Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have no sympathy for alcoholics?

494 replies

Macrometa · 14/05/2020 12:16

I'm the adult child of one, my life has been nothing but completely miserable because of it.

Today in my home town the newspaper ran a story about an alcoholic man who trespassed into the cancer department late at night. He stole two bottles of alcohol sanitizer from a fridge and drank them, he vomited sick and blood on the floor, urinated on the floor and then ripped down a cubicle curtain. He was found by a frightened cleaner the next morning.

The comments are full of people feeling sorry for the bloke, yet no concern for the cleaner who had to deal with the aftermath or the hospital who are now down on vital supplies and have to pay for repairs.

AIBU to have no sympathy for alcoholics?

OP posts:
Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 21:24

Watch the posts by baked
The presenters are fabulous and I'm sure itll knock some empathy into some people

MerryDeath · 15/05/2020 21:23

i have also born the brunt of an alcoholic and no i have no sympathy YANBU. it's a very.. selfish disease.

Topseyt · 15/05/2020 21:20

My feelings on this are a little mixed, although on balance I come down on the side of the OP.

My BIL is an alcoholic and along with DH and my PIL I witnessed a lot of his very worst behaviour. It could be very frightening, and I am aware that for every incident we did witness there will have been many more that we didn't. We were always on eggshells around him and the atmosphere was always much more relaxed when he wasn't there.

DH has very little contact with him now since their parents have both died.

I have always been apprehensive when in BIL's company. I just don't like it. I'm afraid of his behaviour and very uncomfortable with it.

I do try to maintain a vestige of sympathy for him in my own mind because I am aware that the alcoholism is a symptom of his significant mental health issues. That doesn't mean that I can actually cope with him for any great length of time though.

mummylondon16 · 15/05/2020 21:00

@TheNavigator
I hear what you are saying. however as a recovering alcoholic I would like to say not all alcoholics are the same. I am a good mum, a responsible employee and citizen, and i take full responsibility for my recovery. yes active addicts can be sneaky,lying, stealing horrors but just be mindful that some of us have chosen to recover and fight our addiction ( my ex and my father are both alcoholics who have not sought recovery so i can totally understand your anger at this element)

mummylondon16 · 15/05/2020 20:57

as a recovering alcoholic, and the daughter of a not recovering alcoholic, I think you are well within your rights to feel angry and irritated by this persons behaviour. as has been said it’s easy to give theorectical sympathy, however much harder when the behaviour is hurting you or others or is as outrageous as this example. I believe alcoholism is a mental illness but i also believe the tools are there for those who are ready for help. we don’t help addicts by excusing or enabling them

stayclosetoyourself · 15/05/2020 20:51

And won't agree to any change

stayclosetoyourself · 15/05/2020 20:50

Of course other people too. Yes sectioning only needed when there is conflict about safety eg someone at home not able to care fir themselves / v vulnerable / risky behaviour and also the dementia.

Ginfordinner · 15/05/2020 20:47

You can only be sectioned if you develop alcohol related dementia if you danger to self.

Or other people?

SIL's husband is in permanent residential care because he has alcohol related dementia. He wasn't sectioned though.

stayclosetoyourself · 15/05/2020 17:50

You cannot be sectioned for alcoholism fir treatment due to the persons right to make poor choices and it not being an actual mental illness.
You can only be sectioned if you develop alcohol related dementia if you danger to self.

Madein1995 · 15/05/2020 17:50

Again the addiction and the acts taken are almost different. I do empathise for the addiction, that doesn't mean I think drink driving is ok. I'm not a victim of dihydrocodeine. Dihydrocodeine by itself will not leap off the shelf and ram itself down my throat. I make a choice and a decision to use it. I have so many service users claim they are a victim of alcohol. I generally ask them 'did the bottle of vodka leap off the shelf in asda, jump into your hand and thrie itself down your throat' . I pawned my baby jewelry to get drugs, I stole msms drugs, I lied and cheated and manipulated like fjck. I didnt rob banks or shoplift though. And part of that is s choice. Because I remember rattling waiting for a delivery to come and thinking I could go into boots and steal some cocodamol. As soon as I thought it I rubbished it. Although I would have prostituted myself,as I did phone sex work and I looked into escorting

stayclosetoyourself · 15/05/2020 17:46

I think addiction is different from mental illness. But dual diagnosis is common.
There is obviously an element of poor choices at the onset of alcohol dependence followed by psychological dependence then if heavy prolonged regular intake physical addiction.

Bakedbrie · 15/05/2020 16:54

For those who are interested.....good lockdown listening and they are both fantastic broadcasters too!
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p07q3jb7/episodes/player

Bakedbrie · 15/05/2020 16:50

I would also add that my DD was drinking, self harming and suicidal - all in tandem. She didn’t like herself, her life or what she was doing but before help came the addiction becomes a sort of powerlessness and I think it felt like it was the only thing she had to turn to. I think when a person is caught up like this, the morals just go out the window. In fact they become warped and I recall sitting and listening to a lot of twisted rationale and logic. The person just isn’t themselves and I agree with previous pp about that being the nature of mental illness. I’m not saying that abdicates all personal responsibility for wreckless behaviour, but this is not and black & white issue IMO.

Olliephaunt4eyes · 15/05/2020 16:34

But alchoholics lie, cheat steal, abuse, are violent, drive drunk and kill people. That is not a mental illness making them do that.*

I mean, the whole point of mental illness is that it affects how people act, and normally in a way that makes it harder to engage with society. I have schizoaffective bipolar disorder and when I've been manic I've had inappropriate sexual relationships, I've thrown and broken things and said some totally insane things to people.

It wasn't like I woke up and thought 'yeah, today I'm going to break every plate in the house because they are tainted by the evil that's been here and make my husband pay for more, because that'll be a laugh'. I was unwell. Same for alcoholics.

Like I said, protect yourself if you have to from an alcoholic and maybe judge them for not even trying to seek treatment etc, but accept that it's not a choice that someone has made for kicks.

Bakedbrie · 15/05/2020 16:13

Thanks @Taddda. We don’t remind her, we don’t want to remind her - it hurts us too. But we know the guilt is there because we see it in her actions - she is eager to give us receipts for small stuff. Once the trust is damaged it takes a long time to heal.
I think we recognised that some people are predisposed to addiction - any addiction actually. My daughter was depressed, sought help from CAMHS and never got it. Alcohol became her self medication. I feel to this day that it’s too cheap, too accessible, too glamorised and should cost more and have a ugly big health warning plastered all over it!
There is a BBC Radio 5 Live series called “Hooked” available by 2 recovered addicts called Jade and Melissa. I would encourage anyone who is interested in the psychology of addiction to listen to it.

CreepyPasta · 15/05/2020 15:43

But alchoholics lie, cheat steal, abuse, are violent, drive drunk and kill people.

I did used to lie to cover up the amount I was drinking but didn’t do any of the others. No one on this thread has said that society is to blame, or that other people have made us feel shame and guilt. In fact, plenty of posters have tried to explain how and why they developed an addiction. That doesn’t fit your preconception though so you’re choosing to ignore it.

CorianderLord · 15/05/2020 15:19

I mean it takes a really fucked up mind to do all of that so yes I do feel sorry for them. My best mates mum was an alcoholic who died because of it and she still has sympathy for alcoholics.

I can't imagine being driven to such extremes by addiction.

TheNavigator · 15/05/2020 15:15

But alchoholics lie, cheat steal, abuse, are violent, drive drunk and kill people. That is not a mental illness making them do that. No one is making them do that. If you get in a car drunk and kill someone then you committed that crime. If you neglect your children, then you were a neglectful parent. If you lie to your family then you are a lier. Not a disease. Not an addiction. You, the person taking the action.

Alchoholics will do anything to wriggle out of personal responsibility.
You can see it on this thread. Society is to blame. It is other peoples fault for making us feel shame and guilt. No. Own your despicable actions and stop expecting everyone else to excuse you because you are an alchoholic.

rosie1959 · 15/05/2020 15:02

RUOKHon unfortunately people have their own opinions very often without any research
There are selected mental illnesses that are acceptable in society
If I said I had depression or anxiety there is a good chance that nobody would tell me that’s my own choice get a grip I don’t understand depression is it just self absorption. Well following the logic on views of alcoholism it probably is . Except perhaps I have taken the time to read a little about it and get an understanding

RUOKHon · 15/05/2020 14:40

Every time I read someone saying Alcoholism is a disease I just think that is abdicating responsibility

But it is a disease. It’s a severe mental illness. If it was treated as such - and not as a lifestyle choice Hmm - then perhaps there wouldn’t be so many lives ruined as collateral damage.

Nobody wants to be an addict. Part of the nature of the disease is that it turns the addict into a lying, destructive, manipulator.

goldfinchfan · 15/05/2020 13:06

Every time I read someone saying Alcoholism is a disease I just think that is abdicating responsibility.
From what PP's have put it seems that a lot of drinking alcohol does indeed change your body to become addicted and then I understand it is hard to stop drinking.
But if you truly understood the pain and distress of living with an illness that takes away your ability to live without pain and without needing 24 hour care you might see the other point of view.
In my experience alcoholics don't want the pain of going through the process of geting off their addiction.
But so much money is spent by the NHS and Social Services on Addicts when people like myself get the least help.
Why is that?
That a person can claim DLA for being an alcoholic is ridiculous.

Apirateslifeforme · 15/05/2020 11:58

I agree with you to a certain extent, I'm the daughter of an alcoholic so I do understand.
I feel a certain sense of sorrow for anyone trapped in an addiction, I understand the feeling of being so broken that theres nothing you can do to feel better, except rely on something that changes your feelings and perception of life, to make it all more bearable.
That is where my sympathy stops though.
You cannot go through life, fucking up others realities to get your own way.

OliviaBenson · 15/05/2020 11:37

The pleasant law abiding drunk also has a negative impact on their family, from the money spent on their drink to the times they are absent (in mind if not body) from family occasions, to the inevitable arguments about being drunk, not participating etc. The amiable drunk is what the outside world sees. No family knows that person, that amiable public face is just the start of yet another time of apprehension, fear and loathing!

This!!!! Thank you @CuriousaboutSamphire

My dad at first was a fun drunk. Any occasion. I have real issues around birthdays and Christmas even today because of that. To others he was just harmless at that point. To me as a child, I was anxious about how he would be that day, would he burn the food, could he light my birthday candles, could he remember how old I even was, would he embarrass me in front of my friends. Everything was about him.

Alcoholism also isn't static so 'harmless' drunks do spiral.

Everdreamer1990 · 15/05/2020 11:18

Post doesn't make sense. Not post office. Rubbish technology

Everdreamer1990 · 15/05/2020 11:10

Sorry for any typos in that post office make sense. I'm having to use talk to type as I'm holding a 12-week old at the moment