Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
Oliversmumsarmy · 28/06/2020 12:31

if a kid is consistently doing something wrong and doesn't respond to anything else, then as a last resort a small smack on the bum isn't the worst thing in the world

No need to smack. Just ignore bad behaviour and praise the good behaviour.

I learned it in a puppy training class and dc seemed to have turned out ok.😀

Fcukthisshit · 28/06/2020 12:18

@Sizedoesmatter my mum was a single parent. I suspect nobody realised ( or they turned a blind eye to) how often she was hitting me. She almost broke my arm on one occasion when I was 5, requiring hospital treatment. I think I just got to the point that I knew that nobody would stop it from happening so I had to defend myself. I never punched her but when she slapped my face, I’d slap her back or if she’d got hold of my hair I’d hit her until she let go. I remember, even from being little begging her not to hit for some stupid little thing.

Now I have my own kids I couldn’t imagine ever laying a hand on them. As a parent it’s my job to find a way to teach them right and wrong without smacking them.

I see my mum as little as possible now. She visits a few times a year. I don’t visit her as she has a completely untrained, unpredictable dog that I don’t trust around my kids. I try and ensure that my childhood doesn’t ever become a topic of conversation as she genuinely believes she did nothing wrong, and obviously I feel very differently to that so there’s nothing to be gained by discussing it further. She’s never had unsupervised access to my kids either as I just don’t trust her.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 12:12

"it's a last resort for when a time-out doesn't work"

There are always alternatives. How do you think people who work with or have children with additional needswith behaviour that challenges cope. Smacking also doesn't work. It teaches children that hitting is acceptable behaviour.

WanderingMilly · 28/06/2020 12:11

I am in my 60's and grew up when smacking or spanking were considered quite reasonable by many (although not all).
My views have changed over the years of my life.

I was spanked when I was young. I always felt I deserved it; sometimes I had irritated my mother so much she snapped, at other times I had done something more serious and my father said I should be spanked. For instance, I always wanted a pet cat so I captured next door's cat under an old metal tank which my father found. My father hated cruelty to animals and thought it a spanking offence to teach me a lesson. As a child it made me realise how awful I had been....I just hadn't thought about the poor cat and never, ever did such a thing again. But only as an adult did I understand the irony of being spanked for cruelty to another creature.

When I had my own children, they did get smacked. Not often but as part of discipline. I was influenced by my own upbringing but became more uncomfortable with the idea. They were only smacked when very young, not as they got older.

Looking back, I do not agree with the way I brought up my own children. I wish I could go back and change it. As a young parent I was always worried that if the children "got away" with being naughty they would grow up badly behaved and irresponsible adults. I think this was erroneous on my part, my children now say they were unscathed but I am not so sure they had happy childhoods. I would parent very differently now.

I have also learned a great deal about myself during my many years. It has made me more understanding and with a better perspective. I have lived in countries where there is absolutely no smacking allowed, it is a criminal offence. The children grow up better balanced, and with a greater sense of self responsibility. I was also struck by the fact that their whole society is 'gentler', my own British culture seems a very violent one in comparison. Even without smacking there is anger and 'violence' in the way children are shouted at, disciplined and so on.

These days I believe it is wrong to smack a child....or anyone. If I wouldn't deal with an adult in that manner, I certainly shouldn't be dealing with a child that way either.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 12:09

And I'm notplanning to hurt her

It's exactly what you're doing. You've even thought out how you'll bend her over and how long she'll cry for. And she's still a babe in arms. What is wrong with you?

snowybean · 28/06/2020 12:08

@grumpyhoonmain An interesting observation. I trying to think if I was fascinated by other people's bums as a kid. I found them silly, but didn't take that much of an interest 🤔

GrumpyHoonMain · 28/06/2020 12:03

@snowybean - DC teaches reception. In her experience the kids smacked on the bum tend to be the ones trying to touch / be fascinated by other kids bums.

converseandjeans · 28/06/2020 12:03

It's not ok in my opinion. I don't think I could hang out with people who were slapping their kids.

Parker231 · 28/06/2020 11:58

You’re parenting wrong if you need to revert to smacking.

iklboo · 28/06/2020 11:57
  • I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.*

That's horrific. Calculated, deliberate & sadistic. You'd be making them anticipate the pain and humiliation. Bending them over? Smacking their backside? Let them have a small cry? Jesus Christ. The 'big hug' afterwards would in no way mitigate that behaviour. I honestly hope you're being sarcastic and taking the piss because that plan of action is inexcusable.

snowybean · 28/06/2020 11:54

Oh jeez, I'm not hurting her! And I'm not planning to hurt her, especially when she's little. No way, I guess I didn't explain myself properly. But if a kid is consistently doing something wrong and doesn't respond to anything else, then as a last resort a small smack on the bum isn't the worst thing in the world. I think slapping on the hand or arm is far worse, and I would never do that. I'm not cold and calculating either, it's a last resort for when a time-out doesn't work. Everyone has a different parenting style.

MojoJojo71 · 28/06/2020 11:52

@snowybean

I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.

That’s disgusting. Can you really not see that is both physical and emotional abuse? You are supposed to be her protector
Underhisi · 28/06/2020 11:50

snowybean are you on a wind up because if you are not that is a seriously messed up way of thinking.

I don't smack. Aside from the abuse considerations it doesn't work. I have a teenager with very severe learning difficulties so doesn't understand speech and explanations and also some very challenging physical behaviour when distressed. There are always ways of managing things without hitting anyone.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 11:37

@snowybean

I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.

You sound like a terrific parent. Not calculating and sadistic in the slightest.
Parker231 · 28/06/2020 11:31

@snowybean - why is acceptable for you to hurt your DC? They are smaller than you and can’t defend themselves from you.

GrumpyHoonMain · 28/06/2020 11:28

Smacking only really works as a behavioural technique when you do it once in a blue moon; and even then only if the parent is respected by the child. My parents smacked me so much I just ignored them, I never had much respect for them in the first place though.

SimonJT · 28/06/2020 11:27

@snowybean

I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.

So you’re planning the assault of your baby.

I can’t imagine what messed up message a child receives when someone physically assaults them and then hugs them.

thedancingbear · 28/06/2020 11:26

^I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.^

You're describing child abuse. Hitting kids is never okay.

Sizedoesmatter · 28/06/2020 10:58

@snowybean

I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.

This is worrying. That sounds horrible and I don't understand how you could think that's acceptable. You're already planning to hit your child on the bum if she acts out. That's wrong.
OP posts:
Sizedoesmatter · 28/06/2020 10:46

@Fcukthisshit

Nope. I’ve never hit my kids and I never would. My mum used to hit me - almost every day, until I grew up and started hitting her back every time she tried it. 30 years on, our relationship is destroyed beyond repair now and I don’t want my kids Feeling about me, how I feel about my mum.
I hit my mother back when I was about 15, she'd hit me over the head with a frying pan and I turned round and punched her. She never hit me again. I got dogs abuse off my whole family though as she rang my dad, brother and some extended family to tell them that I'd hit her. I've never been so ashamed or terrified in my whole life..

Now though I'm glad I did it, and if she ever brought it up (she never has) I'd tell her why. My dad also apologised and agreed with what I'd done in the end, as she hadn't told him what led to it. In the end he went mad that I'd been being hit for years over stupid crap. Doesn't take away how I felt at the time knowing how dissapointed he was in me.

Her methods 100% did not work, they caused nothing but resentment, shame and fear. It never stopped me from acting out, if anything I acted out more because I had abseloutley no respect for her. To this day I've very little time for her.

OP posts:
ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 10:18

I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I find that chilling tbh. I can understand (not excuse) lack of control -especially if the person stops/seeks help- more than premeditated and planned smacking.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 10:16

I smacked DD 3 times in her whole life . She's 9 now.

Only one time it could be deemed "necessary ". She jaw locked on my lip, it was really painful and she wouldn't let go. I tried pulling her off but that just hurt more. Smack on the bum, she opened her mouth in shock and i freed myself. Lip was swollen and bleeding.

The other two times , I hold my hands up and admit it was lack of control/fear/anger. Once for running into the road and the other for breaking something very dear to me because she was mad at me.

However I did not want to parent that way, or even have smacking as a last resort/back up so found other methods. Especially since my parents didn't smack, but mum would beat me in anger when things /I got too much. I had the occasional slap on the face from dad too, again in anger.

Due to my background I was worried that normalising smacks could possibly lead to something much worse in the future, even if I can't actually see myself doing what mum did.

Sidalee7 · 28/06/2020 10:01

@welcometohell - exactly. That and “more people do it than you think”

snowybean · 28/06/2020 10:01

I would never, ever smack my kids out of anger or frustration. Instead, I will explain to them why they're being smacked, then bend them over and smack 'em on the bum. I'll let them have a small cry and then give them a big hug.

I've not done this yet as DD is 6mo, but I will in the future.

Doyoumind · 28/06/2020 09:59

It's a definite no. How can you teach children that hitting people is wrong when you hit them yourself?