Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
PlanDeRaccordement · 08/05/2020 14:23

“How many white men get arrested or shot down for the crime of running? Anyone have some stats on this?”

This is a decent article about the stats of police brutality. It has one statement that I think has the information you’re looking for about chances of police killing you while unarmed:

“University of Nebraska at Omaha criminology professor Justin Nix examined in his 2017 study on police killings. Nix’s research, which Cesario cites often in his own study, also focuses on police shooting-killings in 2015, when police killed nearly twice as many white people that year (495) than they did black people (258). But 15 percent of the black people police killed that year were unarmed, compared with just 6 percent of white people who were unarmed when killed by police”
www.citylab.com/equity/2019/08/police-officer-shootings-gun-violence-racial-bias-crime-data/595528/

Devlesko · 08/05/2020 14:21

It's not just Black, it's BAME in general.
Jews aren't Black, neither are Roma, but both get the same racism and yes murder, that is tried to be covered up, or lied about, to justify.
If anyone doesn't see this then they are either naive, or racist themselves and in need of educating themselves.

Sandybval · 08/05/2020 14:21

In America especially there is still a long way to go.

Oakmaiden · 08/05/2020 14:20

I agree, but I also think that we need the BAME doctors and nurses too.

Sorry, I didn't make it clear - I was assuming that if we decided to shield all men from front line roles because of their increased risk, then we would do the same for those of BAME. So in effect the only workers would be white women. Which just wouldn't work.

44% of doctors and 25% of nurses in the UK are BAME. Good luck if they suddenly all disappeared!

Thanks for this. On double checking my figure of 27% was very out of date.

So 55% male, 44% BAME. Which means only around 25% of Doctors are white females. Probably fewer in hospitals, because of the increased likelihood of women to be in General Practice.

It is interesting to ask if those of BAME origin and men are both twice as likely to be severely ill, does that correspond to BAME men being 4 times more likely? And how does that compare with the risk of someone with BMI over 40, or taking immunosuppressant medication?

But this is probably a question for another thread.

MagicKingdomDizzy · 08/05/2020 14:20

Pinkginhelps

I agree with everything you say

MagicKingdomDizzy · 08/05/2020 14:19

Sorry, my last post made it seem like I condone racism, I do not!!!

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/05/2020 14:18

“Is there any country, who imported such huge numbers of African slaves, like the USA did?“

Yes. According to Slave Voyages, here are the number of slaves stolen from Africa by nation:

Portugal- 5,848,266
Britain- 3,259,441
France-1,381,404
Spain- 1,061,524
Netherlands- 554,336
USA-305,326
Denmark- 111,040
www.slavevoyages.org/assessment/estimates

Of course, the USA did not exist before 1776, so most of the slaves brought there were originally brought by the British when it was a British colony.

Pinkginhelps · 08/05/2020 14:17

YANBU . I would love for everyone born with the privilege of white skin to experience living in black skin for just one day.
America is full of ignorant red neck scum with guns.
How many white men get arrested or shot down for the crime of running? Anyone have some stats on this?

MagicKingdomDizzy · 08/05/2020 14:16

The 'right to bear arms' law in America is crazy. People forget it's an antiquated law.

Yes, people are racist in the UK, but thank God, guns aren't legal. Can you imagine?!

SimonJT · 08/05/2020 14:16

This made me really sad when I saw it. Imagine having to build that in to parenting.

It’s something every parent of a non-white child has to do.

The world we live in isn’t prohuman, it’s prowhite. All lives matter is bullshit, white lives have always mattered, non-white lives are always an after thought.

I’m not white, I’m subjected to stop and search on a fairly regular basis, I don’t have any white friends who have experienced stop and search. People with non-British sounding names are less likely to be shortlisted for interview. People who do not have white skin typically receive longer/harsher punishments for crime. People who are not white are more likely to be subjected to violence when outside their homes.

The UK voted for a proud racist.

The US voted for a proud racist.

panicstationsready · 08/05/2020 14:14

All lives matter - the bigger issue is that all and sundry can carry guns and shoot whomever they wish. Had the killers not had access to guns they may well have still killed him but certainly not so easily. Stabbings are much more 'up close and personal', guns are a way of distancing yourself from the death

EmeraldShamrock · 08/05/2020 14:13

I hope so. In my eyes every life matters.
Yanbu it is disgusting.
My niece is dating a black boy it has opened her eyes to petty racism, he is a lovely lad it is very sad.

Yellowsubmarinedreams · 08/05/2020 14:10

There are a lot of posters on mumsnet with ingrained racist beliefs and who don't recognise their own white privilege, OP. Posts on race have them all crawling out. YANBU at all.

SkinRash · 08/05/2020 14:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

tara66 · 08/05/2020 14:08

Have you been to Zimbabwe at all these last few years?

VashtaNerada · 08/05/2020 14:08

YANBU. I just keep imagining if an unarmed white man went for a jog through a black neighbourhood and was shot dead, how different the response would be. And it’s so tiring to hear people on here who are so clueless about white privilege. That clip from Grey’s Anatomy was heartbreaking. Sad

Terralee · 08/05/2020 14:07

YANBU Black Lives Matter

Francina670 · 08/05/2020 14:05

This forum is absolutely at its worst on this subject and the ridiculous points made here are repeated on every other MN thread about race issues. It seems to be acceptable to debate whether racism is even a thing and the experiences and opinions of non-white people are consistently ignored.

I think MNHQ need to stage an intervention.

Namechangervaver · 08/05/2020 14:04

I agree, but I also think that we need the BAME doctors and nurses too.

Well, duh! 44% of doctors and 25% of nurses in the UK are BAME. Good luck if they suddenly all disappeared!

ByzantinePrincess · 08/05/2020 14:01

Something bad happens to a woman - people on mumsnet: All men are violent and sexist! There is endemic sexism in the UK and the world!

Something bad happens to a black person - people on mumsnet: Well, come on now, not all white people. Everyone is equal. I’m certainly not racist, so...

CuppaZa · 08/05/2020 14:01

YANBU.
I can’t believe how many have voted you are Hmm
Those commenting on white people/other races getting murdered are missing your point entirely

diddl · 08/05/2020 14:01

"According to an April 26 report in the New York Times, Arbery was a former high school football player who ran for fitness and maintained the habit into his 20s. That day in February, he happened to run past the home of Gregory McMichael, 64, who decided Arbery looked like the suspect in a string of recent robberies in the area. McMichael called to his son Travis, 34, and the two of them jumped in their truck after grabbing a handgun and a shotgun. The local prosecutor (who later recused himself from the case because his son had worked with Gregory in the district attorney’s office) determined that Arbery was shot twice after a scuffle between him and Travis, who was holding the shotgun, and that Travis acted in self-defense. Further, the prosecutor determined that the McMichaels were justified in pursuing Arbery under the state’s citizen’s arrest law."

Self defence & a justified pursuit?

That is insanely scary.

GoddessOfGettingThereInTheEnd · 08/05/2020 14:00

It is certainly my percepti9n that black people in america have to be so careful or some trigger happy cop will blast them with the gun they shouldnt have.

Xenia · 08/05/2020 13:59

Anna, yes places like Jamaica - lots of slaves imported as in the USA although very different countries so I am not sure comparisons can easily be made.

I saw this video the other day - when he moves to the right of the van he goes off camera so I am not sure the footage shows all we need to see but it certainly proves we are very lucky in the UK that just about no one has a gun so we don't have many shootings of anyone.

And yes black lives and all lives matters. Anyone whether of our family's Catholic background (the bible says everyone is equal) or any decent background thinks all lives are of equal value.

The US and UK positions are not always comparable on race issues but always worth people t4rying to be fair. It is going to be very hard as people get back to work in the UK for employers to be fair- if being over weight or being an old man or whatever means your worker may die of covid 19 is it going tyo be fait to pick those ones for redundancies over women or over thin ones? (Assuming there are no back room jobs they can do) A can of worms on gender, race, weight and many other issues is about to be opened.

SayNoToCarrots · 08/05/2020 13:59

Yes, but this particular person was murdered because the perpetrators thought that if a black man is running then he must be up to no good and should be confronted

But why is that?

I think the story has been simplified somewhat

Yeah you are right @SkinRash. The heavily armed white people probably had a good reason to shoot the unarmed black man on his own.