Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 13:55

My child does know if he ever has been smacked that is it for being naughty and prior he would have been warned numerous times.

Translation: I deserve to be hit.

What about when they're older and they are being annoying or doing something someone else deems annoying? Would it be ok for a friend to smack them? Their partner? Their coworker? Their boss?

Parker231 · 28/06/2020 13:52

All smacking does is show lack of control and lets children know that it is acceptable to hit. Perhaps this is the reason for poor behaviour in schools?

Zeroenergy · 28/06/2020 13:49

Repeated myself in the last sentence sorry for the typo

Zeroenergy · 28/06/2020 13:49

Absolutely not ever ok. It’s just a display of power over them to put them in their place but one day that won’t work any more when they are as physically strong as you. Its what people resort to sadly when communication has plummeted and they’ve lost control of the situation which I get does happen and it’s bloody hard but the respect for your child and their respect and right to safety comes above anything else.

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 13:49

@ShebaShimmyShake

The more you praise good behaviour, the less punishment you need for bad. Sometimes just not praising bad behaviour is all it takes.

Do you smackers approve of other parents hitting your children when they're on playdates? If they're at the end of their tethers and so on?

If my child behaved badly when we was out and they continued to do it I would warn them if it continues we will be going home.
Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 13:44

I’m surprised at some people’s response. There is such thing as context. There’s a difference between slapping a child in their face or getting a slipper and repeated beating a child that is unacceptable behaviour and that is my idea of abuse. However there is a big difference between a child deliberately not listening even when they have been told numerous times** to stop doing something. I’m a firm believer there is only so many times you can tell a child and explain not to do something. I have smacked my child before and I do not view this as abuse a smack on the hand will not leave him with horrific childhood memories there’s absolutely no need. My child does know if he ever has been smacked that is it for being naughty and prior he would have been warned numerous times. It is not a daily occurrence by any means. An occasional slap on the hand will not leave any child with horrific childhood memories.

I wonder if that is why society is the way it is today so many rules as everything is so politically correct. Schools for example so many problems and rude children why? (Lack of discipline) from parents and teachers fearing for using words such as “naughty”. In my primary school we would not of dared to back chat our teachers and that was growing up in the 90s.

Bluntness100 · 28/06/2020 13:42

Everyone will say no but it is a cultural thing

No it’s not. It’s an abuse thing, end of,

nokidshere · 28/06/2020 13:39

No....unless you are stopping a child from injuring themselves seriously. Then perhaps a hand smack.

I never understand this comment. If your child is in danger of seriously injuring themselves that is lack of supervision from the parent. Smacking them for your own shortcomings is ridiculous.

When I had my first child my family and friends laughed at my no smacking rule. 'Oh you just wait' they said 'until he's really naughty'. He's 22 now and his brother is 18 and neither of them have ever had so much as a tap.

There are ways to parent and discipline that are effective and don't require corporal punishment.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 13:34

Being a parent to a child with a child with challenging behaviour is though different to working with children with those behaviours. When it is your own child it is all consuming.

motherheroic · 28/06/2020 13:31

Do you slap adults for discipline? If you wouldn't slap an adult to discipline them why would you slap a child who is many times smaller than one. That's my answer.

larrygrylls · 28/06/2020 13:29

Everyone will say no but it is a cultural thing. If smacking was a major deal, we would expect a measurable increase in children’s success and happiness since it has fallen out of favour. We haven’t.

Those who beat their children will continue to do so as they don’t care (until their children are hopefully removed from them).

On the other hand those who use naughty step/send to room/removal of toys as punishment (which they will refer to as ‘consequence’ as a form of Orwellian newspeak) instead of the snack they would have received from their parents will, I would hazard, not do any better (or worse) than their parents at bringing up happy healthy children.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 13:26

My son has challenging behaviour due to his severe disability. Over the years I have learned to consider why he is behaving in particular ways and what he is seeking (either deliberately or instinctively) from it and go from there.I treat behaviour as communication.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 13:23

@Underhisi

You shouldn't always ignore bad behaviour because it can be unsafe and the undesirable behaviour can be the child attempting to communicate something so you need to teach alternatives rather than just ignoring.
It depends on what's going on. Some behaviour, of course you can't ignore. I remember once being at a friend's house and mashing up my dessert, making a mess and trying to be funny. My friend's mother said to my friend, who was behaving, "What lovely manners you have, Sarah, how nicely you're eating", and that was all it took.

Obviously if I'd lamped someone with my bowl, she would have needed to do something more.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 13:19

You shouldn't always ignore bad behaviour because it can be unsafe and the undesirable behaviour can be the child attempting to communicate something so you need to teach alternatives rather than just ignoring.

Oliversmumsarmy · 28/06/2020 13:17

Kalifa my dc never ever kicked the cat or attacked their sibling.

They are noisy even now but it didn’t bother me.

I just found the more laid back i was the more laid back dc were.

anxietyaunt · 28/06/2020 13:13

@bloodywhitecat

No I would not smack a child. I have raised two decent human beings who got to adulthood without being smacked and I have worked with children who have had very challenging behaviour without needing to hit any of them. I was hit as a child and it left a lasting emotional mark.
Were these challenging kids your own? If so, can you explain what you mean by “challenging behaviour”, including how you got through the difficult years? Not to derail the thread. I’ve never hit my 3yo and can’t imagine ever doing so, but his behaviour is challenging to say the least and I’m starting to fray. Sad

A lot of people are quick to say they just talk to their kids and the problems magically disappear. But some of us have kids with very, very challenging personalities which make that near impossible. Love to hear some tips from those whose kids are/were actually challenging!

Apple1029 · 28/06/2020 12:57

I would be horrified. I grew up seeing this happen as normal. Luckily my parents never hit us. But this was legal back then even in schools. I couldnt do that to my DC.

TooTrueToBeGood · 28/06/2020 12:55

The more you praise good behaviour, the less punishment you need for bad. Sometimes just not praising bad behaviour is all it takes.

Bingo, most dog trainers and owners figured that out years ago, pity so many parents don't yet get it. As to the PP who will cuddle and fuss over their child immediately after giving them into trouble, good luck with that strategy.

Eemamc · 28/06/2020 12:48

I don’t think it’s acceptable no, if I want to teach them that hitting others is unacceptable how will me hitting them help that? What a mixed message. I believe I have other tools to give consequences. Smacking won’t be one of them.

Kaykay066 · 28/06/2020 12:48

Smacking here is illegal now although I was smacked and my mum also used wooden spoon and metal spoon I was scared of her/it and yeah maybe I did what I was told but it’s not very nice to fear being hit.

So young mum with my eldest son I smacked because that’s what I knew. But quite honestly I did it once maybe twice and I felt like shit. 3 kids later no smacking in this house, still feel total shame about my Eldest but he can’t remember (19 soon) there are other better ways to parent it’s not always easy but using physical violence with your children isn’t parenting

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 12:46

but is my way of last-resort discipline (and yes, I know there are other ways).

So why don't you use those?

I think you were harmed by your upbringing if you're looking at your baby daughter and thinking about bending her over and how long she'll cry.

And nobody has verbally abused you, for goodness sake. You'll slap your daughter but you think we've been mean on here?

snowybean · 28/06/2020 12:42

I have a hunch that other people who smack don't say it because of what people would say on a platform like Mumsnet. I could be wrong, though.

How will you explain to your kids that you had to hit them when just about every other sane parent didn't?

Good question, I'm glad you asked that than just throwing verbal abuse my way. I will explain to them that it is perhaps somewhat outdated but is my way of last-resort discipline (and yes, I know there are other ways).

It doesn't mean I don't love my kids any less. I could say that my mum did the same to me and it worked, but I wasn't terrified of her, and we have always had a good relationship. If I think it's affecting any of my kids negatively, then I'll not do it again. There's no point. Who knows, maybe they'll get to that age and I'll change my mind. I'm not afraid of apologising if it doesn't work.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 12:42

The more you praise good behaviour, the less punishment you need for bad. Sometimes just not praising bad behaviour is all it takes.

Do you smackers approve of other parents hitting your children when they're on playdates? If they're at the end of their tethers and so on?

Kalifa · 28/06/2020 12:41

Oliversmumsarmy
Just ignore bad behaviour

Really? Even if the child is beating up his/her sibling, kicking the family cat or screaming down the roof? Then you just ignore the kid? It teaches them that whatever they do they can pretty much get away with it.

thedancingbear · 28/06/2020 12:32

Everyone has a different parenting style.

This is true. Some people like to deliberately harm their kids, some don't.

The thing you have to realise snowybean is that most people don't hit their kids nowadays. They think it is fucked up, as you can see from this thread.

Your kids will later in life be able to see that what you are doing is not normal. How will you explain to your kids that you had to hit them when just about every other sane parent didn't?

This isn't a rhetorical question - I'm interested in your answer.