Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:42

His death is a tiny symbol of the millions of gun problems in the USA.

When the USA actually start to do something to regulate guns - that will be a worth while day

YinMnBlue · 11/05/2020 15:42

Gun control is necessary yes.

But what would have equally saved his life in this situation is control of racism.

After all, lynching didn't used to take place with a gun.

You say you are not racist (I am not sure white people are the best judges of whether we are racist or not - we do our best not to behave or think in racist ways is the best we can offer, in truth) but you are incredibly naive about what contributes to racist stereotyping and prejudice. Such as the effect of emphasising irrelevant possibly-but-unproven unlawful activity.

It is exactly like victim blaming rape victims in this case.

YinMnBlue · 11/05/2020 15:37

sorry - does his death matter to you less...

YinMnBlue · 11/05/2020 15:37

"I am of the opinion that you can talk about what he was actually doing before the murder, and still think that the murder was wrong.

But on here , apparantly that is equal to agreeing that he should have been murdered.

Why what he was doing is a point of debste, is that the family said he was jogging, the shooter's family said that he was breaking into houses"

This is a thread about RACISM.
The facts of what he was actually doing in the run up to the murder are only relevant if they might mitigate the motive to shoot him.
As he was an unarmed man alone and not attacking or putting at risk the men who shot him or anyone else, what he was doing is quite simply irrelevant. So why discuss it? To make a point that somehow informs as to why white men armed with guns might shoot an unarmed black man?

Does it matter to you less that he might have been on a building site in an unauthorised capacity? Does that make his death ok to you? So why is it relevant to a discussion on racism?

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:27

@rocklock well I don't think it is fair to say all white people are racist, for a start.

I have never been racist in my life.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 11/05/2020 15:27

There were three of them , I bet even without guns they would've found a way to harm Ahmaud. Because that was their intent.

RockLock · 11/05/2020 15:25

For those saying gun controls are needed, yes that is true. Why are you also not addressing that racism control is needed. Is that because then you have to check your own privilege? Will it mean giving up some of your own privileges? Nah not doing that, if it means black people die, then so be it.

What makes a white person see an unarmed black person and become trigger happy?

We have seen this happen time and time again.

OP posts:
Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:24

@DeeCeeCherry the issue is that people carry guns on them at all times in the USA. That is what the problem is.

But what can we do about gun laws and gun control from here?

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:23

@DeeCeeCherry huh?

DeeCeeCherry · 11/05/2020 15:22

Annamaria14 do you have information regarding a new law we don't know about that legalises citizens chasing down and executing an UNARMED MAN whatever he may or may not have been doing? If you do then when did this law take effect? Do you have the details?

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 11/05/2020 15:21

There were two calls to 9-1-11* made minutes before Arbery's death. Neither call alleged a crime committed by Arbery.[49] The transcript of the calls were provided to The Brunswick Newss*, with the callers' identities redacted.[49]
In the first call to 9-1-1, a male caller said another man was in a house that was "under construction". The 9-1-1 dispatcher asked if the man was "breaking into it right now?" The caller replied: "No ... it's all open." After the caller said the man was now "running down the street", the dispatcher said police would respond. The dispatcher then asked at 1:08 p.m.: "I just need to know what he was doing wrong. Was he just on the premises and not supposed to be?" The caller replied in a garbled manner: "And he's been caught on camera a bunch at night. It's kind of an ongoing thing." The caller identified the man as a "black guy, white T-shirt".[49]

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 11/05/2020 15:20

The owner of the unfinished home, who was 90 miles away at the time of the shooting, later said "I've never had a police report (on my property), or anything stolen from my property, or any kind of robbery."

RockLock · 11/05/2020 15:19

So now the first DA is trying to blame the police for not making the arrest, whilst the second DA laid the following charges before recusing himself: (taken from CNN)

In stepping down, he laid out a defense of the McMichaels, saying: 1) the father and son had "solid first-hand probable cause" as civilians to detain Arbery; 2) they apparently sought only to "stop and hold this criminal suspect until law enforcement arrived"; 3) Arbery's "mental health records and prior convictions" explain his alleged aggression; 4) "McMichael was allowed to use deadly force to protect himself"; and 5) Arbery may have shot himself while fighting for the shotgun.

Now I am no lawyer, but There is so much wrong with this defence that even I can tear each and every one of those arguments apart, so why did all these white law enforcement guys think their actions and version of events were justifiable in any shape or form? They knew they were going to get away with it. They all colluded and tried to dismiss the brutal murder and make it go away. I am surprised the DA didn’t just say whites are goodies and blacks are baddies.

OP posts:
Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:19

What this case does show, yet again, is that their needs to be gun control in the States.

But how do we get that to happen? How do you get a large country, with huge numbers of people, to agree on it

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 11/05/2020 15:16

@Annamaria14 who has more to gain by lying?

The dead man's family or the killer's family?

Also don't forget the surveillance video doesn't show him breaking in anywhere or stealing anything.

For a few minutes he was on the premises of a house under construction, which he left without taking anything. He's in tshirt,shorts and bare handed. The house didn't show any signs it was burglarised according to the police.

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:13

@gabbynorthernbird he did have previous convictions. Fact. Look it up

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:12

*debate

gobbynorthernbird · 11/05/2020 15:12

@Annamaria14 can you please provide a link to a reputable source that confirms Ahmaud had previous convictions.

Also, please explain what the fuck that would have to do with this situation.

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:11

I don't know.

I am of the opinion that you can talk about what he was actually doing before the murder, and still think that the murder was wrong.

But on here , apparantly that is equal to agreeing that he should have been murdered.

Why what he was doing is a point of debste, is that the family said he was jogging, the shooter's family said that he was breaking into houses.

It is important to know what happened in this case, and in every case.

I don't know why - gathering facts about what happened = we believe he should have been killed. It doesn't

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 11/05/2020 15:07

@Annamaria14 yes we've seen the news. I've read about it yesterday. What you don't seem to understand is that it's irrelevant.

It doesn't change the outcome.
It doesn't change the fact that it is murder.

And most importantly it doesn't change their intent... which was to harm.

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 15:06

@BackseatCookers I disagree.

I think that we can debate what happened in the lead up to this.

And yet still absolutely and totally think that it was wrong to kill him.

BackseatCookers · 11/05/2020 15:03

@Annamaria14

Imagine a woman was raped in broad daylight and someone commented on a thread about it "didn't it come to light that she was on her way home from a one night stand?"

Would you honestly not think that was implying that she was somehow less of a victim? Otherwise what is the relevance?

Honest question. Because I don't understand how you can't see that the comment implies some sort of culpability of the victim or mitigation of the perpetrators.

Xenia · 11/05/2020 14:52

I would impose much stricter gun control in the USA. We are very lucky in the UK that most people don't carry guns.

sauvignonblancplz · 11/05/2020 14:47

YANBU- horrible and just barbaric.

@redwoodmazza Really? So he deserved to be hunted and shot? These comments make me sick.
Do you openly tell people you are racist or just document it on anonymous forums?

Annamaria14 · 11/05/2020 14:40

Did you see this in the news: it says that the elder man of the duo, previously convicted Ahmaud Arbery for something, when he was a policeman.

Strange case.

"One of the men accused in the fatal shooting of Ahmaud Arbery was involved in a previous prosecution of Arbery"