Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have no sympathy for alcoholics?

494 replies

Macrometa · 14/05/2020 12:16

I'm the adult child of one, my life has been nothing but completely miserable because of it.

Today in my home town the newspaper ran a story about an alcoholic man who trespassed into the cancer department late at night. He stole two bottles of alcohol sanitizer from a fridge and drank them, he vomited sick and blood on the floor, urinated on the floor and then ripped down a cubicle curtain. He was found by a frightened cleaner the next morning.

The comments are full of people feeling sorry for the bloke, yet no concern for the cleaner who had to deal with the aftermath or the hospital who are now down on vital supplies and have to pay for repairs.

AIBU to have no sympathy for alcoholics?

OP posts:
imsooverthisdrama · 14/05/2020 15:26

I don't know , I feel quite sad for the guy that he's that desperate for alcohol he will steal and drink sanitizer. That's a addiction and it's out of control so most definitely needs help.
Saying that if more people realise that they had alcohol problems before it spiralled and got help .
It must also be terrible living with someone like that and you must loose all sympathy as I'm sure a lot of people have had help they just choose not to except it sometimes.

Coyoacan · 14/05/2020 15:26

I think addictions are a illness, but any adult with an illness, especially if it impacts on those around them, is responsible for seeking help and a cure.

Oh dear, I have to give up smoking on doctor's orders and haven't done a damn thing about it yet. Hypocrite much.

BiBabbles · 14/05/2020 15:23

I think it depends on a lot of things. Individual sympathy is very different to me than social-level sympathy for the issues that we've known for decades now raises the risks it like homelessness, early repeated exposure, familial and community encouragement, and so on. It's be nice if prevention of alcohol addiction was as acceptable to talk about as smoking, but sadly it doesn't seem we're there yet on a society level.

Oversimplifying it yeah, but for me it's similar to the smoking example from Inextremis, the old & quiet user from before we had a lot of the research into it, where they feel it's one of the few pleasures they have left, I do feel for them. Those who are trying and struggling to reduce their use and/or its impact on others with trauma and limited resources yes.

The violent person who thinks their drinking or other drug use can be used to excuse their horrible behaviour, the user who thoroughly enjoys both their own use and in trying to push others to do the same, no. I see no reason to feel more sympathy for them that someone who does the same shit without drink or drugs. It may lower inhibitions, but it doesn't change who someone is as much as popular narratives like to suggest.

I may not entirely agree with the paedophiles comparison, but many addict parents push their drug(s) of choice onto kids and others, abuse kids and others, kill kids and others, so yeah, the question has some merit. In the same way, adults and communities who turn a blind eye when they know it's happening get my ire. I've seen 11 year olds blackout drunk with no repercussions for the parents because 'kids will be kids' ignoring where they got the drink, I've seen little kids given alcohol in quantity because it's 'funny' and 'they have to start sometime', as a kid I had to protect my drinks from my own family and I had to deal with dozens of adults refuse to stop my obviously intoxicated mother from forcing me into a car for reasons I will never understand. I nearly died that night, she wanted me to die that night, but ~she's going through a hard time, you have to be understanding~. No, I don't. It doesn't help anyone if I try to be sympathetic and understanding about people like her.

Like the old saying goes, if you are kind to the cruel, you will end up being cruel to the kind.

PhilSwagielka · 14/05/2020 15:23

when alcohol (or any other substance) is being abused to mask other problems or traumatic experiences

That's what happened to my mum.

AvoidingTheWineAisle · 14/05/2020 15:23

I think the ‘illness’ aspect of addiction is more along the lines of comparable mental health issues - anxiety, obsessive compulsive behaviours, depression etc. All of these issues can devastate lives and hurt others.

Yes, you CAN overcome these with the right treatment and/or support. They are not physical diseases. But you may not be able to just wake up one morning and ‘choose’ to stop being anxious, depressed etc. I think the same goes for alcoholism.

I’m in no way excusing alcoholic behaviour. I’m in AA, facing up to my drinking. Not everyone is able to do that, though. Just like not everyone is able to overcome their mental health issues.

It doesn’t mean you have to sympathise with alcoholics. But I think it is worth pointing out.

Gregoria67 · 14/05/2020 15:22

One of my parents was an alcoholic. It certainly damaged my life beyond repair actually. That parent did managed to become a 'recovering' alcoholic but only after the damage was done really. The other parent remained in situ, which forced me and my sibling to remain in situ and that other parent allowed a lot of awful things. I can't forgive that parent either.

I do understand how the disease takes hold and how people deny the state they're in/the state they're putting everyone else in, but I don't understand why a non-alcoholic parent would allow their children to be put through it. Absolutely not.

Cam2020 · 14/05/2020 15:21

I have sympathy to a certain extent. It's a horrible addiction, but people are capable of changing with a lot of willpower and effort - they don't want to. I think portraying addicts as victims suits them right down to the ground. That's exactly how they like to cast themselves so they are excused from taking any responsibility for themselves or ownership of the pain and suffering they inflict upon other people.

I sound really horrible and unsympathetic there and I really do have sympathy, particularly when alcohol (or any other substance) is being abused to mask other problems or traumatic experiences, but it is ultimately a choice to continue abusing rather than get help.

1forAll74 · 14/05/2020 15:20

I have no sympathy at all for any alcoholic. I was with an alcoholic partner for several years ,some years ago. I was stupidly trying to help him to seek help,as my attempts became futile eventually. He became abusive when I was trying to help him. He sometimes had a few moments of clarity, and knew he was on a downward spiral. with his health and mindset, but never the less, he would not stop drinking.

I had a GP come to the house once, as he fell over into the bath when trying to use the toilet, and was looking quite unconscious. The doctor was aware of the drink problem. He roused from the fall eventually,and the doctor warned him yet again that all this alcohol would kill him. He then gave me the number of the AA group.. (much too late ) but said he could not do anything to stop the drinking, a person has to do that themselves.

Six months later, he was dead. He had a kind of alcohol dementia, a diseased liver, and was as skinny as a rake,due to not eating, just drinking vodka or whiskey all day long.

He had a lovely home, no money worries.a brand new Range Rover,which he could not drive anymore.

I was quite aware where his drink problem had come from many years before I even met him, and hoped that I could have helped him.But it never happened, and would never attempt to help any such person again.

Bluntness100 · 14/05/2020 15:15

I understand where you’re coming from as I habe a friend who is the child of an alcoholic and it did do some damage, particularly because the other parent put up with it and made the children live through it. As adults they understood the weakness of both parents and viewed it as unforgivable.

I think on balance I have way more sympathy for the child than the alcoholic parent and their partner.

I don’t think saying it’s an illness is Often helpful because it removes all form of personal responsibility in some people’s minds..

If you have any other illness you’re expected to seek help and as you descend through the stages of alcoholism there are stages you know and you can seek that help. You’re still in control. You also know the damage you’re doing to your loved ones. Because you don’t just become an alcoholic over night. It’s not like you have that first ever vodka and it’s game over. You’re suddenly an alcoholic. It takes continued effort to become addicted.

goldfinchfan · 14/05/2020 15:14

In fact i am not sympathetic about it being an illness.
I have zero choice in being ill.....an alcoholic CAN choose to get help........I have no choice.....they can stop drinking.
Yes they are often sensitive, and intelligent but it is an act of self destruction and also damages family relationships.
Alcoholics are selfish however nice they are.

PhilSwagielka · 14/05/2020 15:13

OP, I'd just like to add that in this case, I'd definitely say YANBU. You've been on the receiving end of bad behaviour from an alcoholic and it is hard to be sympathetic for them when they make other people's lives a misery. It took me a while to forgive Mum.

@Bakedbrie that's brilliant. I'm glad your daughter is OK now.

okycoky17 · 14/05/2020 15:10

@Macrometa - my father's brother was an alcoholic. He died of it, at the age of 55. It destroyed my Uncle, but also my dad. He won't touch alcohol as a result, hates the stuff. I think alcoholics do despicable things, both to themselves and those around them. And ultimately it's an addiction that does rip everyone apart.

My dad has no tolerance or sympathy for them. I'm not sure what I think - I do agree that individuals are responsible for their own welfare, and really, I do believe it's a choice to self-medicate with excessive alcohol. It's a slippery slope from there. What a place to be in! To want to drink sanitizer fluid. I don't know. It's just awful. Recovery for this man could be very difficult.

Bakedbrie · 14/05/2020 15:03

My DD developed a drinking problem after a horrific bereavement in our family. As a mum, it was truly the most ragged time in my life, I cannot describe the desperation I felt 24/7 - a torn mix of love and deep sadness. We stuck by her, we got support for ourselves and she’s on the otherside now. She was 17 when she “fell into” the alcohol trap. People don’t always have a choice - they can be very young, very unaware of the addictive nature of alcohol, and this becomes a handy but dangerous coping strategy. My DD is a trainee doctor now! We couldn’t be more proud of her.

Hagbeth · 14/05/2020 15:00

OP I have similarly very bad experiences of alcohol and drug users in my life. I have no sympathy and I don’t understand why I should. If you react badly to alcohol it’s your responsibility to stop before it goes that far. Terrible crimes are committed under the influence and there’s no excuse.

PhilSwagielka · 14/05/2020 14:59

In this case I have more sympathy for the cleaner, because they are so underappreciated. But I've become more sympathetic towards alcoholics after my mum became one. She's been clean for a few years, thank G-d. I've been around her when she's been on binges and it's not pretty. She's not abusive or violent, but she gets very weepy and starts rambling on about my dad (who died in 1993) or my aunties or whatever. The nadir was my stepdad's 60th birthday - she conked out at the breakfast table and he and I ended up spending most of the day in hospital. I'm amazed he stayed with her after that, but he is a lovely man and very patient. There were times when I was furious with her and felt so alone and miserable because I didn't know who to turn to, apart from my stepdad as he got the worst of it, but I felt like most of my family didn't want to know, and my brother had cancer and had his own shit to deal with.

As Slashlover says, I love Mum to bits but I hated the way she behaved and I knew if Dad was alive, he'd be furious at her using him as an excuse to just sit around doing fuck all. My brother took it really badly and if anything, he's the reason she's clean now - he came to visit, my stepdad came to pick him up from the station as Mum had been drinking and was too ill, and my brother just went 'fuck this' and went straight back home again. She started taking AA a lot more seriously after that. And I'm glad she did because she herself admits that the current crisis would have been a huge trigger.

One thing I've learned is that you CANNOT change an alcoholic. They have to change themselves, and they have to want to change.

JudyCoolibar · 14/05/2020 14:59

I know it's an illness, but I do know how you feel, OP. My FIL was an undiagnosed alcoholic when meant that at times he was incredibly unpleasant. When he retired, he basically spent his days sitting in an armchair, drinking, smoking, reading the Daily Mail, watching crap TV and occasionally shuffling out to the local off-licence to get more supplies. He ate very little but expected MIL to wait on him hand and foot . I remember once going out with them to visit a relative, and as soon as the relative went out of the room he was ferreting around in their cupboards looking for a drink, which was intensely embarrassing. When they came to stay with us once we tried to hide our booze but he found it, and we kept discovering empty bottles hidden around the place - though it did have the benefit of making him comatose for two days which helped to limit his intake a bit. When we visited them, I found it increasingly hard to tolerate his behaviour and even his presence and used to find any excuse to stay out of his way.

Ultimately he died in his 60s of oesophageal cancer which was a direct result of his drinking and smoking. For MiL in many ways it was a massive relief.

BeelzebubGoesToBenidorm · 14/05/2020 14:57

Thank you for seeing past the ugliness of addiction @Taddda - some of us DO get better with the right support and understanding!

WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo · 14/05/2020 14:56

Yanbu.

I used to be as bleeding heart as they come, I really did.

But since the area I live has become so infested with drug dealers I honestly have no time for anyone with addiction problems. They bring entire areas down and destroy families. They are blatant in my area. Police do not care, I rang the police last night because there was a queue of people longer than the Asda fast lane till on Christmas Eve waiting for their fix

I'm actually sat with my bag on my knee waiting for the dealer literally stood on my doorstep to finish up before I can go to the post office to send some of my son's work.

These people are often given every opportunity to receive help, there's plenty out there. And still they choose to live the way they do as it's easier than sorting themselves out. I've every admiration and respect for those that sort themselves out but let's face it, they're a small, minority of people.

And those that aren't living directly with it through no choice of their own have no right to have an opinion on it.

Taddda · 14/05/2020 14:53

They are despicable human beings on the whole.

I've worked with people in Recovery- some of the most honest, humble, intelligent people I've ever met....in active addiction however, not people you would ever want to be around- and they'd be the first to admit that.

Hate the illness, not the person- and it IS an illness (as recognised by the WHO for anyone who questions it).

It has disastrous consequences for everyone involved- but with the right abstinence based recovery programme, can be treated.

That being said, there are still horrendous people in the world, whether they be alcoholics/addicts or not, who destroy lives with or without a substance controlling their actions- there is a difference.

The desperation of drinking hand sanitiser (I knew of someone who did this whilst they were in hospital 5 years ago) surely you can understand this is not the actions of somebody in control but being controlled?

Theres always going to be differing views, it does affect everyone involved- also some people will never enter in to a 12 step programme or a rehab and live a life of denial, destruction and inevitably death.

But some do Recover, there are millions- don't be so quick to judge.

ForeverRedSkinhead · 14/05/2020 14:48

I struggle to have sympathy @Macrometa
My dad was an alcoholic. I left home as soon as I could to get away from him. The man I moved in with was an abuser , I was with him (trying to 'fix' him like I couldn't fix my dad) for over a decade. It was only in my 30s that I realised why I made those choices. I struggle with feelings of blame towards my dad to this day. I try not to think about it all too much as life is good now.

Healthyandhappy · 14/05/2020 14:46

My husband is a high functioning alcoholic I dont drink much at all. He goes to work daily but evenings stands in kitchen on phone drinking snappy to everyone. Husband at weekend dont wanna do owt and if we do I have to drive. U must have had a hard time with both parents been alcoholic I have no sympathy for husband or any alcoholic at all husband had a fatty liver and iv said no sympathy when goes to cirrhosis as still drinking 6 strong bows and 1 frosty Jack's every day

womaninatightspot · 14/05/2020 14:45

My stepdad was an alcoholic (dead now) and I'd agree with a PP that it's much easier to be sympathetic from afar. TBF I have low tolerance for any antisocial behaviour. Consumption of drugs or alcohol not an excuse.

rhea9009 · 14/05/2020 14:44

I think you are not being unreasonable in having no sympathy for your mother with your individual situation.
My mum was an alcoholic until I was 30. As a result 2 of my older siblings developed an unhealthy relationship with alcohol. And myself for a short period of time.
Thankfully both are recovered but they turned out lives into chaos with their drama. However they were never aggressive to me. our home was very messy and we were of course always skint and I witnessed some awful violence to my mum from her string of alcoholic boyfriends, but I always knew I was loved.I also watched these people suffer on their journey of endless failed rehab attempts, and have sat with through hours of crying and trying to piece their lives back together. They wanted to stop the trauma they were causing and eventually did.
Your mum doesn't seem to that a desire to sort herself out, treated you appallingly as a child and is still trying to give you shit you. Yes she's an alcoholic but more than that she is really selfish and toxic, if that's her personality combined with an addiction it won't end well.
You need to cut her off and talk to someone to help you recover from the damage.
She sounds more narcissistic than alcoholic.
I wish you the absolute best of luck and feel for you.

BeelzebubGoesToBenidorm · 14/05/2020 14:44

It's all very well spouting off about the NHS and the (laughable) mental health support available through it, but have you ever stopped to consider that this help ISN'T available in some areas?

Where I live, the waiting list for a standard psychiatric assessment is 12-16 months long. Somebody in the throes of a mental health crisis quite possibly doesn't HAVE that long.

I have bipolar disorder, which I'm medicated for but only sporadically reviewed, and that is ALWAYS after a battle with the services to be given an appointment. I also have complex PTSD, from an absolute fucking lifetime of trauma. And yes, I'm a recovering alcoholic. My family is riddled with alcoholism. I drank to block out the misery because proper psychiatric help simply wasn't there when I needed it, no matter how long and hard I fought for it.

So what does that make someone like me, who got lost in the system you seem to think is the be all and end all? A selfish, self-pitying waste of space?

RyanBergarasTeeth · 14/05/2020 14:37

@spartansisters agree with your post. Thats why i think its important to understand the difference between alcohol addiction itself not being a choice but steps to recovery are a choice. Its not their fault they are an addict but it is their fault for not seeking help. Thats why these threads tend to be shitty and stigmatising and we all know stigmatised people dont seek help. Thats why its called alcoholocs anonymous. Anonymous because of stigma.