Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He wants to move out but still stay in a relationship

204 replies

CockLodgerornah · 26/06/2020 15:50

I’ll try not to drip feed.

I met DP at the start of 2019.
He moved in with me in February 2020 and we got engaged.

A month after both of those things happened, lockdown happened. March 2020 he tells me he doesn’t think he wants to get married and if he had the choice he’d move back out. He couldn’t as he had a tenant, who will move out November 2020.

We agree to work through things. June 2020 he confirms he definitely doesn’t want to get married and he definitely will be moving out in November. He still wants to be in a relationship, he just thinks cohabiting is not for him

I love him. I really do but.....after a shit marriage, I thought I’d found someone on the same wavelength as me. I thought, I could happily spend the rest of my life with DP. DP isn’t saying he doesn’t want that, just not in the same house. And I don’t think I’m okay with that but I don’t know if I’m being unreasonable. I enjoy going to sleep next to him every night, I enjoy domestic life. We bloody went and got two cats together (which you know, I’m fine on keeping, I adore them)

He said, if he moves out he will be far more relaxed and will want to do things with me rather than shutting himself away all the time. But if he moves out, I’m suddenly paying all the bills again and I’ll be really tight on finances (his mortgage is half my rent etc).

Would you stay in this relationship if you loved him? I feel like I’d be sacrificing what I want from life. But he’s sacrificing what he wants from life at the moment as he thinks he’s just designed to live alone.

If you really love someone should you fight for it, how do you know when you should walk away. The thought of not having him at all is devastating and I’m worried that I’m being a bit dramatic. I can get over the not marrying thing, despite having told my family we were. (We kinda asked each other, rather than him proposing).

I’m worried that I’ll make the decision just to move on, when I could accept what he has to offer and I might be happy. I don’t think I’d want a relationship where we live apart for the rest of our lives. It makes no financial sense but apparently makes emotional sense to him. Am I being unreasonable, should I put myself first? Should I accept what he has to offer?

OP posts:
NoMoreDickheads · 26/06/2020 17:59

You don't want the same things. Not everyone feels this way, but you want a relationship that's 'going somewhere,' progressing. He doesn't want that so he's a waste of your time as he's not going to give you what you want.

If you're thinking you could stay with him and win him round, I don't think it'd work. And he's hurt you. xx

CockLodgerornah · 26/06/2020 17:58

I think part of the problem is that I think I want him living with me. It could be better with him not I just don’t know. I would hate to accept it, him then move out and get dumped. But I’d also hate to dump him now and then that to be a mistake.

Unfortunately, a lot of pps are probably right about me not having much love for myself. I’ve been beaten down for years, and his love helped me a lot. However I recognise that I’m probably codependent.

He’s gone to work (nhs) for the evening so I’ll have to talk to him when he gets back. I did actually ask him if he was breaking up with me by degrees as someone else suggested but I timed that badly as he was getting his scrubs or whatever on.

With regards to him staying here for 4 months. I have no savings and honestly, it would allow me to put maybe £1000 away. So if anyone would be taking financial advantage it would be me. I’ll be a bit financially screwed for maybe 18 months as I’m paying off a loan, but after December 21 I’d be fine. So I should put that side of things to bed, so to speak, and decide if I want more than what he’s offering. I’m just struggling to reconcile the idea that someone could want to marry you, want to live with you and then change their mind and still want to be in a relationship.

He’s tried cohabiting before twice with girlfriends and it’s never worked out, he’s said he just thinks he’s meant to live alone. He needs his own space, it’s not necessarily noise but just knowing the space is only yours and he wants to be able to choose to go see someone not be forced into it because you live together. Now....I do understand all that. It’s not how I view life though

OP posts:
IncrediblySadToo · 26/06/2020 17:57

You are young. Don't sacrifice a full live together relationship (and children if you want them) for these crumbs he's throwing your way.

Personally I think you should tell him to go now, it'll be awful luving as a couple until Nov, all the while knowing he's got one foot out of the door.

You ARE young (whether you feel it or not right now!) and you will meet someone else you're more compatible with.

Love does NOT conquer all, sadly.

Doyoumind · 26/06/2020 17:55

Just move on. You want different things. I think it's the old he's just not that into you.

I have known several men who insisted they didn't want to live with or get married when they were with one woman and yet they went on to marry someone else a reltively short period of time after.

It's shit but you can't make him want what he doesn't want. Don't get caught up in trying to win him over. It will damage you immensely and you won't win.

GreenTulips · 26/06/2020 17:54

I agree with most of the above.

You want a marriage and probably children in the future. He dosent. Don’t throw away your chance.

kazzer2867 · 26/06/2020 17:52

A month after both of those things happened, lockdown happened. March 2020 he tells me he doesn’t think he wants to get married and
if he had the choice he’d move back out. He couldn’t as he had a tenant, who will move out November 2020.

OP. You do realise he's only staying because he has no where else to go. Come on raise your standards, have some respect for yourself and pack his bags.

B1rdbra1n · 26/06/2020 17:51

if there is no mutually acceptable compromise then you and he are not compatible, he should look for a relationship with someone who also wants to live separately.

I'm in a 'LAT' relationship and I love it

Shoxfordian · 26/06/2020 17:49

I'd have told him to get out in March if I were you
I don't know why you would even contemplate settling for this shit.

Yeahnahmum · 26/06/2020 17:49

You are not on the same wave lenght as this man.
This man is not your future. This is not happiness...
This is trouble and unhappiness going forward. You deserve happy. And love. And living together and all that. Not this sorry excuse for a commitment

CloudsCanLookLikeSheep · 26/06/2020 17:48

I think it will eat away at you and sour the relationship over time. It sounds like things are going backwards, not forwards. For me it would be a deal breaker. Unless you both genuinely agreed that you wanted to cohabit, in which case it could work, then this is doomed to failure.

unlikelytobe · 26/06/2020 17:48

No, he can't just stay at yours because his place is tenanted and unavailable until November - tough shit. If he's not interested in a romantic live-in relationship with you he should move out. He has emotionally left anyway, sorry.

If money is tight you could get a lodger maybe.

IdblowJonSnow · 26/06/2020 17:46

I think you just dont want the same things. Hes messing with your head, I'd get him gone asap.
He might be genuine about wanting to stay with you though. I love my DH and kids dearly but really crave my own space and often day dream about having my own place! (Not gonna happen) so I can see how cohabitation just doesn't suit some people. Why dont you have a break and reassess In a month or 2 after hes moved out?
It is an unusual step and I dan see to many it would be negstive/backwards move but it takes honesty I guess and if you stay together after that says quite a lot?
But if it's not what you want and you want the conventional set up then that's ok too.

SunbathingDragon · 26/06/2020 17:45

@dontdisturbmenow

There've been many threads started by female posters complaining about living with their partner who are told to just move out and offer to continue the relationship living seperately. Why is this different because it's the make who wants to live seperately?

He's clearly stressed maybe because OP is a cleaner freak and he feels he can't relax, or the opposite. Maybe she enjoys a lot of noise and he needs quiet and calm.

There are many things that can make living together stressful especially when you've been use to living on your own for some time. It doesn't mean he has an agenda.

It’s different because it’s not what the OP wants so why should they settle?
dontdisturbmenow · 26/06/2020 17:43

There've been many threads started by female posters complaining about living with their partner who are told to just move out and offer to continue the relationship living seperately. Why is this different because it's the make who wants to live seperately?

He's clearly stressed maybe because OP is a cleaner freak and he feels he can't relax, or the opposite. Maybe she enjoys a lot of noise and he needs quiet and calm.

There are many things that can make living together stressful especially when you've been use to living on your own for some time. It doesn't mean he has an agenda.

chatterbugmegastar · 26/06/2020 17:43

No/little sex, doesn't want to live with you, doesn't want what you want out of life....

And this is all you deserve, is it?

Well - if this IS all you deserve then enjoy

metronome1 · 26/06/2020 17:42

Is his name James by any chance?
If it is run far and run fast op 😁

whiteblue · 26/06/2020 17:39

OP, he doesn't want to move out now because it'll cost him. November suits him perfectly financially.'
I'd tell him to go now.
Sure, it'll hurt but you'll have your pride and self respect.
Dance to your own tune, not someone else's.

Marpan · 26/06/2020 17:26

It’s tough times for everyone.
If you cannot make it work then just move on.
You don’t get engaged to someone then unengaged and you certainly don’t move
Our after you have moved in unless it’s a break
Up.
At least you have had lockdown to make you realise he is no good instead of realising it at the alter!!

istheresomethingishouldknow · 26/06/2020 17:22

I'd ask him to go and look for someone to rent out a room in your house instead.

crimsonlake · 26/06/2020 17:20

How awful and I do feel sorry for you.
I am sorry I do have to agree with everyone, he has slowly been checking out. You need to ask him to leave, you deserve better than a flatmate.

SunbathingDragon · 26/06/2020 17:15

I agree that I think he is backing out of the relationship and doing it in stages rather than all at once.

Yes, HBC and TB did successfully live apart for years but that doesn’t work when one side wants to live with their partner (and presumably marry them considering they accepted a proposal).

I’m sorry OP, but I also agree about getting him to move out now. A clean break will be easier for you and after what he has said, you need to prioritise what is best for you and what you want long term.

CatandtheFiddle · 26/06/2020 17:14

And I don’t think I’m okay with that

There's your answer. There's no "reasonable" or "unreasonable" about it. It's what you're OK or not K with.

And frankly, he moves out, you continue a relationship, but what if he then says "Oh I don't think I can cope with monogamy. I'd still like to be in a relationship with you, but I want to see other people"

and so on.

Inkpaperstars · 26/06/2020 17:09

You are young. Best case scenario he cannot offer you what you want, potentially he is going to mess you around and hurt you further on top of that.

Just end this and move on as soon as possible. Please spare yourself.

Flittingabout · 26/06/2020 17:07

This isn't a long term relationship though. They have only just moved in after meeting a year ago. It's not like a 5 year relationship...

Zhampagne · 26/06/2020 17:04

I think it is perfectly possible to have a longterm relationship in two houses. Helena Bonham Carter and Tim Burton famously did so for many years - and they have children together.

Their houses were next door to each other and interconnected. They basically made one massive house with two front doors. It’s not quite the same.