Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have no sympathy for alcoholics?

494 replies

Macrometa · 14/05/2020 12:16

I'm the adult child of one, my life has been nothing but completely miserable because of it.

Today in my home town the newspaper ran a story about an alcoholic man who trespassed into the cancer department late at night. He stole two bottles of alcohol sanitizer from a fridge and drank them, he vomited sick and blood on the floor, urinated on the floor and then ripped down a cubicle curtain. He was found by a frightened cleaner the next morning.

The comments are full of people feeling sorry for the bloke, yet no concern for the cleaner who had to deal with the aftermath or the hospital who are now down on vital supplies and have to pay for repairs.

AIBU to have no sympathy for alcoholics?

OP posts:
Everdreamer1990 · 15/05/2020 11:09

@Coffeecak3 I'm not defending alcoholics a post I put on a few pages ago I was explaining that I had to cut off my ex best friend due to being a nasty alcoholic. she was awful to me and treated me horrendously saving up getting arrested for drink driving tried to leave the scene twice when the police turned up.

I don't really have a lot of sympathy for alcoholics I did initially for her and over that 10 years but I tried to help her she didn't want to help herself.

I'm an ex-smoker gave up a year ago so I was just wondering all the people on here that seems to have sympathy for alcoholics whatever have sympathy for smokers as well as the saying addiction is the mental health issue.

both smoking and alcoholism have an effect on the person with the addiction and those around them I just don't understand how they both seen differently. it seems you can have sympathy for an alcoholic but not sympathy for a smoker despite both of them being able to harm and potentially kill those around them

Taddda · 15/05/2020 11:02

But I do think the sore and painful memory of the hurt and damage done to loved ones serves as motivation not to relapse.

Congratulations on your Dd's Recovery, you sound like a wonderfully supportive and understanding parent!

You are right in your statement regarding motivation not to relapse, remembering the hurt and damage it caused is important-

What I would be wary of is the guilt and shame aspect that can grow out of this.

Meetings are important for this reason, it gives an open, non judgemental stage to air feelings of past consequences and actions without it being a constant in every day life. Walk in, share, leave it there...

I'd also say that a recovering addict doesn't need to be reminded - encouraged to talk, yes, but not in a 'remember when you did x,y,z'...

People who have achieved Recovery should be allowed a life after, always mindful, but not reminded.

Bakedbrie · 15/05/2020 10:18

@forsucksfake....congratulations on your lasting sobriety. I’ve read posters on this with interest. A couple of observations from our own very painful experience; one poster said they felt it took a while to become physically and psychologically addicted to alcohol. Well, our experience was that it was terrifyingly fast! My DD17 started secretly drinking huge amounts of vodka and within a month had a full on physical addiction; sweats, anxiety, getting up in the night to drink, drinking in the morning, uncontrollable craving, lying the lot. It was like taking to a zombie. I saw her, I recognised her, but the person inside had been totally hijacked by the need for alcohol. So heartbreaking. I couldn’t believe this could be so quick, but several helpful alcoholics at AA confirmed that, yes, this can happen.

I don’t think of my DD as a selfish narcissist. She’s actually a fab, kind person; a trainee doctor. But the alcohol produced behaviours and a level of deceit in her over and over which I and others didn’t recognise. But that’s what any substance addiction does. I agree that change can only come from the person themselves, no amount of pleading from others works. But I do think the sore and painful memory of the hurt and damage done to loved ones serves as motivation not to relapse.

Taddda · 15/05/2020 09:15

So I know there are many ways of approaching all addictions. I never did understand the ones that start from the logic that they are all a disease and the addict has no control...

There's a big difference here-

An addict in addiction has no control over their disease- they of course have control over seeking and accepting help and most importantly control over changing themselves and accepting they cannot drink, use substances or engage in any behaviour that may feed their addiction.

Their not void responsibility, infact that responsibility is solely theirs and needs to be understood in its entirety in order for them to get well.

Starting from the point that the addict has choices to make, right now, forever, for their own reasons, not those of family and friends, always made more sense to me.

That's what a 12 step programme will help them achieve. But as I said above and previously, it starts with them. Sometimes it is necessary to walk away from an addict to make them even recognise this.

Fwiw also I have rarely met a person in Recovery who would ask for sympathy (different from somebody in addiction who would likely feed off this). I've met an awful lot who would ask for understanding and forgiveness, nearly all suffering with immense feelings of guilt and shame over their past. Making amends (a very difficult part of the 'step' process, if not the most) is essential.

I'd hope that if anyone affected by this now was to reach a point where their family member/friend was to achieve this stage in their recovery they would be able to listen to this- forgiveness in certain aspects is too much to ask initially, but it might just enable a healing process for all involved.

WitchesGlove · 15/05/2020 08:42

Coffeecak-

A smoker absolutely does spend their last penny on cigarettes.

Coffeecak3 · 15/05/2020 08:13

@Everdreamer1990 a smoker doesn't change personality and become violent, a smoker doesn't spend every last penny on cigarettes, a smoker doesnt lie and manipulate, a smoker doesn't fall in a gutter helpless and covered in urine, a smoker may well become ill but their impact on other people's lives is much less than drinking. They can smoke outside away from others.
I have never smoked btw.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 15/05/2020 08:04

You can be an alcoholic and be pleasant, law abiding etc. Or you can be an alcoholic and be an utter fucking arsehole. I'm not sure that's entirely true.

The pleasant law abiding drunk also has a negative impact on their family, from the money spent on their drink to the times they are absent (in mind if not body) from family occasions, to the inevitable arguments about being drunk, not participating etc. The amiable drunk is what the outside world sees. No family knows that person, that amiable public face is just the start of yet another time of apprehension, fear and loathing!

It's not about alcoholism being like anorexia etc. It isn't. It is completely different and does no alcoholi, anorexic, bulemic, smoker etc, any favours to say they could/should be viewed the same. To do so is to look at the effects and not hunt for the cause.

As forsucksfake says, the level of sheer self absorbption of alcoholics is different, has none of the same causes and none of the same cures as the other conditions mentioned.

Jesus christ, educate yourselves on addictions. Without wanting to mirror your accidental mic drop Tadda I am, through experience, through formal education, through working with various addiction rehab programmes. So I know there are many ways of approaching all addictions. I never did understand the ones that start from the logic that they are all a disease and the addict has no control... always seemed self defeating. Starting from the point that the addict has choices to make, right now, forever, for their own reasons, not those of family and friends, always made more sense to me.

But I am aware that no one route is generally more or less successful than another.

OliviaBenson · 15/05/2020 07:51

Thanks @Macrometa and @TitianaTitsling

I might look up those Facebook groups. I only talk about it on here. I've got 1 friend who knows. I'm sure others do but we don't talk about it.

Counselling has definitely helped. I get irrationally annoyed at the posts on MN which are 'but family is family' etc etc. Ignorance is bliss and I guess I'm just jealous I never had a 'proper' family.

I've decided not to have kids for a number of reasons but one of them is because of my upbringing.

Anyway, today is a new day. It's been good to talk on here so thank you op.

Everdreamer1990 · 15/05/2020 06:47

Do people have the same sympathy for smokers who also suffer addiction? Or are they seen more as disgusting?

Taddda · 15/05/2020 04:29

Jesus christ, educate yourselves on addictions.

This, with bells on.

HannaH021 · 15/05/2020 04:04

I agree with you, i excluded my liver, lungs and kidneys after i die from my organ donation, my family and gp are aware if the person who needs these at the time isnt an alcoholic or a smoker, i'm happy for them to take it, but default is no... I have no sympathy for alcoholics/smokers what so ever... It all starts by choice...

Andahelterskelterroundmylittle · 15/05/2020 04:02

Jesus christ, educate yourselves on addictions.

Turnandfacethenamechange · 15/05/2020 03:50

20Madein our experiences sound really similar. My first day in the rehab clinic I looked around and reassured myself I don't belong here. I have a job and a social life and a house and pay my bills! Took me about 3 minutes with my new keyworker to realise I was exactly the same as everyone else in there and very much needed to be there.

Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 02:07

for I dont think sympathy and kindness is always enabling though. My uni friends (I use the term loosely as there was some bullying there) tried to tough love stance. All it did was make my efforts not to drink seem pointless, make me even more isolated and alone and taking painkillers to try and cope.

My best friend has stuck with me throughout addiction without enabling. Never once given me money or agreed with my bull that what I was doing was ok. She has however been a kind and supportive person.

Removing yourself from an addict can be necessary. But I honestly dont think that tough love is the only answer, ir that support equals enabling

Well done on 6yrs

forsucksfake · 15/05/2020 01:38

Alcoholic with almost six years of clear-headed sobriety. This is my experience.

You don't do us any favours by coddling us or pitying us. We are self-centered, conniving, manipulative people who have chosen alcohol as the solution to our misery. Our only concern is alcohol and we don't give a shit about anyone or anything if it gets in our way. We are the only ones who can diagnose ourselves and decide to get help.

We have to admit and truly reject our narcissism before we can ever recover. More than sympathy (which is always enabling), we need tough love and firm ultimatums. We will never face our demons if we have the crutch of alcohol.

My demons used to terrify me and I really thought I would die without alcohol. I am still here and thriving.

Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 01:30

nat I am so sorry for your loss and your experience 💓

Dying of cirrhosis is a terrible way to go, I watched a cousin die of it. Sad.

Nat6999 · 15/05/2020 01:26

As someone who has lost their partner to alcoholism, it isn't a lifestyle choice, you don't wake up one morning & think today I'm going to be an alcoholic. Most alcoholics have something that has affected their mental health during their life, childhood trauma, abuse, death of a family member, divorce. They don't drink because they want to, they drink because they have to. My partner would get up to go to the loo during the night, go in the fridge & have a drink before getting back in bed so that he wouldn't have the shakes when he woke up next morning. Drink came before everything, me, his kids, his family, his health. I watched him die from cirrhosis, it isn't pretty watching someone who you love drown as their lungs fill up with blood. It was as if I had met two men, the quiet, funny, gentle one & the drunken monster he became, it was like a long drawn out death scene where we would have snatched moments when he was the man I loved before the monster took over again. But much as he was a monster, I still loved him because I knew that the man I fell in love with was still inside somewhere.

Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 01:20

And yes, the stigma around addiction prevented me from getting support for a long time. I was ashamed. I was intelligent, with a good job and a functional life yet I had taken something so often that my body refused to work without it. I wasnt like a heroin addict I'd tell myself. I couldn't be, could I? I just needed to snap out of it. I felt more at home in the role of support staff not service user. I wore a lanyard and smart work clothes to every single appointment. Sometimes I got a taxi if I was running late. Every single the time the driver asked if I'd had a good shift, even without my lanyard on. They automatically assumed I was staff. That just made me feel more like a feud, hypocrite and out of place. Even in NA, someone said 'you dont look like us, you look normal". He was told off by an old timer, but that stuck with me. I clearly stick out, even when I dont dress up. And if he thinks i look different, how many others think it? And do i really belong there?

Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 00:59

French I completely agree re the children. I got involved with a guy from na and ended it when I discovered he was in a relationship. What got to me most that he had used cocaine around his children and yet it was his partner's fault she was pissed off, apparently.

I'm an addict myself and no better than anyone. But when you've a child, all bets are off. When you've a child your priorities should change. If you've gotten clean and then use because you want to, because yiuve a mental craving and not physical agony,and you're a parent ... then you're not a bloody good one. Yes addiction is hard and horrible. Yes when you're in it its fucking hard to stop. But when I stop for a while and relapse, I make a conscious choice to do so and risk everything for a bit of a high. And it's only me I'm harming. When you've got children that's an entirely different ballgame and it is so so selfish

I identify with resenting the complicit parent too. My mam had mental health issues, not addiction. She emotionally and physically abused me from age 7 to age 24. Dad may not have known about the physical at the start but he did later and he knew about the emotional. Yet he never got involved, saying 'hed leave us to it'and stay out of it. Fine, I'm an adult now. I wasnt all those years ago. I get that he was scared of mam, I do. But he was an adult, a grown man. However hard it would have been, he should have stepped in. He had the opportunity to protect his child and chose bot to because he was too scared and gutless himself. And the worst thing is, man has MH issues. I know that. But theres absolutely no excuse for him. He was the nicer parent, who bought me books and comforted me and showed me some kindness. Yet he still did not step in and protect me from years of abuse. And for that I doubt I will ever forgive him

Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 00:40

I've realised recently just how normalised alcohol is in my family, and how desensitized I've become to it. I'm actually very lucky not to be an alcoholic I think, as theres much of that in my family. I used alcohol as a coping mechanism from age 11, dipping between drinking to cope and drinking socially. I know I need to be careful of it and it creeps up quickly. Pain pills are my drug of choice, but I cannot imagine a life without alcohol.

I cant remember a time when I didnt drink. Ever. At family parties age 8 or 9, drinking archers aqua which was given to me by family members. Being allowed alcopops like that for a while at parties, and from around age 12 having wkd and cider etc bought for me. I was also sneaking Malibu into school to cope. By age 15 I was drinking kost weekends at home. Mam saw it as acceptable, and actually encouraged me to drink at home so I would 'know my limita'. She allowed my friends to drink too, often without their parents consent, and was scathing afterwards about how they couldn't handle it. Age 15 me and her split a massive bottle of vodka, I hadnt really drank spirits in that quantity before and was sick all over the place. Mam was more concerned about me not knowing my limits,and it was something I actually took pride in, that I could handle my drink.

My extended family were no better. My mams cousin (I call them auntie and uncle), allowed his grandkids to drink glasses of cider from around age 6. They wrte allowed to drink small glasses or have some from his glass at around age 4. I personally didnt agree with that as I got older, but I was the odd one out.
Mam told me once how my uncle soaked my dummy in brandy when I was a baby as I was teething. I was sick everywhere and they called mam and apparently I was very unwell and was vomiting black stuff. I asked mam why she didnt take me to the hospital, she claims there was no need. I think it was more to do with questions being asked.

And no, none of this mitigate my choice to drink when I'm stressed or pissed off, knowing I'll find it hard to stop. This fact, and that mam used to dole out her tablets like sweets, does.not absolve me of responsibility for my opiate addiction. But it does go some way to showing how utterly fucked up my attitudes to alcohol are, in a way
Painkillers are my first choice but I recall a time I didnt use them. I know I can do it again. I literally cannot remember a time in my 25years on earth where I didnt drink. Its entrenched. And I cannot imagine a time when I never drink again
As. I said, alcohol isnt my first choice. My intake has gone up over lockdown but I do have some alcohol free nights, I never have more.than 3 wines a night max and many nights, like tonight, I leave it at one. But I know I need to be careful.
Is there any wonder that with a history like mine, I'm an addict?

P999 · 14/05/2020 23:34

Taddda. 100%. An illness, it's not my fault. Or an illness it can be treated. Exactly.

MrsBobDylan · 14/05/2020 23:31

@FrenchBoule like you I wish I had talked to SS. I don't think they would have believed me though, especially since my Dad had a well paid job and we were all clean, fed and clothed.

I used to think about running away all the time. I also thought I could go and live with my Gran if she got poorly but she died when I was 13 and I was devastated.

My Dad was the alcoholic but my Mum is just a really awful, horrible person. I was sad when my Dad died because I knew he had loved me. I won't be sad when my Mum goes, it will be a relief. She used my Dad's alcoholism to manipulate him and control us.

I feel sorry for my Dad, because he used alcohol to numb himself to a life he couldn't cope with living. But my Mum did all she did while sober and I can never forgive her.

I have self funded 10 years of counselling just to enable me to live a normal life and be a good Mum and wife. Between them my parents stole my childhood but I'm fucked if I am letting them take away my chance to be happy as an adult. I've not done a bad job of getting happy, even though I do say so myself

Op, I would really recommend talking to a counsellor. I will be scarred and angry forever about what happened, but I do feel much better about myself - some days I even feel like I am good enough!

DukeOfEarlGrey · 14/05/2020 23:00

You can be an alcoholic and be pleasant, law abiding etc. Or you can be an alcoholic and be an utter fucking arsehole. I've no pity for the latter.

Agreed. I’ve known two serious alcoholics in my life, though thankfully not closely enough to be affected by them like some of the posters here. The first was a good friend at uni - he was a lovely guy but eventually really hard to be friends with because he let all of us down so much and did pretty annoying things like pissing all over my living room because he was so wasted. Still, no more than annoying to his friends and ultimately just heartbreaking because he was such a nice person but we just couldn’t get him to admit the issue or seek help.

The second was my boss a few years ago and a completely different story. Dishonest, malevolent and really sleazy with the young women in the office to the point of making them seriously uncomfortable. I tried to shop him to HR and got told to be quiet (he brought a lot of money in). He was so different from my lovely friend - both pitiful for the alcoholism but he was a really unpleasant character as well, the booze just lowered his inhibitions so he showed it more.

I’m so sorry for those on here who’ve been seriously impacted by alcoholic parents, partners etc. It’s such a damaging illness for all concerned 💐

TitianaTitsling · 14/05/2020 22:57

and also @frenchboule you too

TitianaTitsling · 14/05/2020 22:56

@OliviaBenson and OP I think your stories are what needs to be heard and championed. Those who are affected by the alcoholics choices but don't get the 'benefit' of being so intoxicated to not giving a monkeys about anything or anyone