Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
SkinRash · 08/05/2020 15:22

Did you even try to think logically before posting or did all rational thought stop at "black"?

No, the opposite actually. My rationale is thinking of reasons how this happened rather than just gobbling up the media's reports playing the race targeting.

The clip I saw shows two men struggling over a long gun. It certainly wasn't an assassination like how it's being portrayed here.

We don't know the full circumstances. All we know is black man was shot by two white men. Yet that's enough for everyone to quickly assume it was racist.

VerticalHorizon · 08/05/2020 15:22

I know America is easy to point the finger at, but the UK is still rife with racism. It really isn't very far away.

AndMyHairWillShineLikeTheSea · 08/05/2020 15:22

Except they didn't follow to shoot him, he was asked to stop and rather than have a calm conversation about a local burglary he fought with them resulting in the gun going off twice.

I'll ask again. What fucking right did these 2 men have to follow him and ask him to stop and confront him armed with guns. They had no right at all.
I don't even care if that man had just robbed somewhere. He was unarmed! Shooting him was not a proportionate response to their 'suspicions'.

And this folks is why the general public shouldn't have guns.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 15:20

I think that @SkinRash is saying that it was his fault he was shot. You know, for being there, and not reacting exactly as she would have done. And being suspiciously black.

Also it doesn’t matter where he lived in relation to the incident - apartheid isn’t a thing!

SkinRash, if they weren’t following him because he was black, then why were they following him?

MouthBreathingRage · 08/05/2020 15:20

Except they didn't follow to shoot him,

How do you know that? By following him with a gun, they had already prepared for that eventuality, regardless of their initial motives. Their motives, as it happened, was vigilanism at best which already wasn't going to end well.

he was asked to stop and rather than have a calm conversation about a local burglary he fought with them resulting in the gun going off twice.

If you were out on the street, minding your own business, how would you react to armed men (who were not police), stopping you and demanding to know if you were a criminal? Especially if they had already decided you were even if you protested? Would that be a 'calm discussion'?

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 08/05/2020 15:19

If people are seriously suggesting he was gunned down in cold blood purely because he was black then that is ludicrous.

Of course it fucking happens.

Just how some people are killed simply for being women, or gay, or a certain religion etc.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 08/05/2020 15:18
  • Except they didn't follow to shoot him, he was asked to stop and rather than have a calm conversation about a local burglary he fought with them resulting in the gun going off twice.

Was he jogging? Or fleeing a crime?

Did he have a criminal record?

Why did he react violently when approached?

Until the full facts are released I'll remain open minded about the circumstances of the story.*

Since when can civilians take the law into their own hands and follow and confront others while being armed?

His criminal record is irrelevant.
His reason for running is also irrelevant, since the accused didn't know it either.

Don't bloody tell me that you see two armed blokes wanting to have a "chat" and you'd be all sugar and honey.

Did you even try to think logically before posting or did all rational thought stop at "black"?

SkinRash · 08/05/2020 15:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 15:17

@SkinRash seriously??

If they had no intention of shooting him then why did they have guns? And why did they ignore the police representative on the phone? Also your phrasing is interesting: it absolved the perpetrators from blame: the gun did not “go off” on its own - they SHOT an unarmed man. And they killed him. That is the reality of the situation. And they wouldn’t have been following him if he was white, because they wouldn’t have noticed anything “amiss”.

And, would you be asking those questions if the victim was white? Reeeeallly? You’ll probably say you would ask them, but I don’t think that’s true. At all.

If three men with weapons followed you, with weapons, would you have a calm conversation with them? I certainly wouldn’t wait around to have a “calm conversation”.

You’re not remaining open-minded - you’re waiting for evidence that the victim somehow “deserved what he got”. Which is a narrative that lots of people like to use against minorities of all kinds.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 08/05/2020 15:17

Stopped and questioned by two men who were not police but white men who had decided he must be suspicious because he was black.

Who called police, and were questioned about their basis for suspicion, were told someone was being sent and, despite having no authority or basis for their suspicion, other than he was male, moving and black.

Why would he have done anything than told them to sod off, he was just jogging?

If your answer includes: he was in America, he was black, they were armed then you have missed the point!

AndMyHairWillShineLikeTheSea · 08/05/2020 15:16

@SkinRash and what right did those 2 men have to follow him armed with guns? What right did they have to shoot an unarmed man at point blank range?

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 08/05/2020 15:15

If they were concerned theyd called the police not grab their guns and followed him. Or just followed him without the guns! It was obvious why they did and what the outcome would be.

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 15:14

Why did he react violently when approached?

Are you seriously asking this? Seriously? Two armed men drove up to him and yelled at him to stop. They are not police, they are just two men in a truck with guns. At first he tried to run, as anybody would. But they followed him. And then one of the men, carrying a shotgun, jumped out of the truck. Of course he tried to fight back.

MrsDoylesTeaBags · 08/05/2020 15:13

Until the full facts are released I'll remain open minded about the circumstances of the story.

Ahahahahahahahahahah... yeah sure

Panda368 · 08/05/2020 15:12

People posting that "all lives matter" is the same as posting about a woman's rape saying "men get raped too!"
It minimises everything and wildly misses the point.

This man was killed because they believed they could kill him, that his life mattered less, and they would be free from prosecution because he was a black man and they were white.

I am white, I come from a very white part of the country, I have never directly expierenced any racism but have heard enough casual racism to understand that it's a fucking awful and endemic problem in our society.

People who deny racism and derail debate with whataboutery really need to educate themselves and recognise their own knee jerk reactions.
It isnt about you. It isnt about white people. It's about promoting equality and safety for BAME people in our society.

itsnotcakeitsbaby · 08/05/2020 15:12

@SkinRash Would you be happy to have a calm conversation with someone who followed you with a gun?!

MrsDoylesTeaBags · 08/05/2020 15:11

lockeddownandcrazy Well I guess it would suit you for people to not see racial prejudice, don't want them see you as you are. We do see you.

SkinRash · 08/05/2020 15:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DianaT1969 · 08/05/2020 15:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 15:08

@twelvemonkeys great analogy. I’m going to plagiarise it if that’s ok!

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 15:07

This is like arguing there is no pay gap because some women earn more than some men.

AKA it's a fucking dumb argument.

Bristolbitsandbobs · 08/05/2020 15:06

I cannot believe the vote. God almighty.

MouthBreathingRage · 08/05/2020 15:06

It happens - could as easily have been a white person.

No it couldn't have, that's precisely the fucking point.

OhYouBadBadKitten · 08/05/2020 15:06

I hope so, one day. Never give up.

VerticalHorizon · 08/05/2020 15:05

Bad things happen to white people yes, nobody disagrees.
Some bad things happen to black people, and are not racially motivated, nobody disagrees.

But black people suffer. Many black people die at the hands of racists, or suffer prejudice because of skin colour.

Their chances are not the same chances as white people.

To not recognise racism is wilful ignorance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread