20/07/2020 16:28

Was having remote drinks with a friend and his wife yesterday. She's a secondary school teacher in a quite "rough" school (not in the UK). I was quite surprised when, discussing something quite abstract about how different people think and react differently, she had said quite breezily that the majority of teachers she knows "don't believe" in the existence of ADHD.
Incidentally, one of my children is currently being assessed for it, but it is not news that I had shared socially outside of my immediate family. I wasn't offended, but I wonder if it is actually a widespread view behind the closed doors?

OP posts:
CalledYouLastNightFromWaitrose · 22/07/2020 10:16

Thanks wagtail unfortunately there's lot against us. And that's not unique to us, there's plenty of kids barely being contained in a school too under-resourced and over-capacity to properly support them. (I'm not going to go there on what kinds of things have happened to DS3 but he's terrified of school now). At least that seems to be the case in my area. So many out of school or on very reduced long term timetables. 20 mins a day was the lowest I've heard!

wagtailred · 22/07/2020 10:03

@CalledYouLastNightFromWaitrose
Remember to focus on why the mainstream suggestions wont provide an adequete education. (If that is your belief)

CalledYouLastNightFromWaitrose · 22/07/2020 09:56

I'm in an appeal situation for my son's EHCP.
The LA has consulted a number of mainstream schools (we've named an independent special) and of the responses back they've all said they're too full and also have pupils with significant high and clashing needs already. 9 so far.

The LA have engaged a barrister and we're self-repping. It's a horrible situation we're probably going to lose. We will be faced with the choice of "elective" home ed or a school the LA has decided can accommodate him, but really do not actually want him.

It's an incredibly stressful situation

Realityofsen · 22/07/2020 09:39

My DD is in a three form entry school so I know school have the benefit of size to help but both she and another child in her year both have 1-1s and clashing needs. They will never ever be placed in the same class. Nor would DD be placed in class with the boy who does nothing but antagonize her. She is removed during things we know are triggering and removed when she starts escalating to calm down.

I absolutely will fight with only my child in mind. It's up to school to sort the bigger picture but these kids have such little voices that they absolutely need their parents to advocate for them and purely for them.

wagtailred · 22/07/2020 09:30

SoVeryLost - its not a parents job to think of a bigger picture. If a parent doesnt advocate for their own child then who will?
I absolutely appreciate the challenges - but just because it is difficult, challenging or impossible to mitigate it doesnt mean it isnt the cause of the issue. My child with ASD had a number of huge meltdowns when the child with ADHD just couldnt stop themselves poking him with a board pen during carpet time! That it was challenging for the teacher i dont dispute. But for the teacher to suggest the issue was i needed more boundaries at home as the cause of a meltdown was offensive.

OneInEight · 22/07/2020 09:29

This is ridiculous. A child’s mental heath has been neglected? I don’t know where you DC go to school but I know my DS’s school doesn’t neglect any child’s mental health.

Sadly, I could name a few including a special school who really should have known better. If you can not recognise when a child is stressed & force them into situations where they can not cope you will damage their mental health. If you punish for something a child has no control over then you will damage their mental health.

titbumwillypoo · 22/07/2020 09:27

Soverylost makes a good point about schools and trying to please everyone, sometimes it's just not possible. Inclusion as a concept is a worthy goal but until CAMHS, Social Workers and schools are properly funded to deal with SEND children then not much will change. I've never come across an teacher saying they don't believe ADHD exists, but I have come across plenty that say a lot of behaviour is choice. I'll give you a recent example. Year 4 boy comes in, soon as his settling time has finished turns to me and says "If you ask me to do any work today I'll punch you in the face." Now i'm used to this boy, my plan is to have a chat, find out what's wrong, check he's had a good night sleep and some breakfast and to present him with his tasks when I think he's ready. Problem is in a mainstream primary there are rules about threatening staff. Teacher hears the threat, explains to the child that it's not acceptable and that they will be in the thinking room at break time. This escalates the situation and ends with me having to positively handle him out of the room.
Now I know the threat is merely learnt behaviour because the child knows it will delay him having to start work but I can work with that. The teacher sees it as a concious choice that needs to have concequences because he has to apply behaviour policy consistently for the 30 children in there.
This boy hates calming music but it benefits a number of children in the class and often in mainstream it comes down to whose reasonable adjustment trumps anothers' diametrically opposed reasonable adjustment.

puzzledpiece · 22/07/2020 08:57

My son was diagnosed with ADHD. My ex husband when I look at him and his behaviour clearly has ADD. H was punished repeatedly as a child and stigmatised and told he was a bad child. It had horrendous consequences for him as an adult. With support I hope my son can live fairly normally, and understand his diagnosis.

LolaSmiles · 22/07/2020 08:21

You can't 'self-diagnose' for the purpose of school and SEN support though, there is a lengthy pathway ...
Are you talking about SEN diagnosis in school (which the OP refers to) and support given around behaviour difficulties or is this 'self-diagnosing' something you have encountered in another context?

I've said I agree ADHD exists. I know there is a proper pathway for diagnosis.

I perhaps didn't make it clear, but I think some of the reasons why some people in society doubt ADHD exists or think it's exaggerated is because some people are quick to self-diagnose online (along with a handful of other conditions), or they're very selective with when they claim it. As a result, it can lead to people doubting whether the condition exists.

For example, my school has always had great support for children with ADHD. We've also got additional staff employed in our SEN support base trying to push through assessments, though the system can be complicated and that's a different story. When fidget spinners were a trend, dozens of students suddenly presented with notes from home saying their DC should be allowed their fidget spinners, it helps them concentrate, their DC probably has ADHD etc.The parent never mentioned ADHD before, and when school held the rules and the trend died, the parents never mentioned ADHD again.

Every time people do things like that it's an insult to those children who do need additional support for ADHD to have people grabbing the label when it suits.

The ones who say "it didn't exist in my day" wind me up the most. It did exist, but people just suffered and got labelled as bad instead.
This winds me up.
I bet they never say 'nobody had X cancer in my day... Nobody had COPD in my day...' although one of my relatives thinks I can't be asthmatic because I'm healthy and describes my asthma attacks as 'getting a bit out of breath'.Angry

Floatyboat · 22/07/2020 07:32

How can a brain scan prove what symptoms you have and the impact that has on your functioning?

JollyRogerandDiane · 22/07/2020 07:29

I thought brain scans absolutely DO prove it (but aren't diagnostic) - see scan picture earlier on the thread.

Floatyboat · 22/07/2020 07:25

My son has ADHD. Part of the debate about whether ADHD exists in professional circles is because of differing ontological views. Its a philosophical divide. It's clearly not an thing' in the same way as a lamp, a dog or a pebble are a thing. There are no physical tests ( brain scans, blood tests) that can predict whether a child shows the cluster of symptoms associated with ADHD and no clear causal pathway. It's strongly associated with genetics, but sometimes also environmental factors ( eg trauma). At best, at present it's a description of a cluster of behaviours, mostly associated with executive skills that we know to be ameliorated by certain drugs and (possibly to a lesser extent, much to the chagrin of my esteemed colleagues) therapeutic and educational interventions. My son shows pretty classic ADHD behaviours and so it's useful for us to think in those terms in order to understand how to help him, but I do understand ( If not agree) with the philosophical perspective of professionals ( psychologists and psychiatrists, not just ignorant randomers) who argue it's not helpful to determine it as 'a thing'.

This is the correct answer.

SoVeryLost · 22/07/2020 07:18

@Estan

In my experience "bad behaviour" is what presents when a child's mental health has been neglected at school (not at home). There are several comments on this thread accusing parents of not proving the right atmosphere at home. But if you read up in the SEND communities (e.g. special needs jungle) it is the schools and the LAs who are failing these kids.
This is ridiculous. A child’s mental heath has been neglected? I don’t know where you DC go to school but I know my DS’s school doesn’t neglect any child’s mental health. Which has caused some interesting questions in Covid-19 times as touch and contact are very important for developing minds.

As an ex teacher children’s mental health needs are at the forefront of schools minds however, the same can’t be said for teachers. Just because the SEND community say something doesn’t make it so. Sadly what parents need to understand is in a classroom of 30 it isn’t possible to cater for all 30 children, I’d love it to be possible however I have had individual plans for two children in the same class that were opposing, think one likes a buff background on slides and the other likes pink but also questioning styles. I’ve had long conversations with parents who say their child cannot do homework due to their SEN and what can I do to make up for this. Every parent advocates for their child and isn’t thinking about the bigger picture. The fact there are between 15 and 29 other children in the class.

Tunnocks34 · 22/07/2020 06:50

I teach secondary and I completely agree ADHD feel. I’ve taught many children with it. I have developed several strategies to help children with it as teaching them often requires total differentiation, but importantly not ‘dumbing down’ as they are often bright.

I have however taught several children who are just little shits, whose parents have been slack for 10 years, and by year 8, suddenly they believe their child has ADHD. No, they’ve just lived their life with no consequences and now they are going through puberty you’re reaping the rewards of your parenting.

citychick · 22/07/2020 06:00

namechane30000

I agree with you.

Noone is DC's UK school would diagnose anything ( except for ASD which came up as negative). His primary school just kept saying " this isn't the school for your ds'.

We jumped thru all hoops to help him and his school. They were never satisfied.

We moved abroad and after various other tests he has ADHD. Takes a tablet every day. It's not been the game changer we had hoped but he's more easy going with one than without.

The sad thing is he current school don't think the school is the best one for him. Again.

We've jumped thru every hoops shown and more...

I feel he's been let down at every turn. ADHD is a horrible 'disorder' and I wouldn't wish it on anyone.

Still, at least we have a diagnosis to take back to a UK school when we need to.

For those of you unwilling to try medication, please do. It's not your child's fault they have ADHD. They need to live a life.

And yes, i've heard quite a few nasty comments from teachers working abroad who " didn't travel thousands of miles to work with those kids".
Sad

Shmurf · 22/07/2020 03:58

I have it and it's defo real. However, I only found out recently that when untreated it lowers the sufferers's life expectancy by 12 years on average (think it was 12, but defo double figures either way).

Vodkacranberryplease · 22/07/2020 00:32

Bertie if you are in the UK you absolutely are allowed to! Medication will change your driving completely! And no need to declare it.

Where's your devil-may-care adhd ness? I hope you're not one of these people faking it to get fucking speed which isn't a patch on coke and readily available the medication?

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 23:23

Well, I could never pass my driving test and I'm not entirely sure I'm allowed to take it when on medication here sooo.

It is a great name. Very fitting :)

Vodkacranberryplease · 21/07/2020 23:12

@Scatterbrainbox Haha only on this thread!

Lower grey matter density
White matter abnormalities
Reduced total brain volume and volume of some brain structures

This. When I see this I just go noooo..... and put my hands over my eyes. It sounds so damning. It's like one step away from saying 'we have to take their driving licenses away cause y'know, special needs'

Scatterbrainbox · 21/07/2020 23:00

Haha!! I have never realised that my username gave so much away Blush.

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 22:59

I am totally with you brainbox

Scatterbrainbox · 21/07/2020 22:58

It was still showing up as the actual post until I quoted it. Possibly
I hadn't refreshed my screen from earlier in the day. Not particularly relevant to the point I made though.

We can't pretend the physical neurological differences are not there. We have to use the information that we have to best treat and enable people (like me, my siblings and children!) who have neuro differences. It would be criminal to ignore scientific research that could lead to a big improvement in the quality of life in those affected, because there are individuals who don't understand the research. I am not offended by the fact that my brain functions differently to someone who is neurotypical (I have ADHD). There are things I find harder because of it and things I am stronger at. Being ignorant of why this is, or how to develop strategies in the areas I find difficult is not going to help, is it? Ignorance is not bliss!!

I am a firm believer that neurodiversity is a difference not a deficiency, But pretending that scientific evidence, that is in front of our noses, does not exist is absurd.

It is not at all like talking about the size of the brain, it is about pinpointing the functions which are different (sometimes stronger, sometimes weaker) in those with ADHD to develop compensatory strategies.

CalledYouLastNightFromWaitrose · 21/07/2020 22:54

it's off ADHD topic but diet if relevant.
It was really, really hard to get DS1's anxiety recognised by the mental health services because he has a diagnosis of ASD. He's now receiving treatment. But if we'd not managed to break the loop, he wouldn't have the anxiety diagnosis. But he would still have been really struggling with anxiety which was abundantly clear to everyone. It was his ASD teacher at school that urged me to consider medication. She mentioned other families had got caught in the loop and gone private to get help and it had been transformative for their child. But I guess so long as it's not a mere parent observing the struggles then it's ok.
And FWIW I trust DS1's ASD teacher and it was totally the right call.

BertieBotts · 21/07/2020 22:53

It was possibly the one where they reckoned it's not something you're born with :o

Er.... yes. That's exactly what it is!

DancingInDespair · 21/07/2020 22:53

I've never actually met anyone who claims it doesn't exist. I have met plenty who say it's over diagnosed, though. The ones who say "it didn't exist in my day" wind me up the most. It did exist, but people just suffered and got labelled as bad instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread