Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MitziK · 08/05/2020 16:03

If a couple of men, black or white, approached me without any weapons, saying they 'just wanted to talk' to me, I'd be expecting at best sexual harassment, at worst kidnap, rape and murder. And I'd want to run, scream, fight, anything to get away from them. It's happened, I've escaped however I could. It's what girls and women have to do daily to stay safe.

And that's in the UK, not anywhere with guns, not somewhere where there is a known history of anybody in a uniform being likely to rape women like me and being protected by the state, with all my privileges from being an arguably middle class white woman.

To think that anybody has to go about their day knowing that not only are randoms quite likely to kill them, people representing the state are likely to kill them and claim they were justified/frightened/they made them do it just due to how they look, is horrifying.

That's why Black Lives Matter.

VladmirsPoutine · 08/05/2020 16:00

White women in many regards are actually a hell of a lot more dangerous than white men. They can weaponise their proximity to white men and indeed their tears, they're more likely to be our nurses, teachers etc.. It's pretty terrifying.

But that's all - I'm off to read the more relaxed threads about who's neighbour isn't clapping for the NHS or putting out bunting for VE day.

ByzantinePrincess · 08/05/2020 16:00

@Thisfeelslikearipoff What’s your point? I must have missed the previous posts which said there isn’t any anti-white racism anywhere in the world?

VladmirsPoutine · 08/05/2020 15:59

@areyoubeingserviced Oh absolutely! In fact that's one thing I fear the most for black men than being stopped and searched - having a casual sexual encounter with a white woman who isn't sober; or indeed even if she is has explicitly not sent a text saying "come over let's fuck." It would be straight to jail - white women at uni used to joke about this all the time.

Chiyo666 · 08/05/2020 15:58

.

Will black lives ever matter?
MouthBreathingRage · 08/05/2020 15:57

@Thisfeelslikearipoff, well done for both missing the point of the op, and making it about white people in the most horrific way possible. You must be so proud of how graphic you got there to really hammer home 'but white people get racially attacked as well!!'.

Merrymumoftwo · 08/05/2020 15:55

YANBU. I am not BAME but I can see this is not right. I know it’s not everyone and I don’t live the way some of my friends do, the fear, the difference in treatment. A part of me hopes that things will change but somehow I don’t think it will any time soon Sad

YappityYapYap · 08/05/2020 15:55

In the US, black men are the largest demographic of murder victims

White men are second

Hispanic men are third

Women of all ethnicities are a minority as murder victims but white women get murdered the most, black women second and Hispanic women third.

Black men are the largest demographic over all and also the largest demographic to be murdered by another ethnicity

ToPlanZ · 08/05/2020 15:54

I saw a very sad post on Twitter today posted by a black man in the USA saying he doesn't run at night for this very reason.

I don't get off the train at my local strain station at night. It's dark and isolated and makes me feel vulnerable. I feel this way because I'm a woman. Something I can't change. I can understand how bloody sick to death people of colour are having to manage their existence because of their skin colour.

I hope black lives will one day have equal worth in society, and women's lives too for that matter. All lives should matter but at the moment society does not give them all equal weight. The swing towards populism makes me fear we are in fact moving away from equality for all.

Namechangervaver · 08/05/2020 15:53

@HavartitoMeetYou great post

Thisfeelslikearipoff · 08/05/2020 15:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

memememoi · 08/05/2020 15:53

Nope... you asked a simple question and unsurprisingly one if the the first answers is "all lives matter" as if it's all people getting gunned down for existing...

MasakaBuzz · 08/05/2020 15:53

I became aware of the situation 30 odd years ago. I was on a train, and the conductor (who was not white) was making a hash of sorting my change out. I realised he was waiting for the abuse, and was surprised when I started to joke with him.

What shocked me was on another day I might have been as grumpy as hell. It would have been nothing to do with his colour, but he would have assumed it was.

Earlier on in the thread there was a comment about the number of stop and searches of black youth v white youth. Correct me if I am wrong, but since the police have been forced to consider race in their stop and search, and the number of black stop and searches reduced, hasn't it lead to an increase in black on black crime? I don’t have an answer, but hasn’t this policy actually caused more harm to black youths?

I am not being goady- I am genuinely interested in people’s views. I am also quite happy to be corrected.

As for America. I am not sure that is solvable. Whilst American’s continue to insist on the right to bear arms, the slaughter will go on.

This Twitter account is well worth following.

twitter.com/Well_Regulated_

SchadenfreudePersonified · 08/05/2020 15:52

Somebody posted a video of the incident - it was horrific!

It's hard to tell from a short clip, so I may be wrong, but it didn't look as though they had even challenged him - just shot him.

Apparently they thought he was a burglar (because obviously a black man running has to be up to something - he can't possibly be out for a jog to get a bit of lockdown exercise), but it didn't seem to occur to them to convey their suspicions to the police - they decided to deal with it themselves.

Piper1879 · 08/05/2020 15:51

Some of these responses astound me , we have to stop innocent black men and women dying at the hands of ignorant people! It breaks my heart !!
I am dreading having to give my son due in a few months (who will be mixed , Jamaican/British) a talk about what he should do if he's ever stopped by the police for driving a nice car or even entering a shop when I wouldn't have to do that if he was white.
I am angry that when I enter a store with a friend who is black it is them that is profiled and followed not myself , it disgusts me.
I sometimes hate this world we live in

areyoubeingserviced · 08/05/2020 15:49

@Havart agree with your post at 15:42

areyoubeingserviced · 08/05/2020 15:47

It’s so sad that so many black people have to give the ‘talk’ to their young black boys.
The talk whereby they are told not to wear their hoodies up; be aware that the security guard in the local store may think that you are a shoplifting solely by dint of the fact that you are black; be aware that if you have a casual sexual relationship with a white woman make sure that she is sober , so that she doesn’t accuse you of rape.
I am white, but I have been told this my black friends, colleagues etc

Of course these are the sort of conversations any mother would have with their male child. However, the need for this conversation is more urgent when you are the mother of a black/ mixed son because of the possible ramifications.

I am dismayed by some of the casual racism displayed in this thread. The refusal to believe that black men can be killed for the
‘crime’ of being black . The ignorance and victim blaming is shocking to say the least.

picklemewalnuts · 08/05/2020 15:46

I gave my white son 'the talk' because he was a bit vulnerable, and going out with friends who were more streetwise than kind. I was worried.

I've been in the car with kids who were very alarmed and hostile at the sight of a passing police car, and realised they weren't being brought up with the ol' 'ask a policeman' mantra.

All lives are precious and it's outrageous that we have to shout about it in order to protect black lives.

I understand the reasons for the 'black lives matter' slogan. I wonder whether 'all lives matter' might be a stronger and more unifying slogan. It's appalling that we have to specify black lives matter, as if there is any question of that!

It's scandalous that institutions and individuals still fail to value black lives.

MrsDoylesTeaBags · 08/05/2020 15:46

It sickens me Mockers, his poor family, he was barely a child.

MockersxxxxxxxSocialDistancing · 08/05/2020 15:44

Trayvon Martin linked above.

This will go to trial, and they will get off.

VerticalHorizon · 08/05/2020 15:43

It isn't about two idiots setting out to kill a random black man...

it's about them thinking 'ah, a black burglar, let's gear up and teach them a lesson'. If it had been a car theft and the suspect white, would they have gone looking? I suspect not.
That is where the racism lies... 'those damn ni....' (you know the word)', and this was their excuse to go out and teach one of them that they can't get away with that in a WHITE neighbourhood...

HavartitoMeetYou · 08/05/2020 15:42

It’s very easy to invent wild hypotheticals and throw around stuff like “ohhh but did he have a criminal record? Did he have a history of behaving in a sketchy way? Did he have a history of jumping around with a clown nose screaming that Country and Western sucks and Starbucks is overrated?? Did he practically force those poor white men to confront him??”

Yet on the flip side, you reject out of hand the opposite: Did the two murderers have a history of behaving in a racially abusive way? Do they have a history of expressing racist views? Do they have a history of violence? Do they have criminal records? We don’t know the “facts” of the two murderers’ past either, yet you’re not willing to consider that they may be known violent thugs with a history of racist abuse.

Why is the innocent man’s (hypothetical) past being dragged over to justify “not making judgements about why a man was murdered till we know all the facts” (implying there possibly could be some background that could possibly justify murder??) but not doing the same to actual murderers?

Peapod29 · 08/05/2020 15:41

Fuck me, this thread. Now I’m sure there’s a lot more troll posters here than I thought. It seems America really hasn’t moved on at all in 50 years.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 08/05/2020 15:41

TBH if I'm fucking raging at bullshit like this(and other comments on here) , I can't even imagine how members of the BAME community must feel. Sad

TooTrueToBeGood · 08/05/2020 15:41

It's relevant, I believe, that this happened in Georgia. One of the states that operated segregation/apartheid until the 50s. You don't change such ingrained attitudes overnight, more's the pity. It will likely take generations.

Those dismissing the OP for claiming this is a race issue either do not have a clue about the problems in America, especially the southern states, or are the sort of people who would happily put on a pillow case and join a lynching.