Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can I find out what happened in court? (Trigger re indecent images)

156 replies

Sistery · 13/07/2020 16:37

Changed my name as this is totally outing if any of the few people I’ve told read it. I’ve talked about this on here before though and been on here for years and years.

My brother is in court in Scotland today charged with crimes related to child sexual abuse images. Arrested last July, pleading guilty, don’t know what the specific charges are but get the hint it’s as bad as it can possibly be. The only family that know are supporting him and refuse to tell me anything about it.

Unless it hits the local press (not sure if it will due to Coronavirus) how can I find out what the outcome was today? I’m hundreds of miles away. When I asked a similar question about what turned out to be a pre hearing appearance a lot of people on here said I needed to mind my own business etc. I appreciate some people think that but I just need to know Sad. This is my little brother whom I loved and thought was a good person and friend. I can never see him again but I need to know the details for my own understanding and closure. And - frankly - so I can defend my decision against the family members intent on minimising this who will try to manipulate him back into my life in the future. They don’t even know I know the hearing is today.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HarrisMcCoo · 14/08/2021 08:38

How did you get on with finding out OP?Flowers

Not as serious, but a neighbour's son has been on the court rolls and I would like to know what his appearance in court has been for. Is there any way of finding out??

There was someone at his mum's door recently talking about 'curfew 7pm to 7am' and 'tagged' was mentioned. He looked like he may be from a security services company. Whoever tags individuals.

WellThisIsShit · 16/07/2020 22:46

I really feel for you OP, it’s such a horrible time you must be going through...

Nicknacky · 15/07/2020 17:33

thisiseveryonesbusiness Sorry, I missed your question. To be honest the short answer is I don’t know. I haven’t heard of any campaigning of government for tougher sentences but that’s not to say no one has tried.

Sistery · 15/07/2020 17:11

@5tressed I’m very sorry you’re in a similar situation but I’m also weirdly relieved to hear what you said about the Stop it Now forum. I went on hoping for support from people heartbroken by finding out their loved one is capable of this and instead just found so many posts defending and excusing the perpetrators. I do understand a lot of it must be denial and also if you choose to stay with someone who has done this, maybe to live your life you have to convince yourself it isn’t as bad as it really is. Sad But even the lingo - ‘the knock’ for when the police arrived, ‘IIOC’ for the crime (which felt like distancing again) just made me feel like I’d stepped into a world where this was somewhat normalised and it made me so uncomfortable and also very alone and alien in my views.

The court clerk thing is interesting as this information is sort of in the public domain so I’m not convinced it would be illegal. It’s not like accessing a police database or medical records. When I was a juror, I phoned up after sentencing (which was deferred for reports) to ask what the sentence was and got told. It was also reported in the paper - as my brother’s case may be. I just don’t know if it’s the same in Scotland. Though of course I don’t want the PP to contact his/her friend.

OP posts:
OutrageousFlavourLikeFreesias · 15/07/2020 16:54

Could you make a request to the police under Sarah's Law? Apologies, I don't know if this applies to Scotland, but I know in England you can enquire if someone who might have access to your children because of a relationships is on the sex offenders register. I'm so sorry you're going through this.

jessstan2 · 15/07/2020 16:38

I meant 'roles' not 'rules'.

jessstan2 · 15/07/2020 16:38

'Nicknacky', let's not get bogged down with this. I was merely thinking that people in confidential rules do sometimes break confidence and nobody knows it was them who did it but I agree it is a bad idea. Also that no one would do it for a person they don't know.

In the op's place I would write to my brother and ask him to tell me everything so I could make my own judgement.

It's a very sad situation for everyone.

thisiseveryonesbusiness · 15/07/2020 16:27

Are you able to answer my question @nicknacky or is this not the right thread for it or is it not helpful for you to give personal views?

Nicknacky · 15/07/2020 10:40

jessstan2 I really still don’t get your point.

No one is going to risk their job (and that’s what they are doing) for a stranger on the internet. If they do, then they deserve to be sacked.

I have the ability to find out what happened to the OP’s brother as I have access to the police systems where this information is held and I only need my identification number and name to access it. I’m never asked to justify my use however my reason for accessing that could and would be scrutinised if it was ever looked into.

But I still wouldn’t access it for anything outwith policing purposes.

jessstan2 · 15/07/2020 10:28

Nicknacky Tue 14-Jul-20 21:40:44
jessstan2 Sorry, have I picked you up right? That it wouldn’t matter if that information was passed if no one found out?
..
I wouldn't go as far as to say it wouldn't matter, Nicknacky; in my view a person employed in a strictly confidential role should keep confidence. However things are leaked and what I meant is they may not lose their job if a leak cannot be pinned on them.

Emeraldshamrock · 14/07/2020 21:54

Only if someone lets on who told them and that isn't likely to happen in this instance
You are joking you're offering your friends service to a stranger on the internet?
You are aware your friend could not only lose her job but face prosecution?

Nicknacky · 14/07/2020 21:40

jessstan2 Sorry, have I picked you up right? That it wouldn’t matter if that information was passed if no one found out?

jessstan2 · 14/07/2020 21:35

Ledehe Mon 13-Jul-20 20:28:45
berryhead2013

I'm in Scotland and know a court clerk what court is it

This is illegal and your friend should lose their job and be prosecuted if they disclose information to you like this
.......
Only if someone lets on who told them and that isn't likely to happen in this instance.

OP, if you don't live nearby you are not likely to see your brother when he is released, surely?

GreatestShowUnicorn · 14/07/2020 21:03

If you can find the evening paper for the area they will often have court reports, Evening Telegraph for example. Though not sure if that’s Different in Covid.

Coronabegone · 14/07/2020 20:53

@yetea how long ago was the case you're referring to? I'm interested in a case many years ago.

Haworthia · 14/07/2020 10:43

It's shocking that family members can be kept completely in the dark about crimes a near-relative has committed and even whether or not they've been imprisoned. That feels like a loophole that needs closing. Forcing people to rely on word of mouth or the lies of their supporters is how people end up suffering at their hands.

Totally agree. The person I knew who did this (a friend, not family) managed to keep it completely secret because he didn’t go to prison. Bloody should have though. I found out by accident some years later. I went NC immediately but was furious that I’d been lied to about something so despicable.

thisiseveryonesbusiness · 14/07/2020 09:27

@nicknacky why isn't there more noise being made about just how vast this is? Campaigning for tougher sentences for those that access images, proper thought given as to how to deal with them away from society, campaigning to remove the confidentiality element, more done about spreading information to educate families who are in denial?

Nicknacky · 14/07/2020 09:17

Oh, that’s terrible about the support forums for families. I suppose not everyone will be willing to admit their family members are guilty and are responsible for their own actions.

5tressed · 14/07/2020 08:30

Sistery Tue 14-Jul-20 00:48:35 - @Nicknacky Is the Lucy Faithful one the 'Stop it Now' charity? I went on their forum for family and friends but it made me very uncomfortable as there were so so many people making excuses for their loved ones and talking about the 'evil internet' and 'the addiction' and things.

I found the exact same thing 2 weeks ago on my first venture onto that site. I haven't been back. I was thinking about it again this morning and feeling cross actually! One answer particular in reply to a new poster there with the same situation as yourself basically said 'our poor men folk are being honey trapped while watching porn or just 'stumbling' on these images and being condemned for it. Don't tell anyone about it and it all go away' HmmHmmAngry FFS. No one challenged it either. For that reason I left the site. There was much better help here with my own thread on MN recently and none of that minimising shit.

I too am awaiting the time when i'm going to have to dig to find out what the scotish courts say. So reading this with great interest.

I'm one step further removed from you OP, as the offender in my case is my DHs brother. The family are doing a sterling job of making it 'not his fault'. Poor him. I'm really cross and so conflicted about it. I'll stop now as this will turn into a rant!

Flowers for all affected by this.

WeirdAndPissedOff · 14/07/2020 07:50

Hi OP, I second trying to Google shortly after sentencing. When DSIL was in a similar situation, she found info on her brother here:
uk-database.net/
I'm ot sure where they get their info from, but it was quite detailed on the exact nature of the offences, sentencing etc.

Unfortunately poor DSIL got it from both sides - those who seemed to think she was tainted by association, and those in her family who were angry she didn't support him. They did eventually accept her decision once she had DN, but that brought a new wave of arguments as he's now free, and still the apple of his DM's eye, which means that DSIL doesn't feel able to trust her mother to have DN alone. Sad

I'm so sorry you're going through this, and I hope your family come around in time. Flowers

sashh · 14/07/2020 07:21

Scotland has its own version of Sarah's law, it won't tell you exactly what was said in court but will tell you about his conviction.

www.scotland.police.uk/keep-safe/young-people/supporting-children-and-young-people/sex-offender-community-disclosure-scheme/

bookstearocknroll · 14/07/2020 06:48

I haven't read the full thread, so apologies if this has already been suggested but - if you're comfortable with the subsequent coverage - you could phone the court reporter/news room of your local paper and let them know that the case is going ahead as without a tip off or constant presence in court (and a lot of papers don't have the resources for that currently), they may not be aware.

I imagine they'd also be quite obliging if you phoned them up afterwards and asked for details of what happened (often they'll take down much more of the case than they're able to publish).

SunshineCake · 14/07/2020 06:14

Child sexual offences are usually not allowed to be reported on in England and Wales to protect victims, rather than offenders.

This is wrong.

Stannisbaratheonsboxofmatches · 14/07/2020 01:02

Have you tried ringing the procurator fiscals office?

^^
This was what I was going to say.

The CPS in England would generally tell you as it’s in the public domain once it’s been in court.

Sistery · 14/07/2020 00:50

Yikes, sorry that was long. I just wanted to reply to as many people as possible because I do genuinely appreciate the shared experiences advice and also all of the PMs from people offering support.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread