Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinion on slapping kids as discipline?

358 replies

Sizedoesmatter · 27/06/2020 12:36

Just curious to see what the general opinion is on using slapping or 'spanking' (I despise that word) children?

Mine is a very hard no. I don't agree with it in the slightest and I hate the argument of 'I was slapped and I turned out fine', in my opinion you didn't, because if you turned out fine you wouldn't be slapping your children. However 3 seperate sets of parents out of our friend group do use slapping as discipline, so it's obviously still quite common.

Is it ever OK to slap a child? Do you think it's an effective form of discipline? I got my fair share of whacks with the brush off the dustpan and brush or the wooden spoon. I can remember running from the house one day when my mother grabbed the sweeping brush during an argument. Can't say those experiences done me any good. Others may think different?

OP posts:
Procrastination4 · 27/06/2020 18:26

My two boys are now 26 and 30, and I know that it is possible to have discipline without slapping (or shouting for that matter, which is also inappropriate in my opinion). Firmness and routine and consistency are what matter, as well as reminding yourself that you are their parent, not their friend, and sometimes you have to insist on things that they don’t want. There’s plenty of time for friendship when they’re in their late teens, young adults. When children are young, they need boundaries and guidelines re. your expectations of them, behaviour-wise. That’s how you establish discipline, not by slapping or shouting at them. Discipline through fear is totally wrong, I think.

thedancingbear · 27/06/2020 18:24

nestisflown, sorry I will come back on that. I'm not trolling and am very happy to have a sensible discussion.

I found KKSlider's post problematic because it suggested hitting your kids in some situations, if not ideal, is excusable. It presents it as a grey area. I don't think we can treat it like that. First, on a fundamental level, I do think hitting a kid is potentially in the same category as a man hitting a woman - it's an abuse of a power relationship and on a moral basis I struggle to distinguish the two.

Second, if the discourse around the subject is not absolute - if we adopt a position that we shouldn't really hit our kids, but these things occasionally happen, you very quickly end up with posters saying things like braying the kids is 'tempting but ineffective' (a few posts above this one).

I don't think KKSlider is for a second an abuser (though if I'm completely honest I can't identify with the compulsion to hit my kids back). I do think there are plenty of people who need little excuse to hit their kids, and if we give them one, they'll fucking take it.

Do you see where I'm coming from now?

Imissmoominmama · 27/06/2020 18:23

I don’t see the point- what does smacking achieve?

That said, psychological type punishments like ignoring are just as bad imo.

Lockdownseperation · 27/06/2020 18:22

@Smileyaxolotl1

kaheki I’m not particularly pro smacking but your argument (which always comes up) is completely nonsensical unless you don’t believe children should receive any punishment at all. You wouldn’t send an adult to their room or put them on the naughty step or confiscate an item. You are also not responsible for the behaviour of other adults.
The state does send people to prison or confiscate earnings from crime or fine people. The British state doesn’t use corporal punishment.
Bluntness100 · 27/06/2020 18:21

Smacking always equals abuse, there is never justification. Whether it’s your child. Your spouse, your boss, your mum or a random stranger in the street you are slapping, hitting, punching or kicking, it doesn’t matter, it’s abuse.

Being a parent doesn’t give you the right to abuse your own in the name of discipline. Just like marriage doesn’t give you thr right to abuse your spouse in the same name.

Unless there is additional needs in the person hitting then it is always always abuse.

And yes I would have no qualms against abusing someone who I saw doing it. And I’d hope every single decent person would be the same. Sadly though they tend to hide it behind closed doors because they know it’s wrong. And they don’t want called out on it.

nestisflown · 27/06/2020 18:19

@thedancingbear
I can't see how a parent slapping their child is any better than a husband giving his wife a tap.

You said the above up thread. Now if you apply the scenario where the wife hits her husband in the face with a metal pot, is it wrong for the husband to push her back or smack her hand away? Even if you think that violence is never justified, lucky the law disagrees with your black and white view of the word and recognises there are limited circumstances where it will be justified or defendable. Self defence being one of them.

Hopeful57 · 27/06/2020 18:18

So some violence against kids is okay then.

No. Not okay in the sense that I would describe it as desirable. It's actually a very undesirable outcome.

But humans tend to have a reaction when somebody hits them in the face. Yes, even if that somebody is a child.

And if a mother slaps away the hand that just hurt her so badly that she required medical care? Seems like an instinctual response without conscious thought behind it to me. It's therefore imo excusable. (not a desirable outcome but still an excusable action... There's a difference.)

And it's just not comparable to somebody choosing to hurt their child or being unable to control themselves due to anger (or intoxication etc)..

Rosebel · 27/06/2020 18:18

I have given mine a tap on the back of their hand but that was in danger more than discipline (once when she ran in to the road and the other when she went for the iron).
I wouldn't use spanking as a discipline but I felt awful the two times that I tapped my children.
I didn't think any parents used hitting anymore.

Kljnmw3459 · 27/06/2020 18:16

Tempting!!!!! But ineffective. You feel bad, child feels bad and nobody's learnt anything.

nestisflown · 27/06/2020 18:12

@ thedancingbear you’re just being a troll now. You have your own narrative and you’re sticking to it. Not conducive to any discussion at all

KKSlider · 27/06/2020 18:12

Bye.

thedancingbear · 27/06/2020 18:11

So some violence against kids is okay then.

Fine, thanks for clarifying everyone and I'll change my views.

FFS. I'm out of here.

BostonCheers · 27/06/2020 18:10

I'd happily describe myself as a strict parent and I have always set quite strict rules for the DC in regards to bedtimes, screen time and studying/homework etc. But I do believe that smacking is abusive and causes all sorts of issues further down the line.

The issue imo is when parents do not set proper boundaries and they effectively use smacking as a substitute for actually parenting and disciplining their children.

KKSlider · 27/06/2020 18:10

I didn't hit him in anger, there was no calculation or pre-emption on my part. Car to face, I reacted with no thought, and then I realised what I'd done.

Hopeful57 · 27/06/2020 18:10

He wasn't a toddler, he was 8, he was having a meltdown which involved him screaming in my face whilst slapping me, slapping himself, biting, kicking. He had just smacked me in the forehead with a metal truck hard enough for me to require stitches, and in the split-second after it happened I slapped his hand. It was reactionary response to sudden shock and pain. I told the doctor at the walk in what had happened and that I was a terrible person, he told me I wasn't and that it was a knee (or in that case hand) jerk response.

I haven't read all the other responses. But I agree, this seems like an instinctual response. Not a case of "lashing" out...

BananaPop2020 · 27/06/2020 18:09

@LemonPeonies your response was really interesting as I too had an abusive first marriage, which I largely attribute to my having absolutely no idea of what a healthy loving relationship was meant to look like. In fact it is only in the last few years that I have reflected on how bad some of my childhood experiences were, and how much they have shaped me today. I don’t have kids, and I 100% link that decision to my upbringing.

thedancingbear · 27/06/2020 18:09

You still don't hit an 8-year old back out of anger. You just don't. Ever.

KKSlider · 27/06/2020 18:08

but Socrates did say they now lacked respect and are all tyrants!

It was said by Kenneth John Freeman in 1907 although the sentiment still stands because he was writing about the kids of 1907.

nestisflown · 27/06/2020 18:08

@thedancingbear If I had been hit without warning in the face by anyone welding a metal object, my natural instinct would be to hit/push back. You seem determined to see things as black and white. I think smacking as a form of discipline is wrong, but as a defensive response to the violent or dangerous extremities of some children’s behaviour - hitting/ pushing danger away can be an uncontrollable and human response.

I read somewhere an account of a mother who adopted a 3 year old who grew up in an abusive home. Recollecting the time the 3 year old bit her in the breast clamping down hard and her instinct was to throw him away. At that moment in time she wasn’t punishing or disciplining a child but literally responding in self defence to extreme violence on her person. Obviously once she had collected herself she felt extremely guilty but surely you can’t blame someone for being taken by surprise and momentarily forgetting they are responding to a child’s actions while self defensive instinct takes over.

KKSlider · 27/06/2020 18:06

In the second incident you described, you lashed out at your toddler (your words) because they'd hit you first

He wasn't a toddler, he was 8, he was having a meltdown which involved him screaming in my face whilst slapping me, slapping himself, biting, kicking. He had just smacked me in the forehead with a metal truck hard enough for me to require stitches, and in the split-second after it happened I slapped his hand. It was reactionary response to sudden shock and pain. I told the doctor at the walk in what had happened and that I was a terrible person, he told me I wasn't and that it was a knee (or in that case hand) jerk response.

SugarNyx · 27/06/2020 18:05

Don’t agree with it, think if you do it you’re a shit parent and I couldn’t be friends with anyone who thought it was ok either. My mum did it daily and I hate her for it, haven’t spoken to her in 10 years.

ElaineMarieBenes · 27/06/2020 17:57

@KKSlider - but Socrates did say they now lacked respect and are all tyrants!

Every generation complains about ‘the youth of today’ - one of my favourites is the dung throwing gangs in London (see ‘Securing Respect’ - Millie)

And no it is never ok to slap (or assault) anyone let alone a child

LondonJax · 27/06/2020 17:56

I've never hit DS and was never hit as a child in the 1960s. But DS most certainly knows I am in charge. As I did with my parents. If my mum said 'jump' it would be a case of how high! Not that I always did what she said but 9 times out of 10 I did, often begrudgingly.

I suppose I use the same techniques with DS. If I he misbehaved when we were playing with toys and wouldn't stop it, the toys would be put away after a warning that that was what would happen.

If he walked away from leaving a mess, he got called back to clear it up and if he didn't then he'd lose the chance to see his favourite programme that day or we wouldn't go to the park - again with a warning that that was the punishment for not doing as he was told. So his choice - clear up or no park/favourite TV programme.

He's now a teenager - rooms are a mess by default but I only have to give him a look to get 'OK, I'm going!'

If he was arguing, I'd try to listen but if it was a raised voice for the sake of it I'd tell him I was going into the kitchen/bedroom or whatever and to come and find me when he could lower his voice. I refuse to be shouted at (had an exH who did that and I took it for too long. DH doesn't do it and I won't accept it off of DS). Just by walking away, whilst ensuring he was safe and only at home, he learned you get very little done by shouting someone down.

I can't think of a time my parents lashed out but my goodness I had the deepest respect for them and would rarely cross them.

SimonJT · 27/06/2020 17:55

I would never assault my son, I also wouldn’t leave him in the care of someone who thought assaulting children was in anyway acceptable.

Yes, he can be irritating, annoying and a bugger, but it isn’t an excuse to assault him.

I wonder how many people who ‘snap’ and assault their child/ren would support someone who ‘snapped’ and assaulted their partner.

thedancingbear · 27/06/2020 17:52

In the second incident you described, you lashed out at your toddler (your words) because they'd hit you first:

Other DS smacked me on the face with a metal Tonka truck during a meltdown (ASD) and cut my forehead, in the split second after it happened I slapped his hand without thinking. I lashed out because I was shocked and hurt and instantly regretted it because he was in a state where he couldn't actually help it.

This is worse than 'not appropriate'.