Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 29/06/2020 20:26

Who wants toif , as an adult , the only way to deal with an unruly kid is to slap them, then you're the one with issues , not the kid.

Would you be happy if teachers started slapping kids around again? Your own kid?

Kalifa · 29/06/2020 20:16

I am no fan of violence but some kids only learn and understand from a slap. Nothing else will stop them. Of course nobody here would slap their own kids (or won’t admit to it) but when you have a bunch of kids to look after and one starts to terrorise the others or smash the house or scream down the roof because he is a devious little c... are you going to go down to his level and start begging him and use the word please? You can’t reason with him. You give him three warnings and it doesn’t work, you’ll slap him and that’s the only thing that will stop the little shit. Who wants to explain to and beg an unreasonable little kid for years? If you do that, by the time they are big enough you will be a mental vegetable who lives on prozac.

Baluchistan95 · 29/06/2020 20:07

@Sizedoesmatter

Baluchistan95 I'm shocked that you don't understand the concept of having a debate and hearing other people's opinions on a topic, something this website is designed for 🤷‍♀️ if you're going to be unnecessarily rude I suggest you scroll on.
Of course, you can suggest all you want. Please do feel free to show everyone where I have been rude. Just to reiterate my comments, I'm shocked that you need to ask the question whether it is okay or not to violently assault a child. Honestly, this is so worrying.
breakfastclubb · 29/06/2020 19:56

@strugglingwithdeciding

Discussed this with friends all brought up in 70 & 80's and those of us who were smacked very occasionally have no hate towards our parents or feel we suffer from it Those whose parents used it regularly and for anything and everything have very different feelings
That won’t be the same for everyone though. And you seem to be implying that occasional smacking must only be for particularly serious things so less likely to seem unfair, or that it’s less likely to cause harm because it doesn’t happen much.

That’s not how I feel, at all. I was smacked only rarely, by my dad, and it absolutely did cause me harm and make me feel negatively towards him. It mostly wasn’t because I’d done something especially bad, but because on those occasions he was in an especially bad mood and he totally lost it.

strugglingwithdeciding · 29/06/2020 19:35

Discussed this with friends all brought up in 70 & 80's and those of us who were smacked very occasionally have no hate towards our parents or feel we suffer from it
Those whose parents used it regularly and for anything and everything have very different feelings

strugglingwithdeciding · 29/06/2020 19:33

So some on here thing no consequence at all ie taking away an ipad etc
That isn't teaching them anything there is consequences faced in life with every decision you make
If your late for work consistently do you think there wont be a consequence , even adults face these daily so not to teach a child is wrong
Taking a ipad off then isnt just about taking the item , its the use of screen time / internet of which the child does not own etc
My son xbox was a gift so therefore if he wishes to play it 24/7 and refuses to come off , should i just let him as after all he owns it

ShebaShimmyShake · 29/06/2020 10:03

I mean no disrespect to people of my parents' age, but purely from my personal experience of my parents and my friends' parents...they all say that getting walloped as kids didn't do them any harm, but I and my friends would most definitely disagree. Delightful, well-balanced, emotionally mature and mentally healthy individuals they are not.

If you have to tell your kids that they're not harmed by what you did to them then they almost certainly are.

Massive, huge respect and thanks to parents of that age on here who realise it was wrong and wish they could change it. That does in fact make all the difference.

jessstan2 · 29/06/2020 10:00

It is bullying to slap a child and serves no purpose except to humiliate them.

luminette · 29/06/2020 09:51

Of course it’s not ok. And I’m really shocked by those claiming there is no evidence against it - there is loads, including links with depression and other mental health problems, suicide and addiction, and either perpetrating or being victims of domestic abuse.

Yes, lots of people smacked their children in decades gone by - back when people basically believed children should learn to obey adults without question, to be compliant, to be seen and not heard.

Nowadays there is perhaps more understanding that children need to learn to make good choices for themselves and not just be scared or beaten into submission. And also that bringing children up to obey adults without question and feel no ownership or agency over their own bodies might not actually be a good idea.

It isn’t ok to assault someone just because you have reached boiling point. It just isn’t.

People who smack like to claim that they only use it in a completely reasonable way, despite the fact that they’re either doing it because they lost their temper, or because they’re making a calculated decision to assault their child - both are utterly fucked up, and I refuse to deny that just to avoid hurting the feelings of someone who is offended by being told that inflicting physical pain and humiliation on their children is selfish and wrong.

However offended you feel, it’s nothing compared to how your child feels when you hit them.

Hailtomyteeth · 29/06/2020 09:08

I did it, in the eighties.

I was wrong.

Sizedoesmatter · 29/06/2020 09:05

People love to give out about children and teenagers. Years ago when I worked in a local shop, I always found the teenagers to be some of the most polite customers. It was the middle aged and older customers who were rude and spoke horribly to staff 90% of the time. It was very rare that a teenager or younger person left without saying thank you 🤷‍♀️ anecdotal I know but just an observation.

I do think that older generations like to look down in the younger generations, and I disagree with it. If people really think that the way to make children behave, and that bad behaviour in schools is down to not hitting them, then their part of a much bigger problem.

OP posts:
corythatwas · 29/06/2020 08:49

If the decline of corporal punishment is the reason that behaviour in schools is worse now than it was 50 years ago, how do you explain that behaviour in schools has also declined within the same time span in countries where corporal punishment was already banned 50 years ago?

In fact, my parents who were teachers used to read with some kind of horrified amusement about the poor behaviour in English schools in the 70s. (Now they admit they are glad not to be teaching in any country.)

Thornhill58 · 29/06/2020 01:08

So far so good no need to smack them. Now even if I wanted to he is 14 taller than me and a black belt in karate. I'll have to chase him first and that means running. I'll pass.

Bouledeneige · 29/06/2020 00:56

I don't think I've ever hit anyone do I'm not sure why I would have broken that rule by starting on my kids. I really never needed to to have authority.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 21:17

Eh? Someone said they'd hit their kids but apologise if it didn't actually stop them from misbehaving? Either I've missed something or smackers are even....less clever than I've been giving them credit for. And I don't give them much, believe me.

wanderings · 28/06/2020 21:17

@LizzyAnna99

I was hit as a child and now I think if I’m getting shouted at by someone (through school etc) then I would be hit for it. I’m very anxious now.

How can you hit someone you love?

Me too. Because of this, I avoid confrontation, sometimes doing myself a disservice because of it. The times I think were especially damaging were when I was smacked for something I didn't know was wrong. How was I to know that the man on the pavement was blind, that he would stop walking suddenly, and I would bump into him? My mum carefully explained why I shouldn't have bumped into him, then she smacked me. It's a memory that's followed me into adulthood, and it made me fearful of days out, in case I got smacked unexpectedly, and had the humiliation of being made to cry in public.

The other day, I saw a small child heading towards a road. The child was promptly grabbed by the parent, and rightly so, and it was a relief not to see the child being smacked, which would almost certainly have happened if it was the 1980s; that child would then be crying and unable to hear the parent's message that it's dangerous to run towards a road.

A book from the 1980s arguing against hitting children observed: "many parents regard it not just as a right, but as their duty to hit their children. Our language has developed a remarkable vocabulary to cover hitting children: slapping, smacking, spanking, clipping, clouting, walloping, tanning, cuffing, six of the best, slippering, whacking..."

gonesolo · 28/06/2020 21:08

It is the smug superiority, based on zero actual evidence, that grates.

This is about our moral code. Should we as a society condone hitting children? I think the gradual consensus of opinion is no - not ever. There may very well be no actual evidence but then do we need any? We decided it was right to ban fox hunting, corporal punishment etc etc on the basis that we think it's morally wrong.

You're right - it is a cultural thing but like so many issues, attitudes change gradually and I personally think we will see more and more countries following suit.

WaterOffADucksCrack · 28/06/2020 20:51

I'm glad you asked that than just throwing verbal abuse my way So your kids have do deal with being smacked but you can't take people disagreeing with you and call it verbal abuse?

I'm not afraid of apologising if it doesn't work. Aplogising doesn't make it ok. 2 of my friends parents have been stopped from having relationships with their grandchildren because they hit their children.

You're actively planning and visualising physically abusing your children - human beings who can't defend themselves.

ShebaShimmyShake · 28/06/2020 20:43

Haha yeah, the 1960s. The decade when young people were so deferential, proper and adherent to traditional rules and ideas about respect and behaviour! Anyone who truly believes that really must have been on acid the whole time.

FudgeBrownie2019 · 28/06/2020 20:29

It just isn't as black and white as people like to make out.

It really is. If someone smaller and more vulnerable than you displeases you, you're not allowed to hit them. Not because you got cross, not because they worried you, not because you were having a shite day, not because anything. You just don't need to smack children to encourage good behaviour.

DS1 has autism and I genuinely believe if I had ever smacked him I would have lost his trust. He knows I absolutely have his back, he knows my expectations, he knows how to manage himself well, he knows how to show respect and he knows never to resolve issues with violence. There are and were consequences for crappy behaviour, but they were always consequences which helped him learn and having read the full thread I am no more convinced that there's ever a justified reason for slapping a child.

LizzyAnna99 · 28/06/2020 20:22

I was hit as a child and now I think if I’m getting shouted at by someone (through school etc) then I would be hit for it. I’m very anxious now.

How can you hit someone you love?

Nonnymum · 28/06/2020 20:13

What your saying doesn’t add up though. Because people used to hit their children far more frequently and children and teenagers had A LOT MORE respect for general society
I don't think this is true at all. I was at a child in the 60s and 70s I don't think kids had particular respect for their elders or society at all. Young people today seem much more thoughtful and caring than when I was young. Maybe we were scared of adults but we didn't respect those adults who hit us . We made fun of them behind their backs and hated them. Respect has to be earned and you don't get it just because you are bigger and stronger.
Also as I said upthread it was always the same children at school being smacked, sometimes several times a day so it didn't work.

Sizedoesmatter · 28/06/2020 20:11

I'm honestly very surprised by a lot of the responses and the fact that a lot of people agreeing with hitting children, believe it's OK to hit toddlers.. I have an almost 20 month old and I couldn't for one second imagine hitting him. Would those people also hit a puppy if it was bold? It's extremely sad that people in this day and age still believe young children can possibly deserve to be physically assaulted.

OP posts:
Sizedoesmatter · 28/06/2020 20:08

Baluchistan95 I'm shocked that you don't understand the concept of having a debate and hearing other people's opinions on a topic, something this website is designed for 🤷‍♀️ if you're going to be unnecessarily rude I suggest you scroll on.

OP posts:
Nonnymum · 28/06/2020 19:53

I can’t imagine what messed up message a child receives when someone physically assaults them and then hugs them.
Absolutely. Like others I found that post chilling Also snowybean at what age would you do that. You say 6 months is too young, at 12 months, 28 months, 2 years?