Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
Parker231 · 28/06/2020 09:57

There are no circumstances that make smacking acceptable. It’s a loss of control and poor parenting. Why would you do this to someone you love?

Aragog · 28/06/2020 09:56

It isn't ok ever, regardless of reason.

I simply cannot abide smacking, hitting, slapping, tapping or whatever you want to call it.
It's using physical violence, an assault, to someone more vulnerable which I just cannot see how could ever be condoned.

I wasn't hit as a child. My now 18y wasn't ever hit as a child. There's just no need.

Parkmama · 28/06/2020 09:53

No, it's never ok to hit someone

zingally · 28/06/2020 09:49

@ShebaShimmyShake

At what age does smacking cease to be ok? Three? Five? Eight? Sixteen? What's a four year old going to think when they get slapped for being rude while their older sibling gets some reasoning? And of course plenty of shit parents just get used to thinking of their kids as something they can smack about when they think it's ok, and they don't just switch that mentality on the child's birthday.

I would be very interested to know if there are any patterns between gender of parents and children and if any combination smacks more.

Growing up for me, mum was the spontaneous smacker. Like, when we pushed her last button, it was one or two smacks on the bum, and that was it and the issue was forgotten.

Dad was a LOT more calculated, like "you're going to get 4 smacks for that."

zingally · 28/06/2020 09:45

I have 3.5 year old BG twins.
I smacked my DD for the first time a few months ago, after she lobbed a full cup of juice across the kitchen, because it was in the "wrong colour cup". I didn't/don't feel bad about it, but it's not something I want to do for bad behaviour on the regular.
I've never smacked DS.

They say that parents smack, because that's what they grew up with. My dad was a smacker, but has said in later years that he was NEVER smacked as a child, so I don't really understand that. Dad did have a temper though, which maybe that explains it. He also came from a home where his parents were basically uninterested in him. He came in later life, his mum didn't work but was always busy with various clubs and activities (like, didn't take him to the hospital when he broke his wrist at school, because "I couldn't miss poetry club!"), and his dad did 12 hour shifts as a hospital consultant, plus an hours commute either end. Not uncaring, just stressed and busy.
Dad was a very complicated person, for sure. But since he died 3 years ago, the more I've come to reflect on how our childhood experiences ultimately shape the adults we become. He was a prime product of his early years.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 08:45

At what age does smacking cease to be ok? Three? Five? Eight? Sixteen? What's a four year old going to think when they get slapped for being rude while their older sibling gets some reasoning? And of course plenty of shit parents just get used to thinking of their kids as something they can smack about when they think it's ok, and they don't just switch that mentality on the child's birthday.

I would be very interested to know if there are any patterns between gender of parents and children and if any combination smacks more.

Fcukthisshit · 28/06/2020 08:21

Nope. I’ve never hit my kids and I never would. My mum used to hit me - almost every day, until I grew up and started hitting her back every time she tried it. 30 years on, our relationship is destroyed beyond repair now and I don’t want my kids Feeling about me, how I feel about my mum.

Sailingblue · 28/06/2020 08:11

I’ve been amazed how many people on this thread have managed to find a justification for smacking. In my mind it can never be justified. It is an absolute loss of parental control and seemingly In this thread, most often towards towards toddlers. Toddlers can undoubtedly be annoying gits but they are tiny and vulnerable. Using the excuse that they pushed you to boiling point is not ok.

FrugiFan · 28/06/2020 07:57

I was smacked a few times as a kid, and I did turn out fine, but I still don't snack my own children. Times and attitudes have changed.

welcometohell · 28/06/2020 07:53

I think most parents occasionally lose the plot and do a quick smack

No, that's just what you choose to believe to make yourself feel better.

metalkprettyoneday · 28/06/2020 04:36

It’s illegal here in NZ. That doesn’t stop the horrific child abuse stats because those people aren’t worried about breaking laws anyway. But my impression from mixing with other families , and attending playgroups etc is that smacking is seen as very unacceptable . I’ve never come across anyone that does it- my circles seem to use positive parenting / empathy methods .
My parents smacked us. But I think it was because they were young, didn’t read up on parenting etc . I don’t think I’d like to teach a kid that I could hit them because I was bigger than them but that they shouldn’t . My daughter would say that’s not fair and she’s be right . I think even small children know when something is not right.

Purpleartichoke · 28/06/2020 03:45

Assault is assault. The age of the victim doesn’t matter.

strugglingwithdeciding · 28/06/2020 03:40

@FudgeBrownie2019 maybe you should read my post properly i never condoned smacking
And if course there are good kids ( i hope my two teenagers are )
But in general behaviour is a lot worse
My kids tell me what school is like and the abuse the teachers take at times
When i was at secondary yes sure kids misbehaved at times bit some of what my kids say can happen now is shocking
And i went to a inner london city school not some quiet village schiool

alexdgr8 · 28/06/2020 02:33

i'm just wondering.
it was totally the norm when i was young, also at school.
some places it is still the norm, eg africa.
and africans are the ones who cannot understand how we have so many old people's homes. they have the warmest regard for their elders and regard it as a privilege to look after and do anything for them.
respect is demanded from children in african homes. and it is the norm. smacking is not usually needed. but it is not viewed as wrong.
by either children or parents.
i am not talking about any excessive hitting, just a judicious smack.
i know this is a generalisation, but it is generally true.
just a thought.

Oliversmumsarmy · 28/06/2020 02:32

If you have to resort to hitting your children to bring them under control then you have lost control.

If hitting worked then there wouldn’t be any more bad behaviour

Where do you go if hitting doesn’t get a child to behave how you want them to

AoifeAye · 28/06/2020 02:10

I don't know how to deal with my dd's behaviour sometimes when she refuses to do things, screams, punches me, slaps me. She won't sit on a step or a chair or do time out etc. She just won't do it. How do I make her? If I take away a toy or threaten to, she ramps up the screaming and hitting and refusing. She's 5, she's been like this since she was about 2. No interest in sticker charts. Being assessed for autism. I did smack her once. It was a reflexive action after she smacked me in the face. I felt incredibly guilty over it.

ChristmasCarcass · 28/06/2020 01:15

I think there is a difference between stuff like slapping your child’s hand away from something hot or dangerous, or playfully slapping them off you when they are being too boisterous (which I know doesn’t actually hurt, and which I would also do to DH and adult DBro if they stuck their foot in my face), and deliberately smacking your child as a punishment designed to hurt them, which I think is counterproductive and usually a sign of a parent who has lost control.

And obviously slapping your child around the face would be a different kettle of fish again - that I think is just outright abuse, there’s no room for debate about parenting styles at all there.

BoomBoomsCousin · 28/06/2020 01:07

I totally disagree with it. The evidence seems to be heavily weighted towards it being harmful and of low effectiveness as a discipline method.

I try not to be too judgemental, though because I'm not perfect. I've done plenty of things as a parent that I regret, maybe some of them are worse than smacking.

I don't think it's always immediately clear when a parent's response to poor behaviour is successful. Especially when there is more than one child in the mix, I can see why parents sometimes turn to methods they are familiar with rather than advice from "expert" sources.

randolph78 · 28/06/2020 00:45

Even if you think that violence is never justified, lucky the law disagrees with your black and white view of the word and recognises there are limited circumstances where it will be justified or defendable. Self defence being one of them.

Self defence is not violence. It may be force but as violence is "actions or words that are intended to hurt people" and the intention of self-defence is not actually to hurt others but to protect yourself, it's not violence.

Jimdandy · 28/06/2020 00:25

I try not too, but I’m not perfect.

When they’ve been pushing your buttons all day, you’ve done all the Supernanny techniques and been sat out all day for doing the same thing over and over again, had electronics/treats taken etc and still choose to play up, I think a quick, sharp smack can have then desired effect if it’s an ultimate sanction. I think you can’t expect some parents not to be pushed to the end of their tether occasionally.

If a workplace did something to me over and over again I would walk out etc.

I have read negative things about the sitting out technique, withdrawing communication apparently can cause issues or the poster mentioning her Father lashing out with words.

I completely agree it’s not ideal and I don’t agree with what my friend does if half heartedly telling her son to stop it 8 times then suddenly blowing up and smacking. It really is a nuclear option for me, but sometimes you have to draw the line.

I think a lot more parents do it than let on behind closed doors too.

Sidalee7 · 28/06/2020 00:23

Totally not acceptable. I have a temper but I have never,never come close to smacking. It makes me feel physically sick.
I was smacked and I remember the feeling of humiliation so clearly. I remember my primary school teacher hitting me when I was 4, having no idea what it was for, she literally just whacked me. Awful.

Grilledaubergines · 27/06/2020 23:23

It is your circus and they are your monkeys

Christ, that’s some sad reflection of parenting.

LimeTreeGrove · 27/06/2020 23:09

No, it should be illegal.

SmallChickBilly · 27/06/2020 23:04

For those who believe it can be an effective form of punishment, would you be in favour of allowing child care professionals to use smacking in the same way? Or another parent at the park if your child was misbehaving? I agree with PP that if you aren't able to say that it's never acceptable, you are leaving a lot of potential for interpretation which there isn't if you just take it off the table completely, and I do think that this is a genuine cause for concern.

And in cases where it's 'instinctual', (either in response to them injuring you, or putting themselves or others in danger) how then do you limit the potential risk that you will do serious damage? If instinct takes over, do you have control over how hard you are hitting, or where on your child? I think I'd worry that I would really hurt them one day if I had been unable to stop myself in the past.

I'm also trying to imagine how I'd feel if my husband hit me for hurting him accidentally, even if I was doing something stupid. I think I would consider the injury a contributory factor and maybe not react as I would if it were unprovoked, but I think it would lurk at the back of my mind and I'd probably never really stop worrying about it happening again.

I think it's easy to fall into the trap of thinking 'never say never', but we are legally obliged to deal with a whole range of behaviours from adults without hitting them, and we expect professionals and strangers not to use physical discipline with our children, so what is it about a parent-child relationship that makes hitting acceptable?

Llamazoom · 27/06/2020 22:59

Never acceptable as a punishment, I was slapped/smacked often as a child, in fact my mother went to slap me round the face about 18 months ago but thought better of it (I’m 44) my mother has had MH and anger issues all her adult life. I remember feeling alone and scared after she had smacked me and I would never inflict those feelings on my own children. I have swiped DD hand away from the iron once when she was a toddler, the look of shock in her eyes must have been what my mother used to see in mine, it fills me with horror. It’s nothing but abuse and loss of self control.

Swipe left for the next trending thread