Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
Coffeecak3 · 29/06/2020 22:23

@clockworkprincess how do you feel about your dp smacking your dc?
I smacked(tapped) my son's leg twice in his life and feel like the worst parent ever, my dd got one tap also. My dh has never smacked our dc and i told him when i did it and he was so disappointed in me.
Neither of my two( adults now) have any memory of being smacked and my dd says a raised voice scared her most.
I think smacking is pointless, harmful and unecessary but shouting is not much better.

Pp's who say they wouldn't slap another adult at work presumably wouldn't yell at another adult either in the workplace.

PablosHoney · 29/06/2020 22:23

I think the umbrage comes because deep down they know it’s wrong

ShebaShimmyShake · 29/06/2020 22:21

Always interesting when smackers don't see the point in explaining things to kids and reasoning with them. Rather like when they also think hitting kids is fine but salty comments about it on the internet are abusive.

breakfastclubb · 29/06/2020 22:14

@Kalifa

I am no fan of violence but some kids only learn and understand from a slap. Nothing else will stop them. Of course nobody here would slap their own kids (or won’t admit to it) but when you have a bunch of kids to look after and one starts to terrorise the others or smash the house or scream down the roof because he is a devious little c... are you going to go down to his level and start begging him and use the word please? You can’t reason with him. You give him three warnings and it doesn’t work, you’ll slap him and that’s the only thing that will stop the little shit. Who wants to explain to and beg an unreasonable little kid for years? If you do that, by the time they are big enough you will be a mental vegetable who lives on prozac.
If your child behaves like this it’s because you’re violent. You’re not violent because of their behaviour.
Clockworkprincess · 29/06/2020 22:08

I was smacked as a kid, don't actually remember any occasions to be precise though. One punishment i do remember is being sent to bed and missing brownies that week, i remember almost every detail. I have a ds4, dp does smack occasionally but i don't. On the days he's pushed me too far i will go upstairs and just have a cry. It gives us both the time out really

PablosHoney · 29/06/2020 22:02

I was smacked every now and then, didn’t affect me but I still don’t think it’s a valid discipline tool

corythatwas · 29/06/2020 21:58

Kalifa. the bit I was referring to was this:"Except what you leave out of the equation is that the kid has probably annoyed the shit out of her all day when she finally snapped in Tesco." That is not someone applying discipline but (as you yourself admit) losing control, snapping.

MoreThanJustANumber · 29/06/2020 21:57

I don't have children but I was hit as a child. It was premeditated, punishment for minor things that I didn't really understand. It was humiliating and painful.

For many years I thought it did me no harm but now, in my 50s, I realise it's one of the reasons I'm so scared of upsetting people and so desperate to please. I'm a bag of nerves half the time but hide it well and as I work through it I'm so angry at my father who was the disciplinarian. My mother had no idea how bad it was, and is massively apologetic that she allowed it to happen.

In a lot of ways it has ruined me, destroyed my ability to have good relationships because I'm so nervous of people. I'm very sad about it. Please don't hit your children. It's not something a loving parent should do.

PablosHoney · 29/06/2020 21:46

They can be so bloody annoying but so are a lot of people and I wouldn’t hit them so why would I hit my child.

ShebaShimmyShake · 29/06/2020 21:42

I am just permanently amazed by people who keep whining "but kids can be so annnnooooyyyiiinnng...." Yes, yes they can. They're kids, it's their job. You're the grown up and the parent. What's yours?

Kalifa · 29/06/2020 21:41

corythatwas it is not my fault that your comprehension is inadequate. You are another one who starts talking about a completely different subject to the original thread.
This thread is about disciplining children, not slapping grown ups about.I don’t know about you but I don’t tend to discipline adults such as the elderly, let alone hit them. Maybe you are from another part of the country where people practice that habit.

SwelteringInTheHeat · 29/06/2020 21:37

Or what about an elderly person? They can certainly be annoying. I am sure my mother often felt like slapping her mother-in-law, the woman who criticised her children and ran a finger across the mantelpiece to see if she had dusted and complained about the food. Would you not feel you had the right to judge somebody who slapped an elderly lady in the supermarket because they might have been annoying them all day?

Or a carer to a person with dementia? People can justify this all they want. If you wouldn't accept someone slapping you because your behaviour annoys them, then why is justified to do it to your child?

If that child grows up to be a domestic abuser or a victim, because they see physically violence as an acceptable form of control, would you reconsider your position?

PablosHoney · 29/06/2020 21:35

How many times with this same old shite

corythatwas · 29/06/2020 21:29

when you have a bunch of kids to look after and one starts to terrorise the others or smash the house or scream down the roof because he is a devious little c... are you going to go down to his level and start begging him and use the word please?

Do you really think those are the only options?

corythatwas · 29/06/2020 21:28

When your kid is a grown man of six feet, or an adult woman with a black belt in karate, will you still do this or will you magically find another way to manage your anger and frustration when faced with someone who can flatten you?

This.

Or what about an elderly person? They can certainly be annoying. I am sure my mother often felt like slapping her mother-in-law, the woman who criticised her children and ran a finger across the mantelpiece to see if she had dusted and complained about the food. Would you not feel you had the right to judge somebody who slapped an elderly lady in the supermarket because they might have been annoying them all day?

ShebaShimmyShake · 29/06/2020 21:17

@Kalifa

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble This is what gets me. The I am such a mature grown up I have the patience of a saint and all kind of psychological magical tools to deal with deviant behaviour bullshit. Everybody starts with good intentions, they swear they won’t even raise their voice with kids let alone slap them. That’s a beautiful theory. But you know the shitty reality is unfortunately different. Kids can be energy syphoning vampires and some of them just WON’T listen and WON’T learn. So when you are in the supermarket and you see a tired looking mum giving a slap to her screaming kid, all you see is a snapshot of their life and you are horrified by the abuse you witnessed. Except what you leave out of the equation is that the kid has probably annoyed the shit out of her all day when she finally snapped in Tesco.
So it is presumably ok to slap anyone else if they annoy you until you "finally snap"?

When your kid is a grown man of six feet, or an adult woman with a black belt in karate, will you still do this or will you magically find another way to manage your anger and frustration when faced with someone who can flatten you?

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 29/06/2020 21:15

The I am such a mature grown up I have the patience of a saint and all kind of psychological magical tools to deal with deviant behaviour bullshit.

Do I fuck . With my own kid I don't want to become my mother, it's that simple. I've seen glimpses of her in my behaviour when DD was little and it scared the crap out of me. I fucked up many times, I will fuck up again.

With other people's kids , and I work with them, I can't afford to get all ragey and trust me I've had lots of shit thrown at me by kids. Not just because I'd lose my job/get arrested but for my own (mental)well-being and theirs.
A lot of them have sufferers abuse,neglect, poverty, have chaotic home lives, have been made homeless, have been or are into care , have significant SEN etc. For a lot of them school is their safe place.

I want to educate children in more ways than one, not break them.

Rewis · 29/06/2020 21:05

It is a soft no form me. I don't approve of it, but I would report it to social services or police if I knew/saw someone else do it.

ShebaShimmyShake · 29/06/2020 21:02

I am no fan of violence but some kids only learn and understand from a slap. Nothing else will stop them

Then you are a fan of violence. And not a good parent. I think only a slap will stop you, it's the only thing you understand. Can I come over?

Kalifa · 29/06/2020 20:55

Oliversmumsarmy this thread is not about belting kids.

Kalifa · 29/06/2020 20:49

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble
This is what gets me. The I am such a mature grown up I have the patience of a saint and all kind of psychological magical tools to deal with deviant behaviour bullshit.
Everybody starts with good intentions, they swear they won’t even raise their voice with kids let alone slap them. That’s a beautiful theory. But you know the shitty reality is unfortunately different. Kids can be energy syphoning vampires and some of them just WON’T listen and WON’T learn.
So when you are in the supermarket and you see a tired looking mum giving a slap to her screaming kid, all you see is a snapshot of their life and you are horrified by the abuse you witnessed. Except what you leave out of the equation is that the kid has probably annoyed the shit out of her all day when she finally snapped in Tesco.

Cam2020 · 29/06/2020 20:42

It's a no from me too. I can't imagine ever wanting to hit my child. My daughter is three and has really pushed my buttons on occasion. I feel bad enough losing my temper and yelling the odd time. To me smacking is just teaching children to deal with frustration/anger with violence.

MarshaBradyo · 29/06/2020 20:41

Kalifa you’re managing to sound like a fan of violence. Do you have dc?

Oliversmumsarmy · 29/06/2020 20:39

some kids only learn and understand from a slap

All they learn is not to get caught again or it is just a consequence that they aren’t too fussed about.

I knew a boy who’s dad would belt him.
By the time he got to about 9 or 10 years old he would goad his father with “what are you going to do? Hit me”

If you have to resort to hitting I ask what happens when hitting no longer works.

I did get down to their level and ask them to stop doing what they were doing and why. I did it every time.
As I said upthread I think I bored mine into behaving.

Although having got 1 with ADHD and 1 with ADD the shouting and running around and climbing the curtains was just normal behaviour and not considered naughty

strugglingwithdeciding · 29/06/2020 20:29

@breakfastclubb no wont be same for all but like you said he used it as he was in a bad mood etc , thats different
But you know what if someone occasionally smacks their child within the law I am also not about to judge them as I am bit in their shoes
Before having kids i never intended to shout at my kids , they would eat only helathy well balanced meals , sweets would be rare etc , but there you go
In general though i have 2 well balanced , well behaved polite kids despite getting im sure a lot wrong along the way , they only hate me sometimes