Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
Baluchistan95 · 28/06/2020 19:38

@Sizedoesmatter

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

I'm actually shocked that you need to ask the question, if it is okay to violently assault a child. Seriously!!
Tunnocks34 · 28/06/2020 19:34

I do generally to logical and natural consequences, but I have just outright punished with the removal of something, such as a ‘late night’ or his spends, if I cannot see a natural or logical consequence.

Tunnocks34 · 28/06/2020 19:31

I do not agree with hitting, I don’t hit my children, I think it really is about a parents lack of control, rather than an effective discipline measure.

That said, I don’t think a slap on the arse will cause lasting damage to a child, and I can really understand how a parent can sometimes resort to it because my 6 year old honestly...sometimes I am amazed I haven’t snapped to be honest.

Swirlyceiling · 28/06/2020 19:27

However, my late mother used smacking as a punishment and I can honestly say that I always had fair warning and, the few times I was smacked, decided that it was worth it to do what I wanted to do.

I can honestly say that I much preferred getting smacked to when my mother just went silent and became cold and upset.*

So in the case you have described, the smacking wasn't even really a punishment. A punishment generally stops behaviour occurring. If you decided being smacked was worth it, it's an ineffective punishment, so is just abusive parenting.

Going silent and cold is emotional abuse.

How about people talk to their children? Rather than hit, or go cold? It's toxic.

Swirlyceiling · 28/06/2020 19:24

*Losing an access to a toy is not a 'consequence', it is a punishment, no more or less so than smacking. If a child refuses to go out of the house to school, for instance, there is no natural correlation between this and losing a toy.

Re your IPad example, I think it is awful that a child would believe that his continued ownership was contingent upon behaviour. So, in your eyes, is the Ipad merely loaned, rather than a gift? As, if it is a gift, it is the receiver's in law, and taking it back is theft (and you can go to jail for it if you do it to another adult).*

Ok, semantics if you fancy them.
Losing access to the iPad for 2 days is a consequence of bad behaviour
Getting a smack across your legs is a consequence of bad behaviour

One of these things will help children learn that if they are naughty, there are undesired consequences, and if they are good, there are desired consequences.

The other is hitting a vulnerable child who looks to you for safety and can't do anything about it but accept it.

In nt example, the iPad is not loaned, nor is it a gift. It is a family iPad which belongs to the family and everyone may use. However, parents can and do dictate how much time children can spend on it. That is just good sense to prevent too much screen time. If a child misbehaves, no screen time for 2 days (something they like) as a consequence of misbehaving. If they make up for it with very good behaviour, they can earn it back early. Otherwise, the set duration plays out.
They will stop being bad because they learn that they don't get access to their games or whatever.

Calling these things loans and gifts is like saying a child owns every biscuit in the tin, that was purchased during the weekly shop. They belong to the family. The parent still says you can have x amount then stop, to stop the child binging on junk.

If the child has bought the iPad outright from their own money, it cannot be used in this way. The Wi-Fi can be turned off, though.

Even If the iPad had been bought for the child, I'd like to see anyone claim theft for having it confiscated for 2 days as a result of pushing boundaries to the extreme. A friend of mine recently took her child's Xbox away for 3 days as punishment for having a tantrum and swearing at his mum, calling her a nasty fat shit. He had heard it at school and had been told before not say it again.

He hasn't said it since because he knows if he does, his Xbox goes again.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 19:15

Parents who beat, slap around the face, hit with an implement or just strike really hard always think they're "just" smacking. They're frequently not too good at changing their mindset as their child gets older too (why would they? They've ingrained into themselves that hitting the child is fine as long as they "deserve" it. Where else do we hear that?).

We've had people in this debate who are totally fine with slapping their kids (sometimes even treating us to lovely details about how they imagine bending them over and seeing them cry)
and yet get offended and call it "abuse" when they get frank responses to it. Guess smacking doesn't encourage the parents to engage the little grey cells either, hmm.

MarshaBradyo · 28/06/2020 19:14

It just isn't as black and white as people like to make out.

I disagree, I think it is. A child is vulnerable, powerless and unable to leave. Hitting it a hitting so don’t do it. Even if smacking was some ok experience when little all it did was teach you that it wasn’t that bad.

larrygrylls · 28/06/2020 19:05

Thedancing,

Your experiences of growing up were clearly very different to mine. And, I suspect, you are conflating smacking with beating.

I don't smack my children (probably have a handful of times in their lives, and not for years now, and generally regretted it afterwards).

However, my late mother used smacking as a punishment and I can honestly say that I always had fair warning and, the few times I was smacked, decided that it was worth it to do what I wanted to do.

I can honestly say that I much preferred getting smacked to when my mother just went silent and became cold and upset.

It just isn't as black and white as people like to make out.

Oliversmumsarmy · 28/06/2020 19:04

I think I bored dc into behaving.

If they did mis behave I would get down to their level and slowly explain why you shouldn’t do what they had done and the consequences and dangers they could put themselves or other people in by doing what they did.

On the whole I think a 5 minute talk was worth more than the naughty step.

Ds has ADHD and Dd ADD so I didn’t worry too much about their behaviour. As long as they were not disturbing other people then it was fine.
If they wanted to run around the supermarket then they could. I would ask them to get things for me that I knew were on the lower shelves. They needed a lot of exercise.
Dd does a job now where she can work anything up to 16 hours and do anything from 27000 to sometimes 45000 steps in a day.
Ds is similar. I could never imagine them doing a job which involved a lot of sitting down,

xmummy2princesx · 28/06/2020 19:00

No I would never hit

thedancingbear · 28/06/2020 18:59

larrygrylls, I'm not sure if you seriously think these things, or if you're just being contrarian. If the latter, it's misjudged.

If it's not, your casual acceptance of violence against the defenceless makes me want to fucking puke.

HarryHarry · 28/06/2020 18:58

Once when my son was being really badly behaved my husband told me to give him a smack on the hand and at first I refused but then when I got desperate I tried it and though I didn’t hurt him at all it felt so horrible. My parents used corporal punishment that was more like child abuse (beat me with a stick, threw me at a wall). It has taken me a long time to feel OK with even knowing that I have the same blood as them. I never wanted to be anything like them and then suddenly I felt like I was. My son was so forgiving and I really felt like I didn’t deserve it. I would never ever ever do it again.

WaterOffADucksCrack · 28/06/2020 18:56

It is the smug superiority, based on zero actual evidence, that grates. It's not a question of "smug superiority" Hmm It's about not hurting children - humans who can't defend themselves.

larrygrylls · 28/06/2020 18:55

Swirly,

Considering you are looking for consistency in the way adults treat adults vs the way adults treat children.

'No. It teaches that actions have consequences. If you misbehave, you lose access to a toy. If you behave well, you get access to it. If you're having a hissy fit and can't be reasoned with, you go to your room until you have calmed down, and will resume talking when you are not in an extreme emotional place.

Taking away an iPad cannot be compared to stealing when the parent has bought it in the first place.'

Losing an access to a toy is not a 'consequence', it is a punishment, no more or less so than smacking. If a child refuses to go out of the house to school, for instance, there is no natural correlation between this and losing a toy.

Re your IPad example, I think it is awful that a child would believe that his continued ownership was contingent upon behaviour. So, in your eyes, is the Ipad merely loaned, rather than a gift? As, if it is a gift, it is the receiver's in law, and taking it back is theft (and you can go to jail for it if you do it to another adult).

thedancingbear · 28/06/2020 18:55

All of which you get prison time for. So why is it remotely ok to punish children with physical discipline?

The answer, when you boil it down, is because the parent can get away with it. The exact reason why some men beat their wives. One is no better than the other.

This is a useful thread in a way. It reminds of some of the BLM threads which have helped illuminate that there are, unfortunately, plenty of racist arseholes still out there. In the same way, this shows just how many parents are still willing to belt their kids.

thedancingbear · 28/06/2020 18:51

So, is violence never OK, regardless of provocation?

Larrygrylls, the idea that you'd hit a kid not to discipline it, but because it had provoked you, is fucking chilling.

How often do women come on here saying their partners have hit them? Is 'you provoked him' ever, EVER, a valid response?

Self-defence is a separate thing, but I expect the situations where a parent has to hit their child back to avoid worse harm to themselves is vanishingly rare. I'm mystified why the phrase is coming up in a conversation about corporal punishment of kids.

Swirlyceiling · 28/06/2020 18:40

So, is violence never OK, regardless of provocation?

If a parent smacked a child I would back the child if they hit back in self defence. Nobody has to be the first one to hit, and as their care givers, we should not be teaching children that violence is the answer whwn you are in a disagreement.

If you were to hit another adult (not in self defence) it is assault.

If you are to hit your partner, it is assault.

If you hit your elderly relative with dementia, it is assault.

All of which you get prison time for. So why is it remotely ok to punish children with physical discipline?

So does confiscation of toys teach kids to steal, or sending a child to their room teach them to ostracise other children?

No. It teaches that actions have consequences. If you misbehave, you lose access to a toy. If you behave well, you get access to it. If you're having a hissy fit and can't be reasoned with, you go to your room until you have calmed down, and will resume talking when you are not in an extreme emotional place.

Taking away an iPad cannot be compared to stealing when the parent has bought it in the first place.

It is the smug superiority, based on zero actual evidence, that grates.

If you research it there is a lot of evidence in regards to the psychological effects of physical discipline. Conditioning to think you deserved to be hit, compliance through fear and damage that does to self esteem.

Imagine a man/woman is in an abusive relationship. Their partner hits them and gaslights them, saying you made me do that to you because of x reason. If they've been conditioned in to fear based compliance and also thinking they deserved to be hit, they will probably roll over and take it for many years until either they question it and try and summon the courage to leave, until somebody points it out, or until something worse happens to them.

Somebody who has been taught that it has never ok to hit somebody (unless in self defence) is much less likely to do so. They are also less likely to be physically violent themselves.

PreggoFeminist86 · 28/06/2020 18:38

I think it is fucking disgusting. It is abuse of power, and there a million ways to constructively discipline your children without using pain. It teaches children that violence is acceptable.

It boggles the mind that it is legal to hit an innocent child, but illegal to hit an adult.

Swirlyceiling · 28/06/2020 18:31

Can anyone suggest how I deal with my DD when she is hitting, punching, kicking and screaming at me? Geuinine question. If anyone read my previous post I said she is being assessed for autism

Huge amounts of praise when she does do things well

If she leaves time out, stick her back in it. If she has to be in time out for 2 minutes, and she leaves, put her back in and that time restarts at 0 minutes. After some repetition, she will figure out that the more she leaves, the further away her freedom gets. Create a safe time out zone where she can kick off it she wants to, bean bags and things, being tested for suspected autistism if she does lash out she is less likely to hurt herself. She comes out of time out when she is calm only.

What is she willing to change her behaviour for? Access to, or loss of access to, toys? Tv? A chocolate button? (I've seen people make reward charts from chocolate buttons to help the kids get the idea and then they switch to stickers later, seeing the actual reward is helpful).

larrygrylls · 28/06/2020 18:25

'Hitting kids teaches kids to hit.'

So does confiscation of toys teach kids to steal, or sending a child to their room teach them to ostracise other children?

'Secondly, it teaches children that violence is ok in certain circumstances, which is the opposite of what we should teach them.'

So, is violence never OK, regardless of provocation?

Smacking/not smacking is cultural, whether people want to believe it or not.

I don't think we want to reintroduce smacking and it really is not acceptable now, but, equally, I don't think a lot of 'modern' parents parent any better than their own parents and grandparents, who did smack. It is the smug superiority, based on zero actual evidence, that grates.

Swirlyceiling · 28/06/2020 18:19

It's not ok at all. Firstly, why do people want to condition their children in to doing/not doing things through fear? That shit shakes you up for life and you don't suddenly grow out of that when you aren't a child any more.

Secondly, it teaches children that violence is ok in certain circumstances, which is the opposite of what we should teach them.

Finally, I know so many parents that scream at their children 'HOW DARE YOU HIT MUMMY' when their kids lash out during an argument. Hey, maybe lead by example and don't hit them? Why is it ok for adults to smack when they are angry, but not children? Children don't know how to express extreme emotions properly and need help and guidance to do so. One rule for adults and one for kids (when it comes to smacking) is not ok.

In my experience, people that smack their children regularly have never been taught communication skills or are a bit thick, maybe a bit old fashioned so these things are passed on through generations of bad communicators with limited empathetic ability.

Casschops · 28/06/2020 18:06

As much as there are times where my son drives me spare. I would never hit him. I class it as assault if it was an adult it would be. I don't know how people can.

Nottherealslimshady · 28/06/2020 17:02

Hitting kids teaches kids to hit.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 17:02

Hitting wives was also the norm for a long time. Are we going to pontificate about whether they're hardier or happier now than then, as if that's in any way relevant?

gonesolo · 28/06/2020 16:54

Justmemyself

I'm not sure it's helpful to compare to animals. Violence is a routine part of life for many animals (males fighting to prove rank etc). While some humans fight each other on the streets we don't exactly want a society where physical scraps are an accepted way of conflict resolution.

Hitting children might've been the norm for many decades, but surely we try to progress as civilisation as we become more enlightened?

Morally, how can it be right to hit a vulnerable person? Would people who smack their kids also condone smacking their grandparent with Alzheimers with challenging behaviour, or an adult with the mental age of a child who acts accordingly? I think we would agree that it would be very wrong.