Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Babies stranded in Ukraine

202 replies

Scissor · 15/05/2020 19:05

Just watched the footage on C4. Really not comfortable with any of this. Staff, hospital etc all looking very gowned up, lots of cots in a big space all very clean and hygienic looking but newborn babies with no , and I mean zero, opportunities for attachment ??
This is looking very strange to me.

OP posts:
OhHolyJesus · 18/05/2020 10:47

I looked into some other media coverage at the weekend and thought I would post this, my bolding -if this wasn't already commercial -labelled as supposed altruistic - surrogacy, with no legal consequences, then what the hell will happen with commercial surrogacy in the UK?

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/07/01/couples-paying-60000-surrogates-despite-uk-system-reasonable/

Couples are paying up to £60,000 for babies born via surrogate mothers despite a ban on commercial surrogacy, a study has found.
The UK’s “altruistic” system means surrogates may be reimbursed only “reasonable expenses”, which experts say should cost families no more than £12,000.
However, the world’s largest fertility conference heard that British courts routinely sign off costs of far greater value if they can be persuaded the child is going to a good home.
The survey of 177 sets of parents by the University of Kent showed that the largest group - 30 per cent - paid between £20,000 to 30,000 during the surrogacy process, while 25 per cent paid between £10,000 and £15,000, and 21 per cent paid £15,000 to £20,000.
Meanwhile seven per cent paid up to £40,000, and in five cases couples paid up to £60,000.
The law does not set a limit for “reasonable expenses”, however cash transactions are supposed to be scrutinised by judges when they make parental orders, the process that transfers legal parenthood from the surrogate to the intended parents.

Five couples paid up to £60,000, according to a study
Natalie Smith, from Surrogacy UK, which campaigns against commercialisation, told the European Society for Reproduction and Embryology annual meeting the current system gives courts “wiggle room”.
“The welfare of the child trumps everything, so that if someone does pay more than reasonable expenses the judge does have some flexibility," she said.
According to parents who responded to the survey, the maximum they took home was £25,000, indicating that significant legal, medical and other costs are involved.
Meanwhile surrogates who responded said they were never paid more than £20,000.
However, the large sums will fuel fears that total surrogacy prices are heading towards US levels, where the profit motive is allowed.

Commercial surrogacy is banned in the UK
Norman Wells, from the Family Education Trust, said: "It is difficult to see how the commercialisation of reproduction can ever be in the best interests of the child.
"It is adults who control the market and therefore it will always be adults who stand to gain from it.”

Surrogacy UK is one of a number of organisations campaigning for a change in UK’s 30-year-old law following a six-fold increase in legal applications linked to the process, from 55 in 2007 to 316 in 2016.
It wants intended parents to be recognised as the legal parents from the moment of birth, so they can make crucial decisions regarding their child’s healthcare
.
Currently it takes an average of between six and 12 months for courts to grant parental orders.

FannyCann · 17/05/2020 23:27

OneMomentInHistory

Cambodia has clamped down and criminalised the pregnant women that are stuck with a baby they can't afford that they never wanted.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0001bpp

Babies stranded in Ukraine
OneMomentInHistory · 17/05/2020 22:47

@Haworthia Ukraine is currently the centre, I assume they like the money it brings in. What seems to happen is one country has no laws so the clinics pop up, lots of surrogacy cases. Then something will go wrong - a surrogate mother will die, a wealthy commissioning parent will try to sue over something, a baby will be abandoned, and suddenly the government realise it's a nightmare for them. So they introduce strict laws (either banning it outright, banning commercial surrogacy or banning international visitors from commissioning babies) and suddenly the clinics close up shop (often leaving everyone involved in the chain in a nightmare scenario), and pop up in a new unregulated destination. Happened in Nepal a few years ago, Thailand cracked down after baby Gammy, I think Cambodia is the next in the chain.

ChattyLion · 17/05/2020 20:48

The language/imagery that detaches, as it were, the womb from the woman it is in, is popular with both the anti abortion and pro surrogacy types.

Both see the mother as a vessel and both invisibilise the risks involved in pregnancy and childbirth.

So true Beetroot

Babbas · 17/05/2020 10:16

It has increased massively in frequency recently which is shocking, and for reasons which are unethical. Kim K using surrogacy she doesn't ruin her figure, reports of film stars in bollywood not wanting their careers affected, and wanting white surrogates so the babies have lighter skin, male gay couples like Elton buying babies from poor mums. No amount of money should buy you a baby. The reasons for purchase are becoming more and more gross. There is always Ann unfair power dynamic.

OhHolyJesus · 16/05/2020 19:51

For Australians Haworthia after Thailand tightened up after Baby Gammy/David Farnell they headed to Cambodia.

A man who ran what was a smaller version for BioTexCom said he was under threat of being charged with human trafficking and his response was "it's not worth it" so he closed the 'agency'.

Haworthia · 16/05/2020 19:24

It’s interesting that Ukraine seems to be the new global centre of the baby farming trade, since India tightened up its laws (at least, I believe that’s what India did - someone my MIL knows paid a surrogate to birth her first child in India, plus another to birth her second in Ukraine. I’m sure they would have gone back to India the second time if they could have).

Gettingo · 16/05/2020 19:06

[I] would happily be a surrogate for someone else who did want a child. No bother to me...

That"s laughable. There's no way a pregnancy and birth is "no bother".

TheTiaraManager · 16/05/2020 18:37

I'll be sending that to my MP. Thank you for sharing

TheTiaraManager · 16/05/2020 18:33

Fanny that's a heart-breaking read

Clymene · 16/05/2020 18:29

The couple in the article decided to become parents in their late 50s. They used two egg donors to create 5 embryos and 2 surrogates. There is a deeply disturbing disregard for all 4 of the women involved in creating a child who will have parents who are at retirement age before they are adults.

This is not in anyone's best interests.

Clymene · 16/05/2020 18:26

I read this article yesterday

https://heyreprotech.substack.com/p/on-becoming-a-mother-in-your-late?utmcampaign=post&utmmmedium=web&utmsource=copy

Clymene · 16/05/2020 18:25

I'm not sure that most of the babies are not biologically the babies of both 'intended' parents unless they're very wealthy women who don't want to be pregnant because it's inconvenient/takes a toll on their bodies/is too risky.

Many use another woman to provide the eggs for the surrogate. So there are two women whose fertility and health is compromised.

oliviacowell · 16/05/2020 18:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MarylandMayhem · 16/05/2020 17:45

A quick google brings up interviews from surrogate mothers in Ukraine detailing the appalling treatment they received. Many forced to move into an apartment with numerous other women at 32 weeks, having to share beds, lack of own toilet facilities, put under curfew and fined if they break it.
Stories of women who had still births or miscarriages not being paid, no after care for the damage pregnancy and birth caused, put up in crap hospitals etc. Women suffering PTSD from the process.

It's terrible, I don't know how anyone can even begin to defend it.

ohidontgetit · 16/05/2020 17:38

*trauma experienced by the surrogate mother, not bio.

ohidontgetit · 16/05/2020 17:37

Yup. As far as baby is concerned, surrogate is mum. Baby will want and look around for mum immediately after birth. Baby doesn’t give a flying fuck about genetics. In fact, it has been proven that the baby inherits genetic material from the surrogate anyway. The mother’s body adapts to that specific baby and their needs.

Also, just because there is a lack of anecdotes about trauma experienced by the biological mother, it doesn’t mean it hasn’t happened. I doubt a rich American couple bringing their beautiful newborn home and showing them off to their family and friends would be keen to discuss how the surrogate had a breakdown after the birth. That’s if they were even told about the mother’s condition after baby is handed over.

MarylandMayhem · 16/05/2020 17:29

That's a great letter, I've just sent it off to my MP.

softjellycell · 16/05/2020 17:06

It's the punching the air that really gets me.

Me too, I mean what have they actually achieved? They've bought a baby, that's not something to be proud of.

OhHolyJesus · 16/05/2020 16:58

Ah Fanny you beat me too it.

A really great letter, I don't think I'll even change it when I send it.

BoreOfWhabylon · 16/05/2020 16:58

I'm not a fan of surrogacy at all, but most of the babies are the biological child of a couple who can't have their own, and who've simply rented a womb.

The baby may be genetically that of the commissioning couple, but every cell is built, nourished and grown entirely from the body of the surrogate.

The baby recognisesvthe surrogate's smell, voice and heartbeat from its time in the womb. The surrogate is the mother.

BeetrootRocks · 16/05/2020 16:56

'I'm not a fan of surrogacy at all, but most of the babies are the biological child of a couple who can't have their own, and who've simply rented a womb.'

The language/imagery that detaches, as it were, the womb from the woman it is in, is popular with both the anti abortion and pro surrogacy types.

Both see the mother as a vessel and both invisibilise the risks involved in pregnancy and childbirth.

FannyCann · 16/05/2020 16:55

Ha. Cross post @OhHolyJesus Grin

FannyCann · 16/05/2020 16:54

If you don't want to see commercial surrogacy come to the UK please download this letter and send it to your MP. Copy in Mat Hancock if you can. It takes hardly any time at all.

Make no mistake, a LOT of behind the scenes lobbying has been going on to bring California style surrogacy law to the UK and the Law Commission are currently working on their proposals.

If these proposals go ahead the UK will become an international surrogacy destination. And the NHS and UK taxpayer will be funding it. Even if you are not sure about surrogacy I think you can be sure that the NHS shouldn't be funding an international baby trade.

nordicmodelnow.org/2020/05/15/ask-your-mp-to-take-action-on-the-law-commissions-surrogacy-proposals/

OhHolyJesus · 16/05/2020 16:52

I have been posting on the other threads but wanted to jump on and share this.

Nordic Model Now have done a letter template to send to MPs re the Law Commission proposals.

Following the news from Kiev I thought I'd share.

nordicmodelnow.org/2020/05/15/ask-your-mp-to-take-action-on-the-law-commissions-surrogacy-proposals/