Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
lockeddownandcrazy · 08/05/2020 14:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

missionalmostimpossible · 08/05/2020 14:48

Try looking at Brazil @Annamaria14.

If you believe what you see in the press, Gisele Bundchen is "the typical Brazilian". In reality, over 70% of the country is some form of mix, originating from slavery. You won't need me to tell you what proportion of Black Brazilians are trapped in favelas; class mobility there, especially if your skin is darker than a weak tea, is far worse than it is in the UK.

When I travelled to Brazil for the 2014 World Cup, I was completely shocked at how local black people were treated. I didn't expect to see anything like that at all.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 08/05/2020 14:48

And why is it so fucking obvious when put like that, @Monkeys? It's something that every one of us, especially anyone wondering about this:

He was fighting with one of the white men - yes, he has a gun pointed at him by a scared/angry man

He matched the description of a burgler - yes, he was black, male and moving

Who wouldn't try to avoid being shot? Do all black men look the same, any more than all Chinese men, or white men? Think about your own reaction to that.

There is a vast difference between not knowing / meeting many BAME individuals and believing that it is an easy mistake to make....

I may need to reword my posts, not sure they properly convey what mean.

Lexie365 · 08/05/2020 14:44

YANBU, it's heartbreaking and i pray to god it changes.

VenusTiger · 08/05/2020 14:44

All lives matter. There are some disgusting people in the world but the extremely small minority dose not represent society as a whole. I think you are unreasonable for thinking it does

Completely agree - weed out the murderers, the racists, the abusers - don't mix them into a pot with innocent people so that they can hide away better.

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 14:43

Something bad happens to a woman - people on mumsnet: All men are violent and sexist! There is endemic sexism in the UK and the world!

Something bad happens to a black person - people on mumsnet: Well, come on now, not all white people. Everyone is equal. I’m certainly not racist, so...

Because people turn a blind eye to prejudice when it doesn't affect them. This forum is full of women, so sexism is keenly felt and acknowledged by most. But since the majority are white, most like to ignore racism or strongly play it down.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 14:42

Wisdom from @Lifeaback

The fact that people are even debating whether racism exists on a public forum like this makes me feel sick. I am white, I have never been subjected to racism in my life but unlike some people on this thread I’m very glad I don’t use my position of privilege as a reason to ignore racism and deny what a huge issue it is.

Opinions like this make me think that maybe, some people don’t think it’s OK for black and BAME people to be victimised.

justasking111 · 08/05/2020 14:42

Watching americans protesting about covid lockdown by waving guns about while wearing masks gloves, made me realise we really are different despite having a common language, so nothing surprises me any more.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 14:39

Police brutality against black people in the U.K. www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/dec/13/black-people-more-likely-to-have-force-used-against-them-by-police-data-shows

Saying “all lives matter” is like saying “men’s rights matter” - of course they do, this is obvious. However black lives have historically, and to this day, seemed to matter less to white people than white lives. That is proven statistically, and by the opinions here.

When your reaction to the lynching of a black man is, “but statistics show white people die too!” you are completely missing the point and reducing this horrific and racially-motivated death to an argument that essentially says this incident, and all the incidents like it, aren’t significant. It’s unbelievable.

Pumperthepumper · 08/05/2020 14:39

Something bad happens to a woman - people on mumsnet: All men are violent and sexist! There is endemic sexism in the UK and the world!

Something bad happens to a black person - people on mumsnet: Well, come on now, not all white people. Everyone is equal. I’m certainly not racist, so...

Except that’s not exactly true - something bad happens to a woman and MN says ‘why do men allow this to happen?’. Something bad happens to a black person and MN asks ‘why are white people allowing this to happen?’

The problem here is people who think equality means ‘people being treated exactly the same’ rather than ‘fairness’.

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 14:38

Imagine if two armed black men chased down a young white man jogging through a park and shot him dead. And then said "Oh, but there was a police report of a white man burgling a house, and look, this man is white!! That's not racism! He fit the description perfectly!"

Do you think the police would say "well that seems conclusive to me, case closed! You fine gents are free to go, have a lovely day!"

Lifeaback · 08/05/2020 14:34

@ilikemethewayiam I see your point completely as I’ve lived both in the UK and in England and definitely think day to day racism on the streets (in my experience) is a bigger issue in the US.

However what is it a huge issue in England is systematic racism. Mothers like @YinMnBlue across the country have to have conversations with their children who are stereotyped by police forces and targeted in ways that their white peers aren’t- a study was released last year saying that black people are 40 times more likely than white people to be stopped and searched on the street. While it is a good thing that policemen/women in the UK aren’t as trigger happy as in the US so less people die from incidents like this, it is still inherently degrading that innocent people are forced to co-operate with police intervention when the only grounds for this is their race.

I recently read an article which stated that the Department for Education reports that black children are ‘three and a half times more likely to be excluded than all other children at primary, secondary and special schools. These are disparities that exist not because of any underlying propensity to cause trouble, but probably because educators perceive black children as fundamentally disruptive, hopeless, and inferior, regardless of what they do.’

BAME people even in today’s progressive society are consistently faced with people of authority (teachers, bosses, police figures) stereotyping them and forming opinions of them before they’ve even spoke. As white people, most of us have no understanding of what that’s like as we’ve simply never lived through it. One of my best friends grew up with the mantra from her mother that ‘you have to work twice as hard just to be half as good’ because of the racial bias black people face.

The fact that people are even debating whether racism exists on a public forum like this makes me feel sick. I am white, I have never been subjected to racism in my life but unlike some people on this thread I’m very glad I don’t use my position of privilege as a reason to ignore racism and deny what a huge issue it is.

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 14:34

The first three replies to this thread are some of the most stupid I've seen in a long time.

returnofthemollymawks · 08/05/2020 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/05/2020 14:34

Yes, that is true. Some ships would fly a flag of a country that still allowed the slave trade specifically to smuggle slaves to colonies where slavery had been outlawed. Portuguese and British also supplied slaves to other countries colonies as middlemen. But this is a minority of voyages.

The website is great to see the big picture. Here is an essay that talks generally about where the slaves went and it was mostly to Portuguese Brazil and British Americas.
“Given the dominance of Portuguese and British slave traders, it is not surprising that Brazil and the British Americas received the most Africans, though both nations became adept at supplying foreign slave systems as well. Throughout the slave trade, more than seven out of every ten slaves went to these regions. The French Americas imported about half the slaves that the British did, with the majority going to Saint-Domingue.”
“Indeed, overall the United States absorbed only 5 percent of the slaves arriving in the Americas.”
www.slavevoyages.org/voyage/essays#interpretation/a-brief-overview-of-the-trans-atlantic-slave-trade/empire-and-slavery/4/en/

feelingverylazytoday · 08/05/2020 14:33

This isn't an isolated incident, it's the latest in a long list of innocent black people being murdered for no reason other than the colour of their skin
Here's another one www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-50032290
How many more examples do people need?
How many white people have been shot simply for going about their daily business, or even just being in their own homes? Very very few I bet.
No YANBU OP. Rest in peace to this young man who had his life stolen from him. It really is horrific, and I don't see how people can be so quick to minimise it.

Moonmelodies · 08/05/2020 14:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 14:31

@Moonmelodies statistics overall show that you are more likely to be killed by someone you know. Therefore, if you live in a white community and amongst white people, you are more likely to be killed by a white person. If you live in a black community, you are more likely to be killed by a black person.

Your logic seems to suggest that because black people kill each other, it’s ok that white people kill them? Also, I assume you had to take the time to look that statistic up to what, absolve white people who murder black people, somehow?

White fragility is a hideous thing, and also a great book. Would suggest everyone (including BAME people) read it - it’s illuminating.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 08/05/2020 14:31

YANBU. Racism is so bloody ingrained in some that, as in this case, a black man jogging, are knee jerk hard wired stupidity. The men had only one view of a mobile black man and, despite the call handler querying them, chose the act on their own prejudice and then lie to cover it up, once they realised what the son had done.

Other times, and in the opposite direction, someone mentions a business man who may be acting in a philanthropic manner, I s fanning the flames of a situation, maybe spreading misinformation, that benefits him financially, and the person highlighting it gets called racist, fascist because said business man happens to be black, Jewish, or Muslim, or American or any Other that may spring to mind.

In many ways we have lost something. The ability to see others as real people, maybe?

I don't get it. Can't understand the mindset. And am scared by the growing phenomenona of personal isolation, lack of critical thinking, culture of celebrity / popularity = self publicisation.

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 08/05/2020 14:27

It's the actions they took before the shooting..getting guns and chasing him down. Why would you do that?!

Oakmaiden · 08/05/2020 14:27

@Moonmelodies

And your point is?

Moonmelodies · 08/05/2020 14:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kazzer2867 · 08/05/2020 14:23

@Blessed2496 and @VladmirsPoutine. Totally agree with you.

When you have to sit your 11 year old child down and teach them what to do if they are stopped by the police on their way home from school, when you witness innocent black school children being stopped by the police 5 minutes after walking out of their school gates to go home, maybe you would understand. When you witness a black man with his infant child being tasered for trying to protect his child. Maybe you would understand. When every 4 stop and searches (in London) for every 1,000 White people, compared with 38 for every 1,000 Black people. Maybe if these figures were reversed, maybe you would understand. When you yourself are stopped when driving your car and asked how you could afford that car (maybe you would understand). Black Americans are shot at a disproportionate rate. They account for just 13 percent of the U.S. population, but more than a quarter of police shooting victims. The disparity is even more pronounced among unarmed victims, of whom more than a third are black.

Of course all lives matter, but the data clearly shows Black lives quite sadly don't matter.

@Namechangervaver. Great book by the way.

ForeverRedSkinhead · 08/05/2020 14:23

I hope they do op. But sadly , I see otherwise.

Hearing and reading about white people experiencing racism too really pisses me off , it reminds me of when people are discussing violence against women and there's always a 'but what about the men' comment.

For context , I'm white. When I was a teen I overheard my employer referring to the white staff (me and one other girl) as 'those people'. This unpleasant experience was over 20 years ago and I still remember how hurt , shocked and bewildered I was. This happened to me ONCE in 40 years. Try hearing this (and much worse) on a daily basis and then white people can chip in with their what about us crap. It simply doesn't compare.

Oakmaiden · 08/05/2020 14:23

@PlanDeRaccordement

Interesting link.

Isn't that the nationality of the traders who stole them, though, rather than of their eventual buyers? Just because the slave trader was British/Portuguese/Dutch doesn't mean the slave couldn't have ended up in the USA.

Wonder if there are stats anywhere which show where they mostly ended up?