Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have not helped fallen woman?

85 replies

SquishyBones · 17/07/2020 12:38

Went for walk down river bank. Two women walking ahead of us with two big dogs (looked like a Rottweiler and a Doberman). Neither of the dogs on a lead. One of the women fell over. The other woman was in stitches. The woman on the floor was struggling to get back up, all her stuff had fallen out of her bag and she was frantically searching for stuff on the floor. The other woman was not helping her, just laughing. One of the dogs (Rottweiler) was just stood there waiting. The other dog (Doberman) dived on the woman sending her rolling down the hill. Other woman was now howling with tears. The woman looked like she needed help but ...

A) two big dogs
B) two dogs known for being protective of humans
C) the other woman was acting like it was all a bit of a laugh.

Against my better judgement I walked on past. Turned around later to find both women on their feet but the “fallen” woman limping.

Totally confused by the whole thing. Feel bad for not helping but the scene was surreal. Would you have helped?

OP posts:
squeekums · 17/07/2020 14:09

I'd have walked off
They 2 unknown and unleashed dogs who known for strong loyalty to their human, even if your trying to help, they don't know that. I don't want them to deem me a threat
I have an american bulldog and in same situation I'd expect people walk on for the same reason

Raimona · 17/07/2020 14:08

Actually, noone should be picking elderly people up off the floor apart from paramedics
We dialled 999 and the ambulance refused to come because the lady wasn’t critical. They asked is she breathing, is she bleeding, is she conscious? Then they said we’re too busy at present to attend if she’s not critical. There’s a pensioner lying on the pavement in the rain with what appears to be a broken bone?! No, sorry but you’ll have to deal with it yourselves. So we used the lady’s phone to call her son and a couple of bystanders picked her up and lifted her into the car so he could take her to hospital.

BendyLikeBeckham · 17/07/2020 14:07

Any dog that has protective traits (of any breed), you should have a command that tells them they can be 'stood down' when a person who is not a threat approaches. Otherwise you haven’t trained or socialised them properly if they pose a danger to the public.

I was taught by my dog trainer that the dog should always look to the owner for guidance on any possible perceived threat. It must trust you to know which is which and tell them. You never want to dog to think for itself, because its fight or flight response could mean it bites a stranger or runs off into the road. Both potentially fatal for the dog. My dog can be protective but I have a command that tells her this is a friendly situation, so she relaxes and is safe and sociable.

Airbender · 17/07/2020 14:06

Was she wearing a big embroidered scarlet letter A on her top?

AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter · 17/07/2020 14:01

@Raimona

I work in healthcare. Actually, noone should be picking elderly people up off the floor apart from paramedics. If they had broken something, yanking them up can make the injury 100 x worse and it can put the helpers backs at risk. The paramedics have a special inflatable device that raises someone from floor to standing safely and without injury to anyone involved.

Ragwort · 17/07/2020 14:01

That's quite shocking Raimona, so who did help the lady in this situation?

SquishyBones · 17/07/2020 13:59

@AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter

Doberman and Rottweiler protective of humans

Well considering they are bred and used as guard dogs I'd say yes.....

Rottweilers were bred as cattle dogs and later used to pull butchers carts (sorry I’m a dog history geek 😁)

Dobies were bred as personal protection dogs.

OP posts:
Raimona · 17/07/2020 13:59

A couple of weeks ago an elderly lady fell down outside my local supermarket, directly opposite the doctors surgery. Someone called the doctors for help and the staff refused to come out to help because of coronavirus. So if medical professionals in full PPE can’t come out to pick up a pensioner, nobody can blame you for not helping this random woman.

Kelsoooo · 17/07/2020 13:58

Having been this woman...

I tripped and fell on the entrance to a shopping centre. My Dh and kids laughed, my bag and its contents went everywhere.

Two young adults/teenagers (I'd say 19/20?) Rushed to help, she picked up my bag contents and the cash that had rolled away and he helped me up. I was mortified. But also appreciated their kindness. Not quite forgiven my so called family 😂

I'd probably not have helped the woman in your scenario. In my scenario id have helped before I realised what I was doing.

SquishyBones · 17/07/2020 13:58

@fascinated

So are you meaning the dog would help the owner?
I don’t understand what you mean ... if you’re talking about the dog picking the woman up and getting her back on her feet ... then no (although some dogs can be trained to do this).

I’m talking about a dog getting concerned about a stranger approaching their compromised human and maybe lashing out to protect them.

OP posts:
DanielRicciardosSmile · 17/07/2020 13:54

I was so hoping this would be posted by Sybil Birling, regretting that she didn't do something to help Eva/Daisy. Or maybe helping DS with his English Literature for the last however many weeks it's been has affected my brain.

AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter · 17/07/2020 13:54

Doberman and Rottweiler protective of humans

Well considering they are bred and used as guard dogs I'd say yes.....

Viviennemary · 17/07/2020 13:54

No. I am terrified of dogs especially large dangerous ones. You could have made things even worse by interfering. They don't sound seriously hurt. It's a risk you take when you have a dog.

Goslowlysideways · 17/07/2020 13:52

Definitely thought you were talking about a Victorian type of fallen woman!

Llamazoom · 17/07/2020 13:51

@fascinated all dogs bite. Labrador’s are one of the biggest biters but are known as a ‘family dog’
I’m on my 3rd Rott and none of them have ever bitten, their ‘Rottie rumble’ is usually all the deterrent that’s needed.

thistimelastweek · 17/07/2020 13:49

Reminds me of the old joke.
'Do you save fallen women? Well, save one for me.'

Llamazoom · 17/07/2020 13:49

My Rott is protective of the whole family, she paces the beach when the kids are in the sea, won’t take her eyes off them. She is wary of strangers and is my shadow, very loyal and protective breed.

I think you did the right thing op, if she had been alone I would have shouted over but not approached.
Doby’s were specifically bred to be guard dogs in the late 1800’s.

fascinated · 17/07/2020 13:49

I thought I’d heard of such dogs biting children?

fascinated · 17/07/2020 13:48

So are you meaning the dog would help the owner?

Playmysong · 17/07/2020 13:46

When I clicked on this thread I was ready to flame you. I thought that you were going to say that a woman had fallen and you had just left her on the ground, because of Covid!

However YADNBU to walk past in the situation you described. What horrible behaviour from the so called ‘friend’!

Beautiful3 · 17/07/2020 13:45

@fascinated

"Doberman and Rottweiler protective of humans?"

Yes of course they are!

NeutrinoWrangler · 17/07/2020 13:44

I wouldn't have helped, under those circumstances. There was someone with her, and they weren't asking for help.

(And I'm another who was expecting something about prostitution, based on the thread title!)

Beautiful3 · 17/07/2020 13:43

She had her friend to help her. If she were alone, I would have offered help.

Ragwort · 17/07/2020 13:43

Personally I am terrified by big dogs so I probably wouldn't have stopped. A couple of weeks ago I was out walking and a woman, with a small dog on a lead, tripped over. I immediately went to help her and held the dog lead and helped her up at the same time, but she was on her own. This woman's friend sounds horrible to just laugh Hmm.

1forAll74 · 17/07/2020 13:41

I would have left them to it, as they probably knew each other well, and had a kind of connected sense of humour, but the scenario would probably have made me laugh too, I would also not like to interfere where large dogs with their owners are concerned.