Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
WaterOffADucksCrack · 27/06/2020 22:50

If you can't discipline children without physical abuse then you're a bad parent. It wouldn't be seen as acceptable to hurt an adult if they were behaving poorly so why should it ever be acceptable to treat children like that? Children are people but sadly many people don't seem to grasp that.

TooTrueToBeGood · 27/06/2020 20:57

If you had asked before I became a father, I would have said it's perfectly fine and effective. I was smacked regularly by my parents, belted and caned at school so corporal punishment was my normal. After becoming a father, no way. The thought of inflicting physical pain on my children, or indeed any child, became abhorrent from day 1. I've raised my children and stepchildren to adulthood and never raised my hand to them once. I've not even raised my voice to them that often. Yet they were all respectful, well behaved children to be proud of. All bar one are parents themselves now and none of them smack. Aside from the moral argument, I believe smacking is counterproductive and there are far more effective ways of coaching children.

KeepWashingThoseHands · 27/06/2020 20:50

Let me rephrase it for you:

Someone annoyed me in the supermarket so I slapped them - is that ok?

My colleague did a mistake at work so I slapped them - is that ok?

My partner keeps leaving the toilet seat up so I'm going to slap him - is that ok?

ShebaShimmyShake · 27/06/2020 20:50

Oh, it wasn't a thing when I was at school either, but the topic came up with alarming frequency. I remember lots of media debates about bringing back the cane, even in children's programmes and in our own classrooms. Seemed there were a lot of adults our parents' age who were very angry that they'd experienced it and we hadn't. Weird that my parents were against it when they so heartily approved of it at home but you know, ask why again and I'll wallop you. Maybe I'll ask Mum now. She can try bashing me around from two metres away if she likes.

My brothers, sisters and I used to get hit for hitting each other, which seems very counterproductive.

Haha, yeah. But, you know, that's DIFFERENT.

SwelteringInTheHeat · 27/06/2020 20:45

@ShebaShimmyShake

I learnt to be afraid of my parents, and that it's OK to hit people if they annoy you.Great lessons from my parents there. It took a while for school to undo number two, IIRC.

Haha, yeah. My parents, weirdly, were very against corporal punishment in school. I remember asking them why it was ok for them to hit me if they expected teachers to do something else and was told "it's different". I asked why and, you guessed it, got threatened with a smack if I didn't shut my smart mouth.

Then they used to hand wring and wail when my brother and I beat the shit out of each other all the time and wonder why we did it. Good one, parents, smart work!

I was at school in the 90s, so no corporal punishment for us, although I seem to recall a teacher knocking (not violently!) two girls heads together for talking...

My brothers, sisters and I used to get hit for hitting each other, which seems very counterproductive.

ShebaShimmyShake · 27/06/2020 20:43

I learnt to be afraid of my parents, and that it's OK to hit people if they annoy you.Great lessons from my parents there. It took a while for school to undo number two, IIRC.

Haha, yeah. My parents, weirdly, were very against corporal punishment in school. I remember asking them why it was ok for them to hit me if they expected teachers to do something else and was told "it's different". I asked why and, you guessed it, got threatened with a smack if I didn't shut my smart mouth.

Then they used to hand wring and wail when my brother and I beat the shit out of each other all the time and wonder why we did it. Good one, parents, smart work!

JustBumblingAlong · 27/06/2020 20:42

@JustBumblingAlong

Absolutely no way. It’s a parental loss of control, it’s not discipline. Unless you’re smacking their hand away from something dangerous like a PP said.
Even then I wouldn’t think you’d actually ‘smack’ their hand away
JustBumblingAlong · 27/06/2020 20:39

Absolutely no way. It’s a parental loss of control, it’s not discipline.
Unless you’re smacking their hand away from something dangerous like a PP said.

SwelteringInTheHeat · 27/06/2020 20:36

@Kljnmw3459

Tempting!!!!! But ineffective. You feel bad, child feels bad and nobody's learnt anything.
I learnt to be afraid of my parents, and that it's OK to hit people if they annoy you. Great lessons from my parents there. It took a while for school to undo number two, IIRC.
SwelteringInTheHeat · 27/06/2020 20:32

No.
I remember being hit as a child. It hurt, and it humiliated (especially in public).

If you hit another adult, it would be an assault and you could end up in court. Why is it acceptable to do it to a child?

Nonnymum · 27/06/2020 20:22

"No....unless you are stopping a child from injuring themselves seriously. Then perhaps a hand smack.*
I don't understand how smacking a child would stop them from injuring themselves. Just remove them from the danger. I don't see how hitting them is necessary or helpful.

FizzFan · 27/06/2020 20:21

Not ok. I’ve never hit mine.

Voice0fReason · 27/06/2020 20:21

On the very very odd occasion where behaviour is dangerous or incredibly bad it perhaps could warrant it.
And what do you do when they do the same thing again? Or again?
Hit harder?

It doesn't work an it's abusive.

pigeon999 · 27/06/2020 20:18

No not ever okay.

ShebaShimmyShake · 27/06/2020 20:17

My father got off on bashing us around and calling it "smacking", being in control, getting to wallop someone much smaller, weaker and less powerful, in the name of being the great righteous moral tutor. I'm sure he wasn't the only one. Prick.

Nonnymum · 27/06/2020 20:15

No it's never OK and it's not even an effective form of disipline. I am from the era when corporal punishment was very common in school and it was was always the same children who were hit. If it was an effective form of punishment their behaviour would have improved but it never did. I was never hit but seeing others being hit turned me into a very timid and anxious child scared all the time. People may say it does no harm but it does.

puzzledpiece · 27/06/2020 20:13

I think most parents occasionally lose the plot and do a quick smack, but it's often instinctive and not an intentional thing. My mother remembers being smacked twice by her mum, and never by her dad. I was smacked a couple of times when I ran into the road, just a quick smack out of fright I think. I have smacked older DS when he hit his baby brother round the head with a toy, but it again was the instinctive smack across the bottom. Not painful but shocked him and he didn't do it again.

So half a dozen smacks in 3 generations didn't do anyone any harm I'm sure. To use smacking as a routine punishment is totally wrong. There are far more effective ways, and smacking causes more problems than it solves. I hate seeing children smacked

nestisflown · 27/06/2020 20:08

I don't think KKSlider is for a second an abuser (though if I'm completely honest I can't identify with the compulsion to hit my kids back). I do think there are plenty of people who need little excuse to hit their kids, and if we give them one, they'll fucking take it.

Do you see where I'm coming from now?

I do see your point @thedancingbear when you put it like this but I don’t think attacking people such as KKSlider (who was just being honest about her experience of the subject) is a productive way of making that point. I think if you had started off with your last post which I mostly agree with, then that would have helped frame the discussion better. I defended KKSlider because she was posting in the context of the question of whether is it ok to hit a child as a form of discipline, to which she responded no. I think we’re all agreed (with the exception of a few people on this thread) that smacking as a form of discipline is an absolute no.

While there are grey areas- you’re right, if we framed the discussion say on domestic violence around the possible defences, that could potentially encourage abusers to continue/start abusing in the knowledge that the general public was sympathetic to situations where domestic violence was justified. At least that’s what I have taken your point to mean- which I think is completely valid and I hadn’t thought about it that way before.

avocadotofu · 27/06/2020 19:57

It's definitely never okay!!

welcometohell · 27/06/2020 19:29

It's not discipline it's abuse. There is nothing anyone can say that will convince me otherwise and I work in a safeguarding role so believe me, I've heard all the excuses and justifications in the book. People forget that children are people too. The fact that it is legal to slap your child in this country in 2020 as long as you don't hit them with an "implement" or leave a lasting mark is shameful and says a lot about how we as a society treat our most vulnerable.

bloodywhitecat · 27/06/2020 19:25

No I would not smack a child. I have raised two decent human beings who got to adulthood without being smacked and I have worked with children who have had very challenging behaviour without needing to hit any of them. I was hit as a child and it left a lasting emotional mark.

POP7777777 · 27/06/2020 18:45

No. Just no.

gonesolo · 27/06/2020 18:44

I also think it's wrong to hit a child in any way, in any situation. Surely the idea is lead by example?

When I read that thread in the week about examples of abusive partners I wondered how on earth so many people grow up so fucked up. I wouldn't be half surprised it a lot of it stems back to childhood abuse.

FudgeBrownie2019 · 27/06/2020 18:37

But children today are in general a lot worse behaved and less respectful than they were when we were teenagers

Jesus, the amount of times people use this kind of bullshit to justify why smacking is ok - do you know that since Socrates' time adults have been saying this about the next generations?

"The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room."

And yet the children I know, work with, live with and spend time with through volunteering are generally a great bunch. Of course they have moments of ridiculous behaviour and foolishness, but so did every generation of youngsters before them. I hate that adults believe that younger generations are this, that and the other. There are arseholes in every generation. And they're probably the ones smacking their children and trying to justify it.

I have never heard a valid reason for smacking where another response wouldn't have sorted the situation in a more positive way. I've never seen an excuse for smacking that actually made me think "yep, that kid deserved it".

thedancingbear · 27/06/2020 18:27

if you apply the scenario where the wife hits her husband in the face with a metal pot, is it wrong for the husband to push her back or smack her hand away?

Pushing back or pushing a hand away is fine. Smacking the hand away is iffy. KKSlider by her own description 'lashed out'. Each of these is different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread