Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
emojisarentwords · 08/05/2020 15:40

Judging by some of the responses you've gotten on this thread, YANBU.

SonjaMorgan · 08/05/2020 15:40

It is horrific. I doubt equality will ever be reached. Unfortunately the world has limited resources and we are past the peak. Higher costs and a reduced standard in living will cause more inequality. We have middle class friends who like Trump, the economy has improved and they have prospered during his presidency.

VerticalHorizon · 08/05/2020 15:38

Some professions get a hard time, police being a prime example, and you get some horrible idiots spitting, swearing and worse at you...

But being black is from birth. It doesn't stop when you take off the uniform. You can escape the job, but not the colour. All of your life, someone will look at you with prejudiced eyes (whilst you live in a white dominated society).

MrsDoylesTeaBags · 08/05/2020 15:37

If people are seriously suggesting he was gunned down in cold blood purely because he was black then that is ludicrous.

www.motherjones.com/politics/2010/09/aiyana-stanley-jones-detroit/

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trayvon_Martin

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Stephon_Clark

www.vox.com/2016/7/6/12105380/alton-sterling-police-shooting-baton-rouge-louisiana

edition.cnn.com/2016/09/20/us/oklahoma-tulsa-police-shooting/index.html

No, you're right these things never happen

HoppingPavlova · 08/05/2020 15:37

Except they didn't follow to shoot him, he was asked to stop and rather than have a calm conversation about a local burglary he fought with them resulting in the gun going off twice.

Oh, come on. If you were out jogging and two rednecks followed you in a pickup, stopped and cut you off and told you to stop, you’d be happy to stop and have a nice calm conversation with them? I sure as shit wouldn’t, and I’m white. I’d try and get the fuck out of there as quickly as I could, which is what he did and one jumped him. I take it in this case, you’d still be up for that calm conversation? How absurd. Are you from Georgia, maybe this explains things?

itsnotcakeitsbaby · 08/05/2020 15:36

@SkinRash

Get real. Have you ever had a gun or weapon pointed at you? If you think the average person acts calmly and rationally in that situation, you're sorely mistaken.

You are not 'keeping an open mind', you are victim blaming to a preposterous degree.

I think you are largely forgetting that a person is not entitled to murder another person EVEN IF the latter is a burglar (which us not actually the case here).

MouthBreathingRage · 08/05/2020 15:36

Short version, @SkinRash, you can't seem to differentiate between 'he was shot because he's black' and 'it's far more likely that a black person will die in this situation due to the circumstances'.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 08/05/2020 15:34

No. I suspect the older man called in their suspicions, based on a black man moving at speed through a residential neighbourhood.

I suspect they both made an assumption and chose to be good guys, as the older man used to be when he worked in law enforcement.

I suspect, from the words on the 911 call, the son approached and accosted the presumed black thief and was unprepared for the presumed thief to resist him as he was armed, and the presumed thief was not.

The gun went off and the black man died.

At which point the official response was that 2 armed white men must have been acting in self defense when they followed and shot an unarmed black man.

The assumption adds insult to injury; adds a constitutional racism to that of the individuals.

What part of outnumbered, outgunned, guilty of nothing makes any part of that reasonable?

Fedhimtotigers · 08/05/2020 15:34

FFS Listen to the 911 call.

They said they did it because he was black.
They did it because he was a black man in their neighbourhood.

He was in shorts and a T-shirt. Clearly unarmed.

thats pretty much rascism against police officers by saying they are all the same then

There is a very deep problem with institutional institutional racism. in the South it's even worse.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 08/05/2020 15:33

@SkinRash
Gregory McMichael told police he saw Mr Arbery and believed he resembled the suspect in a series of local break-ins.
Mr McMichael and his son armed themselves with a pistol and a shotgun and pursued Mr Arbery in a pick-up truck. Gregory McMichael told police he and his son said "stop, stop, we want to talk to you" and claims Mr Arbery then attacked his son.

By THEIR own admission they didn't know, they just THOUGHT he was suspect because he was -another direct quote- "hauling ass" . They ARMED themselves and then followed him. They stopped their car in HIS way, while still armed. One of them was out of the car ARMED.

In what world is that a reasonable , justified course of action? In what world civilians can grab guns and chase people they think are suspects? In what world two men arm themselves and get in someone's way just to have a "chat"?

He wasn't armed, he didn't go after them and as it turns out he wasn't running from a crime scene either. That's why people shouldn't take justice in their own hands, even when the "suspect" is black.

MouthBreathingRage · 08/05/2020 15:33

It's easy to believe he was followed and shot deliberately because he was black and no other reason. Okay. Believe what you like I will chose to believe otherwise.

No, it's easy to believe he was followed because he was black and therefore must have been up to nefarious activities. It's easy to believe things escalated quicker because the young man was black and the white men went in with the mentality that they had to 'protect themselves and their community'. It's easy to see the facts that black people are more likely to die in escalated circumstances that could and would have been avoided if they weren't black.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 15:32

@skinrash no, most racist people don’t choose to follow and kill every single black person they see - most racist people also don’t shout the N word at every black person they see - however on occasion, a racist person (whether they acknowledge it or not) does something palpably racist, and that usually ends badly for the black person. Usually when the racist person is in a heightened state and/or thinks they have cause.

For example, someone might abjectly refuse to believe that a black man was shot simply because he was black. They refute the very idea that this black man might have done nothing wrong. They might argue that he didn’t live there, or that he might have a criminal record. They might absolutely refuse a reality in which he was totally and 100% innocent. Because how could a black man be innocent?

And then, this person might go back to their life believing that they don’t have racist thinking, and they were entirely in the right.

Just an example, no relation to the current situation Hmm

SimonJT · 08/05/2020 15:30

@SkinRash Is a fairly typical representation of someone who is pro-racism.

Yet they fail to realise that the same argument they use to say non-whites are to blame is the exact argument that is used to blame women for rape and sexual assault.

What @Skinrash has said is no different to “well she didn’t answer questions calmly when the men were waving guns in her face” and then blaming her for a resulting rape.

HaddawayAndShite · 08/05/2020 15:29

thats pretty much rascism against police officers by saying they are all the same then
Christ you can’t even grasp the fundamental basics of what racism is and you’re spouting off about it. I don’t think I’ve seen something so ignorant.

HavartitoMeetYou · 08/05/2020 15:29

SkinRash, you need to give your head a wobble and look at the actual facts (white men accost a random passer-by and slaughter him like a hunted animal) rather than inventing wild hypotheticals that are based on racist stereotypes. There’s literally no way “see random black man on the street minding his own business and assume he might be doing crimes” is anything but racist. And if they had any genuine reason to suspect burglary, they would have called the police.

I keep expecting that twat Laurence Fox to pop up here!!

We’ve had a few threads about that. The consensus was that Fox is a champion of free speech and the handful of unknown black and Asian actors (I got screeched at for referring to the elected official who resigned over not being allowed to tweet decrying racism by his name rather than job title, because apparently it’s totally unreasonable to expect posters in a thread about a specific incident to know the name of the person that thread was created to attack Confused) who publicly condemned his comments are just “wokerati” virtue signallers something something identity politics something something shoehorn in transpeople somehow woke police yadda yadda criticising someone is denying them their right to free speech and trying to destroy their career even though Fox has had the biggest career boost of his life because of the scandal.

HoppingPavlova · 08/05/2020 15:28

There are some disgusting people in the world but the extremely small minority dose not represent society as a whole. I think you are unreasonable for thinking it dose

The problem is though, it’s not a small minority in places like Georgia and it’s a very good representation of their society. Unfortunately there are lots and lots of Georgia’s around.

MitziK · 08/05/2020 15:27

Every parent of a black child (including me) in my area of London gives the country equivalent version of that talk to their black teen boys. Know their rights, but be sure not to put yourself at risk

I've had to do it in school.

Yes, it's World Book Day. Yes, you're an alien/cowboy/spaceman/soldier whatever. Yes, it's summer. But you cannot travel home with the butt of a waterpistol sticking out from your trousers. Not when you're 14. All it takes is one person to see it, make a call and you've got five Glock-17s pointed in your face and they're all screaming at you to get down. No, you can't tell them to fuck off. No, you can't argue with them like you do here. You shut up. You stay still. You do whatever they tell you. If you don't have your schoolbag with you to put it in now, I'll look after it until tomorrow - yes, I'll talk to your Mum, I'm sure she'd have something to say about it if I let you out these gates and you walked straight into a Stop & Search team with that. I am not letting you take that risk just for a waterpistol. Yes, I will tell (insert generic white boy's name) that he can't do it either, but you know full well why I'm telling you this.

Warsawa31 · 08/05/2020 15:27

Strangely just saw the video a friend sent me - the poor guy is literally jogging down the road. The father approached him pointing a gun and there was a struggle.

The two white guys were armed to the teeth, the father was a retired cop I think so maybe killing black people came naturally to him....

SkinRash · 08/05/2020 15:26

SkinRash, if they weren’t following him because he was black, then why were they following him?

Are you serious? The older white guy is 65 years of age, do you believe he's gone through his life following and killing all black people he sees?

Seriously??

You don't think they were following him because something had happened that we're not all privy to at the moment?

It's easy to believe he was followed and shot deliberately because he was black and no other reason. Okay. Believe what you like I will chose to believe otherwise.

Fedhimtotigers · 08/05/2020 15:26

FFS. YANBU this was a lynching pure and simple.
Nothing has changed since Emmet Till.

boylovesmeerkats · 08/05/2020 15:25

It's horrible. I'm glad things are better in this country although not there yet.

I listened to quite a few US podcasts and couldn't believe the stories. I think Serial did one based on the criminal justice system and it was appalling.

Or the other story about the woman that got put in prison for an alleged gaming of the school system although her reasons for moving in with her dad for her daughters education seemed reasonable to me, the fines were horrendous she lost everything and was imprisoned and then felicity huffman got a slapped wrist for much worse.

And then there are the killings, but wrapped up in the issues with policing and law I think. Too much turning a blind eye.

SimonJT · 08/05/2020 15:25

@lockeddownandcrazy You do realise police isn’t an ethnicity Hmm

No, I don’t get spat at, verbally abused or physically abused due to the job I have. I get it because I’m not white.

bananafish · 08/05/2020 15:25

JFC - I knew I shouldn’t have opened this thread.

The casual racism on this site never fails to depress me. I am not particularly surprised by the sheer ignorance of some posters, but it is still infuriating.

That poor man was murdered in cold blood by those two fuckers, and the narrative around their actions is already being written in a way that may well lead to their acquittal. It is sickening.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 08/05/2020 15:24

Not ludicrous, the heart of the issue!

He lived nearby, jogged daily. Number of burgleries is moot as they had, according to the 911 call, seen him in the vicinity of a house under construction when they chose to follow him.

You may choose to ignore the evidence given by police, other people, BAME and white, who were there, and only give credence to some of the words of the father and son who shot him. That initial reaction is, in itself, part of the problem.

Their own words, recorded in the 911 calls, give an insight into their thinking.

MouthBreathingRage · 08/05/2020 15:23

Where did he live in relation to the incident?

What does that matter? When a crime occurs in your local area, do you think 'oh the suspect is the same ethnicity and sex as me, I better be extra vigilant when out just in case they think it was me'? White people certainly don't ever need to worry about that...

Swipe left for the next trending thread