Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
Purpleartichoke · 28/06/2020 16:46

Aoifeaye

There are many techniques

Create a space where she can rage safely

Barrel hug her with arms and legs to hold her limbs (reserve this for times you are worried she will hurt herself or another child)

Love bomb her when she is behaving well

Set aside some time each day with undivided focus where she directs the play entirely.

Figure out her currency. Everyone has something. Use it for rewards.

Learn what sets her off and figure out techniques to help calm her down before things get bad. Therapists can really help on the techniques, but you know your kid. Trust your gut.

Pick your battles. Decide what rules matter and what rules don’t. Every child is different and sometimes you need to meet them where they are, not where you want them to be.

Separate the task from you. If there is something like getting ready for bed that tends to create problems, create a flip chart with all the steps. Now instead of you being the person giving orders, the flip chart is simply guiding the steps.

AoifeAye · 28/06/2020 16:21

Can anyone suggest how I deal with my DD when she is hitting, punching, kicking and screaming at me? Geuinine question. If anyone read my previous post I said she is being assessed for autism, she often has these episodes of screaming and hitting me. She outright refuses to do things like naughty step or time out, no interest in sticker/reward charts. And also as I said in my pp, I did once hit her after she slapped me in the face and I felt awfully guilty after. But it did work. The shock stopped her. I haven't made a habit of it and don't want to, but sometimes feel at my wit's end. If something sets her off, she follows me around the house screaming at me and hitting me. If I say I'm taking a toy away from her the screaming and hitting increases. I've also tried hugging her to calm her and it makes thing worse too. I really would like advice if anyone has any. I do my best to avoid it reaching the stage where the screaming and attacking begins, but it's not always possible to avoid.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 14:29

The complete lack of discipline is the same as neglect in my eyes.

It's not an either or situation though, it's not kids are smacked or kids running feral.

If the two do overlap at some point it's because some of the kids that are smacked or worse will also be the ones acting out. Funnily a lot of the parents that do that aren't too happy about someone else disciplining their child.

Justmemyself · 28/06/2020 14:28

I don't smack and would be horrified if I saw someone else doing it as it seems to me that the parent is generally hitting the child due to their own frustration and loss of control but I do believe that there is a difference between smacking a child on the bum for being naughty as a last resort and beating them up.

I also find the narriative around it being abuse interesting as physical punishment is used universally in the animal kingdom and we use animals as an example of attachment parenting e.g. why its normal to co sleep/ breastfeed responsively etc. but animals routinely nip and swat at their young if they get out of line and up until the last 100 years or so children have always been disciplined by smacking as well.

MilleniumHallsWalledGarden · 28/06/2020 14:27

I have never and will never smack my children. It shows a total loss of control, and if you're not in control you shouldn't have vulnerable people, such as children, in your care, imo.

Whatisthisfuckery · 28/06/2020 14:26

No, no hitting, smacking, slapping, whatever you want to call it. I have smacked my DS in the past, which I’m not proud of, but I’ve not done it for many years.

I used to get hit when I was a kid, sometimes with a slipper or other object, and I resent it massively. My XH was also violent towards both me and DS. I have done a lot of work on myself unlearning what I was taught about violence and it stops with me.

Also, I’m not having my DS learning that it’s ever acceptable to hit someone, or be hit by them. I was taught when I was a kid that if I got hit I deserved it, and my dad, who usually did the hitting, was justified in doing it if he said he was, which in turn lead me to accept it from my XH. My dad was not justified in hitting me, and neither was my XH, and neither was I when I did it.

WeAllHaveWings · 28/06/2020 14:21

Back in the days children didn’t feel so comfortable to speak to people in a rude manner why was this?

I am from "from back in the days" it was because they lived in fear of physical punishment.

The problem is some parents who are too lazy to teach their children properly how to behave and respect, not because they don't smack them.

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:20

This is the problem with MN the boat is rocked as soon as some people do not agree to disagree. People take things completely out of context and start to be deliberately obtuse.

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:18

@Underhisi

I don't think children and teenagers did have a lot more respect. Most children and teenagers now are considerate and reasonable people.
Where are you living Mars?!
Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:17

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble did you read what I wrote or did you just assume? I said it’s not a daily occurrence. You didn’t ask me my other methods? I never stated that it is the only method I use it is not. Just because some don’t agree that is fine. I’m sure there’s things you may do which I may not.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 14:16

I don't think children and teenagers did have a lot more respect. Most children and teenagers now are considerate and reasonable people.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 14:13

I admitted I smacked DD in the past and why. What I'm trying to understand is why you feel it's the only solution, the one thing that "works".

Parker231 · 28/06/2020 14:11

Parents with little or no self control need to get some professional help if they can’t control their children’s behaviour without resorting to smacking.

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:11

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble I am the mother and I am a good mother as I have wrote already. There is such thing as context I do not believe my child is being abused because he may of got an occasional smack on the hand. It’s a form of discipline.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 14:08

I don’t think I’m going wrong and we never get to the stage of where I have to say something ten times

But why does it get to the point where you have to smack?

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:08

[quote Parker231]@Shinebright72 - perhaps behaviour in schools is bad as some children see that hitting is acceptable as that is what they have seen at home. Smacking is never acceptable - there are no exceptions.[/quote]
What your saying doesn’t add up though. Because people used to hit their children far more frequently and children and teenagers had A LOT MORE respect for general society.

I’m happy to agree to disagree.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 14:07

I don't understand why you would hit someone when you don't need to.

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:06

@ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble

I’m a firm believer there is only so many times you can tell a child and explain not to do something.

That's where a lot of people go "wrong". What happens either they give in, or explode after the 10th time which is confusing as fuck for a child , especially a young one. After all there was no consequence after the first,second,third etc.There is no need to repeat yourself many times. I say something once, I repeat myself in case she didn't hear,wasn't paying attention etc(normally I hen I ask her to do something rather than stop doing something) then I give a warning and always follow through If I'm ignored after that. Obviously this is pretty simplistic and won't work for every child in every situation, but as a general rule it works, including at work(school).

I don’t think I’m going wrong and we never get to the stage of where I have to say something ten times. I don’t know why this is being taken out of context.
Parker231 · 28/06/2020 14:05

@Shinebright72 - perhaps behaviour in schools is bad as some children see that hitting is acceptable as that is what they have seen at home. Smacking is never acceptable - there are no exceptions.

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:04

@Underhisi

"I’m a firm believer there is only so many times you can tell a child and explain not to do something."

Would you use smacking with adults with learning disabilities or older people with dementia who may repeatedly do things that are undesirable?

I said there’s such thing as context. Also just because I have give. My child an occasional smack does not make me a bad mother. Nor does it make me an abusive mother of any kind at all. I have no criminal record I also have an occupational working with the public.

I can see that I seemed to be out numbered. I do still consider myself a good parent and person.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 28/06/2020 14:01

I’m a firm believer there is only so many times you can tell a child and explain not to do something.

That's where a lot of people go "wrong". What happens either they give in, or explode after the 10th time which is confusing as fuck for a child , especially a young one. After all there was no consequence after the first,second,third etc.There is no need to repeat yourself many times. I say something once, I repeat myself in case she didn't hear,wasn't paying attention etc(normally I hen I ask her to do something rather than stop doing something) then I give a warning and always follow through If I'm ignored after that. Obviously this is pretty simplistic and won't work for every child in every situation, but as a general rule it works, including at work(school).

Shinebright72 · 28/06/2020 14:00

@Parker231

All smacking does is show lack of control and lets children know that it is acceptable to hit. Perhaps this is the reason for poor behaviour in schools?
Are you serious? I’m not suggesting teachers should be allowed to hit children and go back to them days. But you can not argue that in today’s society there is a lot more children and teenagers that have no respect for adults especially in a school setting. Teachers I know 2 that have given teaching up, high school kids for this reason and the parents of the child being a problem also. Back in the days children didn’t feel so comfortable to speak to people in a rude manner why was this? PS sorry to go slightly off topic.... there was a story not long ago and a boy coughed in someone’s face and shout coronavirus!!. This is the terrible society we live in today and I do personally believe that the majority stems from a child not being told firmly from small! And probably if they got a smack on the hand now and again it wouldn’t of got to this out of control stage....
Twigletfairy · 28/06/2020 13:58

I really disagree with smacking. Adults aren't allowed to go round smacking other adults, so why do it to children who are completely at our mercy?

My in laws have smacked their grandchildren since they were about 18 months old. It makes me feel really uncomfortable. We are supposed to teach children how to behave. What does smacking them teach them? That it's ok to hit other people when not doing as they're told? It's ok to hit people when you're angry?

WeAllHaveWings · 28/06/2020 13:57

Smacking a child is either a lazy form of parenting using quick easy don't need to think about it physical punishment, or it is a concerning lack of control from the parent.

Either way it is wrong to smack.

I wonder if that is why society is the way it is today so many rules as everything is so politically correct. Schools for example so many problems and rude children why? (Lack of discipline) from parents and teachers fearing for using words such as “naughty”.

The problem comes when parents are too lazy to think of, work on, or ask for help on alternative ways to teach their child to behave and they raise children with a lack of discipline and respect.

Underhisi · 28/06/2020 13:55

"I’m a firm believer there is only so many times you can tell a child and explain not to do something."

Would you use smacking with adults with learning disabilities or older people with dementia who may repeatedly do things that are undesirable?