Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
flamingochill · 27/06/2020 14:17

It's never ok. I've got teens who have pushed me to the edge but I've never done it.

cushioncovers · 27/06/2020 14:16

Mine dc are adults now. But yes I did smack them occasionally when they were younger. I always felt bad afterwards and would end up apologising to them.

As a child myself my mother smacked us but my father always lashed out with his words. Years later we laugh about my mother reaching for the wooden spoon. We don't laugh about the cruel words my father used to say. They still haunt me as an adult.

Thelittleweasel · 27/06/2020 14:14

@CantKeepSecrets

Oh thank goodness. If an adult hits another adult = "assault" and if it involved pulling down underwear = "indecent assault".

It cannot be right to hit children and thank goodness that most have that awareness.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 27/06/2020 14:11

I did wallop my DS across the bum because of his actions (he was mucking about despite several warnings , putting DS and DD on either side of me , telling them not to change sides , not to cross in front of me - none of it worked )

My DS was maybe 5-6 at the time and very nearly caused a vunerable eldery man on sticks/crutches to fall as DS was just about to dart in front of him.

My DS got a smacked bum ( I grabbed him too , my DS could wriggle out of my grasp though)
The elderly man didn't land face down on marble floring with several fractures .

I am not at all repentant at my action.

Nonononon · 27/06/2020 14:11

It's a no from me. There has been times where dd has really pushed my buttons and I've felt like it and thats bad enough. It scares me.
My mum used to really lose control when she used to beat me. I'd literally be in corner with her punching and stamping on my head over and over again. It was awful and is something I still think about 20 years on..needless to say i am NC with her now.
I know my experience is on the more extreme end but it has made me feel very strongly about hitting children.
The emotional side of its worse than the pain. As a child you think, how can my parent do? You feel so.. unloved and like a piece of shit tbh and no child should have to feel like that.
And know people will come on and say "yes but what happened to you was abuse not just a smack on the bum" etc etc and yeah I get that but to me, the fear of losing control (like she did) is really scary to me and id rather just not get close to that line, let alone cross it.

randolph78 · 27/06/2020 13:59

Absolute no from me. I was hit and it did do me lasting harm. How would you know whether your kid would be one of the 'did me no harm' or one of the 'did me lasting harm' brigade? Seems like a silly risk to take when there is plenty of evidence that corporal punishment is never necessary.

Cauterize · 27/06/2020 13:58

I've done it in the past and always felt incredibly guilty. It was done out of pure frustration on my part and achieved absolutely nothing. I haven't smacked in a long time and do not intend to again.

TeamLannister · 27/06/2020 13:57

No, never, ever ok.

Bluntness100 · 27/06/2020 13:53

Hard no from me.

The only time I’d find physical violence acceptable is when I knocked several barrels of shit out of someone I saw hitting a child.

It’s never ok. Ever.

whattimeisitrightnow · 27/06/2020 13:52

Also, people saying 'well, you wouldn't discipline another adult anyway' are missing the point. If you told another adult to go to their room, they'd look at you like you were bonkers, obviously, but if you hit them they would call the police. You are deciding that your children have fewer legal rights to protection and safety than those older than them, which is so depressing Sad
I can't imagine intentionally harming any child, let alone one I loved more than anything else in the world. The main purpose of a parent is to keep kids safe - how, exactly, are they safe if they're being hit?

Gatr · 27/06/2020 13:49

Hard no from me. I also dont agree with the use of smack, lets call it what it is which is hitting.

I can never decide which is worse, hitting because you've lost it or hitting as a cold deliberate act.

If in a fit of anger where you want to inflict pain/fear into the child because you have completely lost control of yourself. Or if as people often say "i hadnt lost control, i knew it was only light and i decided to because of xyz", where people in the cold light of day, decide that hitting their child is acceptable and that fear is the best way.

We teach kids its not okay to hit, so why can we hit them? Is it because we are more powerful than them? As adults we should have the skills to regulate our emotions much better than a five year old.

I am slightly more sympathetic in some of the extreme situations eg. I watched a little girl who did something very dangerous, her mum screemed and lightly hit her whilst shouting. The mum was clearly in a state on panic, hugged the girl and apologised explaining how frightened she had been.

whattimeisitrightnow · 27/06/2020 13:49

@Userzzz
It doesn't 'show your daughter who is in charge', it shows her that you've lost control and authority and are desperately trying to regain it, which is exactly the opposite.
If your DD reaches boiling point with another child at school and 'smacks' them, will you tell her that it's okay? What if the two of you argue and she decides you aren't listening to her so she socks you in the mouth - is that fine too? How do you get her to understand that certain types of violence are acceptable because mummy is the one perpetrating but otherwise it isn't okay?

In answer to your question, OP, no it isn't acceptable. It sends shudders down my spine when people justify it using phrases like 'firm, loving discipline' or 'this hurts me more than it hurts you' - no, it bloody well doesn't.
It doesn't teach children anything. It doesn't show them how healthy relationships work, it doesn't teach them to deal with strong emotions, it doesn't explain to them why their behaviour is wrong. It frightens them into submission.
It also makes them far more likely to end up in an abusive relationship when they grow up, either as the victim or the perpetrator, because they associate violence with love. They know that the person or people who loved them most in the world (supposedly) assaulted them regularly as a means of caring for them. So they internalise that sort of treatment and then either accept it from future partners or lash out themselves.

User8008135 · 27/06/2020 13:46

No i don't like it. It's wrong and done to relieve your own temper and frustration. And yes to my guilt I've done it twice and nearly a third. My then toddler pushing my buttons badly and i was already in a bad place mentally. I got cbt for the cause of my stress and depression which helped immensely.

I feel awful thinking of it. I'd never consider using it for discipline. All those i know who do smack in anger so just releasing their own irritation too.

SickOfNorthernExile · 27/06/2020 13:45

No never.

My mum smacked us as kids, as did my stepfather. It really lessened my respect for them both, and broke some deep trust- at the time ofc I couldn’t articulate it that way, but with hindsight it’s easy to see.

I’ll be honest, I’m a LP and DS has pushed me right to the limit, but I’ve always walked away. Occasionally needed to close the door and chuck a cushion across my bedroom, scream silently into a pillow, or whatever- when you have “nowhere to go” and no other adult to hand over to, it can be hard to know what to do with that intensity of emotion- and it’s okay - healthy- to express it. But never by hitting your child. Ever.

As a considered method of discipline it’s of course fruitless at best, traumatising and injurious at worst.

bringincrazyback · 27/06/2020 13:35

It's a hard no from me too.

I was smacked as a child. It did me harm, both physically and emotionally.

fandajji · 27/06/2020 13:35

I'm against it and haven't done it. However I don't think the adult comparison worked. If a work colleague continuously harassed me for something after I had said no, then threw something at me and went to hit me they would get a snack right in the face before they hit me first! When my 4 year old does it he moves straight to red on the behaviour chart and has 10 minutes in reflection time and then a talk about controlling anger...

YorkshireParentalPerson · 27/06/2020 13:35

My mum was very quick with her hands and whatever else she could get her hands on to hit me with.

My son is 16 now and I have smacked his hand 4 times when he was small. Twice as a discipline, twice because he was in danger and I was scared. I'm not proud of it.

I once found myself on the verge of hitting him because I was so angry with him. I made sure he was safe in his room and then locked myself in the bathroom and cried. I have never hit him from that day to this. I realised that my mum had hit me all those times not because of anything I had done wrong but because she was angry. I did not want to become that woman.

I changed the way I disciplined my son from that moment forward. How could I ask him not to hit people and then hit him myself. I and my husband modeled the behavior we wanted him to see and used time outs as discipline.

My son has turned out a respectful, funny, kind young man. More importantly he is not afraid to get out of bed in a morning for fear of me. Hopefully when he has children he will never feel the need to smack his children. Ever.

FudgeBrownie2019 · 27/06/2020 13:34

I still think smacking is not ok, but its ridiculous to liken the parenting relationship to adult relationships.

Adults are supposed to be the ones in control, setting the example, guiding their DC. When my 14 year old behaves like a bellend and I get cross with him, I am the finished article, I am the one in control of my emotions, my behaviour, he's a 14 year old with hormones and lizard-reflexes and all that nonsense going on. To compare slapping a child to slapping an adult is ridiculous because a child is the most vulnerable person imaginable and still posters on here go "oh but it makes them listen to me". I bet it fucking does. I bet they listen to you bang on about how if they'd not done x, y and z you wouldn't have needed to slap them and they turn that shit inwards so it eats away at their self esteem nicely.

Fucking awful. If you wouldn't slap an adult for behaving badly there's no legitimate excuse for slapping a child. Ever.

MojoJojo71 · 27/06/2020 13:33

It’s never OK to slap anyone. It’s even worse when it’s someone vulnerable like a child.

If your husband ‘reached boiling point’ and you were ‘refusing to listen’ and he slapped you, you’d be advised to LTB but a child doesn’t have that option

DramaAlpaca · 27/06/2020 13:29

I've managed to raise three children to adulthood without ever smacking any of them. I was never smacked either, I'm glad to say as a child of the 60s/70s. It's never OK.

Jeezoh · 27/06/2020 13:25

Never done it, never would do it and totally judge people who do it regularly as a punishment. It’s not acceptable to hit another adult, how can you possibly justify hitting a child.

I can kind of understand people who do it once and are then contrite but anything more seems pre-meditated.

FudgeBrownie2019 · 27/06/2020 13:25

In my opinion slapping isn't discipline. It's violence.

I grew up in foster care and experienced violence alongside other abuse. Not once did I ever question it - it was what I believed I deserved. It's only as an adult that I was able reconcile the fact that adults who need to abuse and slap children have problems they aren't able to slap their way out of. And the whole "never did me any harm" is bollocks - yes it did, if you think as an adult that the way to ensure your child behaves is to use the same violence upon them that was inflicted upon you, you didn't turn out alright at all.

We have two DC and I don't - and wouldn't - slap them. They are well-behaved, kind and decent children. They have manners, they have boundaries and they have every chance of growing up to be spectacular human beings without ever needing to be hit or slapped into submission.

Branleuse · 27/06/2020 13:24

well if you are at the end of your tether with an adult, you can change jobs, walk away, flip them the bird, decide never to have anything to do with them again, leave the relationship, or just decide theyre a fucking arsehole.
You cant really do that with your kids. Youre directly responsible for their behaviour. It is your circus and they are your monkeys

I still think smacking is not ok, but its ridiculous to liken the parenting relationship to adult relationships.

Userzzz · 27/06/2020 13:22

I smack once when I reach the boiling point and my DD is refusing to listen. I think it is an effective form of discipline as it kind of shocks her into listening and understanding whose in charge. It is by no means a sustained beating, one quick smack and that's it. I also have a few friends that do the same. I think there's lots of parents that do it but do not talk about it and I don't think there's anything wrong with it.

Meatshake · 27/06/2020 13:21

I smacked my eldest when I was quite unwell with post natal depression.

I now do not smack. If I feel the urge to smack I know that I need a time out, not her and that I might be starting to feel unwell again. It's not right to hit kids, bad behaviour is their way of processing big feelings and dangerous behaviour needs to be explained not stopped with a smack.