Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
BackseatCookers · 10/05/2020 17:09

But I can't personally be shocked by it. As I saw and heard about so many 1 on 1 shootings, gang shootings, and mass shootings while I lived in the USA. It does start to become normal. Which is awful, and shows the extent of the problem.

I don't get it. I haven't asked you to be shocked or questioned if you are or not. Whether you're shocked or not is irrelevant to anything I have said. That was why I asked what your point was bringing up directly to me that you aren't shocked - that has no bearing on anything I have said?

Glowcat · 10/05/2020 17:06

I don’t care if he was walking around with a striped shirt and a bag marked ‘swag’ over his shoulder. What happened was obscene. Armed private citizens chasing down and shooting an unarmed man. The fact that it is normalised in the US with ‘Stand your ground’ laws doesn’t make it less abhorrent.

Annamaria14 · 10/05/2020 17:05

@BackseatCookers personally, I think that it is incredibly sad, awful and an injustice. And the men should go to prison.

But I can't personally be shocked by it. As I saw and heard about so many 1 on 1 shootings, gang shootings, and mass shootings while I lived in the USA. It does start to become normal. Which is awful, and shows the extent of the problem.

BackseatCookers · 10/05/2020 16:59

You said this in response to me:

it is not shocking to me because I have lived in the USA, and shootings happen ALL the time.

I'm still not sure what your point is by this? I didn't say you don't sound shocked enough I said your wording "over the top mode" as a description of a man being shot to death is underwhelming.

MrsDoylesTeaBags · 10/05/2020 16:58

Realistically would an ex police officer with all those years of experience, knowing how situations can escalate and how likely taking a gun into a situation will mean that gun will be used respond in the way McMichael did?

crosstalk · 10/05/2020 16:58

The incident was disgusting, abhorrent and appalling. The fact it took so long for the men to be charged because they had a friend in the judicial system is beyond words. That this isn't the first and won't be the last (remember the black medic shot by police when he was just giving CPR or similar to a white victim of a robbery?).

Not sure what we can do about the US. What about the UK?

Namechangervaver · 10/05/2020 16:55

it is not shocking to me because I have lived in the USA, and shootings happen ALL the time.

Oh that's ok then! 🤔🙄

Well here in normal countries it absolutely is shocking.

Namechangervaver · 10/05/2020 16:54

It's interesting the way some people humanise the killers ("the dad", "former policeman", "just went over the top") yet slander the victim with irrelevancies like a prior shoplifting arrest.
It's all done in a very wide-eyed way as well.

Spot on

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 10/05/2020 16:52

Oh and he didn't enter a house. He was on the premises of a house being built. No one lived there, no possessions ir valuables there, except building materials possibly.
The house showed no signs of being burglarised.
He was unarmed.

Given he was in short ,tshirts and empty handed... what crime did he commit?

VerticalHorizon · 10/05/2020 16:51

I think it's fair to say the VAST majority of us believe this to be a shocking crime, and almost certainly influenced by racist bellefs too.
Some of us see it as premeditated murder, others think it might be more of a premeditated vigilante take down gone wrong...

We will likely never see all of the evidence, but we can see some and discuss it.
It's ok to wonder what he was doing peering into a garage.
It's ok to wonder what was going through the minds of the white guys
It's ok to ask questions of both sides.

If someone asks questions about Mr Arbery, it doesn't make them racist, nor does it mean they think he has any guilt, or contributed to matters.
The same goes with the white guys. The evidence looks quite damning, but it's still ok to ask questions, and double check... it's a good thing to do.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 10/05/2020 16:50

@Annamaria14 here is the police report.

They saw fuck all, or if they did they didn't say that to the police. He said there have been burglaries and video footage and they thought Ahmaud was the suspect.

They lied about blocking his way.

They lied about the confrontation.

Will black lives ever matter?
BackseatCookers · 10/05/2020 16:48

@Annamaria14 I haven't said that.

In fact, I've specifically said on this thread that I am most concerned by the people who say yes it was wrong he was killed BUT also bring into question the character of the victim.

I said this earlier:

Why are some people (especially those who then agree he was murdered in cold blood) so determined to find a way he isn't an innocent victim.

You have popped onto the thread with a number of "news just in" comments all of which call into question the innocence of the man shot to death.

You used the phrase "over the top mode" to describe the murder committed by the "dad / former policeman".

And you don't see that it comes across as you are lessening the malice of their intentions while also lessening the strength his victim status?

MaxNormal · 10/05/2020 16:45

Annamaria14 because you sound like you're attempting to justify with unjustifiable.

Annamaria14 · 10/05/2020 16:44

How does me saying:

The mcmichaels said he entered houses.
His family said he didn't enter houses.
A new video shows him entering a house,,

Equal:

Me saying he should be killed!
Ffs.

Can I not talk about the case at all on here, without some saying I said it is okay for him to be killed.

I don't think it was okay for him to be killed, yet I am still interested in hearing what happened.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 10/05/2020 16:43

they said he was breaking into houses.

They lied. Why would someone involved in the shooting of a man ...it's a mystery.
They claimed there have been reports about burglaries , but there hadn't been any. The only thing reported stolen in the period prior to this is a gun that was taken from the unlocked truck belonging to the suspects.

The video shows Arbery in shorts and a tshirt going on a construction site/house being built, staying for a few minutes, and leaving empty handed.

It is not proof of a crime, and even if there was , you ring the police, you don't arm yourself, box someone in and then confront him with a gun.

Madwife123 · 10/05/2020 16:42

That 911 call alone is horrifying, reporting a black man running. On what planet is that acceptable!

gobbynorthernbird · 10/05/2020 16:41

@Annamaria14 Ahmaud didn't actually enter the house. He had a little look in a wide open and empty garage. You think if he were white those bastards would have hunted him down with shotguns for being a bit nosy?

Annamaria14 · 10/05/2020 16:38

@BackseatCookers it is not shocking to me because I have lived in the USA, and shootings happen ALL the time.

But please don't ever say I said it was okay to kill this man. I did not say that anywhere.

I said - they said he was breaking into houses.
The family said he was just out for a jog.

The new video footage appears to back the mcmichaels statement.

It is more that I want to see what happened in the lead up to this. What actually happened

MaxNormal · 10/05/2020 16:37

It's interesting the way some people humanise the killers ("the dad", "former policeman", "just went over the top") yet slander the victim with irrelevancies like a prior shoplifting arrest.
It's all done in a very wide-eyed way as well.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 10/05/2020 16:35

@Annamaria14 it's an empty house on a construction site. He was empty handed in a tshirt and shorts!

What significant crime could he have committed to excuse at least two armed men chasing after him and boxing him in?

Annamaria14 · 10/05/2020 16:33

@MagentaRocks where did I say he deserved to be shot, I didnt. In fact, I have said the opposite. That they were completely and totally wrong to kill him.

However, they said they saw him enter his houses, his family has said he wouldn't do that, that he was just out for a jog.

So this new video is important! About us seeing what happened

DangerMouse17 · 10/05/2020 16:32

@Annamaria14

Ahmaud's high school record, prior arrests, what he had for lunch that day have ZERO bearing on the fact that he was shot and murdered by two individuals who decided they wanted to accost him and take his life. If he was white this would not have happened. So please cease with your ever so helpful "updates".

Ahmaud's character is not in question here.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 10/05/2020 16:31

Well they said that there had been a batch of robberies in the area.

Surprise surprise... man involved in a murder lies. Hmm

All the reports of robberies are based on McMichals statement to the police.

BackseatCookers · 10/05/2020 16:30

I just think the dad (used to be a police man) got into a over the top mode, with terrible consequences

This is the most underwhelming description of chasing and shooting a man to death that I have ever heard.

Getting into "over the top mode" is shouting about someone recording over a boxset you wanted to watch.

Not shooting a man to death in broad daylight.

If they had shot a young white woman in this situation and she had a shoplifting incident on her record would you say well she had precious so let's not paint her as an innocent? Really?

This thread is the saddest thing on here in ages.

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 10/05/2020 16:29

Not much to steal from a house under construction especially as the video shows he had nothing in his hands...