Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
YinMnBlue · 08/05/2020 13:39

All lives matter but all lives are not equally at risk.

It is stated policy of well established white supremacist groups in the U.S that black lives are second class, and this persists in institutional and systemic racism.

You don’t have to scratch the surface very hard to find it here, either.

It makes me sick when MNers respond to threads about racism with “I’m not black but I’ve never experienced anyone being racist in our village / golliwogs are just loveable toys, I’m not black but we loved them as kids and I’d like one for mine and we haven’t grown up racist” etc etc

Or shuts down a discussion with “playing the race card”, “chip on your shoulder “ or “it’s just victim mentality”

Polite liberal racism runs deep. Optimistic polite voices, shrill in denying that no one is racist any more...

Annamaria14 · 08/05/2020 13:38

Did you see the video where the black man enters his own appartment building. And a white woman living in the apartment building challenges him and follows him all the way up to his flat, in the lift. She assumed he was a criminal because he was black.

He lived there.

They have to put up with this shit all the time, and far worse - getting shot and killed

ThatsWhatHeroesDo · 08/05/2020 13:37

I will hold my hands up and admit that I used to think All Lives Matter when I heard about Black Lives Matter. I didn't realise, then, how little value was placed on black lives in so many places. I know better now. I guess it's more like "We Already Know White Lives Matter But Black Lives Matter Too You Know".

Oakmaiden · 08/05/2020 13:37

Similarly, women have been utterly resistant to the idea of shielding men from frontline roles.

I haven't even seen this seriously suggested, let alone women being resistant to the idea.

I think it is a reasonably good idea, if it can be managed.

The problem becomes when you look at doctors, who are right in the front line, that 27% are BAME and 55% are male. In hospitals the proportion is probably higher, as women are more likely to be in GP. Which means, by removing otherwise healthy men and BAME from the front line workforce you immediately lose probably close to 70% of all doctors (as the only ones still allowed to work would be white women). That would simply make it impossible to operate an NHS.

Whilst the problem is probably less extreme for other medical staff or other frontline roles, it is still always a huge proportion of the workforce that we just can't manage without.

So whilst the concept is obviously an excellent one, I just don't see how the country can operate without allowing men to work in frontline roles. We do actually need them.

Mistystar99 · 08/05/2020 13:36

I keep expecting that twat Laurence Fox to pop up here!!

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 08/05/2020 13:36

FeelinFagin that's what makes it worse. If the video was never posted no doubt nothing wouldve been done.
Yet suddenly video posted and arrests made..hmmm.

CanICelebrate · 08/05/2020 13:36

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe I do genuinely apologise if my comment upset you - I should also avoid these threads as the make my emotions engage before my brain when I type.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/05/2020 13:36

From the photos I have seen most of the protesters are not white.

This is to be expected.
Brunswick, Georgia where the shooting and protests happened is majority black (57%). White people a minority (38%) of the population.

Annamaria14 · 08/05/2020 13:36

@namechangervaver I am white and I see it.

I was so shocked in the USA, I never knew how cruel people could be. I saw black people really being looked down on like they were animals.

White people have a responsibility to get rid of white supremacy

CanICelebrate · 08/05/2020 13:35

@Chloemol ffs Sad that attitude/ ignorance is part of the problem. I can’t believe people can think that black people and white people face the same issues on the same scale. This isn’t about individual gangs or places, it’s about a problem inherent within societies, Institutions and justice systems.

zafferana · 08/05/2020 13:35

I really hope so OP and YANBU. The situation in the USA is different to here in the UK though. While racism is alive in well in both locations, the situation is much worse in the USA. The murder of this innocent man who was going for a jog is but one terrible example in the past few weeks. The sight of a load of tooled up white supremacists storming state buildings armed to the teeth while security guards were made to stand by and the useless tosser of a president defended them was another. If those men had been black rather than white, they'd have been shot on sight. Hell, you don't even have to be armed as a black person to be shot in the USA. Some white idiot with a gun only has to say 'I felt threatened' and that's enough justification.

FeelinFagin · 08/05/2020 13:34

"But... but... but... it wasn't police brutality and has nothing to do with black lives matter. It was citizen on citizen crime"

'Black lives matter' comes into play when the police DID NOTHING UNTIL THEY WERE FORCED TO. There is a clear video showing the murder. The police still did nothing.

Namechangervaver · 08/05/2020 13:34

Talking about racism on Mumsnet (and I say this as a black person who has tried) - is like asking fish to stop swimming. In other words impossible.

Absolutely. That's why I'm currently reading 'Why I'm no longer talking to white people about race' by Reni Eddo-Lodge

Annamaria14 · 08/05/2020 13:34

Are people on here aware that black people suffer terrible human rights abuses in teh USA.

You so know that it is happening right.

The argument being made in this case, is that a black man should be able to go out for a jog in his own neighbourhood, without being ahot and killed.

So sad.

Many white people do not want to see racism. Because who cares? Doesnt happen to them, in fact it benefits them.

But I am white, and I am not a bitch, so I see it.

TorkTorkBam · 08/05/2020 13:34

I have to admit the title got my back up. I found myself thinking FFS another American poster assuming every place in the world is as violent and white supremecist as the USA.

LonginesPrime · 08/05/2020 13:33

The fact the father was a “former police officer” is a red herring. He was acting as a private citizen when he murdered Ahmad.

The fact he is a former police officer is the red herring in the context of Black Lives Matter and police brutality - he has had a career where structural racial bias was culturally ingrained so to pretend that this has absolutely no impact on the attitude of a retired police officer is just wilful blindness.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/05/2020 13:33

CanICelebrate, I understand white privilege, I can't understand what BEM people go through because I never will. I'm sorry about that. I feel it's probably best for me to swerve threads like this in future because I think I'm posting in support and it just causes offence which was never the intention.

WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo · 08/05/2020 13:33

I don't think any lives matter in the US unless those lives belong to rich people.

Their way of thinking is fucked up, especially in the southern states.

Ilovethekittehs · 08/05/2020 13:32

'All lives matter' I hate that. It just takes away from the 'black lives matter' movement. No one is saying all lives dont matter. But people wouldn't get away with hunting down and killing a white man...

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/05/2020 13:31

MouthBreathingRage I'm not doing that. I understand the 'scale' and I understand racism. The shooters are being brought to justice and I hope they get the kicking they deserve in prison, but they probably won't.

I wasn't being flippant, I'm just as appalled at the shooting of an innocent person and I don't understand the mentality but in a country that celebrates firepower, it's a never-ending problem.

CanICelebrate · 08/05/2020 13:30

@VladmirsPoutine Flowers

Oakmaiden · 08/05/2020 13:30

@Chloemol Spectacularly missing the point there. Well done.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/05/2020 13:29

The disproportionate toll of Covid-19 on ethnic minorities and black people in particular has become clear but many white people are utterly resistant to the idea of them being shielded from frontline roles

This is true. However, while it is true black people have 2x risk of dying compared to white people from COVID so too do men have 2x risk of dying compared to women. Similarly, women have been utterly resistant to the idea of shielding men from frontline roles. If the first is racism, would the second then be sexism? It gets very tangled.

VladmirsPoutine · 08/05/2020 13:29

It's actually really triggering reading all these responses. On just about every other issue Mumsnetters are able to apply a critical lens. But when it comes to racial disparities, much less even racism it literally just doesn't exist. It's quite remarkable actually.

Chloemol · 08/05/2020 13:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.